UKUHLASELWA kwamaphekula okuhlotshaniswa kahle kubagibeli base-Mumbai ngoJulayi 11 sekuvule indlela yokuvela kabusha kwezingxabano ezimbili ezilula, okungekho kuzo ezinikeza indlela eqinisekile yokuqeda lolu dlame olungenangqondo, lobugebengu unomphela.
E-India, ukuqhuma sekuholele ekutheni iqembu eliphikisayo i-Bharatiya Janata Party kanye nabahlaziyi abaningi bezokuphepha basole uHulumeni kaManmohan Singh ngokuzibandakanya ohlelweni lokuthula nePakistan, okusobala ukuthi umbuso wayo wezempi awuzange ufeze isithembiso sawo sokuvimbela izinhlangano zamaphekula ekusebenzeni ngaphansi kwawo. insimu. Laba bagxekayo baphinde bathola iphutha ngokuchithwa komthetho iPrevention of Terrorism Act (POTA), bethi amaphoyisa aphelelwe amandla ngenxa yalokhu. Ngokwale nkulumo, izenzo eziningi zobuphekula ziwumkhiqizo wezinhlangano zezobunhloli zasePakistan; futhi i-India iyisisulu ngenxa yokungakwazi kukahulumeni ukuthatha i-Islamabad ukuba ibhekane nokuvumela izinyathelo ezinzima kulabo abasolwa ngokubandakanyeka ebuphekula. I-BJP iphinde yafuna ukuhlanganisa le mpikiswano ngokuxhumanisa icala "elithambile lobuphekula" "nokuvota kwezepolitiki yasebhange" kanye nalokho okubizwa ngokuthi "ukushweleza" kwamaSulumane, indiva iqiniso lokuthi abantu bazo zonke izinkolo nezifunda zaseNdiya bafuna ukuchithwa. yePOTA ngoba yayisetshenziswa kubantu abangenacala.
Ingxabano yesibili, eyinkinga ngokufanayo, izungeza isidingo sokuxazulula lokho okubizwa ngokuthi โumsuka wembangelaโ yobuphekula.
UKhurshid Ahmed Kasuri, uNgqongqoshe Wezangaphandle wasePakistan, unikeze okuhlukile kwalokhu lapho ephakamisa ukuthi ukuqhuma kweMumbai kuhlobene nokwehluleka kweNdiya ukuxazulula ingxabano yaseKashmir. โNgicabanga ukuthi isigameko saseMumbai รขโฌโ nokho singaba sidabukisa kanjani futhi ngokungangabazeki sidabukisa kakhuluรขโฌโ sigcizelela isidingo sokuthi la mazwe amabili asebenzisane ukuze alawule le ndawo, kodwa angakwenza lokho kuphela uma exazulula izingxabano zawo, โ etshela abeReuters ngoLwesithathu. Ukuphawula kwakhe kuveze intukuthelo eqhamuka eNdiya.
Ezingeni lefilosofi, umqondo wokuthi ingxabano engapheli ingaholela odlameni awuhlukile. Okunye okungajwayelekile kungaba isiphakamiso - nakuba uMnu. Kasuri engakwenzanga - ukuthi izisulu "zesibambiso" zomkhankaso wokulwa nokuvukela umbuso kahulumeni waseNdiya eKashmir zingazizwa ziphoqeleka ukwenza izenzo zobuphekula. Kodwa lokho uMnu. Kasuri kanye nezinye izisusa-wallahs abahlulekayo ukukwazisa isimo se-nihilist sokuhlasela okuhleliwe kwabagibeli baseMumbai. Njengokuqhuma kwamabhomu eLondon naseMadrid, kanye nokuhlasela okunonya kweWorld Trade Center, ukuqhuma kwamabhomu eMumbai kwakuwumzamo wamabomu wokukhomba abantu abangamasosha. Abenzi bobubi abasiboni isidingo sokukhipha isitatimende noma ukusakaza umqulu wezimfuno ngoba inhloso yokuhlasela akukhona ukulungisa isikhalo noma ukuxazululwa kwengxabano, kodwa ukudalwa kwayo.
Inhloso ukuvusa udlame olwengeziwe nokungavikeleki futhi kuncishiswe isikhala esikhona sezingxoxo, izinkulumo-mpikiswano, kanye nokuphikisana ngokuvuna iziqinisekiso ze-hawkish zokusungulwa kwezokuphepha.
Yize bungekho ubufakazi okwamanje, uMnu. Kasuri ukhethe ukwenza ukuxhumana phakathi kweMumbai neKashmir. Kodwa obekufanele akusho ukuthi labo abathathe izikhali egameni โlomzabalazo wenkululekoโ noma i-jihad abanalo ilungelo lokulwa nabantu abangahlomile. Amaqembu agxile kwezombangazwe noma ezenkolo athi amelana nokucindezelwa anomthwalo wemfanelo omkhulu wokuqhuba โumshikashikaโ wawo ngokwemithetho yempi njengoba kwenza amabutho ezokuphepha. Ayikho ingxabano engaxazululiwe, akukho ukwephulwa kwamalungelo abantu okungase kunike umuntu รขโฌโ ngisho noma kwenzeka eyisisulu sokungabi nabulungisaรขโฌโ ilungelo lokuqhumisa izakhamuzi ezingenacala esitimeleni noma kwenye indawo. โIzimbangela eziyimbangelaโ zibalulekile futhi kufanele kuxoxiswane ngazo futhi kubhekwane nazo kodwa into yokuqala okufanele ibe wumsebenzi omuhle wamaphoyisa, uphenyo lwezobunhloli kanye nezobunhloli ukuze abenzi bobubi baboshwe. Ngasohlangothini lwabo, uMnu. Kasuri nozakwabo ePakistan kudingeka bakhulume ngokumelene nezenzo zobuphekula ezinjalo. Akumele bafune isiphephelo รขโฌโ njengoba bevame ukwenza รขโฌโ emazwini angathembekile okuthi lonke uvalo oluqondiswe ezakhamuzini empeleni kuwumsebenzi wezandla /ama-agent provocateurs/ noma izinhlangano zezobunhloli zaseNdiya.
Odabeni lwasePakistan, kunomthwalo wemfanelo wokungagcini nje ngokugxeka izehlakalo ezinjalo kodwa nokwenza. NgoJanuwari 2004, uGeneral Pervez Musharraf wathembisa
Njengoba uHulumeni waseManmohan ezindla ngezinketho zakhe mayelana nokuxoxisana nePakistan, kufanele azibuze imibuzo emibili. Okokuqala, ingabe kukhona okungenziwa ukuze isikhungo sasePakistan siguqule imizamo yalo engaphelele yokulwa nobuphekula ibe ngenhliziyo yonke? Okwesibili, ingabe i-India ivumile noma yini engxoxweni eyinhlanganisela eyenza izwe libe sengozini enkulu kwezokuphepha?
Impendulo yami ithi 'cha' kubo bobabili kodwa kukho konke ukugxeka kwabo inqubo yokuthula, i-BJP kanye nabasekeli bayo abanazo izimpendulo ezicacile zanoma yimuphi umbuzo.
> Kusukela ebunyameni baseLahore kuya ebuhleni be-Operation Parakram,
ngesikhathi uHulumeni waseVajpayee wazama konke. Naphezu kokuthunyelwa kwamasosha eqaphe ngokugcwele izinyanga ze-10 kanye nemibono ephekwe ingxenye "ye-coercive diplomacy," "iziteleka zokuhlinzwa," kanye "nempi elinganiselwe," kwacaca ukuthi sasingekho isisombululo sezempi enkingeni yamaphekula asekelwe Pakistan. Kodwa uma ukusongelwa kwezempi kungeke kuveze imiphumela, ukumisa inqubo yokuthula noma ukubambezela umhlangano woNobhala ababili Bangaphandle kungenza kanjani iqhinga? Kunoma yikuphi, inqubo yokuthula kuze kube manje ibe yinhle ngokwedlulele ngokombono waseNdiya. Izinyathelo eziningi zokwakha ukuzethemba kwethulwe, okuvumela i-India ukuthi idlule u-Gen. Musharraf kanye nebutho futhi yakhe indawo yokuthula ukuze kube nokuthula emphakathini wasePakistan, kuhlanganise nomphakathi wayo wamabhizinisi. Futhi eKashmir, izinhlangothi zombili seziqalile ukukhuluma ngendlela evamile evuma ukuthi imingcele ayikwazi ukudwetshwa kabusha.
Ngokusekelwe kwirekhodi kuze kube manje, i-India ayinalutho engalahlekelwa yilolu hlelo oluqhubeka ngaphandle kokuphazamiseka. Uma kukhona, kusePakistan lapho umuntu ezwa khona ukukhathazeka mayelana โnogibe lwe-CBMโ i-India ebeke ukuthi ihlehlise isivumelwano eKashmir.
*Izimo ezintathu*
Lesi siphetho asincike ekutheni bangobani abenzi bokuqhuma kokuqhuma kweMumbai.
Ngobubanzi, kunamathuba amathathu. Okokuqala, i-Al-Qaeda รขโฌโ noma inhlangano ethile exhumene nayo รขโฌโ elwa kakhulu noHulumeni waseMusharraf njengoba kunjalo neNdiya. Inhloso kungaba ukuphazamisa inqubo yokuthula, idale ukuhlehla komphakathi ngokunikeza umfutho ku-sangh parivar, futhi ithumele umlayezo emhlabeni, futhi ikakhulukazi i-U.S., ukuthi 'impi yobushokobezi' isekude ukuphela. Ngaphansi kwezimo ezinjalo, ngokuqinisekile impendulo efanelekile yamaNdiya kungaba ukunganikezi amaphekula amandla evoti phezu kwenqubo yokuthula.
Kuthiwani uma ababhali bokuqhuma kuvela ukuthi yi-LeT noma i-JeM, esebenza ngokubambisana nengxenye ethile yesifunda sasePakistan? Uma nakancane uhulumeni wasePakistan noma enye yezikhungo zayo ixhumene nokuqhuma kwaseMumbai, lokhu kungaba nje ukuthi i-Islamabad ayigculisekile ngendlela inqubo yokuthula ehamba ngayo. Mhlawumbe ukuqhuma kweMumbai kwakuklanyelwe ukufaka ingcindezi eNdiya ukuthi yenze isivumelwano eKashmir. Kepha i-ISI kumele yazi ukuthi iziphi izimvume ezincane e-India ebonakala ikulungele ukuzenza, ikakhulukazi ingqondo kaNdunankulu u-Manmohan Singh futhi iphikiswa ngezinyo nezinzipho yinhlangano yezomthetho nezokuphepha. Uma kukhona-ke, ukuqhuma kwaseMumbai kwenza kube nzima nakakhulu ukuthi ubuholi bezepolitiki bunikeze imvume.
Kunelinye iphuzu abenzi benqubomgomo baseNdiya okufanele balicabangele lapho behlola ukuthi ngabe amasosha asePakistan abe nesandla yini kulokhu kuqhuma. IPakistan ithi kune-firewall ekhona phakathi kwama-anti-American, ontamolukhuni abaxhumene ne-Al-Qaeda kanye namaqembu amelene ne-India afana ne-LeT ne-JeM. Kepha ukuqhuma kweMumbai - uhlobo lwazo olulandelanayo, ukukhetha ezokuthutha zomphakathi, ukuba seduze kwabo nesikhumbuzo sokuqhuma kwamabhomu eLondon - kusebenza ukuqinisa ukuxhumana phakathi kweKashmir kanye `nempi yomhlaba wonke yobushokobezi' kuze kufike emphakathini wamazwe omhlaba. ukhathazekile. Kungaholela engcindezini enkulu nakakhulu ku-Islamabad ukuthi ihlasele abashokobezi abaxhumene neKashmir. Kunzima ukubona ukuthi umphumela onjalo - obekungabikezelwa ngokuphelele kumaphekula ahlela ukuqhuma kwamabhomu eMumbai - uzofeza izithakazelo zombuso kaMusharraf noma i-ISI.
Noma kunjalo, uma kubhekwa ingxenye ethile yokuhambisana okusemthethweni kwePakistan, i-India inezinketho ezimbalwa maqondana nokwanda kwengcindezi ePakistan. Uma kunezindawo lapho inqubo yokuthula ingenza izwe libe sengozini kakhulu รขโฌโ Amasosha angaphikisa ukuthi i-Siachen ingenye yendawo enjalo รขโฌโukuthi ukuhamba kancane okungashiwongo kungase kuthethelelwe. Kodwa kwezinye izinhlangothi, le nqubo ngokusobala isebenza ngendlela ezuzisa iNdiya futhi awukho umqondo wokudebeselela izinzuzo.
Kunesimo sesithathu futhi, sokuthi amaphekula akuwona abaxhasi be-Al-Qaeda noma abasePakistan kodwa abashisekeli basekhaya, noma ngabe amaSulumane, amaHindu noma amanye amakholwa noma ipolitiki. Kodwa futhi, ukukhipha intukuthelo yethu yezwe lonke ohlelweni lwezingxoxo eziyinhlanganisela ngeke kube nengqondo.
Ngaphansi kwazo zontathu lezi zimo, umsebenzi ocindezela kakhulu ukwenza uphenyo olusheshayo noluchwepheshe. Ukuthembela okuyinhloko kufanele kube emisebenzini yezobunhloli kanye nomsebenzi omuhle wobuseshi hhayi ekubhidlizeni amadolo nemithetho ekhethekile. Ecaleni lokuhlasela ePhalamende, amaphoyisa aveze ukuboshwa okumangalisayo kanye `nokuvuma izono' kalula kodwa ongqondongqondo bangempela abazange babonakale. I-Mumbai akufanele ihambe ngendlela efanayo.
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa kuphela ngokuphana kwabafundi bayo.
Nikela