Danny Schechter
In
less than two months, on October 1st, the People’s Republic of China turns
fifty. Mao’s long march liberated a country which in a half century has gone
from championing world revolution to building "socialism with Chinese
characteristics." For many, that means turning the Great Wall into the
Great Mall, the biggest market in the world where radical slogans still co-exist
alongside admonitions like "to get rich is glorious." Forbes, the
self-styled "capitalist tool" now promotes itself with ads in a style
harkening back to the cultural revolution. But this time, the masses waving red
books have big dollar signs plastered over them.
From
the outside, China seems orderly and organized, dominated from above by its old
style party apparatus while modernizing its economy from below along market
principles. Inside, the country is seething with major economic dislocations,
inefficient industries, serious unemployment and growing social unrest.
Oddly
enough, in the last week, New York’s Central Park has played host to three
separate and distinct dissident streams that are riling the bureaucrats in
Beijing. They offer a window into serious schisms and contradictions within one
of the most important, if most poorly covered major countries in the world.
The
most visible of these was the visit of Tibet’s Dalai Lama, who drew 40,000
people to the Park’s East Meadow August 15th to hear a lecture about inner
values, compassion, peaceful change and interestingly economic inequality in the
United States. While His Holiness, as he’s known, only one made one veiled
reference to China, the Chinese officially denounced his visit. They see him as
a "splittist" and insist that China, which was independent before
being "liberated" by the Red Army, is the only legitimate ruler of
Tibet. The Dalai Lama heads an India based government in exile which insists
otherwise. For forty years, he’s sough to return to his homeland but the Chinese
are unwilling to negotiate. It was partially official fears of a Kosovo style
NATO "war for human rights" in Tibet that galvinized the fierce wave
of protests in China that followed the bombing of Beijing’s Embassy in Belgrade.
China
worries about Western intervention, and in recent weeks has been talking tough,
even threatening military intervention of its own in Taiwan which appears to
want to be recognized a separate state, not part of China. On Tibet, even as the
Dalai Lama’s popularity mushrooms, China is sounding more defensive about its
posture although no less strident in its claim to sovereignty. When I was in
China two years ago, I heard about a TV producer who was fired when an image of
the Dalai Lama inadvertently was shown in a documentary. The producer insisted
he didn’t know what the Dalai Lama looked like–since his image is banned in the
same way that South Africa forbid the publication of any image of Nelson Mandela
for years. It didn’t matter. He was fired anyway.
There’s
a new force oin the scene which also turned up in the park that same Sunday
morning, in the shadow of the Joseph Papp Shakespeare Theater. It was a mixed
group of Chinese and Americans doing graceful physical exercises and
meditations. They are pursuing a spiritual practice called Falun Gong or Falun
Dafa, which claims 70 million adherents in China and thirty million worldwide,
including inside the United States. In the last month China has outlawed Falun
Gong, which is based on traditional chigong exercises that draw hundreds of
thousand of Chinese to local parks each morning for an exercise regimen.
Pointing
to the sudden unexpected silent assembly of ten thousand Falun Gong
practitioners outside the compound housing the Chinese leadership in Beijing
last April, China’s President Jiang Zemin is now trying to crush what he is
calling a dangerous cult. He accuses Falun Gong and its founder Li Hongzhi, now
in the US, of trying to overthrow the government. As a result, its practitioners
are being jailed and its books and videos burned as part of a government ordered
campaign against "superstition." China has branded Falun Gong a sect,
even comparing Li to the late David Koresh of Waco Texas "fame," and
is demands his arrest.
Falun
Gong counters that it is not-political, not a sect or even an organization and
has no such agenda. Clearly the Chinese freaked out by having so many of its
citizens, including Party members, loyal to an independent spiritual practice.
Perhaps because of its uniquely Chinese character, the repression of Falun Gong
has only triggered a mild response from the US human rights community, U.S.
government and press. It seems as if op-ed pundits are more distressed by long
sentences handed out to a handful of pro-democracy activists than the hundreds
of thousands of Falun Gong practitioners who seem more a more like a cross
section of the ordinary Chinese population.
A
week earlier, as part of Central Park’s showcase of world music, an even more
prominent if unofficial Chinese figure was on hand: Cui Jian, (pronounced
"Sway-Jen") China’s legendary rock and roller. He was in the United
States on the kind of tour he still has trouble mounting in China where rock and
roll is viewed with suspicion. Cui Jian was one of the voices that inspired
Chinese youth in period leading up to Tianamen Square. He is China’s Bruce
Springsteen (or is Springsteen, America’s Cui Jian?) a hard rocker who is also
introducing rap to his many fans among the youth. His new album is called
"The Power of the Powerless" (World beat records) and is hard charging
but also reflecting the disillusion of his generation: He sings of those who
just want to make money labeling them "Slackers:"
The
new age is here, no one is making trouble anymore You say everyone’s ideals have
been washed away by the times Watch TV, listen to the radio, read the paper You
say the conflict of ideals is no more.
Clearly
there still is a conflict of ideals, and over politics in China–a conflict
which is spilling over into the United States.
You
can see it continuing fight over Tibet, in the overreaction of the Chinese
government towards Falun Gong, as well as in the many Falun Gong practitioners
who are seeking something in their lives that the often empty struggle rhetoric
of the Party no long gives them. As we learned in the 60’s , there is nothing
like the whack of a policeman’s club on the head to politicize the
non-political. Cui Jian told me that while he doesn’t like Falun Gong, he
worries that the government is going overboard in a counter productive way.
Cui
Jian’s music gives you a taste of the struggle that is yet to come in China. He
closed his bi-lingual show by leading the audience in a sing along of an old Red
Army song from the wars for China’s independence, playing to the pride,
patriotism and power of the new generation that will be remaking China in the
next fifty years.
If
the 20th Century was, in Henry Luce’s phrase, the "American Century."
the 21’st is likely to be the century of China. Its a country and culture we
need to know more about. Which way it goes will effect the rest of the world.
The Chinese government is determined not to emulate the devastating decline of
the former Soviet Union. In that respect, as well as because of a need to feed
over a billion people, its emphasis on preserving stability is understandable.
But pressures for more freedom and less authoritarianism are also building.
I
know. I saw them all working out in Central Park.
Danny
Schechter, executive Producer of Globalvision and the Executive editor of the
soon to be launched internet supersite; "The Media Channel." He is
the author of the forthcoming "News Dissector: Passions, Pieces and
Polemics" (l999) (www.electronpress.com)