Nothing better illustrates the political bankruptcy of the Democratic Partyāfor all progressive intents and purposesāthan California State Assembly Speaker Anthony Rendonās announcement on Friday afternoon that he was going to put a āholdā on the single-payer health care bill (SB 562) for the state, effectively killing its passage for at least the year.
The Democratic Party finds itself in a bind in California. They hold the governorship and a supermajority in both houses of the legislature, so they can pass any bill they want. SB 562 had passed the Senate 23-14.
There was enormous enthusiasm among California progressive activists, who, with organizations like Campaign for a Healthy California (CHC,) andĀ the National Nurses United (NNU,) and the California Nurses Association (CNA) were working tirelessly, and hopeful of success.Ā After all, Bernieās people were taking over the California party from the bottom since the election. I recall a night of drinking last year with an old friend who has been spearheading that effort, as he rebuffed my skepticism, and insisted that this time there would be a really progressive takeover of the California party, and single-payer would prove it. After all, once enough progressive pressure was been put on the legislators, the bill would be going to super-progressive Democratic Governor, Jerry Brown, who had made advocacy of single-payer a centerpiece of his run for President in 1992, saying: āWe treat health care not as a commodity to be played with for profit but rather the right of every American citizen when theyāre born.ā Bernie foretold.
Unfortunately, today that Governor is, according to Paul Song, co-chair of the CHC, ādoing everything he can to make sure this never gets on his desk.ā And it wonāt. Unfortunately, all the Democrats like Rendon, who āclaims to be a personal supporter of single-payer,ā will make sure that their most progressive governor is not put in the embarrassing position of having to reject what heās been ostensibly arguing for for twenty-five years, of demonstrating so blatantly what a fraud his, and his partyās, progressive pretensions are.
Thus unfolds the typical Democratic strategy: Make all kinds of progressive noises and cast all kinds of progressive votes, while carefully managing the process so that the legislation the putatively progressives putatively support never gets enacted. Usually, they blame Republican obstructionism, and there certainly is enough of that, and where there is, it provides a convenient way for Democrat legislator to āsupportā legislation they know will be blocked and wouldnāt really enact themselves if they could.
In the California case, the dissembling is obvious. The Republicans canāt be blamed. The only thing standing in the way of single-payer in California is the Democratic Party. As it was on the national level in 2009, when Obama and the Democrats could have passed any healthcare bill they wanted, just as they passed the Republican-inspired, gift to the for-profit health insurance industry, the ACAāwithout a single Republican vote. It was true-believing capitalist Democrats like Max Baucus, led by Obama and his sidekick Rahm Emanuel (who called leftists āfucking retardedā) who arrested single-payer activists (including doctors) in order to prevent single-payer from even being considered. It was they who strong-armed reluctant Democratic legislators, who had signed an oath not to do so, into passing a bill that leaves 28 million Americans without health insurance, and forces the rest into plans whose premiums rise and networks of coverage shrink every year.
In fact, the perfectly reasonable discontent with that plan probably had more to do with helping Trump win than did any actions of bad-old (as opposed to good-new) James Comey. As Marcy Wheeler pointed out, in a analysis thatās contested but should certainly not be ignored, Hillaryās fatal slide in the polls began before Comeyās notorious letter of October 28th, and coincided with the announcement, four days before, of steep Obamacare premium increases. You decide whether you think Anthony Weinerās sexting emails, part three, had more effect on voters than anger over being hit with stiff premium increases (22% average, 25% in 20 states, 60% in some) on increasingly crappy policies:
So the Democrats create the ground for Trump by passing a lousy healthcare law thatās sure to piss people off rather quickly, then use the even worse plan that the Republicans come up with to do nothing but trash Trump, while blocking real progressivesā attempts to get the only plan that would actually cover all Americans and save money. In Colorado last November, Democratic Governor John Hickenlooper refused to support a single-payer referendum because he ādidnāt want to disruptā the āstrides [made] under Obamacare.ā The Democratsā ACA marched the nation straight into the shoals of Trump and the Republicansā ACHA, and now the Democrats are blocking the only plan that solves the problems of both.
As Deborah Burger, Co-President of the California Nurses Association put it, Assembly Speaker Rendon, āActing in secret in the interests of the profiteering insurance companies late Friday afternoon abandons all those people already threatened by Congress and the Trump administration.ā
The excuse, of course, from California Democrats and Governor Jerry Brown is that they donāt know how they are going to pay for it, especially on the state level. That would be the same Jerry Brown who explained in 1992 exactly how single-payer would cut costs:
You cut out all the private health insurance. You have one single payer either at the national level or through the 50 states. And that one single payer will be the one that negotiates with the doctors, the hospitals, and the other providers. And since you have only one source of income in the whole medical establishment, you can drive down the cost.
Leaving aside the indispensable point that healthcare, like education and clean water, should be considered a non-discretionary expense, one of the main advantages of single-payer is precisely that itās the only plan that can cut costs significantly. Not having single-payer will not mean healthcare will cost less; it will cost more every year, for every person and in the aggregate. It just means the for-profit insurance and pharmaceutical companies wonāt care. The real problem with single-payer isnāt about costs to the people or to the state; itās about profits for those companies.
Besides, an economy the size of California has immense power. Weāre not talking about Utah. All the hospitals and doctors and pharmaceutical companies are not going to stop selling their goods and services in California. And once single-payer becomes a reality in California, it will catalyze a movement in every other state and on the national level. Thatāthe fact that it will start a wildfire of imitationāand not the fact that itās too expensive, is what the California Democratic Party is desperate to avoid, and what its donors and lobbyists are ordering it to block.
This is the Democratic Party. Lying losers who will do anything to avoid taking an effective stance for a healthcare policy that would immediately solve one of the worst horrors American families face every day, that would be immediately and concretely helpful to everyone, and, to top it all off, would be immensely popular. The dissembling Democrats are throwing away just about the most popular policy anyone could imagineāsomething people are literally dying for. As Charles Idelson, spokesman for the NNU, says: āThere is broad support for single-payer not only in California, but nationally, even among registered Republicans and Republican and conservative business leaders.ā
Passing single-payer in California and fighting for it everywhere else would guarantee the Democrats electoral victories. But they will not do itātheyāll say they will, butĀ they will notābecause they are fervent supporters of the capitalist market system in healthcare (and everything else), and they are corrupt agents of the health insurance and pharma industries.
Because it captures and cages the energies of so many well-meaning progressives, the Democratic Party is the most effective obstacle to, and enemy of, single-payer, and it has to be fought. People in wheelchairs and cancer patients and all their healthy friends should be sitting in and obstructing Democrat Rendonās, as well as any Republicanās, office, until he lets the bill through. Then they should move on to the Democratic governorās office. And thence to Pelosiās and Schumerās offices as well as Grahamās and Ryanās. This is not a Trump problem, and not a Republican problem, itās a bipartisan capitalist elite problem.
We have to engage in this kind of fight against all of these politicians. Anyone who thinks such a fight can be avoided in order to play the Democratsā game of defending the for-profit insurance plan called Obamacare while obsessing about Trump being a Russian spy, is helping to perpetuate this rotten healthcare system. Twenty-eight million people are now without healthcare, and, if the Republicansā edited version of Obamacare passes (which it probably wonāt, because even many Republicans know they canāt get away with making things worse than they are), thereāll be twenty-four million more. There is no time for either of these contemptuous parties and their contemptuous bullshit.
ZNetwork is funded solely through the generosity of its readers.
Donate
1 Comment
Every word in this excellent article is true. But even if Single Payer is somehow passed in Caly, it runs into some pretty big obstacles:
1) About 2/3 of healthcare spending is federal dollars. Caly will have to have a strong political will to use its massive economic leverage to force the feds to pay up;
2) The right (including Dems) will tie up Single Payer in federal courts over myriad issues, one of which is the interstate commerce clause. It’s not like the right is going to lay down and die even if the law is passed.
So does this mean the fight in Caly should be abandoned? Of course not. It will raise consciousness nationally, catalyze organizing nationally and demonstrate that Single Payer can only be won on a national level.
Healthcare is a human and civil right after all. Single Payer health insurance is part of a process to achieve that right.