The Santayana adage is, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it” – as if reason or knowledge has ever leashed oppression, vengeance, and bloodshed. We live on a carousel of repetition compulsion disorder.
If You Cannot Say GENOCIDE, by Yahia Lababidi, is a feast, an abundance, of lucid articles written under the duress of horrors of Gaza we watch but cannot stop. By a man determined to stay human.
Of Palestinian background, Lababidi watches as I do, from the relative safety and order of the United States, the human catastrophe and pointless degradation of oppressor and oppressed.
One of the best features of the Lababidi’s writing is how he draws on a range of teachings from different moments of trauma and inspiration, from Malcolm X to Victor Frankl to Edward Said.
My early intuitions were clarified by prophetic writers such as
Gibran and Blake, for whom vision meant divine nearness, placing
an infinite claim upon us. Later, in Buber, I could see how relation
became revelation. Or in Heschel, the trembling scribe of divine sor-
row…”
He says he felt compelled to choose prose in addition to his book of poems about Gaza, Palestine Wail. “These essays come out of grief, and out of a stubbornness I could not reason away. They speak in the spirit of the prophets who stood before cities and wept, who sought to awaken conscience.”
I stop short at that. Isn’t the fate of prophets, raging against degrading sins, to be disbelieved like Cassandra the seer? Or am I lost in pessimism?
Labadidi places Palestinian agony in context of other times and places, to salvage decency and mutual regard, common humanity. Gaza lives in a unique moment of atrocity and deprivation, but in the same territory as any population seen by men with arms as beneath humanity.
He video-messages with a young Gaza poet and translator living in conditions of deprivation and peril, and observes his own discontinuity of being in safety while suffering moral injury.
One evening, around six o’clock, he sent a series of alarming messages. I was in my apartment in Florida, standing by the kitchen counter, transfixed by his voice notes and video footage. The contrast was unbearable: my still, secure space and his precarious existence. I stood in silence, torn between helplessness and responsibility.
Lababidi observes the immediacy and pace of the “endless scroll” which deracinates our human responses.
We have devised subtler forms of diminishment. A child is pulled from rubble; by the following day, the image has been captioned and replaced. That is the mechanism of saturation and exhaustion.
…The suffering does not lessen, only the attention given to it. The hardest realization is noticing this change inside oneself. I catch my thumb scrolling past a headline that would once have stopped me cold. …The mind learns to survive constant exposure. …citizens are asked to live alongside permanent crisis as though it were normal life.
Lababidi is describing the way we experience horrors now. One day it is a Gaza tent community of refugees bombed and in flames, another it is thousands existing where all is mud and water and there is no hope of rescue.
The scenes proceed one after another like a slideshow, and we flick-flick-flick past to the next. Schoolgirls bombed in Iran, the charnel house of Bucha, villages methodically destroyed in Lebanon by explosives of IDF engineers, gunsight video of a missile strike on sailors and their boat in the Gulf of Mexico, killed in an explosive moment, from a trophy reel by the US Defense Department.
Poet Lababidi ruminates on the challenges of remaining composed, respectable, speaking for Palestinian humanity.
In an article about Mohammed El-Kurd, Lababidi notes the barrier to being heard of Palestinians:
He asks, with the same precision, why authority of narration
belongs by default to those who have carried out the dispossession:
“Why do we give the authority of narration to those who have mur-
dered and displaced us when the scarcity of their guilt means hon-
esty is unlikely?”
…Many of us in the diaspora know this coercion in subtler forms: the anticipatory editing of one’s own outrage, the knowledge that Palestine remains one of those subjects on which plain speech is treated as excess and accuracy can sound accusatory.
All in all, this collection of 47 essays written over the last 3 years of Gaza horror by this poet is rich, humane, luminous.
If You Cannot Say GENOCIDE: Essays on Conscience and Witness
by Yahia Lababidi
New Village Press/NYU Press
ZNetwork is funded solely through the generosity of its readers.
Donate
