Kukhona izingxabano ezimbili ezihlangene ezikhona njengamanje kwa-Israel, kodwa akukho, naphezu kwe-Western liberal spin, ehlobene nokushabalala okusatshiswayo kwentando yeningi yakwa-Israel. Lokho kukhathazeka kuphakamisa ukuthi i-Israel yayikade ibusa ngentando yeningi kwaze kwaba sekuqubuka igagasi lakamuva lokweqisa elivela ekuzibophezeleni kukahulumeni omusha wakwa-Israel oholwa nguNetanyahu “enguqukweni yezobulungiswa.” Inkulumo-mpikiswano yayifihla inhloso yalesi senzo, okwakuwukunciphisa ukuzimela kwezobulungiswa ngokunikeza inkululeko yokwahlulela. I-Knesset enegunya lokuphoqelela intando yeningi lephalamende yokuchitha izinqumo zenkantolo ngeningi elilula futhi ilawule ukuqokwa kwamajaji. Impela, lezi kwakuyizinyathelo eziya ekusungulweni kombuso wentando yeningi oqinile kwa-Israyeli njengoba kungashintsha ukufana okuthile kokuhlukaniswa kwamandla, kodwa hhayi ukuchithwa kwentando yeningi njengoba kuvezwe kahle ngokuqinisekisa amalungelo alinganayo azo zonke izakhamuzi kungakhathalekile ukuthi ziluphi uhlanga noma inkolo yazo.
Ukuba uMbuso wamaJuda onikeza ngokwawo uMthetho Oyisisekelo ka-2018 ilungelo elikhethekile lokuzibusa ngokukhethekile kubantu bamaJuda futhi ugomela ukuphakama ngenani labantu abambalwa basePalestine abangaphezu kwezigidi eziyi-1.7 kubukela phansi isimangalo sika-Israyeli sokuthi intando yeningi, okungenani maqondana nesakhamuzi sisonke. Futhi, abantu basePalestine kade babekezelela imithetho nemikhuba ebandlululayo ezindabeni ezibalulekile okwathi ngokuhamba kwesikhathi inqubo yabo kahulumeni yahlonzwa kabanzi njengombuso wobandlululo osebenza kuzo zombili iZizinda ZasePalestine Ezithathiwe kanye naku-Israel uqobo. Uma ulimi lunwetshwa lufinyelele emikhawulweni yalo, kungenzeka ukuthi kuthathwe i-Israel njengentando yeningi yobuhlanga noma yentando yeningi, kodwa amagama anjalo ayimifanekiso ecacile yemimoya yezepolitiki.
Selokhu yasungulwa njengombuso ngo-1948, i-Israel inqabe amalungelo alinganayo kubantu abambalwa basePalestine. Ize yenqabela noma yiliphi ilungelo lokubuyela kubantu basePalestine abangu-750,000 abaphoqwa ukuba bahambe phakathi neMpi ka-1947, futhi banelungelo ngokomthetho wamazwe ngamazwe ukuthi babuyele ekhaya, okungenani ngemva kokuba ukulwa kuphelile. Impi yamanje ebabayo phakathi kwamaJuda enkolo nawezwe egxile ekuzimeleni kwamajaji akwa-Israyeli isuka ezindaweni eziningi zasePalestine njengoba izinkantolo eziphakeme zakwa-Israel phakathi neminyaka ziye zasekela ngokumangalisayo izinyathelo eziphikisana kakhulu zomhlaba wonke 'ngokungekho emthethweni' ezivimbela abantu basePalestine, kuhlanganise nomthetho. ukusungulwa kwezindawo zokuhlala, ukwenqatshwa kwelungelo lokubuya, udonga lokuhlukanisa, isijeziso esihlangene, ukuthathwa kwe-East Jerusalem, ukubhidlizwa kwezindlu, nokuhlukunyezwa kweziboshwa.
Ezikhathini ezimbalwa, ikakhulukazi mayelana nokuthembela emasikweni okuhlukumeza asetshenziswa eziboshweni zasePalestine, abezobulungiswa bakhombise inhlansana yethemba lokuthi bangase babhekane nesikhalo sasePalestine ngendlela elinganayo, kodwa ngemva kweminyaka engaphezu kwengama-75 i-Israel ikhona kanye neminyaka engama-56. ngokuthatha kwayo izindawo zasePalestine ezathathwa kusukela ngo-1967, leli themba selishabalala ngempumelelo.
Noma kunjalo, ukulawula kuka-Israyeli indaba yezombangazwe eyakha umbono womphakathi kwavumela izwe ukuba libe semthethweni, kuze kugujwe ngamazwi amakhulu ngokuthi 'ukuphela kwentando yeningi eMpumalanga Ephakathi,' futhi kanjalo, izwe elilodwa eMpumalanga Ephakathi lapho iNyakatho nayo. I-America ne-Europe babelane ngamavelu ngokuhambisana nezithakazelo. Empeleni, uBiden waqinisekisa leli candi embhalweni weSimemezelo saseJerusalema esisayinwe ngokuhlanganyela noYair Lapid, uNdunankulu ngaleso sikhathi, ngesikhathi sokuvakasha kukamongameli waseMelika ngo-Agasti odlule. Esigabeni sayo sokuqala, le mizwa iyavezwa: “Ukwabelana kwe-United States ne-Israel kuwukuzibophezela okungaguquki kuntando yeningi…”
Eminyakeni eyandulela ukhetho luka-Israel ngoNovemba odlule kwaholela kuhulumeni womfelandawonye othathwa njengohlangothi olufanele kunawo wonke emlandweni wezwe, uhulumeni wase-United States kanye namaJuda ahlala e-diaspora bebelokhu besezinhlungwini zokungazinaki ukuvumelana okulimazayo kwezinhlangano zomphakathi zokuthi i-Israel inecala lokudala ubandlululo. umbuso ukugcina ukubusa kwawo kwezinhlanga wawucindezela futhi uxhaphaza amaPalestine ahlala e-Occupied Palestine nase-Israel. Ubandlululo luvinjwe umthetho wamazwe ngamazwe wamalungelo abantu, futhi emthethweni wamazwe ngamazwe lubhekwa njengecala elibucayi ngemva kokuqothulwa kohlanga. Abamelene nokucwasa ngokwedlulele kweNingizimu Afrika, okuhlanganisa uNelson Mandela, uDesmond Tutu, kanye noJohn Dugard baye baphawula ukuthi ubandlululo lwakwa-Israel luphatha abantu basePalestine kabi ukwedlula isihluku iNingizimu Afrika eyasenza kubantu abaningi base-Afrika, okwalahlwa yi-UN nakuwo wonke amazwe. umhlaba njengobandlululo olungabekezeleleki emhlabeni jikelele. Izinsolo zobandlululo lwase-Israel zibhalwe ochungechungeni lwemibiko egunyaziwe: Ikhomishana ye-UN Economic and Social Commission yaseWest Asia (2017), Human Rights Watch (2021), B’Tselem (2021), kanye ne-Amnesty International (2022). Naphezu kwalokhu kugxekwa, uHulumeni waseMelika kanye nezinhlangano ezizimele ezisekela u-Israel zigweme ngisho nokukhulunywa ngesimo sobandlululo sombuso wakwa-Israel, zangalinge zivule udaba lwenkulumo-mpikiswano ngokuphikisa izinsolo. Njengoba uDugard asho lapho ebuzwa ukuthi yimuphi umehluko omkhulu phakathi kokulwa nobandlululo eNingizimu Afrika nakwa-Israel, waphendula: “..the weaponization of antisemitism.” Lokhu kufakazelwe ngokuhlangenwe nakho kwami. Kwakukhona ukuphikiswa kwebutho elimelene nobandlululo maqondana neNingizimu Afrika kodwa akuzange kube khona umzamo wokubiza amasosha njengabenzi bokubi, ngisho ‘nabayizigebengu.’
Ngokwale mibono, okusengcupheni kule mibhikisho, ukuthi ngabe i-Israel izophathwa njengentando yeningi engekho emthethweni efana neyalolo hlobo eyakhiwe eHungary nguViktor Orban, ihlanza ikhwalithi yentando yeningi yenqubo ebikade isebenza ku-Israel J.awu kusukela ngo-1948. Inguquko entsha ku-Israel ikhombisa uhlobo lokubusa okukhulu osekukhona kule minyaka eyishumi edlule eTurkey, okubandakanya isilayidi esibheke embusweni wentando yeningi phakathi kwamaJuda. Kodwa-ke kufanele siqaphele ukuthi eHungary noma eTurkey akukho zinhlaka zokubusa ezinjengobandlululo olwavela, nakuba womabili la mazwe anezinkinga ezinkulu ezihlanganisa ukucwaswa kwabancane. I-Turkey sekungamashumi eminyaka yenqaba izimfuno zedlanzana layo lamaKurd zamalungelo alinganayo kanye nombuso ohlukene, noma okungenani inguqulo eqinile yokuzimela. Lezi zigameko zokugxambukela emalungelweni abantu ayisisekelo okungenani azizange zenzeke ngaphansi kohlaka lwekoloniyalizim yezifiki okwathi kwa-Israel kwenze abantu basePalestine abangaziwa, abafokazi bangempela, ezweni labo lapho asebehlale khona amakhulu eminyaka. Ukucwasa ngokwebala akusona ukuphela kwesizathu sokungahambisani nenkulumo yentando yeningi esengozini, ukuphucwa umhlaba kungase kube yikona okubaluleke kakhulu. Ukube abantu bomdabu bebengabuzwa ukuthi bakhathazekile yini ngokuguguleka noma ukushiywa kwentando yeningi 'ezindabeni zempumelelo' zekoloniyali njengeCanada, Australia, New Zealand, kanye ne-U.S. umbuzo ngokwawo ubungeke ube nokuhambisana okukhona manje ezimpilweni zabo. . Abantu boMdabu babengahloselwe ukuba bafakwe egunyeni lentando yeningi elamukele ngokuziqhenya kwamasiko ezizwe. Isiphetho sabo esibuhlungu savalwa ngokushesha nje lapho abahlali bamakoloni befika. Esimweni ngasinye kwaba ukucwaswa, ukuphucwa, nokucindezelwa. Lo mshikashika womdabu ‘wokuphila okungenalutho’ njengabantu abahlukene abanamasiko asebenzayo nezindlela zokuphila abazenzele zona. Ukucekelwa phansi kwayo kufana nalokho uLawrence Davidson akubize ngokuthi ‘ukuqothulwa kohlanga” encwadini yakhe ehlasimulisa umzimba ka-2012, eyahlanganisa nesahluko esigxeka ukuphathwa kuka-Israyeli nomphakathi wasePalestine.
Ngaphansi kokuhlangana kwamaJuda akwa-Israel, okusolakala ukuthi kudalula umhosha ojule ngendlela yokusongela impi yombango kwa-Israel kukhona ikusasa lephrojekthi yamakoloni kwa-Israel. Njengoba labo abafunde ukuphucwa izwe kwezinye izimo zamakholoni abahlali baphetha, ngaphandle uma izifiki zikwazi ukusimamisa ubukhosi bazo kanye nokukhawulela imizamo yobumbano lwamazwe ngamazwe, ekugcineni bazolahlekelwa ukulawula njengoba kwenzeka eNingizimu Afrika nase-Algeria ngaphansi kwezinhlelo ezihluke kakhulu zokubusa kwezifiki. Yilo mqondo ukuthi imibhikisho yakwa-Israel eqhubekayo idinga ukuhunyushwa njengokubhekana kabili. Okusengcupheni ngokusobala ukungqubuzana okubuhlungu phakathi kwamaJuda angokwenkolo nangokwenkolo kakhulu umphumela wawo ohambisana nalokho amaPalestine angalindela ukuba kube isiphetho sawo ukuya phambili. Kuphinde kube nesandla esicacile phakathi kwalabo abathanda ukugcinwa kwamalungiselelo akhona obandlululo ancike ekulawuleni ukucwasa kodwa ngaphandle kokugcizelela ukuthi kulungiswe izindawo kanye nezibalo zabantu kanye nalabo abahlose ukusebenzisa izindlela zodlame ukucisha 'ukuba khona' kwePalestine njenganoma yiluphi uhlobo lwesithiyo ukuhlanjululwa okuqhubekayo kombuso wamaJuda njengokuhlanganisa iWest Bank, futhi ekugcineni kugcwalise umbono ka-Israyeli njengokuhambisana nalo lonke 'izwe lesethembiso' eligonyelwa njengelungelo elingokwebhayibheli lamaJuda njengoba lihunyushwa ngendlela ye-Zionist optic.
Kuyimfihlakalo lapho uNetanyahu, u-extremist, emi khona, futhi mhlawumbe akakasithathi isinqumo. UThomas Friedman, indawo yezulu enokwethenjelwa kakhulu yeZionism ekhululekile ifaka ingcindezi ngesimangalo sokuthi uNetanyahu okokuqala ngqa emsebenzini wakhe omude wezepolitiki usephenduke umholi 'ongenangqondo' ongasathembekile ngokombono weWashington ngoba ukubekezelela kwakhe ukweqisa kwamaJuda kungukubusa. ukubeka engcupheni ubudlelwano obubalulekile ne-U.S. kanye nokulahla inkohliso yokufinyelela isixazululo esinokuthula sokungqubuzana nge-diplomacy kanye nesixazululo semibuso emibili. Izimiso ezinjalo zendlela yenkululeko kade zasetshenziswa yizindawo zokuhlala zakwa-Israyeli kanye nokuthathwa komhlaba ngale komugqa oluhlaza we-1948.
Ngokwepolitiki, uNetanyahu wayedinga ukusekelwa kweZionism Yezenkolo ukuze aphinde athole amandla futhi athole ukwesekwa kwezinguquko zezobulungiswa ukuze agweme ukuthweswa icala mathupha ngokukhwabanisa, inkohlakalo kanye nokukhaphela ithemba lomphakathi. Kodwa ngokwengqondo, ngisola ukuthi uNetanyahu akakhululekile ngesimo esithandwa abantu abafana no-Itamar Ben-Gvir kanye no-Benezel Smotrich njengoba ezishaya. Kumvumela ukuthi asole izenzo ezingcolile ekusebenzelaneni namaPalestine. Ukuze kugwenywe umphumela owesabekayo waseNingizimu Afrika, uNetanyahu ubukeka engeke aphikise omunye umzuliswano wokugcina wokuphucwa umhlaba kanye nokubukelwa phansi kwabantu basePalestine ngenkathi u-Israel eqeda inguqulo enkulu yePhrojekthi yamaZayoni. Okwamanje, uNetanyahu ubukeka egibele womabili amahhashi, edlala indima yokulinganisa maqondana nempi yamaJuda emayelana nezinguquko zokwahlulela, ngenkathi ecwayiza labo abangakufihli ukuzimisela kwabo ukunxenxa umzuzwana. nakba (ngesi-Arabhu, ‘inhlekelele’), igama elisetshenziswa ngokuqondile ekuxoshweni kwango-1948. Kwabaningi basePalestine, i nakba itholwa njengenqubo eqhubekayo kunokuba umcimbi okhawulelwe isikhathi nendawo enokuphakama nokwehla.
Ukuqagela kwami ukuthi uNetanyahu, naye owayeshiseka ngokweqile lapho ekhuluma nama-Israel ngesiHebheru, akakanqumi ukuthi angaqhubeka yini nokugibela amahhashi womabili noma kufanele akhethe maduze ukuthi azogibela ini. Ngemva kokuqoka u-Ben-Gvir kanye no-Smotrich ezikhundleni ezibalulekile ezinikeza amandla okulawula abantu base-Palestine futhi njengabalawuli abakhulu bodlame lwabahlalisa kuyinto engaqondakali ukuthi ucabangele uNetanyahu njengomuntu obhekene nenkinga yepolitiki emaphakathi noma ezithola eyisithunjwa sabalingani bakhe bomfelandawonye. Lokhu akwenzayo wukukuvumela ukuthi kwenzeke, egxeka ilungelo lezenkolo ngokweqisa, kodwa engeneme ngamaqhinga abo okufuna ukuphela okuphumelelayo kwePhrojekthi yamaZayoni.
AmaZayoni angamaLiberal kufanele akhathazeke kakhulu ngezinga lezi zenzakalo kwa-Israyeli ezivusa ngalo igagasi elisha lokuphikisa kwangempela, okuphambene nohlobo lwezikhali u-Israyeli nabasekeli bakhe emhlabeni wonke abebelusebenzisa njengenkulumo-ze yombuso ngokumelene nabagxekayo. izinqubomgomo nezinqubo zombuso. Laba bagxeki abahlosiwe bakwa-Israyeli abanalo nhlobo ubutha kumaJuda njengabantu futhi bazizwa behlonipha ubuJuda njengenkolo enkulu yomhlaba. Esikhundleni sokuphendula ngokujulile ekugxekweni kokuziphatha kwayo, i-Israel sekuphele iminyaka engaphezu kweshumi iphambukisa izingxoxo zobubi bayo ngokukhomba abagxeki bayo nezinye izikhungo, ikakhulukazi i-UN kanye ne-International Criminal Court, lapho bekunezinsolo zokucwasa ngokwebala nobugebengu. kwenziwa ngesisekelo sobufakazi kanye nokulandelwa ngokucophelela ezindinganisweni ezikhona zokubusa komthetho. Indlela enjalo, egcizelela ukuqaliswa komthetho wamazwe ngamazwe, iphambene nokubalekela izinsolo eziqinile kwa-Israel ngokubeka ukuhlaselwa kwabagxeki esikhundleni sokuthobela imikhuba esebenzayo noma ukuzibandakanya ngokugcizelela ngokugcizelela ukuthi imikhuba yabo kubantu basePalestine inengqondo ngenxa ye ukukhathazeka okusemthethweni kwezokuphepha, okwakuyisu eliyinhloko phakathi namashumi eminyaka okuqala okuba khona kwazo.
Ngalo mqondo, izehlakalo zakamuva kwa-Israel ziveza ngokuyingozi amaJuda njengezigebengu ezicwasa ngokwebala ekuziphatheni kwawo kumaPalestine angaphansi, akwenza ngezibusiso zikahulumeni. Udlame olungajeziswa lwabahlali basePalestine luze lwaqinisekiswa yizikhulu zikahulumeni ezifanele njengasekucekeleni phansi ngamabomu kwedolobhana laseHuwara (eduze kwaseNablus). Umphumela oqoshiwe wezifiki ezidansa emgubheni phakathi kwamanxiwa edolobhana ngokuqinisekile uwuhlobo lwe-Kristallnacht, okungeyona eyenzelwe ukunciphisa ukwesabeka kokubulawa kohlanga lwamaNazi, kodwa ngeshwa imema ukuqhathanisa nemibuzo ephazamisayo. AmaJuda angaziphatha kanjani ngodlame olungaka kubantu bomdabu abasengozini ehlala phakathi kwawo, kodwa enqatshelwe amalungelo ayisisekelo? Futhi ingabe lolu hlobo lombukwane oluhlasimulisayo ngeke lushukumisele ngokuhlanekezela amaqembu entsha yamaNazi ukuba asole amaJuda? Empeleni, u-Israyeli ngakho kokubili unciphisa ingozi yangempela yokungavumelani namaJuda kule nqubo yokunamathisela ilebula lapho ingeyona eyakho futhi ngesikhathi esifanayo ivusa inzondo ngamaJuda ngokuhunyushwa okubhaliwe kokuziphatha kwawo okunonya kubantu abahlukaniswe ngenkani ezweni labo lendabuko. . Ngokwenza kanjalo, i-Israel izibeka engcupheni ngendlela engase ilimaze amaJuda yonke indawo, okuwumphumela ongenakugwemeka womhlaba wonke kusukela kulo mkhankaso kahulumeni weNetanyahu wokuhlukumeza kakhulu abantu basePalestine, okuhloswe ngayo ukuzithoba kwabo okuphelele, noma okungcono ukusuka.
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa kuphela ngokuphana kwabafundi bayo.
Nikela