Alex,
Ngiyavuma ukuthi iqembu lakho liye lehluka kwaze kwaba seqophelweni lokungqubuzana okunodlame namanye amaqembu amaLeninist. I-Leninism ayiyona into eyodwa, kunjalo. Futhi ngivumelana nawe ukuthi akekho kithina okufanele abeke ngokungananazi ukuthi iLeninism iyini. Kufanele sibone ukuthi yini ehlukanisa ama-Leninist kwabanye kwesokunxele kanye nalokho wonke amaLeninst afana ngakho ngokubanzi.
Angicabangi ukuthi โukusetshenziswa ngokuqinile kwesimiso seningiโ kugcwalisa leso sidingo. Isici esivamile esingcono kungaba ukwamukelwa kokuhlaziywa kwe-Marxist, kanye nentando yeningi emaphakathi, kanye nokumela umbono wezomnotho owodwa noma omunye.
Ngiyavuma ukuthi kufanele sivume ukungavumelani nge-Leninism, kodwa ngiyangabaza ukuthi umlando uzosisiza ukuthi sahlulele ukuthi i-SWP noma enye i-Trotskyist Party izozinikela ekuvikeleni ukuxhumanisa kwe-botheconomic kanye nokugunyazwa kwezombusazwe ngaphansi kwengcindezi yesimo soguquko ngoba ngicabanga ukuthi cha. Iqembu elinjalo liyoke liwine amandla ezweni elinezimboni. Ukuphumelela lapha kuzodinga umnyakazo onezici eziningi onaka ubuhlanga, ubulili, isigaba, namandla futhi omelene nokugunyazwa okuhlanganisa nokwakha ingqalasizinda yayo yokuzilawula nangaphambi kokuwina uguquko olukhulu.
Uqinisile ukuthi abanye abangakwesokunxele bayaphika ukufinyelela iningi labantu. Kodwa ngicabanga noma kunjalo, uma isifiso sokwakha ukunyakaza okukhudlwana sichaza ngempela i-Leninism, iningi lama-anarchist emlandweni lingangena ngaphansi kwesambulela, futhi ngokuqinisekile abantu abafana no-Kropotkin noGoldman, njll. Angicabangi ukuthi ukusho lokhu kusheshisa izinkinga zamanje ezedlule ezibhekene nazo. umnyakazo. Izinkinga ezinjalo zifaka phakathi ukuqonda isidingo seningi elikhulu, kodwa futhi zihlanganisa ukuhlanganisa ukunaka uhlanga, ubulili, kanye nesigaba ngaphandle kokubeka omunye komunye, ukuthola izindlela ezihlukahlukene zokufinyelela kabanzi, ukuthola izindlela zokugcina ubulungu kunokuba abantu abajoyinayo futhi kamuva bahambe, bakhe ingqalasizinda engagcini nje ngokusisimamisa futhi isiqinise, kodwa futhi ifanekisela futhi ilungiselele izikhungo zesikhathi esizayo, igxile ezindabeni ezihlukene ngaphandle kokugxila endabeni eyodwa, ukuzuza izinguquko ngaphandle kokuba abantu abashisekeli benguquko, ukuba ngamasu ngaphandle kokuba ngamahlelo, kanye nokuphikisana nobungxiwankulu ngaphandle kokuba umxhumanisi. Kodwa mayelana nakho konke lokhu, kufanele sibuze ukuthi ingabe i-Leninist noma i-Trotskyist noma leyo ndaba i-Marxist formulast iyasiza noma ivimbele ukubhekana kwethu nezinkinga.
Yize iyingxenye yenkulumo-mpikiswano yethu, njengoba uyiphakamisile, ngicabanga ukuthi i-WSF ngeke iyonke ibe nohlelo lobushoshovu ngoba ihlanganisa imibono eminingi engqubuzanayo. Kodwa-ke, ngicabanga ukuthi i-WSF ingaba futhi kufanele ibe inkundla hhayi nje yabantu abahlangana nokufunda komunye nomunye, kodwa eyabantu abahlanganisayo nabakha izinhlelo ezihlanganyelwe ezingathathwa yi-WSF yonke kodwa ezilandelwa amagatsha alowo mphakathi.
Ngiyavumelana nokubaluleka kokuba namasu kodwa kufanele ngisho ukuthi ngicabanga ukuthi okuthile mayelana nendlela yama-Leninists yokuba ngamasu kwenza kube yinkinga. Angiqondile ukwenza kancane noma ukupenda ngebhulashi elibanzi kakhulu noma elingabonakali, kodwa kimina amaqembu e-Leninist abiza izithombe zabantu abathengisa amaphephandaba abangakwazi ngisho nokubona ukudelela okuphelele kwabantu abasunduza kubo, futhi abakwenzayo. ngaphandle kokuxhumana kwabantu, ngisho nangerobhothi. Ngikubonile kusuka eqenjini le-ML kuya eqenjini amashumi eminyaka, futhi-ke hhayi nje mayelana namaphephandaba, kodwa umugqa, njalonjalo. Kuyathakazelisa ukuthi amalungu amaningi eqembu lamaLeninist nawo ayakubona, uma ebheka umkhuba weqembu ngaphandle kwelabo.
Ngesikhathi ngikhuluma eNgilandi bengilokhu ngizibuza ukuthi abantu beSWP engihlangane nabo bezama ukungidayisela leli phephandaba bangaba kanjani enhlanganweni efanayo nawe. Ngisho lokho ngokungathi sรญna, futhi ngicabanga ukuthi kuyinto okufanele ucabange ngayo kanzima. Akuzona izakhi zofuzo, noma izici zobuntu ezihlala isikhathi eside โ yinto emayelana nesikhundla nefayela leqembu le-Leninist ne-Trotskyist elihudulela amalungu phansi kulesi sitayela serobhothi nokuqukethwe. Ngaleso sikhathi, amanye amalungu, eduze naphezulu kwemishini, awanayo inkinga yerobhothi, kodwa njengoba amandla esondela esikhundleni salokho adala inkinga yegunya.
Ngicabanga ukuthi omunye umehluko wethu omkhulu ukuthi ufuna ukubona konke okubi kakhulu efa lakho njengokugeleza ku-Stalin, futhi kusukela uTrotsky ephikisana noStalin, uhlengiwe. Kimina, amaBolshevik akuqala ayeholwa uLenin noTrotsky hhayi nje uStalin aqeda ukunyakaza okusuka phansi eRussia, futhi abeka umnotho nepolitiki engiyenqaba njengento ecindezela ngendlela enyantisayo. Yiqiniso, uLenin noTrotsky babengahlosile ukuthi iStalinism ibuse. Kodwa lapho beshiya okwakukhona kwaba umnotho ongumxhumanisi kanye nombuso wobushiqela. Ezinye izingcaphuno engizinikeze ngaphambili ziwubufakazi. Umuntu angakhiqiza okwengeziwe kalula.
Mhlawumbe โnginedloziโ lokulahla i-Leninism ne-Trotskyism okungenza ngiphuthelwe ubunkimbinkimbi obubanika izaba noma okwenza ukuziphatha kwabo kube okunengqondo ngokomongo. Noma mhlawumbe une-โfetishโ esebenzisa i-Leninism ne-Trotskyism ekwenza uphuthelwe ubunkimbinkimbi obuhlukile okwenza izenzo zabo zibe zimbi kakhulu. Asikwazi ukukuxazulula lokho manje.
Nokho, ingabe singavumelana ngamaphuzu athile abalulekile kithi namuhla? Singavuma yini ukuthi ukunyakaza namaqembu kufanele kugxile ezintweni eziningi, kugqanyiswe ubuhlanga, ubulili, isigaba, namandla, futhi kuqondwe ngamunye ngendlela yawo futhi njengoba zonke zihlanganyela? Singavumelana yini ukuthi izinhlangano kufanele zizibophezele ekuhlanganiseni ukuzilawula hhayi nje emnothweni wesikhathi esizayo nomphakathi, kodwa nasezikhungweni zawo zamanje? Singavuma yini ukuthi sidinga ukufinyelela kabanzi ukuze sakhe izinhlangano ezinkulu kanye nokuthi sidinga ukwakha ukunyakaza okusakhiwo, isiko, isitayela, ukuhlukana kwabasebenzi, kanye nezindlela zokuthatha izinqumo ezihambisana nokunika amandla abantu ekugcineni uhlanga, ubulili, nezigaba zezigaba? Futhi singavuma yini ukuthi ukunyakaza kwethu akufanele nje kugxeke lokho okuyikho, kodwa futhi kunikeze umbono wesikhungo obonisa ubumbano, ubulungiswa, ukuhlukahluka, ukusebenza kahle, ukulingana, kanye nokuzilawula? Futhi, ekugcineni, ingabe mhlawumbe singavuma futhi ukuthi uma i-parecon iyasebenza futhi isebenza kahle, ifeza lezo zindlela zomnotho?
Uthi โenye indlela yokufingqa ukungaboni ngaso linye kwethu mayelana neLeninism ukuthi siyehluka ngesisindo esisinikeza lezi zici ezimbili ekuveleni kweStalinism. Wena [Michael] ubheka ukubaluleka okukhulu ezinhlosweni zezombangazwe zamaBolshevik, mina [Alex] ezimweni zawo zomlando.โ Kodwa angicabangi ukuthi into ebalulekile izinhloso eziseduze njengoba ngicabanga ukuthi ukuzibophezela okungokomqondo kanye nesikhungo. Ngisola ukuthi iningi lamaBolshevik beliyothuka kakhulu ukube libone isithombe sokubuka kuqala ukuthi yini ezoholela ekubhubhiseni amaSoviet.
Izinhloso zibalulekile, kunjalo, kodwa izinhloso ziyavela kumongo, futhi kimina umongo wamaBolsheviks wawungesona nje isimo sezwe labo noma umhlaba - kodwa futhi ngisho nangokwengeziwe izikhungo inhlangano eyayizamukele, kanye nemibono eyayiyisebenzisa. . Kwakukhona abaningi eRussia ababenezinhlelo ezihluke kakhulu kunobuholi bamaBolshevik, okuhlanganisa hhayi kuphela ama-anarchists kanye nokunyakaza kwabalimi, kodwa izishoshovu eziningi zezikhundla namafayela ngaphakathi kweqembu lamaBolskevik ngokwalo - kodwa ubuholi babunomongo ohluke kakhulu kunabo bonke lezo zikhundla nefayela. abantu - ikakhulukazi ngenxa yohlaka lwayo lomqondo kanye nezindima nemibandela yenhlangano.
Wena uthi: โKiwe i-Stalinism imele ukunqoba kwesigaba somxhumanisi 'i-ajenda' yayo uTrotsky evezwe ezindimeni ozishoyo." Akukho lapho engike ngakusho lokho. Ngingathi nguwe, hhayi mina, ocabanga ukuthi inkinga esixoxa ngayo iStalinism. Ngiphendule kuphela nge-Stalinism. Ngicabanga ukuthi inkinga okudingeka siyiqonde futhi siyigweme yandulela indima enkulu ka-Stalin. Uma uthatha iRussia eguqukile bese ubeka kuyo uhulumeni wentando yeningi ephalamende esikhundleni sikaStalin, ngisazowuphikisa umnotho.
Ngiyavuma ukuthi kube nokushoda kwangempela kwamalungu ekilasi lomxhumanisi e-Russia ngemva koguquko ngenxa yokuthi i-Russia yayingenayo intuthuko eyanele ukuze ikhule ibe yinoma yini efana nama-20% wabantu. Isikhala savalwa yizikhulu zezombangazwe. Ngamanye amazwi angicabangi ukuthi i-Stalinism yinto ebangelwa umuntu omubi, kodwa, kunalokho, yilokho okuvame ukwenzeka lapho udala umnotho womxhumanisi nezwe elilodwa elinegunya kodwa ungenalo isigaba somxhumanisi. ukugcwalisa umxhumanisi Slots kwezomnotho. Iqembu elibusayo libe selimela isigaba esishodayo kakhulu futhi izinhlaka zalo azigcini nje ngokuphatha ipolitiki, kodwa nomnotho ngokunjalo.
Noma kunjalo, uqinisile ukuthi noma yimaphi amalebula esiwakhethayo futhi noma ngabe siwachaza kanjani, uma โsingasebenza ndawonye ukuze sakhe umuntu omelene nonxiwankulu (futhi ngingangeza umnyakazo omelene nobulili, omelene nokucwasa ngokwebala, futhi omelene nokugunyazwa) ngokwesisekelo esibanzi, njengokuzihlela ngokwentando yeningi, okunamandla emphakathini, njengokuzicabangela ngokomqondo, futhi kubumbene emhlabeni wonke ngangokunokwenzekaโ lapho-ke ukukhetha phakathi kwemibono yethu kuzokwenziwa ngokusekelwe kulokho okwenzekayo futhi ngethemba ukuthi sobabili sizojabula Inqubekelaphambili elandelwayo, kungakhathaliseki ukuthi imibono kabani ebonakala ifaneleka kakhulu - noma ngisho noma imibono esingayazi ngokuphelele ifakazela ukuthi iyasebenza kakhulu.
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa kuphela ngokuphana kwabafundi bayo.
Nikela