Zvinyorwa zviviri izvi zvakanyorwa muna Ndira naKukadzi 2014 - kusati kwadonha kwehutongi hwaViktor Yanukovich uye zviitiko zvakazotevera - uye zvakangoshandurirwa muchiRungu. Dzinoburitswa pa Links International Journal yeSocialist Renewal sezvavanopa nzwisiso mukufunga kwechikamu chakakosha cheshanduko yakasara muRussia.
A quadrille yezvikara
NaBoris Kagarlitsky, Moscow; rakaturikirwa na Renfrey Clarke
Ndira 21, 2014 - Zviitiko zviri kuitika muKiev zvinopa vanhu vazhinji kumativi ese emuganhu weRussia-Ukrainian nedambudziko risingafadzi. Kana tikarasa kubvutwa kwemanzwiro pamusoro pe "revolution" ichangoburwa (yangani iyi ikozvino?) munharaunda yedu yakavakidzana, pamwe neparanoia yevadziviriri veRussia vanonamata chero masimba anoshanda uye vane kutya kwekutya kwechero shanduko, zvino nhaurirano yacho yose inokwira kusvika pakusarudza pakati pezvakaipa zviviri.
Kune rimwe divi kune huwori, hutongi husina basa hwemutungamiri weUkraine, Viktor Yanukovich, uhwo huri kuwedzera hutongi zuva nezuva. Kune rimwe divi kune vezvematongerwo enyika uye vane kodzero dzepamusoro, vane chisimba uye vane hasha, vasina huwori hushoma, uye vasina nzira yakafanana nemademokrasi maererano nekunzwisisa kupi kweshoko.
Vazhinji vevanhu, avo pakutanga vakanzwira tsitsi kuratidzira, vava kuyedza kuti varambe vari kure nevarwi vemarudzi, kwete zvakanyanya kubva pakufunga nezvepfungwa sechikonzero chakareruka chekuti kuramba uchishamwaridzana nevanhu vakadai kudzinga uye kwete pasina njodzi.
Mativi ese ari maviri, sokunge nemaune, ari kuita zvese zvaanogona kuti abvise rutsigiro rwevanhu vane njere uye vane moyo wakanaka. Zvakakwana kuti rimwe divi riite hupenzi kana kudenha, uye rimwe rinobva rawana nzira yekupfuura vadzivisi varo mumakwikwi aya.
Kuparadzwa kwakaitwa nevenyika muKiev kwechiyeuchidzo chaLenin kwakamutsa hasha dzevagari, vazhinji vavo vasinganzwi tsitsi chero nezvemakomunisti. Asi zvaive zvakakwana kuti pendulum yekunzwira tsitsi kwevanhu kuzununguka zvishoma mukutungamira kwezviremera kune vatsigiri veYanukovich kuti vaunze muSupreme Rada pakiti yese yemutemo unopesana nedemocracy, iyo inogona kunge yakabatanidzwa nemaune kuti ave nechokwadi chekuti mauto emagariro. kusavimba neIndependence Square vaizotora chikamu mukuratidzira.
Zvichakadaro vanopikisa, kusimudza racket yakakura pazvibodzwa izvi uye nehunyanzvi hwekugona kuvhiringidza kuvhota nekuda kwechimwe chikonzero hazviiti chero zvakakosha muparamende. Zvichida izvi ndezvekusakwanisa uye kusanzwisisa, asi zvinogonawo kuva chikonzero chekuti inotarisira kushandisa matanho ekudzvinyirira kune vanopikisa kana pane kuchinja kwehurumende.
Zviremera kana vanopikisa havafariri tsigiro yeruzhinji rwevanhu, uye zvinotonyanya kukosha, hapana divi rine chirongwa chinoripa tarisiro yekukunda rutsigiro urwu uye kuvaka hwaro hwakakura hwemagariro. Dambudziko harisi chete uye kwete zvakanyanya mukuzivikanwa kwakashata kwekumabvazuva nekumavirira muUkraine, sekunge pasina chero kuedza kwekuita chirongwa chesocial-economic chine chinangwa chekubatanidza nzanga, kuvandudza mamiriro ehupenyu, kuderedza kushaikwa kwemabasa nekusimudzira. hupfumi.
Iwo mamonsters ari kurwira masimba mudhorobha reUkraine anogara achichinja nzvimbo, sevanodyidzana mukutamba. Vese izvozvi vakapedza nguva vari musimba, kana zvisiri panyika zvino padanho renzvimbo. Vose, kusanganisira neo-fascists kubva mubato re "Svoboda", vakakwanisa kubatwa nekunyengera. Vose vanoratidza kutsunga kwakafanana kudzivirira nekuchengetedza hurongwa huripo hwemagariro evanhu, avo vane dambudziko riri pachena.
Nekudaro zviitiko zvino zvave kuitika, zvinogona kutaurwa kuti chaiyo yeUkraine modhi yedemocracy, yakavakirwa pakuenzanisa pakati pemaoligarchic blocs maviri, iri kusvika kumagumo. Chero boka ripi richakunda muKiev, richakwanisa kubatirira pamasimba chete nekumisa hutongi hune hutsinye. Mumamiriro ezvinhu aya, mubvunzo wekuti ndiani anofanirwa kutorwa semudiki uye ndiani uipi hukuru hunorerutswa zvakanyanya. "Kuipa kukuru" kuchava boka rinowana kukunda. Zvichakadaro, isu tichakwanisa nekururamisa kwakakwana kudoma boka rinoenda pasi kuti rikunde se "zvishoma zvakaipa", sezvo kusiyana nemukundi, hazvizobudiriri pakuona kugona kwayo kwekuparadza.
Izvi zvinoreva here kuti nzvimbo yeUkraine haina tariro, uye njodzi iyi haidzivisiki? Kuita mhedziso isina tariro zvakadaro kungangove kusati kwasvika. Kukunda kwerimwe divi kunovimbisa dambudziko guru, asi sezvakaitika kare zvezvematongerwo enyika zveUkraine, zviitiko zvenguva pfupi yapfuura zvinoratidza kuti mapoka ari kurwisana anokwanisa kungovhara nzira yeumwe neumwe. Kana zviremera kana vapikisi vavo vakakwanisa kukunda zvisina tsarukano mukukonana kwazvino, nyika ichatarisana nenguva isina kugadzikana, zvichida mhirizhonga yezvematongerwo enyika. Asi izvi zvingava nani kuti kukunda kwakasimba nerimwe remapoka, izvo zvinozoisa hudzvanyiriri hwayo.
Pasi pemamiriro ezvinhu ekusagadzikana kwenguva refu, mukana uchaonekwa wekuunganidzwa kwemasimba matsva evanhu anodaidzira kuvandudzwa kwechokwadi kwehurumende nemagariro evanhu. Zvakafanana nejee rinonyatsozivikanwa pamusoro peVachena, Reds uye "Greens" avo vakarwa nguva dzose musango, kusvikira muchengeti wemasango auya ndokuvadzinga vose. Mubvunzo uri pakuti sei, uye nokukurumidza sei, nzanga yeUkraine ichakwanisa kubereka "sango" iri, uye ndeipi basa rekuita izvi richaitwa nemasangano ekuruboshwe, ayo akafara kugara padivi pemazuva ano. hondo yezvikara zvezvematongerwo enyika.
Kuramba kukweverwa muiyi rwisano, zvisinei, hakurevi kurega kurwisana. Passivity haina kumbobvira yave nzira yekubudirira, kunyangwe kutora chikamu pasina kufunga mune zviito zvevatorwa mauto anoramba ari vimbiso yekutadza. Mauto anonangidzira shanduko yedemocracy zvechokwadi anoronga uye oita akazvimirira, achiisa pamberi pezvavanoda. Izvi zvave kutoitika, semuenzaniso mukuramwa kwevadzidzi veKiev-Mogilyansky Academy vari kuda kubviswa kwemitemo inopesana nedemocratic Yanukovich, asi vasiri kubatana nevarwi vekupedzisira-kurudyi paIndependence Square. Zvichida ichi chingori chimwe chinhu chemunharaunda uye episodic, kupesana nekusingafadzi kusimba kwese. Kunyange zvakadaro, inopa tariro yeramangwana.
