Wani lokaci ana iya hango gaskiyar babban kasuwancin tarihi mai ruɗani a cikin rahoton labarai guda ɗaya. Irin wannan lamari ne game da yakin Iraki, a gare ni, tare da labarin kwanan nan a cikin Washington Post Anthony Shadid da Steve Fainaru suka kira "Gina Sojojin Iraki: Ba za a iya yiwuwa ba." Shadid da Fainaru sun yi wani abu da ba a cika yinsa ba: sun shafe kwanaki da yawa tare da rukunin sabbin sojojin Iraki da Amurka ta horar. (Abin da aka saba yi game da batun ya ƙunshi wasu 'yan tambayoyi da aka yi da jami'an Amurka a yankin Green a Baghdad, wanda ya kai ga kimanta tsawon lokacin da za a ɗauka don kammala aikin.) Post labarin ya fara ne da kalmomin waƙar da sojojin ƙungiyar, da ake kira Charlie Company, suke rera ba tare da jin kunnen masu kula da Amurkawa ba. Shi ne ballad ga Saddam Hussein, kuma ya gudu:
“Mun rayu cikin wulakanci tun tafiyarka
Mun yi fatan mu yi rayuwarmu tare da ku”
Kafofin yada labaran Amurka dai na yawan tattaunawa kan batun siyasar tada kayar baya, sai dai kawo yanzu babu wanda ya ce wasu daga cikin sojojin da Amurka ke horaswa za su yi fatan dawowar Saddam. Har zuwa yadda lamarin yake - ko kuma cewa wadannan dakarun suna adawa da mamaya - Amurka, da nisa daga inganta "tsaro," yanzu tana horar da juriya na gaba ga kanta. Hakika, sojojin na Kamfanin Charlie sun shaidawa Shadid da Fainaru cewa goma sha bakwai daga cikinsu sun bar aiki a kwanakin baya. Sun kara da cewa kowane daya daga cikinsu ya shirya yin hakan da wuri-wuri. Dalilan su sun kasance masu sauki. Sun kasance masu daci a Amurka. "Ku dubi gidajen mutanen Iraqi," wani soja ya ce. "An lalatar da mutanen." Lokacin da aka tambaye shi ta wanene, ya amsa, "Su" - kuma ya nuna Amurkawa da ke jagorantar sintiri. Iraqis sun shiga cikin sabbin sojoji ne kawai don albashi - $ 340 a kowane wata, adadin kishi a cikin rugujewar Iraki a yau. Amma kuɗaɗen sun zo ne da ƙimar mutunta kai. An sayo sabbin ma'aikatan kuma sun ƙi kansu saboda hakan. Wani ya ce bayan sun daina dukansu, “Za mu rayu da Allah, amma za mu daraja mu.”
Mutum na iya yin mamaki ko 'yan jaridun da gangan ne ko kuma ba da saninsu ba sun ɗauki ƙungiyar tawaye ta musamman. Amma a zahiri, Sojojin Amurka ne suka zaɓi Kamfanin Charlie da kansa, mai yiwuwa yana son sanya ƙafarsa mafi kyau.
Martanin da jami'an Amurka suka yi game da ƴan ta'addar da suka yi aiki baƙar fata wani yanki ne tare da duk ƙoƙarin Amurkawa a Iraki. Jami'an suna ɗaukar tuhumar su kamar, saboda wasu ɓarna na sirri, ko ta yaya ba su kai ga aikin da aka ba su ba. Bayan wani lamari na yau da kullun wanda aka kai wa sashin hari kuma aka gudu (tasisin tasi hudu da aka yaba don tserewa), Sgt. Rick McGovern, wanda ke jagorantar rukunin, ya yi musu sutura. "Dukkan ku matsorata ne," in ji shi. Ya ci gaba da cewa, “Sojojina sun zo nan, ba su da iyalanmu tsawon shekara guda. Muna shirye mu mutu domin ku sami 'yanci. Ya kamata ku kasance a shirye ku mutu don 'yancin kanku." Harsuna sun zaci cewa Iraqi da Amurka sun yi tarayya da wani dalili wanda, kamar yadda labarin ya nuna, a zahiri an rasa kashi 100 cikin XNUMX. Mutanen Iraqi da ke kyamar mamayar Amurka ba matsorata ba ne idan suka ki harbe wasu mazan da ke yaki da mamayar. Akasin haka, gwargwadon ƙarfin da suke da shi, ba za su taɓa yin irin wannan yaƙin ba. Lallai mutanen Kamfanin Charlie ba su da ƙarfin hali - ƙarfin hali don yin watsi da kuɗin da suka karɓa don yin riya don yin yaƙi don wani abin da suka raina. Mafi girman lokacinsu, da aka ba da imaninsu, shine lokacin da suka zauna cak yayin da Sajan McGovern ya kira su matsorata. Wani soja, Amar Mana, ya bayyana halin da ake ciki a fili: "Ba ma son daukar alhakin," in ji shi. "Yadda lamarin yake, ba za mu kasance a shirye mu dauki alhakin shekaru dubu ba."
Don haka Amurkawa da Irakin na Kamfanin Charlie, kamar Amurka da Iraki gabaɗaya a yau, zaɓaɓɓu ne a gefe guda kuma ta hanyar cin hanci da tilastawa a ɗaya bangaren, suna taka rawa a cikin rubutun da ba shi da komai ko kaɗan. dangane da halin da suke ciki a zahiri, a cikin wannan yanayi, ba lallai ba ne a yi jimla gabaɗaya don yin ƙarya. Amfani da kalmomi ko jimloli guda ɗaya - "Masarautar Iraqi," "'yanci," "zaɓe," "tsaro," "dimokuradiyya," " dakarun anti-Iraki," har ma "ƙarfin zuciya" da "tsorata" - shigar da mai magana cikin yaudara, domin su ne tushen tsarin tunani da imani wanda shi kansa kage ne.
Mamaya da Amurka ta yi wa Iraki wani sabon abu ne, amma babban kuskuren Amurka yana da dogon tarihi. Shi ne daure tunanin dan Adam a cikin akida mai goyon bayan tashin hankali. Misalin al'ada shine Stalin's Rasha, wanda shekarun da suka gabata na rashin mulki aka yi amfani da su azaman "mataki" kan hanyar zuwa makomar kwaminisanci ta gaskiya. Amma ga bakin ciki da ake ciki, an yi masa lakabi da “kwaminisanci na gaske.” Nan gaba, lokacin da ya zo, ba shakka ba kwaminisanci ba ne, amma rugujewar kasuwancin gaba ɗaya. Duk "matakan" sun juya zuwa jagora babu inda.
Da zarar hankali ya kasance a cikin irin wannan tsarin, kowane "hakikanin da ya kasance" tsoro za a iya gani a matsayin ajizanci kawai a cikin kyakkyawan hoto mai girma, kowane cin nasara mataki a kan hanyar zuwa makoma mai daraja. Mafi sauƙi kuma mafi daidaituwar akida, mafi kyawun iya jure harin gaskiya. Don haka a yau a Iraki, kowane nau'i na azabtarwa, kowane birni maras kyau, kowane magudanar ruwa, kowane harin bama-bamai da fille kan kai, ana gabatar da shi a matsayin wani turba a kan hanyar "'yanci" ga Iraki, ko kuma ga Gabas ta Tsakiya, ko ma ga 'yan tawaye. duk duniya, wanda Shugabanmu ya yi alkawarin kawo karshen zalunci. (A bayyane yake ka'idar akida ce cewa mafi munin gaskiya, mafi girman girman abin da burin ƙarshe ya kasance.)
Amma wani lokaci ya zo - watakila ya zama faduwa kwatsam, ko watakila kawai karanta labari ne kamar na Shadid da Fainaru - lokacin da tunanin ya wargaje, sannan a bar mutum fuska da fuska tare da gaskiyar gaskiyar. Duk "bangare" sun zama doka. Lokacin da hakan ya faru dangane da Iraki, za a kawo karshen mummunar ta'asar da Amurka ta yi a can - wacce ta haifar da karya, ta hanyar karya da samar da karin karairayi a duk ranar da ta ci gaba.
Haƙƙin mallaka 2005 Jonathan Schell
Jonathan Schell, marubuci of Duniyar da ba ta da nasara, shine Harold Willens Peace Fellow na Cibiyar Kasa. Jonathan Schell Reader Littafin Nation ya buga kwanan nan.
[Wannan labarin zai bayyana a fitowar mai zuwa na Mujallar Kasa. Ya fara bayyana akan layi akan Tomdispatch.com, wani gidan yanar gizo na Cibiyar Nation, wanda ke ba da ci gaba ta hanyoyi daban-daban, labarai, da ra'ayi daga Tom Engelhardt, editan dogon lokaci a cikin bugawa kuma marubucin Ƙarshen Nasara Al'adu da kuma Kwanakin Karshen Bugawa.]
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi