Hondo Yemashoko ichangopera, kuparara kweyaimbova Yugoslavia kwakakonzera hondo yevagari vemo muBosnia iyo yakauraya vanhu vanenge 100,000 1. [1992] Hondo yakaenderera mberi kubva muna 1995 kusvika 1995. Varwi vacho vaiva Bosnia Croats, Serbs neMuslim. Nezvikonzero zvayo, NATO yakatora divi revatungamiriri vechiMuslim neCroat. Kupondwa kwevanhurume vechiMuslim kwakaitika kunze kweguta reSrebrenica payakawira kuvaSerb muna Chikunguru 2. Kupondwa uku kunowanzonzi imhosva yakaipisisa yakaitwa muEurope kubva kuna Adolph Hitler. Dzimwe nguva, vaongorori vemakambani vakatobvisa mazwi okuti "muEurope" kubva pakuongorora ikoko.[8,000] Zvinoenderana nemitongo yakaitwa neInternational Criminal Tribunal yeyaimbova Yugoslavia (ICTY) iyo yakatsigirwa neInternational Court of Justice (ICJ) (pasina kuferefeta kwayo), varume nevakomana vechiMuslim zviuru zvisere vakaurayiwa - mhosva yakatongerwa kuve kuuraya rudzi. .
Vanyori ve "The Srebrenica Massacre: Evidence, Context, Politics" (Edward Herman nevamwe vanyori vakasiyana-siyana) vanonyengetedza kuti nhamba yevaMuslim vakaurayiwa yakawedzera zvakanyanya uye nhamba yevakafa "zvichida haipfuure nhamba yevaSerb vakaurayiwa. muSrebrenica nemhoteredzo yayo mukati mamakore akapfuura noMukuru wehondo weBosnia Naser Oric nemapoka ake anoparadza.โ Maererano nomunyori wenhau dzakaitika wokuSerbia, Milivoje Ivanisevic, vakaurayiwa naNaser Oric vakanga vava 3,287 3 pakapera hondo. [XNUMX]
Vamwe vevanonyanya kusemesa cheerleaders vemhosva dzekuMadokero vakafananidza kubvunza nyaya yepamutemo nezve Srebrenica ne "Holocaust denial" - izwi rinoshandiswa kutsanangura kupokana kwakasarudzika uye kusarurana pamusoro peWWII kwakaburitswa neNeo Nazis.[4] "Kuramba kuurayiwa kwemarudzi" ndiko kupomerwa kunoitirwa vanyori vakaita saEd Herman nekuti ICTY yakawana vatungamiriri veSerb vane mhosva yekuuraya rudzi muSrebrenica. Hazvishamise kuona varwi vehondo yerudyi vachipopota kune vanyori vanoratidza, kwete chete kuti mhosva dzeSerb dzave dzakawedzeredzwa, asi kuti mhosva dzemubatanidzwa weNATO muBosnia dzakadzimwa - kwete "kurambwa". Zvisinei, zvinoshamisa kuona munyori anofambira mberi saGeorge Monbiot achiwedzera inzwi rake kune vanoshora Ed Herman nevamwe vake.[5] Nekuda kweizvozvo, vazhinji vanofambira mberi vanogona kushamisika zvakanyanya kana Herman nevamwe vake vanyori vari "kuramba" nezve zvakaitika muSrebrenica.
Mushure mekuverenga bhuku - uye kunyanya mushure mekuverenga kumwe kutsoropodza kwakatorwa naEd Herman mumakore apfuura - zviri pachena kwandiri kupfuura nakare kose kuti Ed Herman nevamwe vake vanyori vanotora chinzvimbo chine musoro uye chinotsigirwa nezvokwadi. Kumberi kwebhuku kwakanyorwa naPhillip Corwin, anga ari mukuru wepamusoro weUnited Nations muBosnia panguva yekuurayiwa kweSrebrenica. Zvinofanira kucherechedzwa kuti mamwe e "dzidziso yekurangana" vanyori vanopomedzerwa kutengesa - semuenzaniso, vachiti humbowo hwakasimba hunoratidza kuti vatungamiriri veBosnia vechiMuslim vakagadzirira kupa vanhu vavo kuti vabatsire mushandirapamwe weNATO - haisi mienzaniso ye" theorizing. " zvachose. Vanyori vanongonongedza mhedziso dzakatorwa nevanhu vakaiswa zvakanyanya mukati meUN neNATO.[6]
Izwi rakakosha rekuyeuka nezve thesis yebhuku "kuuraya". Kuuraya kweSrebrenica kwakaitika pakati paChikunguru 11 naChikunguru 19 wa1995. Kurwa kunotyisa kwanga kuchiitika munzvimbo iyi kwemakore pakati pevaSerb nevaMuslim uye kwaizoenderera mberi kwemwedzi yakati gare gare. Srebrenica payakawa, anenge mamaira 15 chete kubva kure, muguta reZepa, mauto echiMuslim akarega kurwisa kwevaSerbia kwemazuva gumi nemaviri, kwakazoguma musi wa25 July. . Kusava nechokwadi pamusoro penguva chaiyo uye kupi vanhu vakafa, uye kunyanya nezvekuti ndiani akafa muhondo uye ndiani akaurayiwa, zvingave zvakakosha kunyange kana iwe uchifunga kuti (nechishamiso) pakanga pane kusarura kusingakoshi, kusavimbika uye kusakwanisa mumasangano anotungamirirwa neWestern masangano akaita. kuferefeta uye kutongwa.
Bhuku racho rinosimbisa iyi pfungwa inokosha munzira dzakasiyana-siyana. Imwe ndeyekurangarira magadzirirwo akaitwa nhamba yevakafa pamabhomba e9/11 zvichidzika kubva parunyorwa rwekutanga rwevanhu 7000 vakashaika kusvika pakufa kwe2,749 iyo isina kupera kusvika 2003. BBC TV Nhau, akanyora Chitsauko chechina chebhuku, akataura
"Kutsamwa kwakaitika muguta rakapfuma kwazvo munyika yakapfuma kwazvo pasi rose, paine zviwanikwa zvese zvinodiwa kuti muviri uverenge zvakanaka. Kusiyana neBosnia neHerzegovina, yakanga isiri nyika ine urombo, yasakadzwa nehondo ine vanhu vaibva munyika dzavo.โ
Vanyori vangangove vakanongedzera kune inofungidzirwa kufa kubva mumhirizhonga muIraq kubva pakapinda 2003. Kune vezera vaviri vakaongorora zvidzidzo zvesainzi zvehuwandu hwevanhu vakafa muIraq kubva muna 2006. Imwe ongororo, yakabudiswa mumagazini yezvehutano yeLancet, inofungidzira kuti nhamba yevakafa kubva mumhirizhonga ye600,000. Imwe, yakabudiswa muNew England Journal of Medicine (NEJM), inofungidzira kufa kwemhirizhonga se150,000. Iyoyo idanho rakakura kwazvo rekusawirirana. Zvidzidzo zviviri izvi hazvina kupesana zvakanyanya pahuwandu hwekufa kubva kune zvese zvikonzero. Ongororo yeLancet inofungidzira 650,000. Munyori wechidzidzo cheNEJM akafungidzira kufa kwe400,000 zvichienderana nedata rekudzidza kwake. [7] Zvidzidzo zvakaburitswa mumajenari esainzi zvinoda mwero wekujeka unofambisa kuongororwa kwakanyanya. Chidzidzo cheLancet, kunyanya, chakapihwa huwandu hwacho - mukupesana zvakanyanya nehumbowo hwesainzi hwakaunganidzwa nezvekuuraya kweSrebrenica sekuratidzwa kwevanyori.
Vadziviriri venyaya yepamutemo nezve Srebrenica vanonongedzera kubasa reInternational Commission on Missing Persons (ICMP) iro rakafanana neDNA kubva kumitumbi yakatorwa kubva munzvimbo yeSrebrenica (mumakuva anosvika 60 mamaira kubva kuSrebrenica maererano neRooper) kune runyorwa rwe rudungwe rwevanhu vakashaika rwakabva kuvanhu vanoti hama dzavo dzaiva pakati pevagari veSrebrenica โnzvimbo yakakotsekanaโ pana July 11, 1995.
Vanyori vanonongedza kune zvikonzero zvakawanda zvine musoro zvekufunga kuti humbowo hweDNA husina kukwana. Rondedzero shoma yezvikonzero izvozvo inosanganisira zvinotevera:
1) Humbowo hweDNA hahugone kupindura mibvunzo yakakosha yekuti vanhu vakafa sei (kureva muhondo kana kuuraya) kana rinhi. Huchapupu hwemukuru weBosnia Muslim Enver Hadzihasanovic kuICTY hunoti mauto mazana maviri nemazana maviri nemakumi maviri nemasere akaurayiwa vachiedza kurwisa ikoko nemumitsetse yeSerb kuenda kwakachengeteka.
2) Kukosha kweuchapupu hweDNA kunoenderana nekururama kwerondedzero yeakashaika iyo inofananidzwa nayo. Kushaikwa kunonzwisisika kwemarekodhi akavimbika ehuwandu hweSrebrenica muna 1995 kunokanda kusahadzika kukuru pakururama kwerondedzero. Rondedzero dzekuvhota kubva muna 1996, maererano nekuferefeta kwakasiyana kwakaitwa naMilivoje Ivanisevic naJonathan Rooper, vakanyora nhamba yakakura yevanhu sevavhoti vakanyorerwawo sevakabatwa neSrebrenica. Panewo kuramba kana kusakwanisa kwevakuru vakuru vechiMuslim vechiBosnia kupa runyoro rwemauto akabudirira kutiza kubva kuSrebrenica nokurwa nenzira yavo nomumitsetse yevaSerb.[8]
3) Basa reICMP harina kuongororwa kuti rimwe basa resainzi (semuenzaniso kudzidza kweLancet pamusoro pekufa kweIraq) kwakaitwa. Chiyero chekuongorora zviri pachena chinoenderana nekuti zvinobatsira kana kunyadzisa vekuMadokero vepamusoro vanowana basa. Jonathan Rooper akataura
"Chikwata chekudzivirira chaRadovan Karadzic hachina kukwanisa kuwana humbowo hweDNA hweICMP, uye kunyange muchuchisi weICTY Hildegarde Uertz-Retzlaff akabvuma kudare kuti 'ICMP hainawo kutipa DNA.' Uku kubvuma kunoshamisa: kuti ICTY haisati yaona kana kuongorora kunaka kwouchapupu huri paDNA hwakapiwa nomumwe munhu anofarira, ICMP inodzorwa neMuslim wokuBosnia, pakuita zvisarudzo zvakakomba pamusoro poโkuparadza rudzi.โโ
Vaimbove vatungamiriri veICMP vakasanganisira Secretary of State weUS, Cyrus Vance uye aimbove Senator weRepublican weUS, Bob Dole - vezvematongerwo enyika vakazvipira kudzivirira zvido zvehurumende yeUS nevabatsiri vayo.
Kuvhura iyo ICTY
Bhuku racho rinoparadza kuvimbika kweICTY. Dare redzimhosva rinoratidza kuve rakarerekera pachena richitsigira hurumende dzekuMadokero dzakarigadza uye kudzivirira vanobatana nenyika dzekuMadokero. Chinhu chimwe chinonyanyo mira pachena ndechekuti ICTY yakasunungurwa nemukuru weBosnia Muslim Naser Oric, uyo dare redzimhosva harina kana kumbomupomera mhosva kusvika 2003 (uye pamhosva diki dzakapihwa mhosva dzake). ICTY yakatanga kutongera Oric mhosva ikamutongera makore maviri mutongo. ICTY yakazomusunungura.
Naser Oric akatapa vhidhiyo yekuuraya kwake misha yevaSerb uye, muna 1994, akazvitamba achidada vatori venhau vaviri vekuMadokero - Bill Schiller weToronto Star naJohn Pomfret weWashington Post. [9] Bill Schiller, anozove mupepeti weNyeredzi yekunze, akatsanangura Oric se "nyota yeropa" uye akanyora.
"Ndakagara muimba yake yekutandarira ndichiona vhidhiyo inokatyamadza yeinogona kunge yakanzi Nasir Oric's Greatest Hits. Paiva nedzimba dzaitsva, zvitunha, misoro yakagurwa, uye vanhu vaitiza. Oric aingosekerera, achiyemura basa rake remaoko.โ Oric akatsanangura kuderedzwa kwemumwe wevakabatwa nekuona kuti varume vake dzimwe nguva vaishandisa "zvombo zvinotonhora".
Oric akaudzawo Schiller kuti vanhuwo zvavo havana kuurayiwa "nemaune" mukupambwa uku asi vakabvuma kuti dzimwe nguva "vanopinda munzira". Mumwe mutauriri weICTY akataura zvinoshamisa kuti โhavana kuwana uchapupu hwokuti pane vanhuwo zvavo vakafa pakurwiswa kwakaitwa misha yevaSerb munhandare yake yemitambo [yaOric].โ
ICTY haina kumbopomera mutungamiri weBosnia Muslim, Alija Izetbegovic kana mutungamiri weCroatia, Franjo Tudjman. Nekuda kwekuda kuzvipfuudza, ICTY yakaferefeta varume ava kwemakore ichibva yati ingadai yakavapomera mhosva ivo vese vasina kufa nezvikonzero. Sezvakatsanangurwa nemunyori weChitsauko Chishanu chebhuku, George Szamuely, izvi zvakanga zvakasiyana chaizvo nezvakaitika nevatungamiri veSerb "Mladic naKaradzic, vakapomerwa mukati memazuva ekutorwa kweSrebrenica, naMilosevic, vachipomerwa mhosva apo NATO ichiri kubhomba Yugoslavia."
ICTY yakashandisa zvakakwana kubvunzurudza kune vese kumanikidza nekunyengerera vapomeri vakakosha kuti vataure zvavanoda kutaura ivo - nevakuru vavo vekuAmerica nekuEurope. Tichifunga nzira iyo WWII yakakumbirwa kana tichitaura nezveSrebrenica, zvakakosha kuti tizive kuti kuteterera kwekukumbira hakuna kushandiswa kuNuremberg. Sei vachuchisi veNuremberg vaizozvida? Wese anopomerwa mhosva kuNuremberg akabvuma kuti "asina mhosva" kune yese mhosva. Vanopomerwa vakanga vasina sarudzo yekusarudza kukumbira "mhosva" kana "kusava nemhosva" kune dzimwe mhosva.[10]
Munguva yeOperation Storm muna 1995, Croatia yakadzinga maSerbs anofungidzirwa kuti 250,000 munzvimbo yeKrajina nerubatsiro rwakananga rwemauto eUS. Chakanga chiri chiito chikurusa chokuparadza dzinza muhondo. George Bogdanich, akanyora Chitsauko Chinomwe chebhuku racho, akatsanangura
โOperation Storm, iyo yakatangwa isingasviki mwedzi mushure mekutorwa kweSrebrenica, yakatsigirwa neUS uye yakaitwa nemauto eCroatia akadzidziswa uye akashongedzerwa nenyanzvi dzemauto eUS kubva kuMilitary Professional Resources Inc. (MPRI), kondirakiti yemauto yakazvimirira. 'Vakasiya basa' Vakuru vemauto vekuUS vakaita saCarl Vuono naRichard Griffiths vakabatikana zvakanyanya mukuronga kuvhiyiwa, uye MPRI yakagamuchira rutsigiro rwemhepo kubva kumauto emugungwa eUS kubva kuAviano air base, avo vakabvisa maSerbs ekudzivirira zvemagetsi panguva yakakosha. โ
Muna 2004, The NGO Veritas inofungidzira 1960 maSerbs akaurayiwa panguva yeOperation Storm - 1205 vavo vanhuwo zvavo. [11]
ICTY yakanonoka zvikuru (mushure memakore ekuratidzira kubva kune vanoita zvekuratidzira) vakapomera vanhu vakasiyana-siyana vekuCroatia (asi kwete vagari vemuUS) nekuda kwekuita kwavo muOp Operation Storm, asi haina kupomera mhosva ye "genocide" sezvayakaita panyaya yekuurayiwa kweSrebrenica.
Sei Kudenha ICTY Pamusoro peSrebrenica?
Kubva pakuona kwekuita kuti vakuru veNATO nevabatsiri vavo vazvidavirire, zvingadai zvakave zvine hungwaru kungofunga kuti shanduro yeICTY yeSrebrenica massacre yaive yakarurama? Izvo zvingadai zvisina kudzivirira mushandirapamwe wekupokana nevanyori vakatsausa kubva kune dzimwe mhosva dzavanogadzirisa? Vatsoropodzi vanogara vachifuratira izvo vanyori vanotaura nezvevaSerb vakabatwa. Nekudaro, kune mutengo wakakwira wekubhadhara kana zviyero zvehumbowo munyaya yeNATO vavengi vepamutemo vakabvumidzwa kudonha pasi, ivo vachikwidziridzwa kumakomo eUS uye ayo anoenderana nawo. Kune zvakare mutengo wakakwirisa wekubhadhara, kana tikasarudza kudzokera kumushandirapamwe wekubiridzira uyo unotsvaga kuvhara nhaurirano ine musoro nekupopotera "kuramba kuurayiwa kwevanhu".
Vanoenderera mberi havafanire kuramba vakanyarara kana vaongorori vemakambani emhando dzakasiyana siyana vachiita mushandirapamwe wakadaro.
ZVINYORWA
[1] Jonathan Rooper anotsanangura muChitsauko chechina che "Kuuraya kweSrebrenica: Humbowo, Mamiriro ezvinhu, Zvematongerwo enyika" kuti nhamba ye100,000 yakabva kune zvinyorwa zvekambani, nemitemo yayo, yaisakwanisa kuzvidza. Zvakangodaro, idi rekuti vezvenhau vaive neanopfuura makore gumi manhamba asina kutsoropodzwa akakwira se200,000-300,000 nguva dzose "hazvina kukonzera nyonganyonga ingave yakakarirwa kubva mukuwanwa kwomumwe wemienzaniso yakashata zvikurusa yokushumwa kusina kururama kunopfuurira munguva pfupi yapfuuraโ
Bhuku racho rinogona kutorwa mahara
http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=25112
Kune ichangoburwa uye yakadzama data pamusoro pekufa muBosnia hondo yevagari vemo ona
http://www.hicn.org/research_design/rdn5.pdf
[2] Semuyenzaniso, Jon Snow, mutapi wenhau weChannel 4 News muUKK akanyora kuti โNhasi kuurayiwa kwevanhu vakawanda kuSrebrenica nekukombwa kweSarajevo zviviri zvezviitiko zvakaipisisa zvekutambura nekufa kwevagari zvakaitika kubvira Adolph Hitler akazvipfura. yake muBerlin makore anopfuura 65 apfuura.โ
Mukuchinjana neemail neni, Snow akabvuma kuti mazwi ekuti "muEurope" aifanira kunge akaiswa.
[3] ona peji 289 yeโThe Srebrenica Massacre: Evidence, Context, Politicsโ;
Onawo The Srebrenica ID Card naMilivoje Ivaniลกevic
http://serbianna.com/analysis/?p=496
[4] Kutamba paguva revanhu vakawanda - Oliver Kamm weTimes Smears Medialens
http://www.medialens.org/alerts/09/091125_dancing_on_a.php
George Monbiot tweeted kuti basa raKamm rakafumura Medialens ""kuramba kuurayiwa kwevanhu"
[5] Kupa Mazita eGenocide Deniers naGeorge Monbiot
http://www.monbiot.com/2011/06/13/naming-the-genocide-deniers/
Onawo "More Monbiot uye Left Wing Genocide Belittlers"
https://znetwork.org/more-monbiot-and-the-left-wing-genocide-belittlers-by-joe-emersberger
[6] Semuenzaniso, funga zvinotevera kubva papeji 235
โโฆ Boutros-Ghali akaita, chokwadi, kupa mvumo kumauto eUN kuti aite basa, asi mundangariro yake. Asina kukurirwa, anoyeuka hurukuro neMunyori weHurumende yeUnited States Warren Christopher zvichitevera kuputika kwemusika:
Ndakaudza Christopher kuti [UN Special Representative Yasushi] Akashi akataura kuti dhaka radzingwa neBosnia maMuslim kuitira kuti NATO ipindire. Christopher
akapindura kuti akanga aona mashoko eungwaru akawanda uye kuti vakaenda 'nenzira mbiri.'
Avo vane chokwadi chekuti mauto echiMuslim ndiwo akakonzeresa kuurayiwa kweMarkale Marketplace vaisanganisira mukuru weNATO wehungwaru US General Charles Boyd.... "
Imwe ndima kubva papeji 236
โโฆSomuenzaniso, the New York Times yakashuma muna August wa1995 kuti mauto eUN yeFrance akataura kuti โkutozosvikira pakati paJune wegore iroro, pfuti dzakabva kuvarwi veHurumende vaipfura nemaune vanhuwo zvavo. Mushure mekuferefeta kwayakadaidza kuti "yechokwadi", chimwe chikwata chemugungwa cheFrance chinotenderera chichirwisa vapfuri chakati chakatsvaga moto wepfuti kuchivakwa chinowanzogarwa nemasoja eBosnia [maMuslim] nemamwe mauto. Mumwe mukuru mukuru weFrance akati, โTinozviona zvisingabviri kudavira, asi tine chokwadi chokuti ichokwadi.โ'
[7] Mohamed Ali, akaita fungidziro yekufa kubva kune zvikonzero zvose muIraq yakabva kune yake (NEJM) kudzidza pamusangano muDenver muna 2008. Yakashumwa naMiother Jones.
http://motherjones.com/politics/2008/11/iraq-math-war
[8] Jonathan Rooper akanyora muChitsauko chechina kuti kubva โsampuli diki kwazvo ya1996
runyoro rwekuvhota" akakwanisa "kuyambuka-mazita anopfuura zana pakati peRed Cross' vanhu vakarasika uye runyorwa rwekuvhota".
Milivoje Ivaniลกevic (zvisiri pamutemo) akawana runyorwa ruzere uye akawana "vanhu 3,106 kubva parunyorwa rwevakashaikwa murondedzero yevavhoti veSrebrenica musarudzo dza1996"
Ona The Srebrenica ID Card naMilivoje Ivaniลกevic
http://serbianna.com/analysis/?p=496
Maererano ne Bosnia Muslim mukuru Hadzihasanovic, mauto echiMuslim anoda kusvika 3000 akabudirira kupinda munzvimbo yakachengeteka.
http://www.icty.org/x/cases/krstic/trans/en/010406ed.htm
[9] Zvinyorwa zvataurwa ndezvi
Bill Schiller, "gamba reMuslim rinopika kuti acharwa kusvika kumunhu wekupedzisira," Toronto Star, Ndira
31, 1994.
Bill Shiller, "Murwi anotyisa weMuslim anonzvenga mauto eBosnia Serb", Chikunguru 16, 1995.
John Pomfret, Washington Post, "Zvombo, Cash neMhirizhonga Zvinokweretesa Simba kuSrebrenica's Tough Guy", Kukadzi 16, 1994.
[10] Pazasi kubva pa "Mukati Justice" webhusaiti
http://www.insidejustice.com/law/index.php/intl/2005/11/11/nuremberg_birth_of_international_law
โVanhu makumi maviri nevana nemasangano manomwe vakapomerwa mhosva yakaenzana nekuuraya rudzi. Vose vaipomerwa mhosva 'havana mhosva.' โ
Vanhu vazhinji vanoti Albert Speer ndiye ega muNazi kuNuremberg kukumbira "mhosva" asi izvo hazvisi chokwadi sekutsanangura kunoita webhusaiti yeInside Justice.
"Albert Speer, ari kupomerwa mhosva, akaudza Mambo [muchuchisi weNuremberg] kuti mhosva yacho yainyanya kutsvaira uye isingachinjiki. Nokudaro, Speer akanzwa kuti aifanira kubvuma โkusava nemhakaโ kupomero dzose kana kuti kupomerwa zvenhema pane dzimwe pomero. Speer angadai akada sarudzo yekuramba mhosva kune dzimwe mhosva uye ane mhosva kune dzimwe mhosva. "
[11] Agence France Presse, "Kurangarira 9th yegore rekubuda kweSerb kubva kuCroatia", Nyamavhuvhu 4, 2004.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta