Ndinobvuma kunzwa kugutsikana kusinganzwisisike kuti Ken Roth akagadzwa seMukuru weCarr Center of Human Rights yeHarvard's Kennedy School of Government akanzurwa. Mushure mekushanda kwemakore makumi maviri nemapfumbamwe seMukuru weHuman Rights Watch, sangano rinotungamira pasi rose rinotarisana nekutyorwa kwekodzero dzevanhu, Roth aive akakodzera zvakanyanya uye aine kodzero yekugadzwa uku. Uye ndingadai ndinazvo asi nekuda kwekushandisa simba reZionist donor pesvedzero kuHarvard. Pasina yakadaro backroom factor iyi inoremekedzwa zvikuru yedzidzo ingadai pasina mubvunzo yakadada nekuvapo kwaRoth. [Chris McGreal, โHarvard Inovhara Basa reAimbova Mukuru Werimwe Rekodzero Dzevanhu Pamusoro peKutsoropodzwa kweIsrael,โ The Guardian, Ndira 29, 6] Mushure menguva yakareba uye yakatanhamara pachigaro cheHRW Roth akanga ava munhu ane mukurumbira munzanga. Chiitiko ichi chimwe chiratidziro chekuti kunyangwe zvikoro zvinoremekedzwa uye zvakapfuma zvedzidzo yepamusoro hazvina kunyatsodzivirirwa kubva kupfungwa dzakashata uye nedzvinyiriro dzehunyambiri dzinopesana nezvavakaziviswa.
Kusabatwa zvakanaka kwaRoth kunorangarira imwe anecdote inovhenekera inoita seyakakosha zvekuti handikwanise kuramba kuburitswa kwayo. Makore gumi apfuura ndaiva nhengo yedare remazano reHRW muSanta Barbara kwandinogara. Rimwe zuva ndakafonerwa neimwe shamwari yaiva sachigaro wekomiti iyi. Akandiudza nezvekubviswa kwangu kubva mumutumbi uyu nekuda kwekupokana kwechido kunobva kubva kwandiri ndakabata chinzvimbo cheUN Special Repporteur yekutyora kweIsrael Kodzero dzevanhu muPalestine Yakabatwa. Ndakafunga zvinoshamisa kuti mutemo uyu wehunyanzvi, wakapihwa basa rawo risinganzwisisike pano, waifanira kunge wakangoerekana wakumbirwa mamwe makore mushure mekunge ndatora chinzvimbo cheUN, izvo zvakanditungamira kuti ndienderere mberi nechikonzero chaicho chekubviswa kwangu kamwe kamwe.
Uye ndinofunga zvisingashamisi, hazvina kunditorera nguva kuti ndiwane tsananguro yechokwadi yekudzingwa kwangu. UN Watch, NGO yeIsrael yekuGeneva yakanyunyuta kune HRW kuti zvaive zvisina kunaka kuchengetedza pachati yavo yesangano munhu ane mukurumbira wakashata senge ini. Akanga ari Ken Roth, ndakaudzwa kuti ndiani akanga aita danho rokundidzinga. mhinduro, Zvakazotevera zvingave zvakatarisirwa, UN Watch yakabata chiitiko ichi kuzvirumbidza pamusoro pesimba ravo, ichizivisa 'kukunda' uku kunyorwa pawebhusaiti yavo uye kuburikidza nekuburitswa kwenhau. HRW yakanyarara mukupindura, ichibvumira fungidziro kumira yekuti ndakabviswa mukomiti yavo nekuda kwekusafarira kwangu. Ndakabvunza kuti HRW ibudise chirevo ichijekesa kubviswa kwangu mukomiti nekuda kwezvikonzero zvavo zvataurwa, izvo zvandaifunga sechikumbiro chenguva dzose, uye ndikaziva kuti zvakatsigirwa nevashandi veHRW vakati wandei, asi zvakarambwa naRoth. Chiitiko ichi chakava nemigumisiro yakaipa paupenyu hwangu hwedzidzo: kukokwa kwezvidzidzo kwakabviswa kana kukanzurwa, uye ndakaona zvimwe zvakasiyana-siyana zvisingafadzi zvakaita kuti ndive โnegakava risingagamuchiriki.โ
Sezvineiwo, mavhiki mashomanene gare gare Roth neni takaoneka paboka rimwe chetero paYunivhesiti yeDenver, uye ndakamuudza kuti ndakanga ndakuvadzwa nenzira iyo kubviswa kwangu muDare reSB kwakabatwa nayo, zvichipa UN Watch zvikonzero zvokuratidza kuti ndakanga ndiri muboka rimwe chetero. zvakanyanyisa mukushoropodza kwangu kweIsrael kunyangwe HRW. Roth akandirasa nemashoko aya ekunyomba asingakanganwiki - "hapana anoteerera zvinotaurwa neUN Watch." Mukururama, ndinobvuma hushingi hwakazotevera hweHRW makore akazotevera mukubatana neAmnesty International neBโTselem mukuona kuti Israel yakanga yatanga hutongi hwerusaruraganda kana zvasvika kuvanhu vePalestine. [Ona โAthreshold Crossed: Vakuru veIsrael neMhosva dzeApartheid uye Kutambudza,โ Human Rights Watch, Kubvumbi 27, 2021; onawo mushumo wekare naRichard Falk & Virginia Tilley, "Israeli Pactices Towards the Palestinian People and the Question of Apartheid," UN ESCWA, MRCH 15, 2017.] Yaiva iyi chirevo chimwe chete pakati pemazana akabudiswa panguva yakareba yeRoth yakakonzera zvakakwana zve kudzoka shure kwekuita kuti Harvard akunde.
Ndinoshuva kuti dai chaive chokwadi kuti smears neUN Watch uye vanhu vane pfungwa dzakafanana uye masangano akashaya simba ravainaro rekuburitsa mhedzisiro isina kurongeka sezvakaiswa paRoth. Ndinofungidzira kuti chakakurudzira Roth munyaya yangu yaive nhengo ine simba yeZionist paHRW Board. Ndichiri mudiki, ndaiziva Bob Bernstein, muvambi weHRW, seshamwari yemhuri muNYC, uye ndakava nechisvusvuro chisingafadzi naye pano muSanta Barbara makore mashoma zvisati zvaitika paakanga ari mutungamiriri weIsrael mumiriri paHRW Board. . Ndakadzidza kuti iye nedzimwe nhengo dzebhodhi vaive vatsigiri veIsrael vasina zvisungo vangadai vasina kuchema nekurapirwa kwangu makore mashoma kubva ipapo.
Chiitiko chaRoth chinorangarira nhetembo ya1946 yakakurumbira yenyanzvi yezvechitendero uye mufundisi weGermany, Martin Niemรถller, iyo yairatidzira zvakajeka zvinetso zvinobva mumuitiro wavakasununguka pasi pedzvinyiriro yokurega misimboti nokuda kwemhindu yemari kana kuti kumutsa tsika. Nhetembo iyi pasina mubvunzo yakafemerwa nehupenyu hwaMufundisi Niemรถller, kunyanya shanduko kubva pakuva mutsigiri weNazi muudiki mumakore ake ekutanga kusvika pakuva musungwa aipokana neNazi mushure mehupenyu:
Vakatanga Vauya
โVakatanga vauya kumaKomonisiti, uye handina kutauraโnokuti ndakanga ndisiri muKomonisiti.
Vakabva vauya kune vesocialist, uye handina kutauraโnekuti ndakanga ndisiri mutsigiri wegutsaruzhinji.
Vakabva vauya kune vevashandi, uye ini handina kutaura โ nekuti ndakanga ndisiri mushandi wemubatanidzwa.
Ipapo vakauya nokuda kwavaJudha, uye handina kutauraโnokuti ndakanga ndisiri muJudha.
Ipapo vakauya kwandiri, uye pakanga pasina mumwe akasara akandimiririra.
Mufundisi Martin Niemรถller
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta