“Pamusana pezvikanganiso zvayo zvose, hurumende yeUnited States inoramba iri mutsigiri ane simba zvikuru wekodzero dzevanhu, uye sangano reHuman Rights Watch riri muUnited States rinopa sangano racho mukana chaiwo wokuenda kuWashington.”— Ken Roth.
The quote pamusoro yakabva muchinyorwa chaNdira 4, 2015 naKen Roth, mukuru mukuru weHuman Rights Watch (HRW). Fungidzira kuti mhuri dzei inosvika hafu yemiriyoni Iraqis vakaurayiwa nekuda kwekupinda zvisiri pamutemo kweUSA vangataura nezvechirevo ichocho. Mhosva dzakadai, kana dzabvumwa zvachose, dzinodzikiswa kusvika ku“kukanganisa” kana “kukanganisa” nevakuru vane rusununguko vakaita saKen Roth.
Kufa kwazvino kwaMambo Abdullah weSaudi Arabia kunoratidza maitiro ane "special access" kuWashington paHRW. A chirevo chakaburitswa mushure mekufa kwaAbdullah neHRW yaive nemusoro wekuti “Saudi Arabia: King’s Reform Agenda Haina Kuzadzikiswa: Hutungamiri Hutsva Hunofanira Kukoshesa Kuvandudza Rekodhi Yekodzero Dzevanhu Yenyika.”
Muhutsinye uye kumashure, pane zvishoma zvekusarudza pakati peISIS nehurumende yeSaudi se Anasi Abhasi zvakatsanangurwa muchidimbu, asi HRW inoedza nepainogona napo kuisa chimiro chakanaka panhaka yemubatsiri weUS anosemesa. Izvi ndizvo chaizvo zvaungatarisira kubva kuboka rinotenda hukuru hwehunhu hweUS, uye rinokoshesa zvikuru "kuwana kwakakosha kuWashington."
Chirevo cheHRW hachingovharidzi hutsinye hwaAbdullah kumba; haitauri zvachose nezve basa raAbdullah rinoparadza mudunhu. Murtaza Hussain, mune yekufa yakanyorerwa the Bvisa, yakaongorora rekodhi yakashata iyo HRW yakafuratira. Hurumende yaAbdullah yakaedza kuita kuti USA ibhombe Iran muna 2008. Muna 2011, mauto eSaudi akabatsira kuparadza Bahrain's reform movement. MuSyria, maSaudi anga aripo vatsigiri vanokosha vemaIslam anonyanyisa kurwisa hurumende yeAssad. Abdullah akatsigira nechido hutongi hwehudzvanyiriri hwaGeneral Abdelfattah al Sisi muEgypt nerubatsiro rwemari. Chigadziko che drone chechirongwa chekuuraya chepasi rose chaObama chakatambirwawo naAbdullah. Hapana chimwe cheizvi chakaonekwa sechinofanirwa kutaurwa neHRW payakapfupisa nhaka yaAbdullah.
Zvino funga nezve chirevo chakaburitswa neHRW maawa mushure mekunge Hugo Chavez, mutungamiri weVenezuela akasarudzwa zvine demokrasi, afa muna 2013. statement yakanga ine musoro unoti “Chávez’s Authoritarian Legacy: Dramatic Concentration of Power and Open Disregard for Basic Human Rights.”
Zviripachena kana Venezuela yaive munyasha dzeUSA, yaigona kuzvishandura kuita humambo hwakazara anogura vanhu misoro nekuda kuroyiwa uye maoko ane pfungwa dzakafanana nevanopenga kunze kwenyika. HRW yaizopfavisa kutsoropodza kwayo zvakanyanya kuti ichengetedze "yakakosha kuwana kuWashington". Mukutaura kwayo nezve Venezuela, HRW haina kungo shandisa pachena zvakapetwa zviyero uye tsvakurudzo isina maturo asiwo nekunyepa chaiko sezvandatsanangura mukati ichi chikamu. Chikamu che "nhaka yechiremera" yaChavez maererano neHRW yaive yekuti "akambundira hurumende dzinoshungurudza," kunyanya North Korea, Libya, Iran, Syria uye - zvakanyanya mukufunga kweHRW - Cuba. HRW yakataura kuti "Pasi peChávez, mubatsiri weVenezuela aive Cuba, iyo chete nyika muLatin America inodzvinyirira nzira dzese dzezvematongerwo enyika. Chávez akaziva Fidel Castro - akatungamira hurumende yehudzvanyiriri yeCuba kudzamara hutano hwake hwaderera muna 2006 - semuenzaniso uye chipangamazano.
Mamiriro eHRW eCuba haamirire kuongororwa sezvandakatsanangura pano, asi cherechedza mutauro wakakasharara unoshandiswa neHRW kushoropodza hurumende yeCuba iyo USA yakaedza kuparadza kwemakumi emakore akati kuti. Aya mazwi pamusoro peCuba anopa mutsauko wakanyanya nekushomeka kweHRW, kusinganzwisisike uye kunonzvenga nezve nhaka yaAbdullah.
Muna Chivabvu 2014 tsamba iyi yakatumirwa kuKen Roth nenyanzvi dzinopfuura zana dzinosanganisira Nobel Peace Prize Laureates Adolfo Pérez Esquivel naMairead Maguire; aimbova Mutevedzeri weMunyori Mukuru weUN, Hans von Sponeck; uye iyezvino UN Special Rapporteur paHuman Rights muPalestine Territories Richard Falk. Tsamba iyi yaikurudzira kuti HRW "Basa avo vakagadzira kana kuita mutemo wekunze weUS kubva kushanda sevashandi veHRW, vanachipangamazano kana nhengo dzebhodhi. Nepadiki padiki, raira nguva refu 'yekutonhorera' nguva isati yasvika uye mushure mekunge chero mubatsiri afamba pakati peHRW neruoko rwehurumende.
HRW akapindura ichiti inogara ichishoropodza hurumende yeAmerica chinova chechokwadi asi chisina basa zvachose nezviri kutaurwa muchikumbiro ichi. Ichokwadi zvakare, semuenzaniso, kuti HRW yakashoropodza rekodhi yaMambo Abdullah uye yaHugo Chavez. Icho chokwadi hachipindure mubvunzo wekuti kutsoropodza kwacho kwakaenzana here kana kuti kwakaringana mune yega yega.
Keane Bhatt, uyo akaronga nekunyora chikumbiro chakatumirwa kuRoth, pamwe nevamwe vanhu vana vakasaina, vakaburitsa gwaro. yakadzama mhinduro kune HRW. Pakati pezvimwe zvinhu, vakanyatsotsanangurira HRW kuti nei kuve neaimbove mukuru weCIA saMiguel Diaz pabhodhi ravo rekupa mazano kwemakore hachisi chinhu chinotenderwa neboka rekodzero dzevanhu - kunyanya tichifunga kuti Diaz akazodzokera kuhurumende yeUS se "mutauriri pakati pe nharaunda yevasori nevasiri vehurumende.” Irworwo rwegonhi rinotenderera inoshatisa indasitiri yekodzero dzevanhu sezvinoita vamwe vakawanda.
Mhinduro yacho yakatsanangurawo zvine ruremekedzo kunyangadza kwaJavier Solana kutora nzvimbo mubhodhi reHRW kubva 2011. Solana aive mukuru wemauto eNATO muSerbia pavakabhomba nemaune chiteshi cheTV vachiuraya vanhu 16 — a. hondo yemhosva.
Izvi zvinofanirwa kunge zvakatsanangurwa kuboka rekodzero dzevanhu rine mukurumbira zvinoratidza kuti hazvigoneke kuvandudza kana pasina shanduko dzakadzama munyika dzekumadokero. Mafambisirwo anogona kuunza shanduko idzi anofanirwa kudzidza kubva muzvinhu zvakanaka zvakaitika munyika dzakawanda zvakasvibiswa nemapoka akamisikidzwa akaita seHRW - nyika dzakaita seCuba, Venezuela, Ecuador neBolivia. Kutsoropodza kwechokwadi kwenyika idzi kuri pachena kunodiwawo, asi vanhu vanofanirwa kuziva kuti HRW harisi sangano rinopa.
Sezvineiwo, mauto eUS ari kutsigira makwikwi ekunyora rondedzero yekukudza Mambo Abdullah. Aiwa, uku hakusi kuseka. Mumwe mufananidzo wezvinoreva "mutsigiri ane simba wekodzero dzevanhu".