Umthombo: Scheerpost
Kwisincoko sango-1979 esibizwa, “Intetho Yam Kwabaphumeleleyo,” uWoody Allen wabhala:
Ngaphezu kwalo naliphi na elinye ixesha embalini, uluntu lujamelene neengxaki. Enye indlela ikhokelela ekuphelelweni lithemba kunye nokungabi nathemba. Enye, kukuphela ngokupheleleyo. Masithandaze sinobulumko bokukhetha ngokuchanekileyo.
U-Allen wayehlekisa ngembono yokuba kusoloko kukho ukhetho oluhle ebomini. Amaxesha amaninzi, azibikho. Ngamanye amaxesha ifolokhwe kwindlela engaphambili ikucela ukuba ukhethe phakathi kweendlela ezahlukeneyo eziya esihogweni. Ongasekhoyo, omkhulu uGilbert Gottfried wakha wenza inqaku elifanayo kwi standup yesiqhelo malunga nabavangeli basemazweni abaswelekileyo nje kancinci kancinci kunoAllen.
Ingqondi yoluntu engenakunqandwa uNoam Chomsky wenze udliwano-ndlebe kuye Izinto zangoku kwiveki ephelileyo, “Indlela yokuthintela iMfazwe Yehlabathi III.” Ngokuphathelele eUkraine, uChomsky waphinda watyelela “Intetho Yam Kwabaphumeleleyo”:
Kukho iinketho ezimbini malunga neUkraine. Njengoko sisazi, enye inketho a isivumelwano sothethathethwano, eya kunika uPutin ukubaleka, indawo yokuhlala embi. Ngaba iyafikeleleka? Asazi; ungafumanisa kuphela ngokuzama kwaye siyala ukuzama. Kodwa le yinketho enye. Olunye ukhetho kukukwenza kucace kwaye kucace kuPutin kunye nesangqa esincinci samadoda ajikeleze kuye ukuba awunakubaleka, uya kutyala lolwaphulo-mthetho lwemfazwe kungakhathaliseki ukuba wenzani. Boris Johnson nje wayiphinda le nto: izohlwayo ziya kuqhubeka nokuba wenza ntoni. Ithetha ntoni le nto? Kuthetha ukuba qhubeka uye kuyicima iUkraine kwaye uqhubeke nokubeka isiseko semfazwe ebulalayo.
Ezi zimbini iinketho: kwaye sikhetha okwesibini kwaye sizincome ngobugorha kwaye siyenze: ukulwa neRussia ukuya kwi-Ukraine yokugqibela.
Kwabakho ingqumbo ekhawulezileyo (kutheni i-Twitter ingenayo i-emoji "yetotshi" ekhethekileyo yamahlokondiba agxekayo?). UChomsky wagwetywa njenge-genocide-enabled, iMelika-ithiyileyo i-Kremlin stooge. Isampulu encinci:
Ndafika kuChomsky malunga ne-brouhaha. Unjingalwazi olungileyo wayengazi ukuba uqalise ukunyibilika kwimithombo yeendaba zentlalo, kodwa waphawula ngendlela eqhelekileyo.
“Kuyinto eqhelekileyo kubaphathi bemfundiso ukuba babagwebe ngokukrakra abantu (1) abangagcini ngokungqongqo kwiParty Line, ngoko ke abanakwamkelwa kwizangqa zabo kwaye (2) babe nokufikelela okuthile kumarhashalala,” utshilo. “Iyavakala, iqhelekile. Kufuneka uqiniseke ukuba 'umhlambi weengqondo ezizimeleyo' awuphambuki.”
UChomsky uye rhoqo khankanyiweyo a intshayelelo ecetywayo kwi Ifama yezilwanyana Oko akuzange kubonwe de kwangowe-1971. Kuyo, uGeorge Orwell wathi imibutho ekhululekileyo icinezela ingcinga phantse ngokufanelekileyo njengeeSoviets ezinobuzwilakhe awayezigculela kumzekeliso wakhe odumileyo wefama. Wabhala, umzekelo, ukuba ukugxeka uStalin akuzange kwenziwe kwi-liberal society yesiNgesi ngelo xesha:
Umba obandakanyekileyo apha ulula kakhulu: Ngaba zonke iimbono, nangona zingathandwa – nokuba zibubudenge kangakanani na—zinelungelo lokuviwa? Yibeke ngolo hlobo kwaye phantse nayiphi na ingcaphephe yesiNgesi iya kuvakalelwa kukuba ifanele ukuthi “Ewe.” Kodwa yinike ubume bekhonkrithi, kwaye ubuze, “Kuthekani ngohlaselo lukaStalin? Ngaba oko kunelungelo lokuchotshelwa?” kwaye impendulo rhoqo kunokuba ithi “Hayi.”
UChomsky waphinda waveza le ndinyana ye-Orwell malunga nempikiswano yaseUkraine, ecaphula umzekelo wonozakuzaku waseMelika ogama linguChas Freeman.
"Oku ngamanye amaxesha kunabela kumanani ahlonitshwa kakhulu ngaphakathi," utshilo. “Imeko enomdla ngoku nguNxusa uChas Freeman, ohlonitshwe kakhulu phakathi kwemibutho. Kodwa uye wemka kwizithethe zaseUkraine.”
UFreeman, owayesakuba ngunozakuzaku eSaudi Arabia kunye nosekela Nobhala wezoKhuselo kwiMicimbi yoKhuseleko lwaMazwe ngaMazwe, kutshanje unike i udliwano-ndlebe ukuya Grayzone apho wayethetha ngokukhwankqiswa luhlaselo lwaseUkraine. Wasibiza ngokuba “sisigqibo esikhawulezileyo” “esiyimpazamo efanayo” nokuhlasela kukaTsar Nicholas eJapan, okunokubakho kweziphumo eziyintlekele ezifanayo. Kwangaxeshanye, uFreeman wayeyigxeka impendulo yaseNtshona, esithi kukho “izinto ezingenamsebenzi” ezininzi ekugqubeni kwaye wongeza, “Imfazwe yinkungu yobuxoki macala onke. Akunakwenzeka ukuxela eyona nto yenzekayo kuba macala onke abonisa umboniso. ”
UChomsky uthe abantu abanjengoFreeman abashiya i-orthodoxy yezokhuseleko lwesizwe bahlala beshiywe ukuba benze udliwano-ndlebe kwiindawo ezincinci ezizimeleyo, apho abahlalutyi baseziko baye babalandele ngokunxulumana nezinye izinto kwezo ndawo, iqhinga elicocekileyo.
“Yinkqubo esebenza kakhulu yolawulo lweengcinga kuluntu olukhululekileyo, luhamba ngaphaya koko u-Orwell wayekucingela kumagama akhe ambalwa ngalo mbandela,” utshilo.
YayinguFreeman owasebenzisa ibinzana elithi, “ukulwa ukuya kutsho kwi-Ukraine yokugqibela” ukuchaza iqhinga laseMelika eUkraine. Eli binzana lalucaphukisa uninzi lwabagxeki bakaChomsky, ababebonakala becinga ukuba la ngamazwi akhe. Udliwano-ndlebe lwatolikwa ngendlela engaqhelekanga ngezinye iindlela. Umzekelo, uChomsky wayengathi iUkraine kufuneka "inikezele" (njengomcimbi osebenzayo nkqu nomongameli wase-Ukraine uVolodymyr Zelensky uya kuba nexesha elinzima lokuthengisa phantse naluphi na ukupheliswa komlilo kubantu baseUkraine, kodwa ngumbuzo owahlukileyo lowo). Wayecingela malunga nokuba umgaqo-nkqubo wase-United States malunga ne-Ukraine kufuneka ube yintoni, kwaye wabeka oko akubona njengokhetho olubi.
Enye yimfazwe eqhubekayo yezixhobo kunye neproxy echasene notshaba olunomkhosi nolungalindelekanga oluxhomekeke kwinkqubo yenyukliya yakudala. Le ndlela inokukhokelela kwiArmagedon okanye ukutshatyalaliswa ngokupheleleyo kweUkraine. Olunye ukhetho lutyhalela isivumelwano sothethathethwano, iiparameters ngokubanzi esele zaziwa ngawo onke amaqela. Oku kuya kubandakanya ukwenza imvume embi kakhulu kurhulumente osele egwetyiwe kulo lonke elaseNtshona ngokwenza ubugebenga bemfazwe, kwaye ayinakuphelisa ubutshaba ixesha elide.
Ukuphela ngokupheleleyo, okanye ukungabi nathemba ngokupheleleyo. Ukufa, okanye Ugu. Ukuthabatha okudandathekisayo, kodwa ukungcatsha?
Into enomdla malunga namagqabantshintshi e-Ukraine kaChomsky yayingekuko nokuba babedukile, kodwa wayebanika. Izinto zangoku. I-hits kunye ne-traffic yodliwano-ndlebe oludala impikiswano kaChomsky yayinokuba yeyo ENew York Times, Washington Post, okanye i-MSNBC, ethe kunyaka ophelileyo yaphula isithethe sexesha elide esasaza udliwano-ndlebe ne IMvume yokuVeliswa umbhali. Nangona kunjalo, kweli lizwe, xa kufikwa kwimfazwe, iinkampani ezinkulu zemithombo yeendaba azibonisi nje iimbono eziphikisayo, nangenxa yokuzingca kwezoqoqosho.
Ngaphambi kokuba "i-de-platforming" ibe ligama kwi-American consciousness, umshicileli wethu wenkampani wayifezekisa ngokumalunga nabagxeki bemfazwe. Emuva ngoMeyi ka-2003, iinyanga kuhlaselo lweMfazwe yase-Iraq, i-media watchdog FAIR yenza isifundo ye-1,617 yemithombo yekhamera ekhankanywe kuthungelwano lukamabonwakude amathandathu kwaye yafikelela kwizigqibo ezimangalisayo. "Amazwi achasene nemfazwe ayeyipesenti ye-10 yayo yonke imithombo, kodwa ipesenti ezi-6 kuphela zemithombo engeyiyo yase-Iraqi kunye neepesenti ze-3 zemithombo yase-US," iqela laphawula, kodwa yayiyi-appetizer kuphela:
Kwimithombo engama-840 yemithombo yase-US ekuyo ngoku okanye yangaphambili okanye amagosa asemkhosini, bane kuphela abachongwe njengababambe iimbono ezichasene nemfazwe-uSen. URobert Byrd (D.-WV), u-Rep. Pete Stark (D.-Calif.) kunye neembonakalo ezimbini ngu-Rep. Dennis Kucinich (D.-Ohio). U-Byrd uboniswe kwi-PBS, kunye no-Stark kunye no-Kucinich bavela kwi-Fox News.
Lo mboniso wamashumi eminyaka kamva iMelika yenzeke ngo-2003. Umboniso wemihla ngemihla — ngubani onokuyilibala ekaJon Stewart "Zonke ziphakamela intshontsho elihloniphekileyo loBulungisa elinoDick!" qhula ngaloo nyaka malunga nokuzimisela kukaKucinich ukutyumba umntu otshintshe isini ebhentshini-kwaye kwafuneka aye kwiFox egcinayo ukuthetha ngokuchasene nohlaselo lwase-Iraq. I-FAIR ifumene imvumelwano yokwenyani malunga nemfazwe phakathi kwezikhululo eziphambili ze-ABC, CBS, NBC, kunye ne-CNN phantse kwiminyaka engamashumi amabini eyadlulayo.
Ukusukela ngoko, siye sandisa kuphela indawo yokungabhabhi. Kuphuhliso olwaluya kuthi ngelo xesha ndibheje ngobomi bam ukuba soze yenzeke, amazwi achasene nokungenelela okanye abameli babantu abanjalo baya bevaleleka kwiFox ukuba bavela kumajelo eendaba amakhulu konke konke.
Oku kuqala ngabo bangabathinjwa ngokoqobo okanye ide facto amabanjwa ezopolitiko, njengo-Edward Snowden okanye uJulian Assange, kwaye uyaqhubeka noluhlu olukhulayo lwabantu abafana noHersh okhankanywe ngasentla okanye umenzi wefilimu wase-Australia uJohn Pilger okanye uKucinich okanye uTulsi Gabbard okanye ukulungiswa kwetotshi yakutsha nje uJohn Mearsheimer, bonke abaye bafakwa kwi-pay-no. Uluhlu lwengqondo lweembono nge-Iraq, Libya, Afghanistan, Syria, Ukraine, kunye nolunye ungenelelo lokwenyani okanye olunokubakho emkhosini. Xa uSenator weDemokhrasi (D-DE) uChris Coons ekhuphe enye yokuqala kwinto eqinisekileyo ukuba luluhlu olude lweefowuni ezisemthethweni zokubandakanyeka ngokuthe ngqo kwe-US kungquzulwano lwaseUkraine, esithi uVladimir Putin "uya kuyeka kuphela xa simnqanda,” ekuphela kwento yokutyhalela phambili kweendaba eziphambili yeza ukusuka kuTucker Carlson kwiFox. Ayisiyiyo into yokuba iFox yiparadesi ekhanyisiweyo ye-pacifism, kodwa indawo yeendaba esekhohlo yintlango epheleleyo xa kufikwa ekuchaseni ubulumko obuqhelekileyo beNatsec. IFox xa ithelekisa mhlawumbi inemithi yesundu eshwabeneyo elundini phayaa. Ngeli xesha, amazwi athandabuzayo emfazweni ngasekhohlo afakwa kwiindawo ezihlala zincinci.
Umthengi ofunda ushicilelo lwemveli kuphela uya kubona ukhuselo lwaseUkraine luvalelwe kwezi parameters zilandelayo: ngaba kufuneka sibambelele kwizohlwayo nje kunye nokuthumela iingalo, okanye phezulu? Jonga indlela amabali amalunga novoto ngalo mbandela achazwa ngayo. Wonke umntu ukhuliswe ngolwimi olufanayo: ngaba kufuneka sibandakanyeke ngakumbi? Nantsi indlela yokuvula i-AP ibali, enesihloko esithi, “I-AP-NORC yokuvota: Inkxaso engakumbi ye-Ukraine, inkxalabo malunga neRashiya":
WASHINGTON (AP) - Njengoko IRashiya iyandisa imfazwe yayo eUkraine kunye namabali okwenzakala kwabantu kunye nokutshatyalaliswa kwizixeko zifikelela eUnited States, inkxaso iye yaphakama kwindima enkulu yaseMelika-kwaye kunjalo noloyiko lwesisongelo esiseRashiya e-US.
Oku kuvela kwiNPR's “Uninzi lwabantu baseMelika abayithandi impendulo yeBiden yaseUkraine":
Entsha Uvoto lweNPR/Ipsos ufumanisa ukuba uninzi lwabantu baseMelika bacinga ukuba uMongameli uBiden akenzanga umsebenzi olungileyo ekuphatheni kwakhe imfazwe. Uninzi luthi umongameli ulumke kakhulu, nanjengoko uninzi lusithi lulumkile ukuvusa ungquzulwano olubanzi.
Lo yayingumzobo wokuqala “kwi-CBS News poll-Imfazwe e-Ukraine: I-US ifanele yenze ntoni ngoku?”:
Ababukeli babona iintatheli zibuza izihlandlo ezilikhulu ngosuku ukuba sibandakanyeka ngokwaneleyo okanye sithumela iingalo ezaneleyo. Ngeli xesha enye intatheli, uRyan Grim we NONE ikwazile ukufumana umbuzo phambi kukaJen Psaki malunga nokuba iUnited States iceba ukuphendula okanye ayizizo izicelo zase-Ukraine zoncedo lozakuzo. Bukela le vidiyo yothelekiso ingoyikiyo:
Uninzi lwabalandeli beendaba baseMelika mhlawumbi abayazi nokuba uZelensky ubuzile i-US yoncedo lwezozakuzo. Zonke iintloko zimalunga noZelensky ecela izixhobo okanye izohlwayo, nokuba kukho isivakalisi esingcwatywe kwezinye zezicatshulwa malunga noncedo lwediplomatic. Thatha umzekelo "UZelensky uphakamisa ukugxekwa kweNtshona, efuna izixhobo kunye nezohlwayo"(Washington Post), okanye “UZelensky waseUkraine ucela uncedo olongezelelekileyo lwasemkhosini"(Wall Street Journal), okanye “IUkraine icele uncedo lomkhosi. Nantsi indlela amahlakani abonelela ngayo uncedo” (CNN).
Amabali ambalwa achaze ukuba i-United States ibonakala inqabile ukuthatha inxaxheba kwiintetho zoxolo, okanye ukunika amandla uZelensky ukuba athethe ngokupheliswa kwesohlwayo. Nokuba bambalwa baye bachaza inani elikhulayo lezimvo ezivela kumagosa angoku kunye nangaphambili aseMelika acebisa ukuba i-US kufuneka "itsale iqhinga leBrzezinski," njengoko uChomsky esitsho. Lo ngumbono wokuba ukutsala iRussia kumgxobhozo omude womkhosi kunokulwenza buthathaka utshaba ekuhambeni kwexesha, njengoko uMcebisi weSizwe woKhuseleko kaJimmy Carter (kunye noTata we-MSNBC’s yammerer enamehlo amaqhosha uMika) uZbigniew Brzezinski wayekholelwa ukuba yimeko emva kohlaselo lwaseSoviet eAfghanistan. . “Le yimodeli abantu abayiyo ngoku, oh, bajonge ngakuyo,” uHillary Clinton oncumayo. utshilo kwi-CNN hayi kudala.
Ukuba ukwicala elingalunganga lemvumelwano yokhuseleko lwesizwe, okanye ufuna nje ukucebisa ukuba ezinye izimvo zomgaqo-nkqubo zikhona, awuyi kuyenza kufutshane neendaba eziphambili ngoku. Ubupolisa ngalo mbandela buqatha ngakumbi kunokuba kwakunjalo nakwimvisiswano yexesha langaphambi kwe-Iraq. Ngaphezu koko, njengoko uFreddie deBoer nje iphawulwe kwi-Substack, kwanabantu “abazichaza ngokwabo ngokuthethelela ukungavisisani nenkululeko yokuthetha” “akufane kwenzeke ukuba bafune ukuba wonk’ ubani abe nengxelo ebalaseleyo., "U Ukongeza, "uninzi lwabantu abasoloko behlekisa ngezopolitiko ze-Instagram-bio babeke iiflegi zaseUkraine kwezabo." IMelika ibonakala idiniwe kukucinga kwaye ifuna ukubuyela ekuvuyiseni, kodwa ngamanye amaxesha akukho nto inokuvuyisa. Ngamanye amaxesha, ngaphandle kokuba ungumphathi weRaytheon, zonke iinketho ziyoyikeka.
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa ngemali kuphela ngesisa sabafundi bayo.
Nikela
2 izimvo
Njengommi waseYurophu, ndihlala ndikufumanisa kumangalisa xa (kumzekelo nje apha) i-ABC, i-CBS, i-NBC kunye ne-CNN zichazwa "njenge-center-left" (Ndibone iiwebhusayithi zeendaba zide zibeke i-CNN "njengekhohlo elikude"). Ingaba ithetha ntoni? Ndicinga ukuba kulapho useta khona iiparamitha. Ngale migangatho, uJoe Biden "ushiywe" kwaye uMitch McConnell "uphakathi". UHitler, ndicinga ukuba, uya kuba "lilungelo eliphakathi". Kum, igama elithi "ekhohlo" lithetha "ubusoshiyali" kwaye andiboni nto yentlalontle eBiden okanye nakweyiphi na indawo yeendaba yase-US. Kubonakala kum ukuba njengoko i-right ekude e-US iya icaphuka ngakumbi ngamajelo aqhelekileyo, ngenxa yaso nasiphi na isizathu, ngakumbi "ekhohlo" echazwe, ngaphandle kokuba naziphi na iziqinisekiso zasekhohlo.
Eli nqaku liyasilela ukukhankanya ingongoma ebalulekileyo. Isikhundla sikaChomsky eCrimea, oko kukuthi igcinwe etafileni, yindawo yabaxoxisi baseUkraine kunye noZelensky ngokwakhe. UChomsky akakhuthazi nantoni na abantu base-Ukrainian ngokwabo abafuni kuthethathethana.