Edward Snowden has become the year’s most visible and mysterious newsmaker. The former NSA whistleblower is in and out of the media, visible but invisible, living precariously in Russia, castĀ offĀ by his country, and desperately seeking asylum and sanctuary in others.
A growing number of nations have turned him down, most recently Germany and Brazil.
Luckily for him, a dedicated media team led by a clever and contentious lawyer columnist Glenn Greenwald has been disseminating his findings, leaking them to newspapers the world over, even while he and his Brazilian boyfriend David Miranda tangle with authorities who are determined to plug the leaks but admit they donāt know what Snowden stole, or how to stop him except with threats that are growing more extreme.
In his most recent interview with Aljazeera, Greenwald says that the US government is continuing to justify its growing surveillance in the name of fighting terrorism.Ā The US, he says, āuses terrorism as an excuse to do almost everything.ā
Officially, the Obamatons are unchanged. On Monday AP reported, āThe White House Monday renewed its demand for Edward Snowden to return home to face trial, after a top spy official floated the idea of an amnesty deal to plug his damaging intelligence leaks.”
Former State Department official John Bolton, as hawkish as they come, said he wants to see Snowden hanging from a tree.
Donāt minimize the seriousness or dismiss these threats as bluster. There are no shortage of covert mercenaries and assassins who may already be hunting him if they believe there is a bounty on his head. All it may take is a āwink and a nod.ā
Snowden also has many backers.Ā The billionaire Pieere Olymdar says he will finance a new media company headed by Greenwald to the tune of $250 million. That hasnāt happened yet, but, reportedly, he has put up $50 million, a sign that Snowden and Company have serious support and some deep pockets to work with.
Now it seems that the government is getting ready to back off its sanctimonious and hard-headed defense of the NSA.Ā Reforms are being promised even as the idea of massive spying, or in current parlance, ādata miningā has been defended and expanded.
Some cynics among us fear that Obamaās strident defense of the agency may be because of what they have on him!
Nevertheless, the disclosures ofĀ NSA outrages have embarrassed the Administration, pissed off allies and adversaries alike, inflamed media coverage and, soon, stimulated an effort to āreformā the project.
This is all happening quickly. There seems to be a trifecta of pressureāon the legal front, pressure from the hi-tech industry, and defections within the government itself.
First,Ā a Federal Judge, Richard Leon, appointed by President Bush no less, issued an opinion excoriating the constitutionality of the NSA practices. He tore into the rationale for the program with both sarcasm and legal advocacy.
Leon wrote, āI cannot imagine a more ‘indiscriminate’ and ‘arbitrary invasion’ than this systematic and high-tech collection and retention of personal data on virtually every citizen for purposes of querying and analyzing it without prior judicial approval. Surely, such a program infringes on ‘that degree of privacy’ that the Founders enshrined in the Fourth Amendment.”
Next, leading technology companies that had been outed for working the governmentĀ began to experience pushback from their own users.Ā Customers that had been pressed to sign bogus privacy agreements Ā began calling and writing the companies to express displeasure.
I know I did, denouncing my AT&T telephone provider who reportedly was being reimbursed by the government for services rendered to the surveillance program. When I challenged them, I was told it was a matter of ānational Security,ā and they could say no more.
Like millions of others I signed dense terms of service documents that I long ago gave up trying to read, and instead just clicked āāagreeā even though I knew it was a scam.
So much for informed consent, but now, many customers are outraged that these companies were giving their private information to the spooks.
As a result, many of the tech companiesĀ are now pressing the government to āreformā their practices.
The Guardian reports the companies were openly dissenting at a recent meeting with President Obama.
“We appreciated the opportunity to share directly with the president our principles on government surveillance that he released last week and we urge him to move aggressively on reform,” they said in a joint statement issued after leaving the White House.ā
Obama had his own reasons to listen as his approval ratings on the issue fell, he has begun looking for face-saving āreformsā!
Suddenly, reform proposals were there, wrapped up in a 300 page document blessed by a group of no less than five intelligence āexpertsā and lawyers.
Reported the NY Times, āA panel of presidential advisers who reviewed the National Security Agencyās surveillance practices urged President Obama on Wednesday to end the governmentās systematic collection of logs of all Americansā phone calls, and to keep those in āprivate hands, āfor queries and data miningā only by court order.ā
Boom, Boom, Boom!
Score one for Edward Snowden whose face already adorns busses in Washington D.C in a campaign accompanied by the slogan āThank You, Edward Snowden.Ā In the eyes of his boosters, he is a hero, not an information terrorist.
The major media outlets that largely denounced Snowden began to realize that their readers want more of his NSA scoops. (Greenwald has said that there are many disclosures to come).
While some media outlets are still aligned with the “intelligence community,” more and more stories about NSA outrages appear in print. The most recent on NSA overreach in Europe was reported by the Guardian, Der Spiegel, and once again, the New York Times that had earlier turned its back on Wikileaks.
More is needed to insure that changes will occur. Higher profile challenges to the surveillance system are coming, along with more parodies and ridicule that in the end may turn the spy guys into a joke without any credibility.
Maybe itās time to unleash actors like Will Ferrell playing Ron Burgandy Ā and his Anchorman 2 movie ānews team,ā now in theaters nationwide, Ā to get on the NSAās case with some Dr Stangelove-like Ā satires ridiculing the house of paranoia headed by General James Clapper, the StrangelovianĀ GeneralĀ Buck Turgidson of our times.
Go āNews Team, Go.
News Dissector Danny Schechter edits Mediachannel.org and blogs at NewsDissector.net. His latest book is Madiba AtoZ: The Many Faces of Nelson Mandela (Http://madibabook.com).
ZNetwork is funded solely through the generosity of its readers.
Donate