Phyllis Bennis, uchwepheshe waseMpumalanga Ephakathi, ungumuntu osebenza eSikhungweni Sezifundo Zenqubomgomo futhi uqondisa Umklamo Wawo Omusha Wamazwe Ngamazwe. Uvele ku-PBS, NPR, BBC, kanye ne-CBC. Ungumbhali wezincwadi eziningi ezihlanganisa Ngaphambi Nangemuva: Inqubomgomo Yezangaphandle Yase-US kanye Nenhlekelele yangoSepthemba 11 futhi Ukushayela Isibhamu: Indlela IWashington Ibusa Ngayo I-UN Yanamuhla. Izincwadi zakhe zakamuva Ukuqonda Ukungqubuzana kwe-Palestine-Israel futhi Umbuso Oyinselele.
Siyakwamukela kuhlelo.
Ngiyabonga kakhulu. Kuhle ukuba nawe, David.
Ngizoqala ngezinkondlo ezimbalwa, eyodwa kaLangston Hughes ebizwa ngokuthi โHarlem.โ Lokho ngikwenza ngamabomu ngoba ngicabanga ukuthi kungasinika umqondo wenkinga ekhona kanye nempi. U-Hughes uyabhala,
โKwenzekani ngephupho elihlehlisiwe? Liyoma njengomvini omisiwe elangeni, Noma libole njengesilondaโ
Bese ugijima?
Inuka okwenyama ebolile? Noma uqweqwe noshukela ngaphezulu-Njengeswidi elinesiraphu?
Mhlawumbe ivele ihlehle Njengomthwalo osindayo. Noma liyaqhuma?โ
Futhi enye inkondlo ngeka-Mahmoud Darwish, Imbongi Yesizwe YasePalestine. Eqenjini elidumile, uyabuza,
โSizoyaphi ngemva kwemingcele yokugcina lapho izinyoni zindiza khona ngemva kwesibhakabhaka sokugcina?โ
NgamaPalestine aseGaza, bayoshonaphi ngemva kwesibhakabhaka sokugcina?
Lezi zinkondlo ezimbili zihlangene ziyinhlanganisela engavamile. Bobabili bakhuluma ngokulahlekelwa yithemba. Ngicabanga ukuthi umbuzo kuphela uwukuthi, ingabe lalikhona ithemba ngaphambi kwalokhu? Ingabe lalikhona ithemba ngaphambi kuka-Okthoba 7? Ingabe lalikhona ithemba ngaphambi kwalokhu kudlondlobala esikubonayo manje? IGaza ibivinjezelwe iminyaka engu-16 ngenxa yokushoda kokudla, imithi, ugesi, amanzi, amanzi anzima. Ku-2012, futhi futhi ku-2015, iZizwe Ezihlangene zatshela umhlaba ukuthi iGaza yayizoba, ngamagama e-UN, ingenakuphikiswa ngo-2020. Futhi i-2020 yafika futhi yahamba, futhi iGaza yaba yinto engaphili, futhi umhlaba akenzanga lutho. Umhlaba akenzanga lutho.
Futhi ngicabanga ukuthi abantu abaningi eGaza, ikakhulukazi abantu abasha, ingxenye yabantu baseGaza, iGaza inabantu abacishe babe yizigidi ezimbili nengxenye basePalestine. Ingxenye yabo ineminyaka engaphansi kweyi-18. Futhi labo bantu ngokuvamile abakaze baphumele ngaphandle kwale ndawo encane empofu, eminyene. Abakaze babone ngisho iPalestinian West Bank noma iMpumalanga yeJerusalema, ingasaphathwa eyokuba ngaphakathi kwesifunda sakwa-Israel sika-1948, futhi ingasaphathwa eyokubona noma iyiphi ingxenye yezwe langaphandle. Ngakho, kulabo bantu, ingabe lalikhona ithemba elase lishaywe yilokhu kudlondlobala? Mhlawumbe kwabanye, kodwa ngicabanga ukuthi ithemba belilokhu lishoda kakhulu eGaza isikhathi eside kakhulu.
Nokho, njengoba umngane wethu nomeluleki wethu, isazi esikhulu sasePalestine-America u-Edward Said, sake saphawula ngendelelo, โIPalestine iyimbangela yokungabongi, lapho uma ukhonza ngokweqiniso, ungatholi lutho ngaphandle kwencithakalo, ukuhlukunyezwa, nokucwaswa. Bangaki abangani abayigwemayo le ndaba? Bangaki ozakwethu abafuna kungabikho mpikiswano yasePalestine? Mangaki ama-bien pensant liberal anesikhathi seBosnia neSomalia, iRwanda neNingizimu Afrika kanye neNicaragua, namalungelo abantu nawomphakathi yonke indawo emhlabeni, kodwa hhayi ngePalestine namaPalestine?โ Lawo mazwi wawasho ngasekupheleni kwawo-1990. Ingabe kukhona okushintshile kusukela ngaleso sikhathi?
Nakanjani. Ngiyaxolisa kakhulu ngokuthi u-Edward waphasa ngesikhathi esishiya ngo-2003, ngoba ushintsho lwalungakaqali. Kodwa ezinye zezinto asizile wazenza, okuhlanganisa nokwakhiwa kwalokho osekuyi-US Campaign for Palestinian Rights. Kwakungu-Edward owasifundisa okuningi ngalokho okwakudingeka ngaleso sikhathi, okwakuyinhlangano ngokukhethekile, hhayi nje inhlangano, kodwa inhlangano eyayigxile ekuguquleni inkulumo, ukulandisa kwe-United States. Futhi kule minyaka engu-25 edlule, sibone ukushintsha okungajwayelekile kulokho kulandisa. Eminyakeni engaphansi kwemibili edlule, cishe unyaka nengxenye edlule, ukuvota kwakamuva okwenziwa yi-Jewish Electoral Institute kwabonisa ukuthi ama-25% amaJuda aseMelika ayekholelwa ukuthi i-Israel iyizwe lobandlululo. I-38% yentsha yamaJuda yasho into efanayo. Lokho uguquko olungajwayelekile. U-44% wamaDemocrats ekuqaleni kwalo nyaka uthe ukholelwa ukuthi i-Israel ifana nobandlululo.
Abashongo ukuthi wubandlululo, bathi lufana nobandlululo. Lokho kuwukuguqulwa okuphelele kombono osekunesikhathi eside wokuthi amaDemocrat ayesekela kakhulu u-Israyeli kunamaRepublican.
U-Bibi Netanyahu eminyakeni yakhe njengondunankulu wakwa-Israyeli, futhi useneminyaka eminingi kakhulu kuleyo minyaka, ukuguqule lokho ukuze manje, ngokungafani nemigomo ye-AIPAC nezinye izingxenye ze-pro-Israel lobbies iminyaka eminingi, inhloso yayo ephelele. kwakuwukuqinisekisa ukuthi i-Israel ihlala iyingxenye yobumbano lwezinhlangothi ezimbili, ukuvumelana kwe-bipartisan kuKhongolose. Hhayi-ke, akusekho lokho futhi kuyindaba yeRiphabhulikhi kakhulu. Ukusekela i-Israel sekuyinkinga yeRiphabhulikhi. Manje lokho akusho ukuthi esimweni sokuhlasela okunyantisayo kwangomhla ziyisi-7 kuMfumfu, ukubulawa kwama-Israel ayi-1400, uma sibuza labo bantu namuhla, ucabanga ukuthi i-Israel iyizwe lobandlululo? Anginakho ukukhohlisa ukuthi sizothola umphumela ofanayo.
Kodwa noma ngasiphi isikhathi inhlolovo ayilutho kodwa isifinyezo. Kuyisithombe esifushane sesikhathi. Okubalulekile ngalezo zingxoxo zangaphambilini engizibalulile, ukuthi beziyingxenye yomkhuba futhi ukuthambekela bekulokhu kuvumelana. Sizobona ukwehla nokwenyuka, sesibona manje ukuvuselelwa kokuvumelana kuKhongolose, umbono wokuthi wonke amalungu eNdlu ayi-10 avotele isinqumo sohlangothi olulodwa ngokuphelele, ethi sima no-Israyeli, empeleni, kungakhathalekile ukuthi yini. bangase baphendule kulokho okwenzeka ngo-Okthoba 7. Futhi sekunzima kakhulu ukuthola ukwesekwa odabeni olulula njengokuqeda ukudubulana, ukumiswa kwezikhali nhlangothi zonke, okudingeka kakhulu ukumisa ukubulawa. Yilokhu esikudingayo njengamanje. Futhi esikhundleni salokho, sibona idiplomacy yebhere likaJoe Biden ebukela phansi noma yini angayisho lapho ethi ukhombisa ukukhathazeka ngezimpilo zabantu, noma yini enjalo.
Kodwa noma kunjalo, akufanele ngisho ukuthi ngiyethemba ngemva kokulalela izinkondlo zikaMahmoud Darwish kanye noLangston Hughes imbongi enkulu ye-Harlem Renaissance, kodwa nginethemba elincane lokuthi sizogcina lezo zinguquko ezinkulumweni okungenzeka kube noshintsho emithonjeni yezindaba, futhi lokho kwenza ukuthi ekugcineni kube noguquko enkulumweni yezepolitiki, inkulumo yenqubomgomo. Sesikubonile okunye kwalokho. Njengamanje sinabasebenzi abangama-300 ababekade besebenzela uSenator u-Elizabeth Warren kanye noSenator Bernie Sanders, amalungu amabili athuthuka kakhulu eSenate, ebanxusa, ebancenga, efuna ukuthi bacele ukuthi kuqedwe ukudubula, ukuthi babeke isinqumo esifana nalesi sokuthi U-Cori Bush no-Rashida Tlaib babeke phambili eNdlu, ukusho ukuthi sidinga ukumiswa kwezikhali manje. Sidinga ukumiswa ngokushesha.
Uma sibheka emuva ku-2021, okokugcina lapho u-Israyeli ehlasela iGaza, kwakungeyona into embi njengalokhu, kodwa kwakusenokuhlasela okuqhubekayo futhi kwakunezinsuku zokuqhunyiswa kwamabhomu, kwabulawa amakhulu amaPalestine. Futhi ngaleso sikhathi, futhi, uMongameli uBiden wayethi, โAsikudingi ukumiswa kwezikhali okwamanje.โ Njengoba esho manje, abenele abantu asebashona, asikakadingi ukumiswa kokudubula. Futhi kuleso senzakalo, wawunamalungu angu-12 angamaJuda eNdlu abhalela umongameli wawo incwadi, wonke ayengamaDemocrats, ethi, โNgiyacela, Mnu. President, sidinga ukumiswa kokudubula manje. Ngicela kumiswe ukulwa.โ Izigele ezingamashumi amabili nanhlanu zibhale zasho okufanayo. Bese kuthi-ke, intandokazi yami yomuntu siqu, futhi mhlawumbe nethonya elikhulu kunabo bonke abasebenzi bomkhankaso we-Biden-Harris abangama-500, abantu empeleni abaqhuba imikhankaso yesifunda kanye nemikhankaso yedolobha, ababafaka emandleni, ababangenisa eWhite House, Abangu-500 kubo babhalele uBiden encwadini engajwayelekile eyayikhuluma ngeminyaka engama-73 yokucindezelwa kwama-Israel kwabasePalestine, ngesikhathi esimangalisayo. Futhi ngaleso sikhathi babethi, kulungile, sidinga ukumiswa komlilo manje.
Futhi okwakubaluleke kakhulu ngalowo mzuzu, babephinde bethi lokhu kusho ukuthi sebefinyelele esiphethweni sokuthi kwakungasesona isenzo sokuzibulala kwezombusazwe ukuthi umbutho wezombusazwe kuDemocratic Party ugxeke u-Israyeli. Ukuthi bebecabanga ukuthi basazokwazi ukuthola umsebenzi okhethweni oluzayo ngemuva konyaka. Futhi benza. Akekho owalahlekelwa umsebenzi ngenxa yalokho. Isibhakabhaka asizange siwe, ngoba kwakukhona lokhu kushintsha kwenkulumo, lokhu kushintsha kokulandisa.
Noma ubani obuka iphephandaba namuhla wayengathi, โO Nkulunkulu wami, umshini wokunyathelisa ugxile ohlangothini olulodwa ngendlela emangalisayo. Kungaba khona kanjani okuhle ngakho? Singasho kanjani okuhle ngakho?โ Hhayi-ke, indlela esingasho ngayo into enhle ngayo, siyiqhathanise nalokho eyayiyikho eminyakeni emihlanu edlule, siqhathanise neminyaka engama-20 edlule, siqhathanise nonyaka ka-2003 lapho u-Edward Said esishiya. Qhathanisa nalokho futhi sibona ifa lomsebenzi wakhe, ifa lawo wonke umsebenzi wethu, ifa lenhlangano yethu, ukuthi kunendlela entsha ehluke ngayo ukuthi abezindaba ngisho namanje kufanele basondele embuzweni wokumboza lokhu. Kukhona amazwi asePalestine, yebo, acindezelwa ezinkundleni eziningi kakhulu, ezindaweni eziningi kakhulu, kodwa manje sekuliwa. Kukhona ukulwa emuva futhi kukhona amazwi asePalestine avelayo. Kukhona incazelo yenhlekelele esabekayo yabantu eyenzeka eGaza nsuku zonke ekhasini lokuqala le- New York Times futhi Washington Post. Indaba ehamba phambili ku-NPR, indaba ephambili ku Izindaba ze-PBS. Yonke imithombo yezindaba esezingeni eliphezulu kufanele ikhulume ngalokhu. Abakwenzi kahle, abakwenzi ngokwanele, angikubangi lokho. Kuningi ukugxekwa okudingeka kuye phambili futhi kufanele kube nokhahlo futhi kungaguquki. Kodwa futhi kufanele siqaphele ukuthi yini eshintshile futhi yilokho kuphela okusinika ithemba.
Khuluma ngobekwenzeka kwa-Israel uqobo ngokwepolitiki yangaphakathi lapho. Lokhu kungaphambi kokuhlaselwa kuka-Okthoba 7. I-New York Times ibiza uhulumeni ngokuthi โukucasha ngakwesokuneneโ kunabashisekeli abafana no-Itamar Ben-Gvir kanye noBezalel Smotrich abaphethe izikhundla ezibalulekile. "I-Israel yayilwa nayo ngokwayo" ngokukaDavid Ignatius eWashington Post, ngohlelo lukaNetanyahu lwezobulungiswa. UNetanyahu ubefuna lokho ngokukhulu ulaka. Ngakho-ke, kwenzekani ngaphakathi kwa-Israyeli ngaphambi kwempi?
Ngicabanga ukuthi ngaphambi kwale mpi, ebesikubona yilokho okwashiwo nguDavid Ignatius, ukuthi kunoqhekeko olukhulu oluhlukanisa abantu abangamaJuda akwa-Israel. Kodwa kufanele sicace ngokuthile. Kunokwehlukana phakathi komfelandawonye wamanje okukhabhinethi njengamanje, okuwumfelandawonye welungelo, ilungelo elikude, ilungelo elidlulele, futhi ngisebenzisa leli gama ngokucophelela, ilungelo lobufascist. U-Smotrich no-Ben-Gvir, laba ababili obashilo, bayizibonelo ezinhle kakhulu zalokho. Omunye wabo othanda ukuzibiza ngokuthi "i-homophobe yama-fascist." Omunye owayeboshelwe ukusekela inhlangano yamaphekula, inhlangano yamaJuda yakwa-Israel ecwasa ngokwebala eyayisabisa izakhamuzi zasePalestine. Ngakho-ke yebo, lona nguhulumeni oweqisayo, owedlulele kunawo wonke owake waba khona, kodwa ngeke ngikubize ngokunyenya kwesokudla okusho ukuthi ngandlela thize ukuthi bekungenye into ngaphandle kwelungelo ngaphambi kwalokho.
Kwaba ukuphothulwa kokushintshela kwesokudla, kodwa futhi kwakungesikhathi lapho abaphikisayo, labo abazibiza ngama-centrists, okuhlanganisa nalabo abadlula njengenxele kwa-Israel, bephikisana nemibuzo yokweseka inkululeko ye-Independent. ezobulungiswa, amalungelo abesifazane, amalungelo e-LGBTQ, inqwaba yezindaba ezibaluleke kakhulu kuma-liberals akwa-Israel.
Abazange bakuphonsele inselelo ukuhlasela kuka-Israel umhlaba wasePalestine, umgomo wakwa-Israel wobandlululo owake waba nomthelela omubi kumaPalestine angaphakathi kwa-Israel, ezindaweni ezazidla imbuya ngothi, nakubabaleki ababephucwa ilungelo lokubuyela emakhaya. Lokho akukaze kube ku-ajenda, ngoba abagqugquzeli balowo mbutho wokubhikisha babazi ukuthi uma leso sidingo sifakiwe ezimfuno ezibanzi zenhlangano, babengeke babone ababhikishi abayizi-200,000, 300,000, 400,000, 300 emigwaqweni isonto ngalinye. Bazobe bebona ababhikishi abangama-400, noma abangama-500, noma abangama-XNUMX, mhlawumbe izinkulungwane ezimbalwa.
Bebengeke bakubone okubonwa wumhlaba, ngoba alikho lelo zinga lokusekela amalungelo asePalestine. Futhi kuyamangalisa ukubona abantu bebhikishela amalungelo abo, kuyinto enhle leyo kodwa akufanele sibe nenkohliso yokuthi lokho ngandlela thize kwakuklanyelwe ukuvikela izimpilo zamaPalestine, noma amalungelo asePalestine. Kwakungenjalo. Futhi empeleni, abanye babaholi baleyo nhlangano bahlanganisa nondunankulu bangaphambili nabanye ongqongqoshe bakahulumeni, kuhlanganise nalabo asebenesikhathi eside besekela lo msebenzi.
Omunye wabo, uBenny Gantz, okwathi ngesikhathi engenela isikhundla sokuba ngundunankulu, ngikholwa ukuthi kwakungu-2016, anginaso isiqiniseko sokuthi nginonyaka ofanele. I-video yakhe yomkhankaso iqale ngevidiyo ayithatha endizeni enophephela emhlane kulandela impi ka-2014 u-Israyeli ayilwa eGaza, eyathatha amasonto ayisithupha futhi yashiya abantu basePalestine abangu-2200 bebulewe ngamabhomu akwa-Israel. Futhi ukubukisa kwakhe kwaba, โBuka engikwenzile. Yingakho kufanele ningivotele undunankulu.โ Yilokhu ayeziqhenya ngakho, kwakuwumonakalo ayewenza eGaza. Ngakho lowo kwakungomunye wabaholi benhlangano yokubhikisha kwa-Israel. Ngakho-ke, akufanele sibe namaphutha mayelana nokuthi leyo nhlangano yokubhikisha yayiyini futhi yayingeyona yini.
Ngomhla zingama-24 kuMfumfu, uNobhala Jikelele we-UN u-Antonio Guterres wakhuluma emhlanganweni okhethekile woMkhandlu Wezokuphepha. Yena, engimcaphuna manje, โuzilahle ngokungananazi izenzo zobuphekula ezesabekayo nezingakaze zenzeke zangomhla ziyisi-7 kuMfumfu okwenziwa iHamas kwa-Israyeli. Akukho okungathethelela ukubulawa kwabantu ngamabomu, ukulinyazwa nokuthunjwa kwezakhamuzi, noma ukwethulwa kwamarokhethi ngokumelene nezinhloso zabantu. Wengeze wathi, "Kubalulekile futhi ukuqaphela ukuthi ukuhlaselwa kweHamas akwenzekanga nje." Inxusa lakwa-Israel le-UN licele uGuterres ukuthi esule esikhundleni, ethi "ubuthethelela ubuphekula."
Ngifanele ngisho ukuthi, amasosha ase-Israel ane-chutzpah eningi, enza ngempela. Hhayi ukuthi kufanele baphendule ngalokho abaningi, izazi eziningi zomphakathi emhlabeni wonke, kuhlanganise nezazi zokuqothulwa kohlanga, okuwumkhakha, abaningi babo abangamaJuda, ezihlonze njengezenzo zokuqothulwa kohlanga empini yakwa-Israyeli eqhubeke kulawa masonto amathathu. Ukuthi akufanele bathweswe icala ngalokho, kodwa umuntu obabizele ngakho kufanele noma kanjani aphoqwe ukuthi asule. Lokhu kuyamangalisa.
Abantu abahlala ngaphansi kombuso wezempi banelungelo ngaphansi komthetho wamazwe ngamazwe lokusebenzisa izikhali, ukuphikisa lokho kuthathwa kwezempi. Ayinalo nhlobo ilungelo lokuhlasela izakhamuzi, ukubulala izakhamuzi. Ngakho-ke, okwenzeka ngo-Okthoba 7th ngokubulawa kwabantu abaningi kangaka kwakuyicala elingenakuphikiswa, ubugebengu bempi, ubugebengu obubhekiswe esintwini, isikhathi, isitobha esigcwele. Akukho okuthethelelayo. Futhi uma sinethemba lokukuvimbela ukuba kungenzeki futhi, kubalulekile ukuthi siqonde ukuthi kungani kwenzeka, kwenzeka kanjani, nokuthi kuvelaphi. Ngaphandle kwalokho, sizomane siphindaphinde imijikelezo yodlame sengathi lokho kuqhuma kwenzeka nje esibhakabhakeni, kanti akunjalo, siyakwazi lokho. Abakwenzi. Kwenzeka ngenxa yezimo ezingabekezeleleki. Ingabe izimo ezingabekezeleleki zinikeza abantu ilungelo lokuhlasela izakhamuzi? Lutho neze. Kuseyicala. Futhi kufanele siqonde ukuthi ziyini lezo zimo.
Uma sibheka umthetho wamazwe ngamazwe, usinika izinkomba ezibalulekile lapha. Incazelo yokubulawa kohlanga, ngokwesibonelo, inezingxenye ezimbili. Ingxenye yokuqala iwukuthi, kufanele kube nenhloso ethile yokubhubhisa bonke noma ingxenye yeqembu elichazwa ubuhlanga, inkolo, ubuzwe, ulimi, inkitha yezinye izindlela ezingaba khona. Ngicabanga ukuthi akungabazeki ukuthi sinakho lokho esitatimendeni sakwa-Israel kulawa masonto adlule, isitatimende selungu le-Knesset elathi, โSidinga enye. nakba.โ Usebenzise igama lesi-Arabhu, leli gama lisho inhlekelele, futhi yigama abantu basePalestine abalisebenzisayo ukuchaza okwenzeka kubo ngo-1947 no-1948, lapho abantu basePalestine abangu-750,000 1947 bexoshwa, baphucwa imizi yabo kanye nezindawo zabo, futhi baphoqeleka ukuba babe ababaleki. . Ngokweqile, inani labantu baseGaza namuhla lakhiwe yilabo babaleki abavela eningizimu yePalestine, kusukela ngo-1948 no-XNUMX, abagcina beseGaza Strip njengababaleki.
Futhi ngokuqinisekile kwakungesona ukuphela kwesitatimende. SinoMongameli wakwa-Israel esho lokho, sengathi yinto engenakwenzeka ukuyicabanga. Uthe, "Ufuna ukukhuluma ngezakhamizi zasePalestine," okusho ukuthi yayingekho into efana nezakhamizi, "ngemuva kokwenzeka ngo-Okthoba 7th?" Okusho ukuthi ngesikhathi kubulawa izakhamizi zakwa-Israel, kukhona ukushaqeka nokucasuka okufanele, kodwa uthi umbono wokuthi kukhona ngisho nezakhamizi zasePalestine awulona iqiniso. Ngakho, sinalezi zitatimende. Esinye isitatimende sikamengameli lapho ethi, asikhulumi ngabantu, sikhuluma โngezilwane ezingabantu.โ Yilokho akubiza ngesibalo sabantu baseGaza, abantu basePalestine abayizigidi ezingu-2.3, ingxenye yabo kuyizingane.
Ngicabanga ukuthi lowo kwakungu-Yoav Gallant, ungqongqoshe wezokuvikela owasho lokho.
Konke lokhu kuwubufakazi benhloso yokuqothula uhlanga. Ingxenye yesibili yomthetho yalokho okwenza ukuqothulwa kohlanga noma ukuqothulwa kohlanga okungase kube khona, iqoqo lezenzo ezinhlanu, noma yiziphi ezenziwa ngaleyo nhloso ethile zikwenza kube ukuqothulwa kohlanga. Kuyiguqula isuke ekuhlanzweni nje kohlanga, isenzo, ibe ukuqothulwa kohlanga, lapho inhloso imelene neqembu lonke. I-Israel manje yenza ezintathu kwalezo ezinhlanu, ibulala amalungu eqembu, ilimaza noma ilimaze amalungu eqembu ngokwengqondo noma ngokomzimba, nokudala izimo ezenza impilo njengeqembu ingenzeki, njengokuvinjezelwa lapho amanzi, nokudla, kanye imithi, nogesi banqatshelwa. Lezo zinto ezintathu zihlangene zonke ziphakathi kwemibandela yokunquma ukuthi yini ukubulawa kohlanga. Engeza lokho kunhloso ecacile yokuqothula uhlanga futhi unokuthile okufanele ngabe iNkantolo Yamazwe Ngamazwe Yobugebengu kufanele ikuphenye njengamanje. Kufanele ngabe bayakumemeza manje bathi, โUma u-Israyeli eqhubeka nalezi zenzo, ngokusekelwe kulezi zitatimende asebezishilo, lokhu kubeka izikhulu zakwa-Israel, izikhulu zezempi kanye nezombusazwe, engozini yokuthweswa icala lokubulala kule nkantolo, ngesenzo sokubulala abantu.โ Futhi angikuboni lokho kwenzeka, kodwa ngicabanga ukuthi yilokho okufanele umhlaba ukufune.
Okokuqala, sidinga ukuqhubeka nokufuna ukuthi kumiswe ukulwa. Sikudinga kakhulu ukumiswa kwezikhali njengamanje. Alukho usizo olunamanani anele oluzokwazi ukungena uma ukuqhuma kwamabhomu kuqhubeka. Lezi zinqola zamaloli amathathu, amaloli ayisikhombisa, amaloli angu-15 anele ukuphakela abantu abahlezi esiphambanweni saseRafah bezama ukuphuma izinsuku ezimbili. Cishe akukho okuhlobene nalokho okudingekayo.
Izibhedlela, izingxenye ezintathu kwezine zazo sezimemezele ukuthi ziyavala, ngoba azinamanzi, azinawo uphethiloli wamajeneretha azo, azinawo ugesi, nodokotela bazo nabahlengikazi abaningi bashonile. Bangu-75 abashayeli bama-ambulensi, ama-EMTs, abasebenzi bezimo eziphuthumayo babulewe. Zonke izinsiza zama-ambulensi sezimemezele ukuthi ngeke zikwazi ukuthumela ama-ambulensi ukusiza noma ngubani. Noma ubani olimele, noma ubani obanjwe ngaphansi kwesakhiwo, uzimele yedwa. Alukho usizo oluzayo. Izimpahla zokwelashwa ezisalinde ukuthunyelwa kubalwa nezimpahla zokubeletha eziklanyelwe abantu abangazi ukuthi bangasiza kanjani owesifazane obelethayo, abangaqeqeshelwanga ubudokotela ngoba bazi ukuthi yibona abasizayo. abesifazane ababeletha kulo lonke elaseGaza Strip kulezi zinsuku ezilandelayo. Kuyinto ehlasimulisa umzimba ukucabanga ngayo, ukuthi leyo ngenye yezinto okufanele ilungiswe izinhlangano ezisiza abantu.
Igama elithi ukuqothulwa kohlanga laqanjwa umJuda wasePoland, isazi sezomthetho esidumile, ummeli, uRaphael Lemkin, ebone lokho abaseTurkey abakwenza kubantu base-Armenia ngo-1915, kwase kuba nokuQothulwa Kwesizwe. Manje sekunesazi-mlando sakwa-Israel sokuqothulwa kohlanga, igama laso nguRaz Segal, kanti odabeni lweJewish Currents, ubiza ukuhlasela kuka-Israyeli eGaza โnjengecala lokuqothulwa kohlanga.โ
Futhi akuyena yedwa. Kunencwadi yezikhalazo esayiniwe, angazi ukuthi zingaki, ngicabanga ukuthi zingaphezu kuka-100 izifundiswa emhlabeni wonke, izifundiswa zokubulawa kwabantu. Lokho kuyisiyalo sezemfundo. Kunzima ukukucabanga, kodwa kunjalo. Futhi yibo abakuqonda kangcono kunanoma ubani ukuthi umthetho wamazwe ngamazwe uthini ngempela futhi ongasho lutho mayelana nokuchaza ukubulawa kohlanga, ukuthwesa icala labo abasolwa ngezenzo zokubulala, futhi okubaluleke kakhulu, izibopho, kuleli cala, amazwe angamalungu asayinile. umhlangano wokulwa nokuqothulwa kohlanga, okuhlanganisa vele i-United States ne-Israel. Noma yimuphi umuntu ongaphandle osayine kuleyo ngqungquthela unesibopho samazwe ngamazwe sokuyimisa. Pho, wenzani uhulumeni wethu? Asithumeli nje kuphela u-Israyeli u-$3.8 billion njalo ngonyaka njengenani lokuqala. Sekuvele, kulo nyaka, kungaphezu kwezigidigidi ezi-4 zamaRandi, kodwa manje sesimemezela ama-dollar ayizigidi eziyizinkulungwane eziyi-14 abaphathi beBiden abafuna ukuwathumela ngale mpi.
Ngakho, siyayikhokhela le mpi. Isabelomali sonke samasosha akwa-Israyeli siyizigidi eziyizinkulungwane ezingama-23 zamaRandi. Uma le mali eyizigidi eziyizinkulungwane ezingu-14 idlula, futhi kunokungabaza okuncane ukuthi kuzokwenzeka, kuzosho ukuthi abakhokhi bentela base-United States bakhokha ngaphezu kuka-75% wesabelomali samasosha akwa-Israyeli kulo nyaka. Kuyashaqisa lokho. Kuhulumeni owenza izenzo ezinobugebengu bempi obungcono kakhulu, futhi okungenzeka kube ubugebengu obubhekiswe esintwini, kanye nezenzo zokuqothula uhlanga. Sinecala. Uhulumeni wethu uyaziphendulela futhi thina njengabakhokhi bentela kufanele senze okwengeziwe ukuze sithi, โHhayi egameni lethu. Sidinga ukuthi kumiswe ukulwa manje.โ Lesi yisidingo sokumisa ukubulala. Ingabe ukumiswa kokudubula kuzozixazulula zonke izinkinga? Vele akunjalo.
Sidinga nosizo lwabantu. Sidinga ukuziphendulela ngawo wonke amacala, okuhlanganisa nobugebengu bamhla ziyisi-7 kuMfumfu. Siyakudinga konke lokho. Sidinga abathunjwa ukuze bakhululwe. Manje sekungaphezu kuka-10,000 abantu basePalestine ababoshwe ngokungemthetho emajele akwa-Israel, sidinga ukuthi bakhululwe. Ezingu-160 kubo izingane. Eziyishumi nambili zalezo zingane zigcinwe ngaphansi kweziboshwa zokuphatha. Kuyashaqisa. Imithetho yokuboshwa kwamasosha akwa-Israel iyasebenza ezinganeni ezineminyaka engu-12 ubudala. Izwe kuphela emhlabeni elinesimiso sobulungiswa bezingane. Ngakho-ke, kuyiqiniso elimangalisayo futhi sidinga ukuqhubeka nengcindezi. Kwakukhona ucezu phakathi New York Times namuhla bethi abaphathi beBiden bazwa ingcindezi evela eqenjini elihlukene leDemocratic Party. Esinye sezingxabano ezinkulu phakathi kwamaDemocrats akhethiwe namanje, ngicabanga ukuthi, ahlala ebhamuza ecabanga ukuthi ngandlela-thile ukuzibulala kwezombusazwe, yilokho isisekelo sabo esingafuni, ukugxeka u-Israyeli. Akunjalo nje. Sekunesikhathi eside kungenzeki, kodwa empeleni akusenjalo manje. Kodwa nokho, sibona lokhu kwehlukana okukhulu phakathi kwesizinda seDemocratic Party nalabo abakhethwe amaDemocrats ngalolu daba, phakathi kwezinye izindaba. Ziningi izingqinamba lapho kunokuhlukana khona, kodwa lena ingase ibe yisimanga kakhulu kunanoma iyiphi ngoba kunothando olunjalo lokuyimisa, ngoba sibona ngesikhathi sangempela ukuthi le mpi ibukeka kanjani. Sibona ukubulawa kwabantu kuqala ukwenzeka. Lesi akusona isixwayiso sokuthi u-Israyeli angenza okuthile. Nazo ke. Bayakwenza. Ngenxa yokunqamuka kwamanzi eGaza, maduze nje sizobona izifo ezibangelwa amanzi ezinezela ezingozini zokufa. Ngeke kube ngabantu ababulawa ukoma kuphela, kodwa abantu bazobulawa yicholera nezinye izifo ezibangelwa amanzi, ubani ozofa kuqala? Izingane, izingane kanye nabadala ngoba yibona abasengozini kakhulu. Futhi sikubuka kwenzeka ngesikhathi sangempela. Siyibuka ezikrinini zethu. Into yokuqala eyenziwa abantu baseGaza lapho bethola isikhashana ugesi kumuntu othile, emotweni elayishwa umuntu futhi ibhethri likhona, abantu bayawashaja amafoni abo, ukuze bathumele izwi emindenini yabo ukuthi, โ 'basaphila,' futhi emhlabeni ukuthi, "Yeka."
Khuluma nge-Hamas futhi uchaze ukuthi iluhlobo luni lwenhlangano. Iphumelele ukhetho ngo-2006, ithatha amandla eGaza ngonyaka olandelayo. Inobudlelwano neMuslim Brotherhood. Kepha yiliphi izinga lokusekelwa enakho phakathi kwamaGazans ajwayelekile, futhi ingabe lokho kusekelwa kudlulela eWest Bank, noma kugxile eGaza ngokuphelele?
I-Hamas iyinhlangano eyinkimbinkimbi kakhulu. Inophiko lwezepolitiki. Njengoba usho, yanqoba ukhetho ngo-2006 okwayenza yaba amandla okubusa eGaza, hhayi eWest Bank. Inomkhakha wezenhlalakahle. Yilokho okwenza ukuthi abantu abaningi abampofu kakhulu eGaza baphile, ngale kwe-UN. Futhi inephiko elihlomile, ngezinye izikhathi eliye lenza izenzo ezisemthethweni ngaphansi komthetho wamazwe ngamazwe, futhi izikhathi eziningi liye lafeza, njengoba lenza kakhulu ngo-Okthoba 7, izenzo zobugebengu ezisabekayo eziphula umthetho wamazwe ngamazwe, ngoba akekho, kuhlanganisa nenani labantu, linelungelo lokuhlasela futhi libulale izakhamuzi. Ngakho, yinhlangano eyinkimbinkimbi. Umbono esiwuzwa kuma-Israyeli, "Sizoyiqeda i-Hamas." Ngabe lokho kusho ukuthini? Uzowaqeda nya amalungu avotela, amalungu eqembu asayina ukuvotela iHamas emuva okhethweni olwedlule, olwalungo-2006?
Umbuzo wokuthi iHamas inakho ukwesekwa okungakanani. Umbuzo ofanayo, uFatah unokungaki ukwesekwa? Inhlangano evamile ye-PLO, okungamandla ezombusazwe avelele eWest Bank, amandla ezombusazwe anamandla ngaphakathi kwePalestine Authority. Lowo obizwa ngomongameli wePalestinian Authority ungumholi weFatah. Futhi iFatah, njengeHamas, bobabili baba nokhetho ngo-2006 iminyaka emine. Eminyakeni eyishumi nantathu kamuva, basengabantu abafanayo abasezikhundleni. Badala, banciphile, abasekelwa muntu okhethweni.
Ngakolunye uhlangothi, uma ubuza abantu basePalestine, "Ingabe uyayisekela i-Hamas njengento ethile?" Kwezinye izinhlolovo kuze kufike ku-30% wamaPalestine, ikakhulukazi eGaza, kodwa naseWest Bank. Angizazi izibalo zeWest Bank, izinombolo ezibalulekile zizothi, "Yebo, kuzo zonke, zihamba phambili." Leyo ibha ephansi kakhulu. Kuyibha ephansi kakhulu, ngoba abantu basePalestine bavame ukuba kude kakhulu nezikhulu zabo ezikhethiwe zayo yonke imikhakha yezepolitiki.
Ngicabanga ukuthi inkinga ukuthi i-Hamas ayiyona nje inhlangano yezempi, kodwa ezinye izinto eziningi. Futhi okuye kwacaca ukuthi uphiko lwezombangazwe kanye nophiko lwezenhlalakahle, uphiko lwezenhlalakahle, lwalungenalo ulwazi lwangaphambili mayelana nalokho okwakuhlelelwe kulokhu kuhlasela kuka-Okthoba 7. Lokho kuyingxenye yenkinga yokuthi lezi zinto zisebenza kanjani. Umbono wokuthi u-Israel ucabanga ukuthi angayiqeda iHamas umane awenzi mqondo. Ukhuluma ngenhlangano yezombangazwe, nezomnotho, nenhlalakahle yomphakathi ezinze phakathi, vele, izakhamuzi.
Laba ngabantu abavela eGaza. Awehliswa esibhakabhakeni eGaza kwenye indawo. Laba ngamaGazans. Banemindeni, banezingane, banabadala, njengabo bonke abantu baseGazan. Ngakho, konke lokho kufanele kucatshangelwe. Uma indlu iyindlu yomuntu oyisikhulu emnyangweni wezenhlalakahle ye-Hamas, ingabe lokho kubenza babe yisisulu esisemthethweni futhi umndeni wabo, izingane, abazukulu babo, uninazala, ingabe bonke bayizisulu ezisemthethweni? Ngokwezenzo zama-Israel impendulo izoba yebo. Ngokomthetho wamazwe ngamazwe, akunjalo. Ngakho lolo uhlobo lwenkinga esiyibona lapha.
OwayenguNdunankulu wakwa-Israel u-Ehud Olmert wayeseDeutsche Welle ngo-Okthoba 11, futhi wakhuluma ngeHamas ngenkathi uNetanyahu engundunankulu ngeminyaka yawo-1990. Yilokhu okushiwo u-Olmert, "Iminyaka eminingi, uNetanyahu wayekhetha ngokusobala ukubhekana neHamas ukuze angadingi ukubhekana nePalestine Authority. I-Hamas ixhaswe ngosizo luka-Israel iminyaka eminingi ngamakhulu ezigidi zamarandi ayevela eQatar, ngolwazi olugcwele nokwesekwa kukahulumeni wakwa-Israel oholwa nguNetanyahu.โ Ngingalokotha ngithi bambalwa abazi mayelana nokuxhumana kuka-Israyeli ne-Hamas kulesi sikhathi.
Kuyathakazelisa. Ibuyela emuva nangaphambi kwalokho. Ibuyela emuva esikhathini sika-1987 lapho i-Hamas yasungulwa eGaza. Yasuka ku-Muslim Brotherhood yaseGibhithe, njengoba usho, uDavid, kodwa futhi kusukela ekuqaleni, njengoba u-Olmert esho lapha, kodwa u-Olmert naye unombono wakhe weqembu. Uthi konke lokhu ngoNetanyahu. Lokhu empeleni kwaqala ngenkathi iLabour Party, ngenkathi uRabin ephethe, lapho abanye beQembu Labasebenzi bebusa. Ngakho-ke, lokhu akuyona nje inkinga ye-Likud noma ye-Netanyahu. Okuyiqiniso ukuthi ukusekelwa kokudalwa kwe-Hamas njengesikhungo sezomthetho eGaza kubonise kakhulu lokho okwenziwa yi-US e-Afghanistan, lapho isiza ukudala i-mujahideen eholwa, kamuva, umholi we-Al-Qaeda u-bin Laden. Ngakho-ke, sinokukhuphuka kwe-Al-Qaeda ngaphansi koxhaso lwase-US, njengenye yezinhlangano eziningi ze-mujahideen i-US ecabanga ukuthi izoba usizo olukhulu ukulwa namaSoviet.
Ngokufanayo, umbono wakwa-Israyeli wawuthi, i-PLO iyinkinga ngempela manje. Asifuni ukubhekana nazo ngaphezu kwalokho okufanele sibhekane nazo. Iyiphi indlela engcono yokwenza abantu bangayisekeli i-PLO phakathi kwabantu basePalestine, kunokuba kube nenye indlela, kulokhu okunye okufakwe ngokwenkolo kwenhlangano yamaSulumane. I-Israel yayiseseka futhi yasivumela ukuthi sichume futhi yasivumela ukuthi sisebenze ngokusemthethweni ngesikhathi lapho izikhulu ze-PLO zazibulawa emhlabeni jikelele. Ngakho-ke, lokhu kunomlando omude noyinkimbinkimbi obuyela emuva nangaphambi kokuba uNetanyahu abe ngundunankulu.
U-Ismail Haniyeh ungumholi wezepolitiki we-Hamas. Ucashunwe kuyi-Guardian ethi, โInhloso yethu icacile. Sifuna ukukhulula umhlaba wethu, izindawo zethu ezingcwele, i-mosque yethu ye-Al-Aqsa, iziboshwa zethu. " Wabe esenezela, โEsitheni,โ ekhuluma noIsrayeli, โinye kuphela into esizoyisho kini: Phumani ezweni lakithi. Ayikho indawo yokuphepha kwakho.โ Manje, ukube ubungumIsrayeli ojwayelekile futhi ukuzwile lokho, ubungeke ujabule kakhulu ngokuqomisana ne-Hamas uma ingekho indawo futhi ingekho indawo ephephile yakho.
Kunjalo impela. Nami ngeke ngizizwe kahle ngalokho, futhi angiyena umIsrayeli. Ngicabanga ukuthi okubalulekile, wukubheka ukuthi ubuholi bezepolitiki, nobezempi, nobunye ubuholi be-Hamas, nobunye ku-Hamas bushintshe kanjani izikhundla zabo eminyakeni edlule. Iminyaka eminingi, benqaba ukwamukela noma yikuphi ukuvuma noma izingxoxo no-Israyeli. Njengoba kwenzeka, eminyakeni edlule, baye baxoxisana kaningi no-Israyeli, muva nje ekuhwebeni kweziboshwa, into u-Israyeli ayenza njalo. Ngokungafani ne-US, i-Israel isobala kakhulu ngokuzimisela kwayo ukuxoxisana nganoma yiziphi iziboshwa noma ama-POW asele ngemuva. Kwakukhona isosha elilodwa lakwa-Israyeli, uGilad Shalit, owayebanjwe iHamas eGaza iminyaka emihlanu. Izingxoxo zaqhubeka isikhathi esiningi. Kwathatha iminyaka, kodwa ekupheleni kwakho, uGilad Shalit wakhululwa emndenini wakhe, ukuze kukhululwe cishe iziboshwa zasePalestina eziyinkulungwane.
Akungabazeki ukuthi i-Hamas ibona ukuthathwa kwama-POWs njengendlela yokubuyisela iziboshwa zabo. Ingabe lokho kusemthethweni? Hhayi uma ilandela izakhamuzi, akunjalo. Kodwa ingabe kuyaqondakala? Impela, yindlela okhulula ngayo iziboshwa. Futhi ngicabanga ukuthi kulo mongo, kusobala ukuthi ama-Israyeli akubona ngendlela efanayo. Esontweni eledlule, kube nabanye abantu basePalestine abangaphezu kuka-5,000, abangama-4,000 kubo okungabasebenzi baseGaza, ababenezimvume zokusebenza ngaphakathi kwa-Israyeli. Bonke bashanelwa bagqunywa ejele. Bacishe baphinda kabili isibalo seziboshwa zasePalestine eziboshwe ngokungemthetho emajele akwa-Israel. Ngithi ngokungekho emthethweni, ngoba inombolo yokuqala, abakhokhiswa. Okwesibili, akukho emthethweni ukuthi umuntu ophethe umbuso adlulise iziboshwa, noma adlulise noma yiziphi izakhamuzi, zisuke kubantu ezihlalayo ziye ezweni elikuyo. Kumane nje akukho emthethweni. Ngakho-ke ukuboshwa kwamaPalestine asuka eGaza noma eWest Bank noma athathe i-East Jerusalem aye ejele elingaphakathi kwa-Israel kukodwa nje kuwukwephula i-Geneva Conventions, ubugebengu bempi. Ngakho-ke, konke lokho kuyaqhubeka, futhi kusobala ukuthi isizathu esenza u-Israyeli kungazelelwe alandele izisebenzi zaseGaza ezengeziwe ezingu-4,000 ezazinezimvume zokuba kwa-Israyeli yingoba ibanika abantu abaningi. Ngicabanga ukuthi babheke ngabomvu ukushintshana ngeziboshwa. Mhlawumbe nalokhu okubanjwe njengamanje, okubanjwe ngokungemthetho kufanele sicace, izakhamuzi kanye nabantu bezempi ababanjwe yi-Hamas. Ngakho, lokhu kuyinto eyinkimbinkimbi kakhulu. Akukho ukucaca kokuthi lokhu kuzoxazululwa kanjani.
Sikhulume kancane mayelana nabezindaba abasezingeni eliphezulu. Asiqhubeke ngaleyo migqa. Ngizokusho kanjani? Ukusebenza kokusakazwa kwabezindaba okujwayelekile kokungqubuzana. Intatheli engumakadebona eMiddle East kanye noprofesa wase-American University of Beirut, uRami Khouri, wanika abezindaba ibanga lika-F. Uphinde weluleka, โI-CNN ayilungile empilweni yakho.โ U-Anderson Cooper, uWolf Blitzer, u-Erin Burnett, uNic Robertson, et al, bahlinzeka nge-cheerleading kwa-Israyeli. Awukho umlando, akukho ingemuva, akukho ngqikithi. Bavuselela izindawo zokukhuluma ze-IDF njengezihlangu zabantu, izindawo eziqinile zamaphekula, kanye namanethi e-hornet. Ukuqagela okushumekiwe akukaze kuphikiswe. Abakhulumeli bakahulumeni wakwa-Israel, bonke abakhuluma isiNgisi esihle kakhulu, bavezwa kaningi. Amazwi asePalestine mancane futhi aqhelelene phakathi. Futhi cishe ngaphandle kokukhetha, kuhlala kuyi-Hamas esekelwa yi-Iran, iHezbollah esekelwa yi-Iran, amaHouthi asekelwa yi-Iran. U-Israyeli akakaze asekelwe yi-US, lokho kunikezwe. Khuluma ngalokho okusakazwa kwabezindaba.
Hhayi-ke, angikaze ngiphikisane noRami. Ake siqale ngalokho. Ungumhlaziyi ohlakaniphile futhi ungumhlaziyi wezindaba omkhulu. Ngicabanga ukuthi uqinisile, bafanelwe i-F. Ngingathi eminyakeni emihlanu edlule, babefanelwe i-F-. Ngakho-ke, ngithanda ukucabanga ngezinto eziqhubekayo. Uma ungenzi kanjalo, usebenzela lolu daba, awusoze wasinda kulo mnyakazo. Awukwenzi nje. Ngakho-ke, ngibheka esimweni salokho okushintshile ngesikhathi se-Operation Cast Lead, lapho u-Israyeli ehlasela iGaza ngo-2008 kanye no-'09. Enye yezinto zokuqala u-Israyeli azama ukuzenza, futhi waphumelela kakhulu ukuzenza, kwakuwukugcina umshini wokunyathelisa wamazwe ngamazwe ungangeni eGaza. Okwamanje, abazami ukwenza lokho. Ngisho ukuthi bazama kancane, bayakumemezela, kodwa akukho mzamo wangempela. Kungani? Ngoba kukhona ama-stringers ezitolo zemidiya ezijwayelekile ezizinze eGaza, abesevele ekhona.
Lokho kwenzeke ngesikhathi sokuhola kwe-Cast. Kwakukhona omunye wesifazane osemusha owayecula New York Times ezinze eGaza. Babengakwazi ukwenza lutho ngaye, ngoba wayehlala eGaza, ehlala nabazali bakhe. Futhi wayemuhle, nezinto zakhe zazisekhasini lokuqala izinsuku, kodwa ucezu oluncane olwandle lokuqagela okusekela uIsrayeli nanoma yini. Manje lokho kwehluke kakhulu. Sizwa amazwi asePalestine. Okunye kwalokhu kuhlobene nomsebenzi wenhlangano ebizwa nge-IMEU, i-Institute for Middle East Understanding, eyaqala eminyakeni eyi-10 edlule. Futhi eminyakeni eyi-10 edlule, babenomuntu oyedwa emsebenzini futhi kwadingeka bathwale kanzima ukuthola noma ubani ukuba banake. Manje banenqwaba yabasebenzi, angazi ukuthi bangaki abakuyo, kodwa abantu abaningi, futhi abakwazi ukuhambisana nazo zonke izidingo zosizo, zamazwi asePalestine. Obani okufanele sibaxoxise? Sibafinyelela kanjani abantu abasekamu lababaleki elingu-X? Kungumehluko ongavamile.
Manje, ingabe lokho kuzohlehlisa amashumi eminyaka, futhi amashumi eminyaka amaningi, okuqagela kwe-pro-Israeli emaphephandabeni aseMelika? Vele akunjalo. Ngeke sibe nobuwula ngalokhu, kodwa futhi ngicabanga ukuthi ukukubona ngaphandle komongo kuyiphutha. Ikhona ngaphakathi kwengqikithi ebanzi, yokuthi zingakanani izinto ezishintshile. Ngakho-ke, ingabe kusadingeka ukuthi kube nokugxekwa njalo kwabezindaba base-US? Nakanjani. Ingabe sisadinga ukukhomba izintatheli ezithile ezizwakala sengathi zingabakhulumeli bePentagon noma be-IDF? Nakanjani. Ziseziningi zazo ezindaweni ezinethonya elikhulu, kodwa zikhona nezinye. Manje usunabantu abehlukene abaqhamuke, izintatheli ezisencane eziqhamuke enkathini ehlukile, okucatshangwa ukuthi zazifunda ngepolitiki zisafunda amabanga aphezulu, besesekolishi, nalapho zifunda esikoleni sobuntatheli, kwakungefani nalabo abafunda esikoleni esiphakeme, nasekolishi, nasesikoleni sobuntatheli eminyakeni engu-20 edlule, noma eminyakeni engama-30 edlule, noma eminyakeni engama-40 edlule.
Ngakho, kukhona umehluko. Futhi ngisho naphakathi kwamazwi asekela kakhulu ama-Israyeli, uTom Friedman ngenxa kaNkulunkulu, empeleni useshintshile kancane mayelana nendlela abona ngayo isimo phansi. Ngoba noma ngubani ongazimisele ngokuphelele ukuvuma lokho akubona phambi kwakhe, akubona ngqo phambi kwamehlo akhe, kufanele akubone lokho. Futhi umbono wokuthi ungahlehla futhi uthi, โAsikudingi ukumiswa kwengxabano manje,โ empeleni akuyona into elula ukuyenza.
Kosopolitiki kulula, ngoba kunomlando. Lo mbono wokuthi asikudingi ukumiswa kokudubula okwamanje, yisimo esinesikhathi eside saseMelika. Lokhu sakubona ngo-2006 ngesikhathi i-Israel isempini eLebanon, lapho uCondoleezza Rice, uNobhala Wezwe kaGeorge Bush Jr, esho ngokusobala, โAsikudingi ukumiswa kwezikhali okwamanje.โ Lapho uMkhandlu Wezokuphepha uvota futhi cishe wonke amanye amazwe eMkhandlwini ayethi, โSidinga ukumiswa kokudubula. Kuyahlanya lokhu. Kuyadabukisa lokhu. Sidinga ukuthi kumiswe ukulwa.โ
Impendulo yakhe yathi, โAsikakudingi ukumiswa kwezikhali okwamanje.โ Futhi kufanele ukufunde lokho njengokuthi, โAbanganele abantu asebafa, sidinga abantu abaningi ukuthi bafe. Mhlawumbe kusasa, mhlawumbe ezinsukwini ezimbalwa singaba nokuqeda ukulwa.โ Yini eyohluka ngaleso sikhathi, ngaphandle kokuthi abantu abaningi bayobe sebefile? Ngo-2008 nango-2009, ngesikhathi se-Cast lead, into efanayo ku-United Nations. Futhi, ngo-Condoleezza Rice ekupheleni kwegama likaBush, "Asikudingi ukumiswa kokudubula okwamanje."
Kepha okwenzekile kulokhu, ngikhulume ngokwenzeka ngo-2021, lapho uMongameli uBiden manje ethi, "Asikudingi ukuthi kuqedwe umlilo," futhi kungazelelwe kube nokuhlehla emuva kwamalungu eCongress. Futhi lawa akuwona amalungu eCongress empeleni asekela amalungelo asePalestine. Laba bahlanganisa abantu abangakaze basho lutho ukweseka amalungelo asePalestine. Kodwa ngenxa yezizathu zabo zobuntu kanye nezizathu zezombangazwe, mayelana nokuthi lokhu kusho ukuthini ngendlela umhlaba obona ngayo ukuthi i-United States imayelana nani, ngenxa yazo zonke lezo zizathu, balungele ukuthi, "Sidinga ukumiswa komlilo." Ngisho noma beqala futhi bephetha incwadi yabo ngokuthi, โU-Israyeli unelungelo lokuzivikela ukwenza noma yini ayifunayo, futhi kufanele sibakhokhele ngokuthanda kwabo ngakho konke abakudingayo.โ Bakusho konke lokho, kodwa phakathi kwakho, bathi, โSidinga ukumiswa komlilo.โ Kukhulu lokho.
Ingabe kwanele? Vele akunjalo. Senze umsebenzi owanele nalawo malungu kaKhongolose nabasebenzi bawo? Cha, asikaze. Kodwa kukhulu ukuthi manje sebethi kunesinqumo sokuthi akumiswe ukulwa manje, amalungu eKhongolose athi mhlawumbe ngeke asayine lesi sinqumo, kodwa azothi akumiswe ukulwa. Noma uma kungenjalo, uma lelo gama seliyingozi kakhulu, bazothi: โNgizobiza ukuba kuphele ubutha.โ Kusho into efanayo. Kulungile, sebenzisa noma yiluphi ulimi olufunayo, kodwa biza ukuthi kumiswe ukulwa, ngoba yilokho okudingeka kakhulu. Futhi yilapho sibone khona ushintsho. Akwanele ngoshintsho. U-Rami uqinisile, basathola u-F, uKhongolose uthola u-Fโ, ngoba banamandla engeziwe. Kodwa noma kunjalo, kuyashintsha. Iyashintsha.
Ukuthathwa komhlaba ngendluzula kuyingxenye engenakuphikiswa yomthetho wamazwe ngamazwe, kanjalo nokujeziswa okuhlangene. Sike sakhuluma ngalokho. Lesi sakamuva wumkhuba wesikhathi eside wakwa-Israel, kuqhunyiswa amakhaya. I-East Jerusalem kanye neSyria Golan Heights zithathwe yi-Israel ngokwephula ngokusobala umthetho wamazwe ngamazwe. Akuvamisile ukuvela kunoma yiluphi uhlobo lwenkulumo, kodwa ikakhulukazi i-Syrian Golan Heights, mhlawumbe izikhangiso zabo ezigcwele zakwa-Israel ezincoma ubuhle bewayini le-Golan Heights ku-New York Times Sunday Magazine. Kodwa ngaphandle kwalokho, awuboni okuningi kwakho. Imigwaqo emikhulu yeWest Bank ithathwe ukuze kuhlaliswe ama-Israel. Kukhona okungenani izifiki eziyingxenye yesigidi, cishe ngaphezu kwalokho, eWest Bank. Ngabe lokho kufakazela noma yiluphi uhlobo lwezwe lasePalestine elisebenzayo?
Ingxenye yesibili yombuzo wakho, ngicabanga ukuthi ilula. Akusekho ithuba lesixazululo semibuso emibili. Kucace kakhulu. Lena akuyona indaba engase iphikiswe okwamanje phakathi kwanoma ubani owaziyo noma yini. Isixazululo semibuso emibili, noma njengoba sivame ukubizwa ngokushesha, isixazululo semibuso emibili ngokushintshana. Kufanele ukusho ngokushesha okukhulu futhi kufanele ukusho ngokushintshana, into ekhona kosopolitiki kanye namanxusa angenayo impendulo, abangenayo impendulo yokuthi benzeni mayelana nengcindezelo yamaPalestine, ubandlululo olubhekene namaPalestine, i-settler colonial. iqiniso lika-Israyeli. Akukho abangakunikeza ukuxazulula leyo nselele. Ngakho-ke, esikhundleni salokho, bathi, "Sidinga ukubuyela esixazululweni semibuso emibili." Ngeke kube nesixazululo semibuso emibili, ngoba awukho umhlaba osele wezwe lasePalestine elisebenzayo.
Manje uma sikubeka eceleni lokho, umbuzo wokujobelela usewukhiye kakhulu. Futhi asizange sizwe esikhathini esingeside kakhulu esidlule, amaqiniso athile athile nasabisayo mayelana nomsebenzi kanye nokuthathwa kweGolan Heights. Ukuthathwa kweGolan empeleni kwamenyezelwa yi-Israel emuva ngo-1981, eminyakeni embalwa nje ngemva kokuba ithathwe ngo-1967. Ayizange ibonwe yinoma yiliphi izwe emhlabeni. Lokho kwashintsha ngo-2018. UDonald Trump ungumongameli, uya kwa-Israel. Uhlangana noNetanyahu, futhi uthi, โManje ngimemezela ukuthi sikubona njengokusemthethweni ukuthatha kuka-Israyeli iGolan Heights.โ Kufana nokuthi, ngubani othe ungakwenza lokho? Ngokuphula ngokuphelele umthetho wamazwe ngamazwe, futhi akekho ombiza ngakho.
Okubi nakakhulu, wabe esebuyela eJerusalema futhi umemezela ukuthi i-ambassy yase-US manje izosuswa, futhi ngokuphula ngokuphelele izinqumo ze-UN kanye nomthetho wamazwe ngamazwe. Uzosusa ihhovisi lenxusa laseMelika e-Tel Aviv aliyise eJerusalema, futhi ubuyela e-United States futhi uhlangana neqembu lezicebi zamaRiphabhulikhi angamaJuda, abaxhasi abakhulu be-Republican Party kanye nomkhankaso wakhe. Futhi uyaqalaza futhi uthi, โMina, ngokokuqala ngqa, ngabona ukuthathwa kuka-Israyeli eGolan Heights.โ Bese ethi, โFuthi lapho ngikwenza, nganginondunankulu wenu.โ Futhi akukho noyedwa wabo owasukuma wayesethi, โUxolo, Mnu. Mongameli, asiwona ama-Israyeli. SingamaMelika. Asinaye undunankulu kwa-Israel. UNetanyahu akayena undunankulu wethu. Ungumongameli wethu.โ Akekho owasho lokho. Kwakuwuhlobo lokugcina lwe-anti-Semitic canard ethi amaJuda anokwethembeka okukabili ku-Israyeli. Kwaba ukucasuka futhi akekho owambiza ngakho esendlini noma emaphephandabeni avamile. Thina ngaphandle kwalezo zinkundla senza.
Wabe eseqhubeka kulowo mhlangano ofanayo, futhi waqalaza futhi wabona uSheldon Adelson, omunye wabaxhasi abacebe kakhulu be-Republican Party, kanye nezinqubo zokuhlaliswa kwabantu nama-Israel, kanye nomkakhe. Futhi waqalaza futhi wathi, lapho ekhuluma ngokuthuthela kwenxusa eJerusalema, empeleni i-US yayikubona ukuthathwa kweJerusalema, nayo engekho emthethweni futhi engaziwa muntu. Wathi, โSheldon noMiriyamu, ngikwenzele kona.โ Yini engaba ukuvuma okucacile ukuthi wenza inqubomgomo yakhe ngokusekelwe ezifisweni zemali yamaJuda acebile? Ngokuqondile lokho u-Ilhan Omar akuthakasela ukuzonda ubuJuda, lapho ekhuluma ngakho njengento edabukisayo ukuthi abanye osopolitiki bazothatha izinqumo zabo ngokusekelwe emalini ehlinzekwa yizindawo zokungcebeleka ezahlukene, futhi waveza indawo yokwamukela ugwayi, i-big pharma, eyesithathu, kanye Indawo yokusebenzela yakwa-Israyeli. Ukhulume ngezindawo ezine ezihlukene zokungena, kodwa ngenxa yokuthi ihlanganisa indawo yokwamukela izivakashi yakwa-Israel, wajatshuliswa ukuzonda amaJuda.
UMongameli uTrump ngaleso sikhathi wenza inkomba emelene namaSemite ngokusobala ekwenzeni isinqumo sakhe, ngoba abanikeli bakhe abacebe kakhulu babesifuna. Futhi akekho othi zwi. Ngakho-ke, kuyinto engavamile, wonke lo mbono wokujobelela. Kodwa noma ngabe i-proforma annexation, okusho ukuthi bayahamba ngayo, bayawuthatha lowo mhlaba, noma ngabe uyavunywa noma cha, noma u-de jure annexation, okusho ukuthi umenyezelwe ngokusemthethweni, empeleni awubalulekile kakhulu ezimpilweni zasePalestine. sikhishwe kulokhu. Lapho abantu bexoshwa ezweni labo, izindlu zabo ziyabhidlizwa, iminqumo yabo iyasishulwa, futhi bona nemikhaya yabo bayanyakaziswa ngokoqobo, bexoshwa ezweni labo. Yingakho ingekho indawo esele yezwe lasePalestine. Noma ngabe yini ebesike sayicabanga mayelana nezwe elizimele lasePalestine elihambisana no-Israel, kungani belingakaze lilingane, nokunye, nokunye. Akusenani ngempela. Ngeke nje kwenzeke, ngoba akusenani. Ukuthi bekunjalo noma cha, akuyona inkinga. Indaba ayisekho umhlaba, asiqhubeke.
Indaba manje ayimayelana nezifundazwe, izwe elilodwa, izifunda ezimbili, isimo esibomvu, isimo esiluhlaza okwesibhakabhaka. Akuyona indaba leyo. Indaba ngamalungelo. Ingabe sinokulingana namalungelo abantu bonke, noma akunjalo? Esinakho njengamanje yisimo lapho yonke indawo yendawo eyake yaba yiPalestine yomlando, indawo kusukela emfuleni kuya olwandle, kuhlanganise nemingcele ye-Israel 1947-48, iWest Bank, iGaza, kanye neMpumalanga yeJerusalema. Konke lokho ngokuhlanganyela kungaphansi kombuso owodwa kanye nebutho elilodwa lezempi, leli lika-Israel. Futhi ukuthi yimaphi amalungelo abantu kuleyo ndawo abanawo anqunywa ngokwengxenye ukuthi bakuphi kanye nohlanga lwabo, inkolo yabo, ulimi lwabo.
Yileyo ncazelo yobandlululo. Lapho abantu endaweni eyodwa ebuswa amandla owodwa, uhulumeni oyedwa unamazinga ahlukene wamalungelo kuye ngezindaba ezinjengobuzwe, inkolo, ubuzwe, ulimi, nokunye. Yileyo ncazelo yobandlululo. Kungakho zonke izinhlangano ezinkulu zamalungelo abantu emhlabeni, iHuman Rights Watch, Amnesty International, B'Tselem, ezinye eziningi kwa-Israel, izingxenye zeNhlangano Yezizwe zonke zinqume ukuthi i-Israel iqhuba ubugebengu bobandlululo. Lokho akuseyona into engokoqobo eyinkimbinkimbi. Iqondwa kabanzi.
Ake sikhulume ngeMpi yaseGaza kanye nemithelela yayo esifundeni esibanzi. Kuthiwa uBiden noBlinken bebesondele esivumelwaneni neSaudi Arabia kanye ne-MBS, uMohammed bin Salman, inkosana yaseSaudi kanye nombusi we-de facto. Phela, usephumile ku-โpariahโ egameni lika-Biden waya kozakwethu, i-jujitsu yangempela yengqondo eqhubekayo lapho. Kuthiwani ngeSaudi Arabia nemithelela yayo?
Kucace bha ukuthi isivumelwano esingaba khona ebesizokwenza ubudlelwano phakathi kuka-Israel neSaudi Arabia bube bujwayelekile, obekuhlala kuyisimangalo esingamanga. Kunobudlelwano obude phakathi kuka-Israel neSaudi Arabia. Umehluko wukuthi bathule nje. Awamukelwa, awekho esidlangalaleni, awafaki izinto ezibonakala phezulu njengokuvakasha kwama-Israel, izinto ezinjalo. Konke lokho manje kwase kuzobonakala emphakathini, umehluko omkhulu lowo. Ubudlelwano bangempela, ubudlelwano bokuvikeleka, ukulwa nobuphekula njengoba bethanda ukukubiza kanjalo, lezo zinhlobo zobudlelwano, ubudlelwano bezomnotho, zonke izinhlobo zobudlelwano sezivele zikhona, kodwa zifihlakele kakhulu, zithule kakhulu, futhi azikho. cishe njengoba izinhlangothi zombili zingathanda ukuba zibe.
Lokho akusekho ku-ajenda okwamanje, okwamanje, ngicabanga ukuthi mhlawumbe kuze kufike inkosi yamanje, esekhulile impela futhi egula kakhulu, ize idlule emhlabeni, kanye neNkosana yoMqhele, iNkosana yoMqhele, eyayibambe iqhaza, ngokusho kuka. I-CIA kanye nomhlaba wonke, ngokubulawa kuka-Jamal Khashoggi, i- Washington Post umlobi wephephandaba owabulawa e-consulate yaseSaudi e-Istanbul, futhi enecala ngokubandakanyeka kweSaudi empini yaseYemen, okuholele ekutheni abantu baseYemen bahlupheke kuze kube manje. Futhi ngokusobala, kubi kakhulu eGaza, kodwa kuze kube yileso sikhathi, inhlekelele embi kakhulu yabantu emhlabeni ngokusho kweZizwe Ezihlangene, okwakuyi-MBS kakhulu, uMohammed bin Salman.
Ngakho-ke, konke lokho ngeke kwenzeke kuze kube yilapho inkosi isidlulile. Inkosi yaseSaudi Arabia ebonakala ingenawo amandla okwamanje yayinesibopho emuva ngo-2002 ngalokho okwaziwa ngokuthi yiSaudi Peace Initiative, noma kwethize i-Arab Peace Initiative, eyaveza isikhundla esisekelwe kakhulu emthethweni wamazwe ngamazwe. , eyayithi ukujwayezwa kobudlelwane phakathi kwe-Israel nezifunda ezahlukene zama-Arab kwakuzokwenzeka kuphela uma u-Israel esehoxile ekuthatheni izindawo zawo ngo-1967. Futhi lokho kwakusho ukuhoxiswa kwezifiki, nokunye. Lokho kwamukelwa emhlabeni wonke. Kodwa-ke, yenqatshwa u-Israyeli kanye ne-United States, ngoba ayizange ivumele ukuqhubeka kwephrojekthi yamakholoni eyayivele iqhubeka. Futhi kulowo mongo, kwanyamalala, kodwa ngenxa yokuthi kuhlotshaniswa nenkosi yaseSaudi Arabia, indodana yakhe, ngicabanga ukuthi, ibilokhu ithandabuza ukuyishiya ngokuphelele. Futhi uzolinda kuze kube yilapho zombili izinkinga zaseGaza sezehlile kancane futhi kuze kudlule uyise. Ngakho-ke, angicabangi ukuthi lokho kuphuma ku-ajenda. Izobambezeleka nje isikhashana.
Ingabe umangale nganoma iyiphi indlela, ngokuthi i-China ilamula isivumelwano phakathi kwe-Saudi Arabia ne-Iran?
Ngandlela thize, lesi bekuyisikhundla esisha seShayina, ebambe iqhaza kakhulu esifundeni ngokwezomnotho kodwa engazange idlale indima enkulu yobunxusa. Ngakho, lokhu kwakuyinto entsha. Lokhu kwakuyinto i-US eyayingajabule ngayo ngempela, kodwa kwenzeka esimweni salokho i-US eyayizama ukukwenza mayelana nenqubo yokujwayela phakathi kweSaudi Arabia ne-Israel. Impela i-US ayizange ijabule ngeChina evela njengomdlali obalulekile wezokuxhumana lapha. Futhi lokhu kwakunzima kakhulu, ngoba ngasikhathi sinye noma ngesikhathi esifanayo lapho i-China yayixoxisana ngayo ngalesi sivumelwano, okusobala ukuthi i-US yayingazi nokuthi, phakathi kwe-Iran neSaudi Arabia, i-US yayixoxisana ngalesi sivumelwano phakathi kweSaudi Arabia ne-Saudi Arabia. I-Israel, futhi lokho kwakuzofaka ukwanda okukhulu kwezempi, kanye nobudlelwano bezomnotho, phakathi kwe-US neSaudi Arabia, okuhlanganisa nokunikeza iSaudi Arabia ilungelo lokucebisa i-uranium, okucatshangwa ukuthi izinhloso zokuthula kuphela, kodwa yini ngokusobala ukuqala komunye umjaho wezikhali zenuzi esifundeni sonke. Kuzobandakanya iziqinisekiso eziningi zokusekelwa kwe-US kwe-Saudi Arabia uma kwenzeka kuba nokungqubuzana kwesifunda, okungabeka i-US sesimweni sokulwa ne-Iran, ngokwesibonelo, uma kuqubuka ukungezwani kweSaudi-Iranian.
Ngakho-ke, kwakuyimibuzo eminingana ebalulekile, kanye nokubeka eceleni ngokuphelele udaba lwamalungelo asePalestine nasePalestine, okwakungafanele acatshangelwe kule nqubo yokwejwayelekile. Ukujwayezwa kwalokho okubizwa nge-Abraham Accords esifundeni kube buhlungu kakhulu kubantu basePalestine ngoba yize kungekho noyedwa kuhulumeni wama-Arab owanikeza ukwesekwa kwangempela kwabasePalestine nganoma iyiphi indlela, isimo noma isimo, inkohliso yokusekelwa okuvela emazweni ama-Arab, ngoba kukhona Ukwesekwa okusabalele kubantu bama-Arab, kwakusho ukuthi ukulahlekelwa lokho, ukuba kucace ukuthi ohulumeni bama-Arab babeneliseke ngokuphelele ukulungisa ubudlelwano no-Israyeli, ngaphandle komcabango wesikhashana ukuthi lokho bekuzosho ukuthini kumaPalestine, kufanekisela ukwehla okukhulu kwemizamo yezobunxusa yasePalestine. Ngakho, kwaba nemiphumela kuyo yonke indawo yalokhu. Futhi ngenkathi i-US kusobala ukuthi yayingeneme ngokuvela kweChina kulowo mongo, impela bekuhambisana nendlela i-US ebona ngayo inqubomgomo yayo yezangaphandle njengoba ilolongwa ezingeni lomhlaba wonke ngokugcina ithonya lamaShayina liphansi. Ngakho-ke, lokhu kwakuzoba esinye isibonelo saso okwakudingeka sinyathelwe phansi.
Ekugcineni, futhi ngiyaqiniseka ukuthi ubuzwa lo mbuzo kuzo zonke izingxoxo ozenzayo, yini abantu abangayenza?
Njengamanje udaba luwukuphela kwengxabano. Yilokho kuphela udaba olubalulekile njengamanje. Maduze kuzoba nezinye izinkinga eziningi. Kodwa njengamanje, sidinga ukumiswa kokudubula. Lokho kuphuthuma kakhulu. Kudingeka usizo lwesintu. Abathunjwa badinga ukukhululwa. Kukhona zonke izinhlobo zezinto, kodwa okokuqala, sikudinga kakhulu ukumiswa kokudubula. Lokho kusho ukubiza, futhi, futhi, futhi ngokuphindaphindiwe ehhovisi lomuntu wakho wekhongolose. Uma besayine isinqumo sokuyeka ukulwa, batuse, babonge, banikeze izimbali, noma yini edingekayo ukuze ukhuthaze lokho, bese ubanxusa ukuba benze okwengeziwe. Banxuse ukuthi bathumele eyabo incwadi phezu kwesinqumo e-White House bethi, "Kuzomele ucele ukuthi kumiswe ukulwa." Asikwazi ukwamukela lokhu kunqaba ukubiza ukuthi kumiswe ukulwa.
Imibhikisho ngesonto eledlule, okuhlanganisa nowangoLwesithathu obuholwa yiJewish Voice for Peace, lapho kuboshwe abantu abangaphezu kuka-300 bethi, "amaJuda adinga ukumiswa kwezikhali manje," futhi kuhlanganisa norabi abangaphezu kuka-25 ababoshwe eCannon Office Building. . Leyo mibhikisho yonke ibigxile odabeni lokumiswa kwezikhali. Futhi lesosiyalo ukuze kucace kakhulu ngalokho okufanele kwenzeke njengamanje, kuyindaba yokuphila nokufa. Kusele izinsuku ezimbalwa kuphela ngaphambi kokuba siqale ukubona ukufa okukhulu phakathi kwabasengozini kakhulu, phakathi kwezingane, phakathi kwabadala, phakathi kwezingane zaseGaza, ngenxa yokuntuleka kwamanzi kanye nezifo ezibangelwa amanzi. Ngoba lapho amanzi aphuzwayo engekho, abantu bayophuza amanzi angcolile, futhi bayophuza amanzi anosawoti olwandle.
Ukuphuza olwandle kuyinkulumo endala ngeGaza, futhi kuzoba ngokoqobo phakathi namahora noma izinsuku. Ngakho, asikho isikhathi sokuchitha. Abantu badinga ukwenza umsebenzi wokubiza amalungu abo eCongress, babhalele umhleli izincwadi, babhalele wonke umuntu abangamcabanga, bashayele umndeni wabo, bethi, "Ngicela ushayele ilungu lakho leCongress ngokuphindaphindiwe." Babala ukuthi bangaki abantu abafonayo, futhi kubalulekile ukuthi lezo zinombolo zikhuphuke. Ngakho-ke, qhubeka, qhubeka nokucindezela. Sidinga ukumiswa komlilo manje, ukumiswa komlilo nhlangothi zonke. Iyona kuphela indlela yokunqanda ukubulala.
Siyabonga kakhulu ngesikhathi sakho.
Ngiyabonga, David.
(Ngenxa yemikhawulo yesikhathi ezinye izingxenye zenhlolokhono azifakwanga ekusakazeni kuzwelonke. Lezo zingxenye zifakiwe kulo mbhalo.)
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa kuphela ngokuphana kwabafundi bayo.
Nikela