1. Unoona sei kuburitswa kwenhau kwechiitiko ichi? Pane here kufanana neHondo yeGulf mu "mvumo yekugadzira?"
Kufukidzwa kweMedia hakuna kufanana sekutenda kwevaEurope, pamwe nekuti vari kuchengeta NYT, NPR, TV, zvichingodaro. Kunyangwe iyo NYT yakabvuma, mangwanani ano, kuti maitiro emuNew York akasiyana chaizvo neavanga vachiratidza. Inyaya yakanaka, zvakare ichinongedza nyaya yekuti vezvenhau vemazuvano vanga vasingataure izvi, izvo zvisiri zvechokwadi, kunyangwe changa chiri chokwadi, zvakanyanya, cheNYT. Asi zvakajairika kune vezvenhau vakuru, uye makirasi ehungwaru kazhinji, kusimuka mukutsigira simba panguva yedambudziko uye kuyedza kuunganidza huwandu hwevanhu nekuda kwechikonzero chimwe chete. Icho chaiva chokwadi, pamwe nekunyanya kutyisa, panguva yekubhomba kweSerbia. Hondo yeGulf yakanga isiri yechienzi zvachose. Kutora muenzaniso uri kure zvakakwana kuti isu tigone kuzvitarisa neshungu, vakangwara veEurope neNorth America vakaita sei kuHondo Yenyika I - mumativi ezvematongerwo enyika? Kusarudzika vashoma zvekuti tinogona kutovanyora, uye vazhinji vane mukurumbira vakapedzisira vari mutirongo: Rosa Luxemburg, Bertrand Russell, Eugene Debs,โฆ
2. Tichifunga kuti magandanga akasarudza World Trade Center sechinangwa chekufananidzira, kudyidzana kwenyika dzepasi pose uye hutsika hunobatsira sei kuumba ruvengo kuAmerica.
Uku kutenda kuri nyore kwazvo kune vakangwara vekuMadokero. Inovabvisa pamutoro wezviito izvo chaizvo zviri shure kwesarudzo yeWTC. Yakabhombwa muna 1993 nekuda kwekunetsekana kwekudyidzana kwepasirese uye kusimba kwetsika? Mazuva mashoma apfuura, Wall Street Journal yakataura maitiro evaIjipita vakapfuma uye vane rombo rakanaka pane imwe resitorendi yeMcDonald vakapfeka zvipfeko zveAmerica zvemhando yepamusoro, nezvimwewo, uye vachitsoropodza zvakanyanya US nekuda kwezvikonzero zvemitemo, zvinonyatsozivikanwa kune avo vanoda kuziva. : vaive neshumo mazuva mashoma apfuura pamusoro pemaitiro evemabhanga, nyanzvi, vezvemabhizimisi mudunhu, vese vanotsigira maAmerican, uye nekutsoropodza zvakaomarara kwemitemo yeUS. Iko kunetseka pamusoro pe "globalization", McDonald's, uye jeans? Maonero emumugwagwa akafanana, asi akanyanya kusimba, uye haana kana chekuita nezvikonzero zvefashoni izvi.
Kana iri network yeBin Laden, havana hanya nekudyidzana kwepasirese uye tsika nemagariro sezvavanoita kune varombo uye vanodzvinyirirwa vanhu vekuMiddle East avo vanga vachikuvadza zvakanyanya kwemakore. Vanotiudza zvinovanetsa uye zvakajeka: vari kurwa Hondo Tsvene kurwisa huwori, hudzvanyiriri, uye hutongi hwe "usiri hwechiIslam" hwedunhu, nevatsigiri vavo, sekurwa kwavakarwa Hondo Tsvene kurwisa maRussia munharaunda. 1980s (uye zvino vari kuita muChechnya, Western China, Egypt (mune iyi nyaya kubvira 1981, pavakauraya Sadat), uye kumwewo.Bin Laden pachake zvimwe haana kumbonzwa nezveโkudyidzana kwenyika.โ Avo vakamubvunzurudza zvakadzama, sezvakaita Robert Fisk, anoshuma kuti hapana chaanongoziva chenyika, uye haana basa nazvo.Tinogona kusarudza kufuratira chokwadi chese topinda mufungidziro dzekuzvigutsa kana tichida, asi nengozi huru kwatiri isu, pakati pevamwe. zvimwe zvinhu, isu tinogonawo kufuratira, kana tikasarudza, midzi ye "Afghanis" yakadai saBin Laden nevamwe vake, uyewo kwete chakavanzika.
3. Vanhu vekuAmerica vakadzidza here kuona izvi? Pane kuziva kwechikonzero nemhedzisiro here?
Zvinosuruvarisa kwete, sezvakangoita vanhu veEurope. Izvo zvakanyanya kukosha kune vane rombo rakanaka mudunhu reMiddle East (uye zvakatonyanya zvakadaro, mumigwagwa) hazvinzwisiswe pano, kunyanya muenzaniso unoshamisa: mutsauko weUS marongero kuIraq nekutorwa kwemauto eIsrael. Pamusoro pekupedzisira, chokwadi chakakosha hachina kutaurwa, uye zvinenge zvisingazivikanwe pasi rose, kunyanya kune vane njere dzepamusoro. Zviri nyore kwazvo kupa mienzaniso. Inogona kukuendesa zviri nyore kune zvakadhindwa kwemakore mazhinji, kana uchida, kusanganisira izvozvi.
4. Unoona sei kuita kweHurumende yeAmerica? Vari kumiririra ani?
Hurumende yeUS, sevamwe, inonyanya kupindura kunzvimbo dzemasimba epamba. Icho chinofanira kunge chiri chokwadi. Ehe, kune zvimwe zvinofurira, zvinosanganisira mafambiro akakurumbira - ichokwadi munharaunda dzese, kunyangwe masisitimu ane hutsinye ehudzvanyiriri, chokwadi anotonyanya demokrasi. Sezvo isu tine ruzivo, hurumende yeUnited States ikozvino iri kuedza kushandisa mukana wekuita gondohwe kuburikidza nehurongwa hwayo: mauto, kusanganisira "missile defense," izwi rekodhi rekugadzirisa nzvimbo; kukanganisa zvirongwa zvedemocracy yemagariro uye kunetseka pamusoro pemhedzisiro yakaipa ye "globalization" yemakambani, kana nyaya dzezvakatipoteredza, kana inishuwarenzi yehutano, zvichingodaro; kutanga matanho anozowedzera kuendeswa kwehupfumi kuzvikamu zvakamanikana (semuenzaniso, kubvisa mutero wekuwana mari); kudzora nzanga kuitira kubvisa nhaurirano nekuratidzira. Zvese zvakajairika, uye zvakasikwa zvachose. Kana iri mhinduro, ivo, ndinofungidzira, vachiteerera vatungamiriri vekune dzimwe nyika, nyanzvi dzeMiddle East, uye ndinofunga masangano avo ehungwaru, ari kuvayambira kuti mhinduro huru yemauto ichapindura minamato yaBin Laden. Asi kune vanhu vane hawkish vanoda kushandisa mukana uyu kurova vavengi vavo, nechisimba chakanyanya, zvisinei nekuti vangani vanhu vasina mhosva vanotambura, kusanganisira vanhu muno uye muEurope vanozobatwa nechisimba chiri kuramba chichiwedzera. Zvese zvakare mune yakajairika dynamic. Kune akawanda mabin Ladens kumativi ese, semazuva ese.
5. Kudyidzana kwepasi rose kwezvehupfumi kwakaparadzira muenzaniso wekumadokero kwese, uye USA mune primis yakatsigira, dzimwe nguva nenzira dzisina mubvunzo, kazhinji inonyadzisa tsika dzeko. Tiri kutarisana nemhedzisiro yemakumi emakore apfuura eAmerican Strategic policy? America haina mhosva here?
Iyi thesis inonyanya kuenderera mberi. Handibvumi. Chimwe chikonzero ndechekuti modhi yekumadokero - kunyanya, iyo US modhi - yakavakirwa pakupindira kwakakura kwenyika muhupfumi. Mitemo ye "neoliberal" yakafanana neyenguva dzekare. Iwo ane mativi maviri: kurangwa pamusika kwakakunakira iwe, asi kwete kwandiri, kunze kwekungobatsirwe kwechinguvana, pandinenge ndave pachinzvimbo chakanaka chekukunda mukwikwidzi.
Chechipiri, zvakaitika munaGunyana 11 hazvinei nechokuita nekudyidzana kwenyika dzepasi rose, mumaonero angu. Zvikonzero zviri kumwewo. Hapana chinogona kururamisa mhosva dzakadai saSept. 11, asi isu tinogona kufunga nezveUS se "munhu asina mhosva" kana chete tikatora nzira iri nyore yekuregeredza zviito zveUS nevabatsiri vayo, izvo, shure kwezvose, zvisingaite. chakavanzika.
6. Munhu wese anobvuma kuti hapana chichafanana mushure me11th september, gadzira hupenyu hwezuva nezuva nekudziviswa kwekodzero kusvika kuhurongwa hwepasi rose nemibatanidzwa mitsva nevavengi. Ndeapi maonero ako pamusoro peizvi?
Kurwiswa kwehugandanga kunotyisa neChipiri chimwe chinhu chitsva munyaya dzepasi rose, kwete muhukuru hwavo uye hunhu hwavo, asi muchinangwa. KuUS, aka ndekekutanga kubvira Hondo ye1812 kuti nharaunda yenyika yave ichirwiswa, kunyangwe kutyisidzirwa. Makoroni ayo akarwiswa, asi kwete nharaunda yenyika yacho pachayo. Mumakore aya US yakapotsa yaparadza vagari vemo, yakakunda hafu yeMexico, yakapindira nechisimba munharaunda yakapoteredza, yakakunda Hawaii nePhilippines (kuuraya mazana ezviuru zvevaPhilippines), uye muhafu yezana remakore rapfuura kunyanya, yakawedzera nzvimbo yayo yekumanikidza. munyika dzakawanda. Nhamba yevanotambudzwa ihombe. Kekutanga, pfuti dzakanangidzirwa kune imwe nzira. Zvimwe chetezvo ndezvechokwadi, zvinotonyanya kushamisa, zveEurope. Europe yakatambura kuparadzwa kwemhondi, asi kubva muhondo dzemukati, uku ichikunda nyika zhinji nehutsinye hwakanyanya. Asi India haina kurwisa England, kana Congo Belgium, kana East Indies Netherlands. Mumwe anogona kufunga nezvekusarudzika, asi iyi inyaya yechokwadi mumazana emakore akati wandei enhoroondo - kwete muchiyero, zvinosuruvarisa, asi mukusarudza kwechinangwa.
Handifungi kuti zvichatungamirira kudziviswa kwenguva refu kwekodzero mukati mune chero pfungwa yakakomba. Zvipingamupinyi zvetsika nemasangano kune izvo zvakanyanya kudzika midzi, ndinotenda. Kana US ikasarudza kupindura nekuwedzera kutenderera kwemhirizhonga, kupindura minamato yaBin Laden nevamwe vake, zvino mhedzisiro yacho inogona kunge inotyisa. Kune, hongu, dzimwe nzira, dziri pamutemo uye dzinovaka. Uye kune zvakawanda zvakatangira kwavari. Ruzhinji rwakamutswa mukati menharaunda dzakasununguka uye dzegutsaruzhinji vanogona kutungamira marongero kune nzira ine hunhu uye inoremekedzeka.
7. Masevhisi ehungwaru pasi rose uye hurongwa hwepasi rose hwekutonga (Echelon, semuenzaniso) aisakwanisa kuona zvaizoitika, kunyangwe kana network yepasi rose yeIslamic terrorism network yakanga isingazivikanwi. Zvinoita sei kuti maziso aBig Brother akavharwa? Isu tinofanira kutya here, iye zvino Mukoma Mukuru?
Ini kutaura chokwadi handina kumbonyanya kufadzwa nekunetsekana kwakataurwa muEurope pamusoro peEchelon sehurongwa hwekutonga. Kana dziri hurongwa hwehungwaru hwepasirese, kutadza kwavo nekufamba kwemakore kwave kukuru, inyaya ini nevamwe takanyora nezvayo, uye yandisingakwanise kutevera pano. Icho ichokwadi kunyange kana zvinangwa zvekunetseka zviri nyore kubata nazvo kupfuura network yeBin Laden, inofungidzirwa kuti ine mhosva yemhosva dzeSept. 11. Chokwadi munhu angatarisira kuti network ichanzwisiswa zvine mutsindo neCIA, French intelligence, nevamwe vakapinda mukuimisa nekuichengeta chero yaibatsira kwavari Hondo Tsvene kurwisa muvengi weRussia, asi kunyangwe zvakadaro vakaita. kusazvinzwisisa zvakakwana kudzivirira zviitiko zvakadai sekuurayiwa kweMutungamiri Sadat muna 1981, bhomba rekuzviuraya iro rakadzinga mauto eUS kubva kuRebhanoni muna 1983, uye nemimwe mienzaniso yakawanda yezvinonzi "blowback" mumabhuku enyaya idzi. .
Parizvino network haina mubvunzo kuti yakaganhurwa zvakanyanya, ichishaikwa muhurongwa hwehutungamiriri, uye yakapararira munzvimbo zhinji dzepasi zvekuti haichapindike. Iwo masevhisi ehungwaru pasina mubvunzo achapihwa zviwanikwa kuti aedze zvakanyanya. Asi kuedza kwakakomba kuderedza kutyisidzira kwerudzi urwu rwehugandanga, semune dzimwe nyaya dzisingaverengeki, kunoda kuedza kunzwisisa uye kugadzirisa zvikonzero.
Apo Federal Building yakaputika muOklahoma City, kwakanga kune kudanidzira kwapakarepo kwokubhomba Middle East. Izvi zvakapera pazvakaonekwa kuti mupari wemhosva aibva kuUS ultra-right militia movement. Kuita kwanga kusiri kwekuparadza Montana neIdaho, uko kwakavakirwa mafambiro, asi kutsvaga nekubata mupari wemhosva, kumuunza kumatare edzimhosva, uye - zvakanyanya - kuongorora zvichemo zviri shure kwemhosva dzakadai uye kugadzirisa matambudziko. Hunenge hutsotsi hwese - hungave humbavha mumigwagwa kana hutsinye hwakakura - hune zvikonzero, uye kazhinji tinoona kuti dzimwe dzakakomba uye dzinofanirwa kugadziriswa. Zvinhu hazvina kusiyana munyaya iyi - zvirinani, kune avo vane hanya nekudzikisa kutyisidzira kwemhirizhonga yemagandanga pane kuiwedzera.
8. Bin Laden, dhiyabhorosi: uyu muvengi here kana kuti mucherechedzo, rudzi rwechiratidzo chinozivisa nekuita kuti uipi huve hwomunhu?
Bin Laden anogona kana kusave akabatanidzwa zvakananga muzviito izvi, asi zvingangoita kuti network yaakange ari munhu mukuru ndeye - ndiko kuti, network yakagadzwa neUS nevabatsiri vayo nekuda kwezvinangwa zvavo uye inotsigirwa chero nguva. yakazadzisa zvinangwa izvozvo. Zviri nyore kwazvo kugadzirisa muvengi, anoonekwa sechiratidzo chehuipi hwekupedzisira, pane kutsvaga kunzwisisa zvakakonzera hutsinye hukuru. Uye kune, semasikirwo, miyedzo yakasimba kwazvo yekufuratira basa remunhu - iro mune iyi nyaya, haina kunetsa kuburitsa, uye zvechokwadi inozivikanwa kune wese munhu ane chero ruzivo nezvedunhu nenhoroondo yazvino.
9. Iyi hondo haisi njodzi yekuva Vietnam itsva here? Kushungurudzika ikoko kuchiri kurarama.
Ndiko kuenzanisa kunowanzosimudzwa. Zvinoratidza, mumaonero angu, kukanganisa kwakadzama kwemazana emakore emhirizhonga yehumambo pahungwaru nehutsika hweMadokero. Hondo muVietnam yakatanga sekurwisa kweUS kurwisa South Vietnam, iyo yaigara iri chinangwa chikuru chehondo dzeUS, dzakaguma nekuparadza kwakawanda kweIndochina. Kunze kwekunge isu tichida kutarisana neiyo yekutanga chokwadi, isu hatigone kutaura zvakanyanya nezvehondo dzeVietnam. Ichokwadi kuti hondo yakaratidza kudhura kuU. Kupinda kweAfghanistan kwakaratidzawo kudhura kuUSSR, asi harisi iro dambudziko rinouya kumberi kana tikafunga mhosva iyi.