Ukraine: Kupwanya chidyiro chekudya
NaBoris Kagarlitsky, Moscow; rakaturikirwa na Renfrey Clarke
Kukadzi 3, 2014 - Dambudziko rakamuka muUkraine, rinosanganisira makwikwi pakati pehurumende inopokana iyo iri kuwedzera kuve nehutongi nezuva uye nekupokana kusingaite nemaitiro echifascist zviri pachena, yakagadzira chimwe chinhu chiri pedyo nekupunzika kwehungwaru kumativi ese muganhu. Kuwanda kwemaonero kunobva pakugadzirira kutora chikamu mukuratidzira uye kuratidzira kwemhando ipi zvayo - pasinei nezvinangwa zvavo, chinangwa, mafungiro uye maonero - kudana kutsigira masimba aripo se "huipi hushoma".
MuRussia nharo idzi dzakaiswa pamusoro pehurukuro isina kukwana yakanangana nezvidzidzo zvezviitiko zve 2011-2012, kunyange zvazvo migumisiro inobatsira yekufamba panguva iyoyo iri pachena zvakakwana: zvose zvakapera mukukundikana zvachose. Mibvunzo chete ndeyokuti ruboshwe rwaigona kuita zvakasiyana nenzira yayakaita, uye kuti mauto akazogovewa sei pamusana pemugumisiro wezviitiko (zvinopesana nemamiriro ekuderera kwekuderera kwesangano, kwete vose vatori vechikamu. vakapedza kurasikirwa; vamwe, pane zvinopesana, vakasimbisa nzvimbo dzavo).
Asi sezvatinoziva, Ukraine haisi Russia. Kupesana nemaonero evakasununguka vakangwara, musiyano unoonekwa kwete mune chero rudo rukuru rwerusununguko kana rudo rwakanyanya kune chikamu chevavakidzani vedu vekumavirira, asi mukuti boka rinotonga muUkraine rinongove riine zviwanikwa zvishoma zvarinogona. Izvi zvinosarudza muenzaniso chaiwo weoligarchic democracy inowanikwa muKiev. Madzinza anotungamira ekuUkraine, akasiyana nemakambani eRussia, haakwanise kusvika pakubvumirana uye kugovera nyika kumusoro nenzira yekuti munhu wese ave nezvakakwana uye hapana zvikonzero zvekukonana pachena.
MuRussia kwaisava kuita kwehutongi hwaPutin, asi kugona kwemapoka anotonga kugutsa vatambi vese vakuru (vakawanda kana vashoma) izvo zvakabvumira kugadzikana kwemakore gumi kubva muna 2000. Kufunga kwakafanana kwakakonzera kuputika kwakangoerekana kwaitika muna 2011. , apo uku kukwanisa kwezviremera kwakaiswa mukupokana.
Zvichakadaro, mutsauko wezviwanikwa unowanikwa kumapoka anotonga enyika mbiri idzi unosarudza mamiriro emagariro zvakare. Chikonzero isu maRussia takashivirira matambudziko edu kwenguva yakareba kwete nekuti isu tisina shungu, asi nekuti mamiriro edu ari nani. Zvakadaro, kukurumidza kuwedzera kwedambudziko remagariro muna 2014 kunotyisidzira kugumisa mamiriro ezvinhu aya, kunyangwe kusvika padanho rekuti "vatambi vanochinja nzvimbo". Kana dambudziko rezvematongerwo enyika uye kuratidzira kwakavhurika kwemagariro kukabuda muRussia, zvese zvakaitika pamakwere eUkraine zvinozoita sekutamba kwemwana.
Zvakananga nekuda kwechikonzero ichi, mubvunzo we "zvidzidzo zveUkraine" wakanyatsoenderana neRussia kuruboshwe. Mubvunzo hausi wekuti vamwe vedu vari pamusoro pemuganhu wekumadokero vangakwanise kana kusakwanisa kuita sei, asi nezve mhedziso dzenguva yemberi iyo masangano akasara enyika mbiri idzi anogona kutora kubva pane zvakaitika.
Muhurongwa hukuru, zvinzvimbo zvikuru zvitatu zvinogona kusiyaniswa munhaurirano yeUkraine, paine mamwe kana mashoma akasiyana ezvematongerwo enyika masangano uye mafungu akamira kumashure kwavo.
Sezvinoita muRussia chinzvimbo chekuruboshwe chekuruboshwe chinosanganisira kukumbira kusangano kuti riuye pamwe chete, munyaya yeUkraine paIndependence Square, uye "zvisinei nekutonga ikoko kwebapiro rekurudyi", kubatana nevakuru vemarudzi uye mafascist mune pfungwa. kurwira hegemony uye "pesvedzero pamusoro peruzhinji". Iyi ndiyo mhando yekuzivisa yatinonzwa kubva kune dzimwe nhengo dze "Kuruboshwe Kupikiswa", vane zvinyorwa uye maonero anoburitswa nechido panzvimbo yeMoscow. Vhura Kuruboshwe.
Pano tinoona kuenderera kunonzwisisika kwemutsara unoteedzerwa nevakasununguka vakasununguka muRussia panguva yekuratidzira kwe2011 na2012, kungotorwa kusvika pamwero wezvisina musoro. MuRussia, hurukuro yose, pamwe chete nemaitiro aiitwa, yakatsanangurwa nekuti kuruboshwe kubva pakutanga kwaive chinhu chakakosha mukufamba kwese. Nhamba dzakakosha dzevaratidziri dzakatora hutungamiriri hwavo kubva kuruboshwe, uye vekupedzisira vakawanawo chiremera chakajeka uye pesvedzero pakati pemhomho yevaratidziri.
Kusvika padanho rakakura mikana iyi yakaregwa ichitsvedza nekuda kwechinzvimbo chakatorwa nevatungamiriri veKuruboshwe Front, asi huwandu hukuru hwevaratidziri nemasangano vakazvibvisa panguva yakanaka kubva pachinzvimbo ichi, vachiwana iyo Forum yeKuruboshwe mauto kugadzirisa voramwa kanzuru yevanopikisa. Mhedzisiro yaive yekuti semugumisiro wedambudziko ra2011 huremu hwepfungwa hwekuruboshwe munharaunda yeRussia hwakawedzera; kunyange vanhu vakanga vaita makore 20 vachiita setisipo vaisungirwa kuticherechedza. Asi isu tichatadza kutaura zvakafanana nezve mhedzisiro yezviitiko zvazvino muUkraine.
Panewo mumwe musiyano mukuru. MuRussia muna 2012 takatarisana nekunetsana pakati pevakasara uye vakasununguka vehegemony pamusoro pekuratidzira, pasi pemamiriro ezvinhu apo vezvematongerwo enyika pakati pevaratidziri vaive simba risingaite. PaIndendence Square muKiev kuruboshwe kunomanikidzwa kukwikwidzana nevenyika uye mafashist, avo ivo vasingadzore zvese nenzira ipi neipi, zvakadaro vane chinzvimbo chekuraira. Kunyange zvichikwanisika kuita nharo nevakasununguka, kutaura kune vekupedzisira-kurudyi hakuna maturo, nekuda kwekuti nhaurirano ine musoro padanho renharo uye kupokana-kupokana hazvigoneke. Chimiro chese uye tsika ye-ultra-right movement yakavakirwa pane imwe nheyo yakasiyana zvachose; hegemony mumadenderedzwa aya hairegi pazvivakwa zvedzidziso kana zvekuongorora, asi nechisimba, uko kune rimwe simba rakadaro rinofanirwa kuverengerwa.
Mumashoko akajeka, kubatana nevakasununguka, zvisinei nekukahadzika kubva pamaonero epfungwa, "chivi" chakaderera pane kubatana nechakanyanya-kurudyi. Asi mubvunzo hausi we "zvivi" zvisinganzwisisiki. Kana kosi yakadaro ikazarura kariro dzipi nedzipi nokuda kwekuruboshwe, zvaizobvira kukurukura kunyange mibatanidzwa yakanga ichishamisa zvikuru mumurangariro wedzidziso. Chiripo, kunyanguvezvo, ndechokuti hakuna kariro dzakadaro dziripo. Kuruboshwe paIndendence Square muKiev haioneki uye hainzwiki. Vashoma vakasara, chokwadi, vakamborohwa ndokudzingwa. Asi parizvino, ruboshwe haruna kukosha maererano nekuvepo kwayo uye pesvedzero zvekuti hapana anotombozvinetsa kurova nhengo dzayo. Kune chikamu chikuru, iyo yekuUkraine yakasara iripo chete mukati mekufungidzira kwayo. Izvi, zvechokwadi, hazvirevi kuti ruboshwe haruzombofi rwakaita sesimba rezvematongerwo enyika, asi mamiriro ekutanga eizvi achava kuti anoziva mamiriro chaiwo ezvinhu.
Zviripachena, vanhu vari paIndependence Square havangori vemunyika uye vateveri vaStepan Bandera. Asi hapangori niche ipapo yekuti ruboshwe rutore. Nehunyanzvi uye maererano nemamiriro ezvinhu, hapana munhu kunze kwevenyika uye Banderovists [Banderovists vaive vabatsiri veNazi vane mhosva yekuponda vanhu vazhinji] vanogona kubuda mberi. Ava ndivo chete vanhu vari kuwana "mikana iri kubuda" inokodzera magumo avo. Zvichakadaro, imwe nzira yekukunda yeIndendence Square udzvanyiriri pasi peYanukovich; muchiitiko ichi, chinzvimbo chedemocracy chingave chakaipisisa kupfuura kuratidzira kusati kwatanga.
Pakupedzisira, tarisiro ye“yananiso yenyika” inova yechokwadi zvikuru nezuva rimwe nerimwe rinopfuura. Izvi zvingasanganisira kuwirirana pakati pembavha dzeDonetsk nevepogrom-vanyanduri veLvov (iyo inonyanya mutsauko), kana kuti kupatsanurwa kweUkraine, kwete nemitsara yekumabvazuva-kumadokero asi maererano nemapurovhinzi (kwete iyo yakaipisisa mutsauko, uye zvakare zvinogoneka chaizvo).
Kana miganhu yezvinobvira ichiwedzerwa, miganhu yemamiriro ezvinhu aripo inofanira kutanga yaonekwa. Uyezve, tinofanira kunzwisisa nzvimbo yedu chaiyo. Panzvimbo yekuyera mutemo mumwe wakarurama mune abstract uchipesana neimwe shanduko yepolicy, zvakare yakarurama mune abstract, isu tinofanirwa kucherechedza zano nemaitiro emamwe masimba aripo, tichifungawo mamiriro anoshanda. Zvinyorwa nevakawanda vekuUkraine kuruboshwe vanotadza kupa chero pfungwa kune izvi. Zvakatonyanya kuipa, mukudzokorodza nhaurirano idzi, vatauri veRussia vanodzokorora zvisina tsarukano zvimwe chetezvo. Izvo hazvigoneke kuti usayeuchidze nezve yakakurumbira Plato "reflection of the reflection".
Kana masangano, mafungiro uye mabhiriji enhau asina kugadzirwa kare, hapana tarisiro yekuchinja chero chinhu kuburikidza nekuedza kuzvipinza muchirongwa chiri kutoitika isu tisina kutora chikamu. Kuruboshwe kwakakwanisa kuita rimwe basa rakazvimirira mukuratidzira kweRussia muna 2011 na2012 nekuti zvimiro, vatungamiriri, varatidziri nemasangano aivepo aizivikanwa mune mamwe madenderedzwa, uye ayo akashandisa masimba kupfuura nzvimbo dzakatetepa. Kana mabhiriji akafanana asina kugadzirwa pachine nguva, saka kupusa uye kuzvinyengedza kutarisira kuti vakarurama vanogona kuratidzwa paIndependence Square, kuti veruzhinji vanofarira kurwisana pakati pehurumende nevanopikisa vaswedere pedyo. kurutivi rworuboshwe, uye “vatungamiriri vakazvizvidza” ivavo vachasemburwa.
Kunyange mumamiriro ezvinhu akadaro, zvisinei, kusava nehanya hakusi mhinduro. Zvinonyanya kukosha kuti saiti yebato re "Borotba" yakabata kuzviitiko zvaiitika zvakaitenderedza nekuburitsa chinyorwa chakaitwa nemuzivi wemuSlovenia ane fashoni Slavoj Žižek chine musoro unoti, "Papfungwa dzenhema dzekukurumidzira", uye kurumbidza kubviswa kwepfungwa kubva munyika isingagutsikane. :
Mune mamwe mamiriro ezvinhu, nzira chete yechokwadi "inoshanda" ndeyekurwisa muedzo wekuita chiito pasina kunonoka, uye panzvimbo pacho "kugara uye kumirira", uye kuita ongororo yemurwere.
Zvinosekesa kuti muchiitiko ichi vanhu vakatendeukira kuŽižek vanga vasiri vakasiya vakashama kubva Kuvhurika Kuruboshwe kana Kuruboshwe Vanopikisa, asi vapikisi vavo vekare vekuBorotba. Iri, hongu, harisi iro dambudziko guru.
Kutaura zvazviri, maonero aŽižek ane kodzero yekuvepo. Asi zvinhu zvinogoneka uye zvinotenderwa kune mumwe munhu anofunga zvine njodzi uye hazvigoneke kusangano. Kana iyo yekupedzisira ichingogara uye kumirira, ichinyura muhunyengeri hwekuongorora kwakadzama, zvino mhedzisiro yekumirira kwayo ichava yekuti inodonha kana kushanduka kuita kirabhu yevazivi vezvigaro zvemaoko vasingakwanisi basa rinoshanda. Kutaura zvazviri, uku ndiko kutyisidzira kwakarembera pamusoro pebato reBorotba. Kuongororwa kwemamiriro ezvinhu anowanikwa panzvimbo Liva, iyo iri pedyo nepati, inonyatsogutsikana uye inonyatsokakavadzana, asi kazhinji inokundikana kupindura mubvunzo we "chii chinofanira kuitwa", kunyange pane tactical level.
Hapana chinhu chinotyisa kuramba tiri vashoma; chinotyisa kuramba usingaonekwi. Kusabvumirana uye kushoropodza kunova chokwadi chekurarama kwedu pamwe chete kana maonero edu akazivikanwa, kana zvisiri kune ruzhinji zvino kune chimwe chikamu chakakosha chenzanga. Ipapo ndipo chete apo kururamisa kwedu kunogona mukutarisa kuwana zvishoma zvazvinoreva zvematongerwo enyika.
Tichifunga nezve chokwadi chekuti mamiriro ekuruboshwe panguva ino haatenderi kukunda, chinodiwa chakanyanya kukura kuti isu tifunge uye tiite zvine hungwaru, kumisikidza mabhiriji edanho rinotevera, kuitisa kunetsa panzvimbo yedu. isu pachedu takagadzirira, kutsvaga nzvimbo nemikana yekuparadzira pfungwa dzedu nehasha, kushandisa kusasimba kwezviremera kuitira kumanikidza mapoka anotonga kugadzirisa misoro mitsva padanho renzvimbo, uye kufambisira mberi zvido zvedu. Izvi zvinogona kusanganisira zviito zviri kuitika nenzira yakafanana neIndependence Square, kunetsana nezvinetso zvemagariro evanhu, kana kutorwisana nevenyika kuitira kuti vawane nzvimbo pachikwere. Iyi nzira yekupedzisira yakatorwa nechikamu chevanarchist, vane maonero epfungwa, ari padiki, mashoma akakudziridzwa uye akasarudzika pane ayo eMarxists eBorotba. Kune vekuRussia vanosiya, vachitevera zviitiko kubva kure, nhau dzemhirizhonga pakati pevanarchist uye fascists muLvov neKharkov inogona kungoonekwa sechiedza chechiedza murima redambudziko reUkraine. Asi pano isu tinofanirwa kungwarira zvakanyanya, tichinzvenga manyepo uye pfungwa.
Purogiramu yezvematongerwo enyika yevanarchists ishoma. Havana zano. Maitiro avo anogona kuderedzwa kuita mafomula ari nyore kwazvo, kunyangwe achifanira kuzivikanwa, anoshanda:
Mugore rapfuura takaisa nhamburiko dzakanyanya mukusimudzira simba rinoshamisa rebato reKharkov. Izvi zvakatibatsira kuti tirambe takamira panzvimbo yeKharkov panguva yekurwiswa kwenzvimbo dzedu musi wa19 Ndira. Mushure mekunge tarwisa kurwiswa kwevaFascist vemo mukuona kuzere kwevazhinji vevatori vechikamu pachikwere muKharkov, kutsamwiswa nevanorwira kodzero kwakapera. Nyaya yemhirizhonga yakanga isiri iyo chete pabasa, asi yakanga isingakoshi. Zano rangu kumunhu wese nderekutora chikamu mumitambo, zviri nani martial arts pasi pemamiriro akaenzana neayo emigwagwa.
Zano iri rakakosha pasina mubvunzo, asi sechirongwa chezvematongerwo enyika zviri pachena kuti harina kukwana. Pano munhu angarota, nenzira yaAgafya Tikhonovna muGogol Muchato, kuti "miromo yaNikanor Ivanovich inogona kutarisana nemhino yaIvan Kuzmich ..." Pakati pese, kana kuongorora kweMarxist kweBorotbists kuchigona kusanganiswa nemaitiro ehasha evanarchist ... Asi chokwadi ndechekuti hapana kusanganiswa kwakadaro kuri kuitika. , uye haigoni kuuya nenzira yemuchina. Kuburikidza chete nekuita basa mumafambisirwo evanhu vakawanda, kuburikidza nekugadzirwa kwehurumende itsva, mubatanidzwa wevashandi nemamwe masangano akazvimiririra, uye kuburikidza nekushingaira kukurumbira uye kuparidzira kwekurwisana uku kunogona kugadzirwa nemisoro yezvematongerwo enyika yekuruboshwe, pamwe nemikana yekubatanidzwa ( uye mutual re-education) yemamiriro akasiyana ezvematongerwo enyika.
Izvi zvinoreva, zvisinei, kuti ruboshwe harugone kuita zvisina basa, uye harugone kungovhiringika paIndependence Square (kana kutenderedza), asi inofanirwa kushandisa kushaya simba kwekutonga kwenyika uye nekushaikwa kwesimba kwave kubuda muhurongwa. kugadzira nzvimbo dzayo dzakazvimirira. Pahwaro hweizvi, zvichave zvichibvira kupinda mune itsva, "post-square" nhanho yehupenyu hwezvematongerwo enyika.
Vese muUkraine uye muRussia, mapoka e oligarchic ave kuita kurwira nzvimbo panzvimbo yekudyira. Zvichakadaro iro basa renhoroondo iro budiriro uye kunyange kupona kuri nyore kwenyika dzedu kunogona kupfupikiswa sekupwanya ichi chidyiro chekudya. Nokukurumidza kana kuti gare gare basa iri richazivikanwa, kana risiri nehuwandu hwehuwandu hwevanhu, zvino pamwe nehuwandu hwayo. Ipapo kuruboshwe ruchawana mukana waro unotevera. Chinhu chikuru ndechekuita chokwadi chekuti mukana uyu haurege kutsvedza mukati senge fashoni yakapusa seyakapfuura.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta