Iyo hashtag #TalibanTrump akatanga kutenderera kupera kwesvondo, mushure mekunge Donald Trump aita zvisinganzwisisike uye zvekubvuma kuruzhinji paTwitter:
Zvisingazive kumunhu wese, vatungamiriri vakuru veTaliban uye, zvakasiyana, Mutungamiriri weAfghanistan, vaizosangana neni muchivande kuCamp David neSvondo. Vanga vachiuya kuUnited States manheru ano. Nehurombo, kuti vavake manyepo enhema, vakabvuma ku..
Mutungamiri weUnited States akange aronga kutambira maTaliban paivhu reUS, mazuva matatu kusati kwasvika zuva rekurangarira kurwiswa kwa9/11. Ungatotanga kufungidzira kuita kubva kurudyi dai Barack Obama akaita chiziviso chakafanana?
Kujeka: Kukoka anosemesa Taliban kuCamp David, kwenzvimbo dzese, kumusangano wega nemutungamiri weUS, kwete chete pamberi pechibvumirano cherunyararo chakapedzwa asiwo manheru emhemberero ye9/11, yaive mbeveve uye. pfungwa inogumbura. Nekudaro, kuita nhaurirano neTaliban kuyedza uye kupedza gakava reAfghan - sezvanga zvichiitwa nekutonga kwaTrump kwegore rapfuura muQatar, kusanganisira. misangano mipfumbamwe yakasiyana inotungamirwa nemumiriri weAmerica mumiriri Zalmay Khalilzad - haina mbeveve kana kugumbura. Icho chinhu chaifanira kunge chakaedzwa naGeorge W. Bush manejimendi kumashure muna 2002 kana 2003.
Hondo muAfghanistan, rangarira, yave iri ngwavaira huru. Inogona kunge yadonha kubva pamisoro yenyaya muno muUnited States, asi ichine musoro weiyo kurwisana kwenguva refu munhoroondo yeAmerica. Sezvo iyo Cato Institute yaDoug Bandow ine Ratidza, hondo yeAfghan yakatora โnguva yakareba kupfuura Hondo Yenyika, Hondo yeSpain neAmerica, Hondo Yenyika I, Hondo Yenyika II, uye Hondo yeKorea dzabatanidzwa.โ
Kunetsana uku kwakakanganwa kwakadhura mutero weU.S inenge $1 trillion uye zvakakonzera kufa kwe Kupfuura 2,400 Vashandi vemauto eUS - pamwe chete makumi ezviuru yevasina kudomwa nemazita, vasina mhosva vagari veAfghan. "Tave pedyo nezuva ratichamuka tichinzwa nhau dzemunhu akakuvara muAfghanistan asina kuzvarwa musi wa9/11," Democrat Pete Buttigieg, iye pachake akaendeswa kuAfghanistan muna 2014, akati pagakava remutungamiri weCNN muna Chikunguru.
Saka Trump, asati ave mutungamiri wenyika, aive chokwadi paakazivisa Afghanistan kuve "messUye "njodzi yakakwana. "
Uye akanga akarurama, pakutora chigaro, kuva nacho hurukuro dzerunyararo dzakabvumidzwa neTaliban (zvisinei vachishora nehasha Obama nekuyedza kuita zvimwe chete muna 2012). Vakasununguka vanoshora VaTrump nehutsinye nekuyedza kuita chibvumirano neboka revapanduki vechiIslam vanofanirwa kutsanangura kuti vanoronga sei kupedza kurwa vasingayedze kuita zvimwe chetezvo. ("Pane imwe nguva," tweeted Nyanzvi yezvematongerwo enyika Paul Musgrave nemusi weSvondo, "US ichafanirwa kusvika pachibvumirano neTaliban, kubvuma kukundwa, kuenda kuhondo, kana kuita hondo chaiyo yekusingaperi.")
Zvakadaro vhiki ino yeTwitter antics humwe humbowo hwekuti anonzi munyori ye "Iyo Art of the Deal" haikwanise kuita iyi dhiri. Sei? Nhamba yekutanga, se CNN yakashuma, "Sarudzo yekukoka vatungamiriri veTaliban neMutungamiriri weAfghan Ashraf Ghani kuCamp David yakaitwa svondo rapfuura. ... Trump akaudza timu yake kuti angave ari nani kuti aite nhaurirano iye pachake. " Zvechokwadi, akanyengedzwa. North Korea ndiye a stark chiyeuchidzo nezvezvinoitika kana VaTrump vapinda pachezvake mukudyidzana nedzimwe nyika.
Teerera kuna Barnett Rubin, nyanzvi yekukonana uye aimbove chipangamazano mukuru kuUS Special Representative yeAfghanistan nePakistan, anofunga kuti izvi zvese zvaive pamusoro pehumwe hwaTrump kwete ramangwana reAfghanistan. "Aida foto op uye yepamusoro-yepamusoro-yeTV show," Rubin tweeted neSvondo, โuye pazvisina kushanda, akakanzura.โ
Nhamba yechipiri: Trump haina chitendero chakasimba kana misimboti, uye haina kunzwisisa chero yezvekunze mutemo kana mauto zano. Saka anonyengetedzwa zviri nyore neavo vakamukomberedza - uye avo vakamukomberedza vanowanzoita semhashu. Anga ari Lt Gen. HR McMaster, chipangamazano chaTrump-chenyika chezvekuchengetedzwa kwenyika, uyo akakurudzira mutungamiri akazeza kutumira mamwe mauto kuAfghanistan muna 2017, mushure mekumuratidza mufananidzo wa1972 wevakadzi veAfghan vakapfeka miniskirt sehumbowo hwekuti Western mores inogona kudzoserwa mukati. iyo nyika (Handikufiri).
Uye iyi sarudzo yazvino yekukoka (uye kuzobvisa) maTaliban kuCamp David, uye vobva vadhonza plug panhaurirano pabhodhi, zvimwe zvakakonzerwa neuber-hawk John Bolton, chipangamazano chaTrump chezvekuchengetedzwa kwenyika, achizevezera munzeve dzake.
Kune vanofarira zveBolton naMcMaster, Afghanistan ndeye "hondo yekusingaperi.โ Ndeipi imwe nzira, ivo vanobvunza? Kucheka uye kumhanya? Kusiya vanhu veAfghan kuti vadzvinyirirwa kana kuurayiwa mumaoko eTaliban? Kubvumira Afghanistan kuti ive nzvimbo yakachengeteka yemagandanga zvakare?
Hungave, hupenzi, kunyepedzera kuti kune mhinduro yakanaka kune mhirizhonga muAfghanistan, nyika ine urombo yakakamurwa pamadzinza, madzinza, uye ezvitendero, yakarwiwa neboka revekunze, uye yatambudzwa nechisimba. kweanopfuura makore makumi mana.
Hapana. Asi hezvino izvo zvisingaudzwe nemhashu: Vagari veAfghan vari kutofa nenhamba huru, kwete chete kunyangwe kuvepo kwemauto eUS - 2018 yakaona kufa kwevanhu veAfghan kwakarova. rekodha zvakakwira - asi nekuda kwavo, zvakare. Vangani vanhu vekuAmerica vanoziva nezve chokwadi chekuti mumwedzi mitanhatu yekutanga yegore rino, hurumende yeAfghan nevamiriri vayo vanotungamirwa neUS vakaurayiwa. vanhuwo zvavo vakawanda kupfuura veTaliban? Izvozvo hazvifaniri kutivhundutsa tose here?
Kana iri yekuedza kuramba magandanga nzvimbo yakachengeteka, kana 100,000 mauto eUS Hatina kukwanisa kukunda maTaliban pakukwirira kwekuvhiya kwakarairwa naObama muna 2011, nei tichifanira kutenda kuti kutumirwa kwazvino 14,000 US mauto inogona kuwana chero rudzi rwekukunda muna 2019 kana 2020?
Kuti tirege kukanganwa, maTaliban izvozvi anotonga "inenge hafu yeAfghanistan.โ Kune vanosvika mazana maviri nemakumi mana evarwi veAl Qaeda pasi muAfghanistan, maererano neU.N. Security Council. Zvichakadaro, nyanzvi yehugandanga yeGeorgetown University Bruce Hoffman anoti inokwira ISIS yakaisa mari "huwandu husina kuenzana hwekutarisisa uye zviwanikwa muAfghanistan," nepo Pentagon ichiti boka rejihadi rinoisa "kutyisidzira kukuruโ kunyika.
Vhiki rapfuura, Khalilzad aikurudzira kuti chibvumirano chaitwa: "Pamusoro pezvo, tasvika." Mukudzoka kwekubviswa kweUS kwechikamu, Zvinonzi Reuters, "veTaliban vaizozvipira kusatendera Afghanistan kushandiswa ne ... al Qaeda kana Islamic State senzvimbo yekurwiswa."
Zvakadaro, neMugovera, mutungamiri wenyika akazivisa kuti akanzura musangano weCamp David uye "kumisa nhaurirano dzerunyararo." Uku kupenga. Trump pachake, asati apinda muWhite House, akashora hondo yeAfghanistan se ".tsvina yakakwanaโ ndokubvunza kuti โkukurumidza kubvisa.โ Iye zvino anoenda kuTwitter ku dzinga mukana wekusaina "chibvumirano chine musoro" neTaliban uye kubvunza uyu mubvunzo wakajeka: "Mangani mamwe makumi emakore avanoda kurwa?"
Mhinduro? Makumi emakore akawanda kupfuura vazhinji veAmerica.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta