Uri kunetseka here nezvesimba riri kuwedzera rezvematongerwo enyika revachena vezvematongerwo enyika vane chisimba muAmerica? Zvakanaka, une kambani yakawanda, kusanganisira Vakuru vezvekuchengetedzwa kwenyika nekurwisa hugandanga veUS. Uye isu tiri kunetseka, zvakare - kunetseka zvakakwana, kutaura zvazviri, kunzwa kuti yave nguva yekutarisa zvakaitika kuIndia, uko dzidziso yeHindu supremacist yakawedzera kusimbiswa kuburikidza nenzira dzechisimba. Kunyange paine kufanana kunoshamisa pakati penyika mbiri idzi, India inoratidzika kunge yakaenderera mberi nemhirizhonga yekurudyi. Chiitiko chayo chinogona kupa vanhu vekuAmerica zvimwe zvakakosha, kana zvisizvo, zvidzidzo.
Kutanga, ngationei zviitiko zviviri zvichangobva kuitika, chimwe muIndia uye chimwe muUnited States.
Mitemo yakadzikwa munyika zhinjisa dzeIndia inorambidza kuurawa kwemombe yakashanda sechikonzero chinozivikanwa nokuda kwokutevedzwa kwechisimba kwezvitendero zvechiHindu. Munguva pfupi yapfuura, semuenzaniso, varume vatatu vakasungwa vachipomerwa mhosva kupamba uye kuuraya Junaid naNasir, varume vaviri vechiMuslim vanotakura mombe vachipfuura nekuchamhembe kweHaryana. Vakatanga varova Junaid kusvika afa, ndokuzodzipa Nasir. Mitumbi miviri yakanga yapisirwa mumotokari yakanga yasiiwa padivi pemugwagwa. Kurwiswa ikoko kwakabatana nemapoka emapurisa anozivikanwa se gao rakshaks (vadziviriri vemombe) avo, mumakore ano apfuura, vanga vari mumhirizhonga kuchamhembe kweIndia, kunyange zvakadaro. zvinotyisa ichangobva kunyorwa zvakare kumaodzanyemba muMaharashtra, kumusha kuguta guru reIndia, Mumbai.
MuUnited States, zvakare, ruvengo rwechisimba rwuri kuwedzera uye rwuri kupembererwa zvakashata kurudyi. Mukati memazuva matatu apomerwa mhosva yekuponda asina kuzvidira, Daniel Penny, murwi wekuUnited States Marine akataura nhau dzenyika nekukachidza kusvika pakufa Jordan Neely, murume asina pekugara, anorwara nepfungwa pamotokari yepasi peNew York City, akaunganidza anokwana $ 2.7 mamirioni kubva kuChristian crowdfunding saiti GiveSendGo. Akapomerwa mhosva yekuuraya munhu, akatonzi aโSubway Supermanโ naFlorida Republican Congressman Matt Gaetz, nepo mumwe wake Floridian, Gavhuna Ron DeSantis, tweeted kuti "kumisa chirongwa cheKuruboshwe chekutsigira mhosva" tese tinofanira "kumira nevaSamariya Vakanaka saDaniel Penny."
Zvinosuruvarisa kuti, zvikamu izvi, zvichiitika hafu yepasi zvakaparadzana, angori mapoinzi maviri edata mukuwedzera kwemhirizhonga inotsvaira India neUnited States. Maitiro aya akatanga kuitika muIndia muna 2014 nekukunda musarudzo kwaNarendra Modi Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), achimuita mutungamiriri. MuUnited States, zvakabata nguva huru nesarudzo dza2016 dzaDonald Trump semutungamiri wenyika. Asi mhirizhonga yakadai - uye kubvumidzwa kwakafara kwemhirizhonga yezvematongerwo enyika nevakuru vechiHindu ikoko uye vachena vepamusoro pano - yakangokura mumakore kubva ipapo.
Zviitiko izvozvo zvinoratidzawo musiyano mumwe unokosha pakati pechisimba chekurudyi muIndia neUnited States. Nepo kuwedzera kwechisimba cheHindu-supremacist chave mubatanidzwa wakarongeka wenyika, mhirizhonga yakawanda yekuAmerica yevachena-supremacist ichiri kuitwa nevanhu vari kuita vega.
MuUS, takasangana nekuwedzera kuri kuita kupfurwa kweruvengo uko vakakuvadzwa vanongozviwana vachipinda nzvimbo isina kururama panguva isiriyo (uye kazhinji kazhinji yemavara asina kunaka), kunyangwe seyenguva refu yenguva kuuraya vanhu vazhinji zvakaitwa nerusaruraganda uye anogara akashongedzerwa zviri nani "mapere ari oga" anosimuka. Zvikuru, pakati pevaimbi vega, Kyle Rittenhouse, uyo akapfura nekuuraya vaviri varatidziri veBlack Lives Matter muna 2020, uye vazhinji vevamwe vakawana rumbidzo huru kubva kune vanotungamira vezvematongerwo enyika veTrumpublican, kusanganisira iyo MAGA kingpin The Donald pachake. (Iye, chaizvoizvo, vakakokwa Rittenhouse kuenda kuMar-a-Lago muna 2021.) Uye 2023 yatove munzira kuenda. isa rekodhi pakupfurwa kwevanhu vakawanda, ukuwo mhosva dzeruvengo dzakawedzera Kupfuura 200 pavhiki muna 2021, gore rekupedzisira iro FBI ine data rakazara. Huzhinji hwemhosva idzodzo dzakaparwa nevanhu vasina mubatanidzwa.
MuIndia, mukupesana, masimba masimba oruvengo anowanzova akarongwa zvikuru. Vachengeti vemombe munguva pfupi yapfuura vakasungwa muHaryana, semuenzaniso, vaive vakabatana naBajrang Dal, bato repwere reVishnu Hindu Parishad (World Hindu Council), iyowo, iri nhungirwa yesangano rakakura remauto echiHindu, Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh. (RSS).
Bato reRSS rakatangwa muna 1925 nechinangwa chimwe chete: kuita India (yakanga ichiri koloni yeBritish) muHindu. Rashtra - ndiko kuti, "Rudzi rwechiHindu." Maitiro ayo akafemerwa nemafascist mafambiro zana apfuura muItaly neGermany. Nhasi, ine nhengo yemamiriyoni mashanu kusvika matanhatu uye inobata misangano yezuva nezuva munzvimbo dzinopfuura zviuru makumi matatu nenhanhatu dzakasiyana muIndia. Zvakatonyanya kuipa, bato rinotonga reBJP, rine Modi kumusoro, nhungirwa yeRSS.
Muna 2002, Modi aive gurukota guru renyika yeGujarat pakaitika mhirizhonga yaityisa munharaunda. vakatora hunoda kusvika 2,000 2014 upenyu, zvikurukuru maMuslim, mukudengenyeka kwapasi kwezvamatongerwe enyika nenzanga uko kwakabetsera kutanga fungu razvino uno rourudzi hwechiHindu. Muna 12, nesimba rechitendero chechiHindu chaainge awana makore gumi nemaviri apfuura, akava mutungamiriri wehurumende uye munguva pfupi gehena rose rakatanga.
Mhou uye Mabhuru ** t
Mune ruzhinji rwematunhu eIndia nhasi, kuuraya mombe kunoitwa mhosva uye kuiswa muchikamu chimwe chete kubata chibharo, kuponda, kana kumukira. Sokutsanangura kunoita Harsh Mander, uyo akaronga kurwisana nemhirizhonga munharaunda uye nechitendero mubhuku rake Zvikamu zveMoyo, โMushandirapamwe nhasi unoti unodzivirira [mombe] hauna chokuita norudo rwemhando ipi zvayo.โ Iri panzvimbo "chimwe chiratidzo chinosimudzira kurova vadiki veIndia mukuzviisa pasi nekutya."
Mitemo inorambidza kuuraya mombe uye kudyiwa kwemombe haichashandi kusvika muna 2014. Iye zvino, iri kuramba ichitevedzwa nechisimba nevaHindu vanongwarira zvikuru. Mitemo iyoyo, kutaura zvazviri, yakapa chikonzero chaidiwa chemhirizhonga yakanyanyisa. Sezvo Tej Parikh akadaro munguva pfupi yapfuura mumagazini yeAsia-Pacific Dhipatimendi, "Vakadzi vaviri vechiMuslim vakabatwa chibharo muMewat [kudunhu reHaryana] kutanga kwaSeptember [2022], mushure mekunge vavarwisa vavapomera mhosva yekudya nyama yemombe." Uye kuisa zviito izvi mumamiriro ezvinhu epanguva ino, akawedzera kuti "mutongo mukuru kune akabatwa chibharo muHaryana wakaderera makore matatu pane mhosva yekuuraya mombe."
Sezvakataurwa naMander, kurambidza nyama yemombe iyi chishandiso chekukunda maMuslim, maDalits (aimbonzi "asingabatike"), maKristu, uye Adivasis (Marudzi echiHindu). Zvinoshamisa sezvazvinganzwika, fananidzo yeAmerica inogona kunge iri mhosva yekubvisa nhumbu. Mune imwe nyika, mombe, kune imwe, mbereko dzevanhu dziri kushandiswa sezvishandiso zvine bapiro rekurudyi kudzvanyirira, kutonga magariro, uye kusimbisa hukuru pamusoro pezvikamu zvakakosha zvevanhu vedu.
SekuUnited States, chisimba chinoitirwa vakadzi chatekeshera muIndia uye vanopara mhosva vanowanzobatwa netsitsi. Funga nezvaSandip, Ramu, Lavkush, naRavi, vaHindu vana veboka repamusoro avo, muna 2020, vakatambudza, vakabata chibharo nemapoka, uye vakauraya musikana ane makore 19 okukura Dalit pakati pemunda wemapfunde mudunhu reUttar Pradesh. . Kurume uno, dare rakawana Sandip ega ane mhosva - uye chete "yekuuraya nemhosva kwete kuponda." Vamwe varume vatatu vakasunungurwa.
Muchirevo chechiHindu chepamusoro-soro, mutsara ghar wapsi (zvinoreva kuti โkudzoka kumbaโ) zvinoreva kutendeutsa vanhu nechisimba kubva muchiIslam kana chiKristu kuenda kuchiHindu. Mune imwe nyaya ichangobva kuitika, mumwe wezvematongerwo enyika weBJP, munyori wehurumende weChhattisgarh kuchamhembe kwakadziva kumabvazuva kweIndia, kumusha kune maHindu mazhinji nemarudzi, akamanikidza maKristu anodarika chiuru nezana kuti apinde muhondo. ghar wapsi mhemberero.
Vakuru vechiHindu vanowanzoshandisa kupfigirwa uye chisimba kuti vawane kutendeuka kwakadaro. Somuenzaniso, vakadzi vaviri vakamhanโara vapristi vepanzvimbo ye yoga mudunhu reKerala kwavaiva. akasungwa mukuedza kuita kudaro. "Ndakamanikidzwa kuita basa remumba rinosanganisira kutsvaira nekubikira vasungwa 65 ndiro," mumwe wavo akapika muafidaviti yake. Mupristi, akanyora kudaro, โakatyisidzira kuti vaizouraya Isaka [murume wake wechiMuslim] kana ndikadzokera kwaari.โ Mumwe mukadzi akaudza dare kuti, โVanhu vepanzvimbo ye[yoga] vakandikumbira kusiya [murume wake wechiMuslim] Hameed. Pandakaramba, vakandirova nembama kumeso, vakakava nechepazasi pedumbu rangu uye jira rakaiswa mukanwa mangu kuti ndisaridza mhere.โ
VechiHindu verudzi vari kusimudzawo maalarm pamusoro pe "love jihad," dzidziso yekurangana yenhema inoti varume vechiMuslim vari kunze kwekukwezva vakadzi vechiHindu kuti varoore, kutendeuka, uye kugadzirwa kwevacheche vechiMuslim. Imwe firimu ichangobva kuburitswa propaganda, Nyaya yeKerala, inoda kuratidza kuti vakadzi 32,000 vanobva mudunhu iri vaive sei akashandurwa kuva Islam uye yakatorwa nemagandanga eIslam State. Hazvina mhosva kuti hapana chimwe chazvo zvakamboitika, "love jihad" rhetoric, kusanganisira kuratidzwa kwevarume vechiMuslim se "zvikara zvinonyengera, zvepabonde," zviri kumbundirwa kunyange nevachena vepamusoro muUnited States, maererano ne Zeinab Farokhi, purofesa paToronto University.
Kumabvazuva Kunosangana Kumadokero, Kumadokero Kunosangana neCaste
Washington neNew Delhi nguva pfupi yadarika yakazivisa kuti Prime Minister Modi achange achishanya kuUS muna Chikumi. Mukushanya ikoko, manotsi nzvimbo yeIndia The Wire"Modi angangoshanyira New York kuYoga Day musi waChikumi 21."
Chokwadi, achaita, kune iyo yegore yoga chiitiko chaive brainchild yaModi. Muna 2014, akakurudzira kuti International Day yeYoga ipembedzwe panguva yezhizha uye UN General Assembly inotora Chisarudzo kuti zvidaro. An avid yoga practitioner, Modi ipapo akanyora, "Yoga inobatanidza kubatana kwepfungwa nemuviri, kufunga uye chiito ... nzira yakazara [iyo] yakakosha kuhutano hwedu nekugara zvakanaka." Mazuva ano, pamwe Modi anofanirwa kutora imwe nguva yakati wandei yeyoga, izvo zvingamutendera kuti awane kunzwisisa kwakazara kweruvengo uye hutsinye hwave kuitika muIndia. (Tsiva Donald Trump weModi achiita yoga, kana iwe uchida kuseka kushoma izvozvi.)
Nhasi, kune vanosvika mamirioni mana nemazana matatu evaSouth Asia-America vanogara muUS, kusanganisira vanhu vanobva kuBangladesh, India, Nepal, nePakistan. Chirevo yakabudiswa neboka revanobvisa zvematongerwo enyika, Equality Labs, ine musoro unoti โCaste in the United States,โ yakawana kuti kunyange muAmerica, โvazhinji vokuSouth Asia vanozviti vanobva mumapoka โepasiโโฆ vanowanzovanza dzinza ravo,โ nokuti vanotyira kuti โivo nemhuri dzavo vanogona kurambwa munzvimbo dzetsika nedzechitendero dzeSouth Asia, kurasikirwa nenyanzvi nesocial network, kana kutodheererwa, kushungurudzwa, uye chisimba.โ
Zvisinei, munguva pfupi yapfuura, mwaranzi mishomanene yechiedza yakabaya rima rezvamatongerwe enyika. MunaFebruary, Seattle rakava guta rekutanga muUS kurambidza rusarura rwemhando uye (joke, joke) yoga yakanga isina chekuita nazvo. Kurambidzwa uku kwakapfuura nekuda kwekushanda nesimba uye kubatana kwevaratidziri venzvimbo, pamwe nenhengo yekanzuru yeguta reSeattle, Kshama Sawant uyo akazvikurudzira. Zvino, muna Chivabvu 11, casteism yakadzingwa kubva mudunhu rose, hombe yenyika, apo seneti yeCalifornia. vakapfuura musayiri kune izvozvi.
Kuwedzera imwe noti yakanaka, zuva raitevera chairo, Modi's BJP yaive trounced neCongress Party musarudzo dzedare reparamende reKarnataka, nyika yakakosha mune zvematongerwo enyika dzeIndia. BJP payakahwina makore mashanu apfuura, yakatorwa senhanho yakakosha mukusimuka kwebato iri pakutonga kwenyika. Ikozvino, isu isu tinofarira demokrasi yechokwadi uye kwete yerudyi-kutyisa munyika mbiri idzi vanogona kungotarisira kuti kukundwa kweKarnataka chiratidzo chekudzikira kweBJP (sekuvimba kwatinoita kuti hapana Donald Trump kana Ron DeSantis anogona kutora White House mukati. 2024).
Asi kunyangwe kukunda kudiki hakuuyi pasina kusundidzirwa kubva kuHindu-nyika vakatamira kune dzimwe nyika uye RSS/BJP โvakangwaraโ muIndia, sezvazviri neVaTrumpists muAmerica. Zvisingashamise kuti, vakashora matanho matsva emuUS, vachivati โโ"Hinduphobic" (kungofanana nevachena-vachena mapapiro pano vachiimba "All Lives Matter" mumamiriro emhirizhonga yemapurisa uye kuseka bato reBlack Lives Matter). Asi, anobvunza nyanzvi yezvematongerwo enyika Kancha Ilailah Shepherd, "Nzira yerusarura rwevanhu ... ingagadziriswa sei pasina mitemo yemunharaunda kana mitemo yemasangano?"
MaIndia akawanda zvikuru eboka repamusoro uye vachena vokuAmerica vanozvifunga vamene saivo bedzi vakafanirwa nokufarikanya zvakapambwa zvapasi. Vanozvida zvose uye vakagadzirira kuzviwana kuburikidza nekushandisa, kwete kutaura kutyora, kwete-yepamusoro-caste miviri muIndia uye isiri-chena muU. Mitumbi yeDalits, maMuslim, maChristu, vanhu veKashmir yakagarwa, vakasununguka, vatori venhau, vanyori venhoroondo, mamiriro ekunze uye vanorwira kodzero dzevanhu, vadzidzisi, Vatema, Vechivanhu, vakadzi, LGBTQ vanhu - vese vari mafuro echisimba. munyika mbiri idzi.
Mumatope ekusarudzika kunoparadza kwakadaro, panogona kunzwika pfungwa yekusagadzikana, mukana wekuti nzanga dzedu dzose dziparare zvachose. Zvinosuruvarisa, iyo yoga uye yezvinomera hazvifukidze hupenyu muIndia; upper-caste exceptionalism inoita. Saizvozvo, "runyararo nerudo," tisingatauri nezve democracy, haichatsananguri hupenyu muAmerica zvakare kune inokura seti yeTrumpublicans. Kwavari, chena kusarudzika kunoita uye, zvakatoipisisa, mazuva ano zvinoenda zvakashongedzwa nazvo chombo chinotengeswa zvakanyanya yenguva ino, iyo AR-15 semi-otomatiki pfuti.
Chokwadi, panofanira kuva nehurukuro yakadzama yezvose izvi nguva isati yakwana.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta