ʻAʻole anei ʻo George Monbiot i "hoʻohaʻahaʻa" i ka pepehi kanaka i ka wā i waiho ai ʻo ia i ka make o 8,000 mau koa ma Srebrenica i ka papa like me nā ʻeono miliona mau Iudaio i pepehi ʻia ma nā kahua hoʻomoana make Holocaust? ("ʻO ka hema a me ka libertarian ʻākau noho pū i ka honua ʻē aʻe o ka poʻe hoʻomāʻewaʻewa pepehi kanaka," ke Kahu, Iune 14.)
Hana ʻo Monbiot i kāna hihia no ka hōʻole ʻana i ke kūkākūkā e pili ana i ka pepehi kanaka ma Srebrenica a
Hiki iā ʻoe ke loaʻa ka "genocide" ma kekahi kūlanakauhale liʻiliʻi, kahi i mālama ʻia ai nā wahine a me nā keiki, a i ka wā i maopopo ʻole ai ka nui o ka poʻe i pepehi ʻia a ʻehia ka poʻe i make i ke kaua? ʻO ka Bosnia Muslim General Enver Hadzihasanovic i koi me ka "ʻoiaʻiʻo" i ka hoʻokolokolo Bosnia Serb General Radislav Krstic i ka 2,628 Muslim "koa a me nā luna hoʻomalu" mai ka 28th Division i pepehi ʻia i ke kaua i ko lākou hoʻi ʻana mai Srebrenica, a ua ʻike ʻia e ka forensic pathologist Ljubisa Simic. ʻO ka nui o nā kino i hoʻoneʻe ʻia i loko o nā lua kupapaʻu e nā limahana o ka ʻAha no nā makahiki 1996 a hiki i 2002, no ka 77 pakeneka o nā kino ʻaʻole hiki ke hoʻoholo i ke ʻano o ka make (hoʻokō a hakakā paha) a i ʻole ke ʻano o ka make i manaʻo ikaika ʻia he hakakā. -pili. Ua haʻi mai ʻo Monbiot iā mākou ua ʻae ʻo DNA i ka International Commission on Missing Persons (ICMP) e ʻike i nā "kupapau o 6,595 o nā Bosnia 7,789 i hōʻike ʻia e nalowale ana ma hope o ka hoʻopuni ʻana iā Srebrenica," akā ʻaʻole ʻo ia e haʻi ʻaʻole hōʻike ʻo DNA i ke ʻano o kahi kanaka. make, a i ʻole i ka manawa, e ʻae ai i ka ICMP, ka Yugoslavia Tribunal, a me Monbiot e hoʻohālike i kēia mau mea a pau. ʻO ka ʻōlelo a Monbiot e ʻōlelo nei kā mākou puke "ʻo ka 8,000 make ma Srebrenica he 'hoʻonui hiki ʻole ke kākoʻo'," e hoʻololi i ka "make" no ka huaʻōlelo i hoʻohana maoli ʻia, ʻo ia hoʻi "ka hoʻokō."
ʻAʻole hiki iā Monbiot ke noʻonoʻo i ka manaʻo o ka ICMP, ʻoiai ua koho ʻia kona luna hoʻomalu e ke Kakauolelo o ka Moku'āina ʻo ʻAmelika, ua holo pololei ʻia e nā luna Muslim Bosnia, a ʻaʻole ia e ʻae i kāna mau hopena e hōʻike ʻia a hoʻāʻo ʻia e kekahi ʻōlelo aʻoaʻo no ka poʻe i hoʻopiʻi ʻia. He mea hoʻomāʻewaʻewa ʻo ia i ka manaʻo "ʻo ka pepehi kanaka ma ka mākeke [ma Sarajevo] i hana ʻia e nā mea hoʻonāukiuki Muslim Bosnia," ʻoiai he nui nā ʻōlelo e pili ana i kēia ʻōlelo. Ka pepehi kanaka Srebrenica, a, "e like me Karadzic," e like me ka Monbiot i hōʻike mai ai iaʻu, ua manaʻoʻiʻo nā luna UN a me Lord David Owen i ka poʻe Muslim i puhi i ka pūpū i hoʻokumu i ka luku ʻana i ka laina berena o Pepeluali 5, 1994 (e nānā iā Owen ma ka BBC1 Panorama TV hoʻolaha o ʻOkakopa 30, 1995; ʻo Owen hoʻi, Balkan Odyssey, pp. 279-280).
E like me ka nānā 'ole
No ka
He liʻiliʻi loa nā huaʻōlelo i loko o kā George Monbiot's June 14 diatribe e kū nei i ka nānā pono ʻana. Akā, ke koi aku nei au i ka poʻe heluhelu e nānā i nā kumu kumu i kuhi hewa ʻole ʻia: ʻO ka politika o Genocide (me David Peterson, Monthly Review Press, 2010) a me ʻO ka pepehi kanaka Srebrenica: Hōʻike, Hōʻike, Politics (Alphabet Soup, 2011).
Hāʻawi kālā ʻia ʻo ZNetwork ma o ka lokomaikaʻi o kāna poʻe heluhelu.
E Makana mai
2 Comments
Me he mea lā ua hoʻohana ʻo Edward lāua ʻo David i ka hana paʻi puke a Amazon e hoʻopuka i kēia puke. Aneane au e haʻalele ma hope o ke kākau ʻana iā "Edward S. Herman" i loko o kahi kahua huli ma ka punaewele CreateSpace a loaʻa iaʻu ka 'aʻole hoʻi' ma ke ʻano he hoʻihoʻi. Makemake maoli ʻo Edward lāua ʻo David e hana me Amazon? Pono anei? A laila hoʻāʻo wau i ka inoa puke wale nō. Panned out.
Ke ho'āʻo nei au e kūʻai aku iā Edward Herman lāua ʻo David Petersons ' "Enduring Lies: The Rwanda Genocide In The Propaganda System, 20 Years Later" me ka hoʻohana ʻole ʻana iā Amazon a i ʻole ebay (ʻaʻole paha e hana.) ʻAʻohe oʻu lanakila. ʻAʻole hiki iaʻu ke kauoha i ka puke ma Toronto mai ke kaulahao Indigo nui. ʻO kēlā a me nā puke ʻē aʻe aʻu e hoʻāʻo nei e kauoha mai iā lākou, ʻaʻole hiki iaʻu, ʻaʻole ia he mea kupanaha. ʻO Google Heather Reisman a ʻike koke ʻoe he 1 pakeneka ʻo ia me ka inaina no ka demokala a me ka 99%. Aia ʻo ia ma ka moʻolelo e ʻōlelo ana ʻo kāna hale kūʻai puke (ʻo ia ka mea i haki i nā mea kūʻokoʻa he nui ma TO) ʻaʻole ia he hale kūʻai puke. A pēlā ke ʻano o kēia manawa. Ua piha me ka palaka. Ua hoʻonui nui ʻia ka ʻāpana keiki, ma ka lilo o nā puke ʻē aʻe. Manaʻo wau hiki iā mākou a pau ke noho kamaliʻi a maikaʻi.
ʻO kaʻu hale kūʻai puke indy, Book City, ʻaʻole pinepine. Ua hana ia ma keia hihia. Hoʻopau ʻo Barnes & Noble (me kahi memo ʻaʻole hiki iā lākou ke hoʻouna i koʻu wahi). ʻO ka loulou ma laila i [pale ʻia ka leka uila] Ke alakaʻi wale nei au i kahi msg hewa ke pā wau i ka hoʻouna. Loaʻa iaʻu kahi msg hewa 404 ma kēia pūnaewele ma ka ʻāpana puke a Edward kahi aʻu i ʻike ʻole ai i ka puke i helu ʻia, akā ʻike wau i kahi loulou "Read more".
He aha lā?!!!