Source: In These Times
At the end of NovemĀber, memĀbers of the ColumĀbia UniĀverĀsiĀty-Barnard ColĀlege chapĀter of Young DemoĀcĀraĀtĀic SocialĀists of AmerĀiĀca (YDSA) launched aĀ tuition strike camĀpaign against āāexorĀbiĀtant tuition ratesā which, they say, āāconĀstiĀtute aĀ sigĀnifĀiĀcant source of finanĀcial hardĀshipā durĀing the panĀdemĀic. StuĀdent demands are wide-rangĀing and include aĀ 10% reducĀtion in the cost of attenĀdance, 10% increase in finanĀcial aid, and an amalĀgaĀmaĀtion of demands from disĀparate stuĀdent camĀpaigns, many of which were set in motion long before the panĀdemĀic began. So far over 1,700 stuĀdents have signed aĀ petiĀtion to withĀhold tuition for the Spring 2021 semesĀter and any future donaĀtions to the uniĀverĀsiĀty afterĀ graduating.
ColumĀbia has conĀsisĀtentĀly topped charts as the most expenĀsive priĀvate uniĀverĀsiĀty in the counĀtry, chargĀing over $61,000 a year in tuition and fees, which accounts for nearĀly aĀ quarĀter of the schoolās revĀenue. āāWe just felt like the only way to presĀsure aĀ uniĀverĀsiĀty that is strucĀtured around the profĀit motive would be to directĀly impact their botĀtom line,ā says EmmaĀline BenĀnett, aĀ stuĀdent at Columbiaās TeachĀers ColĀlege and one of the foundĀing memĀbers of ColumĀbia-Barnard YDSA, which sheĀ co-chairs.
Since the panĀdemĀic began, the universityās $11 bilĀlion endowĀment has seen a $310 milĀlion increase while the response from adminĀisĀtraĀtion, BenĀnett says, āāhas been mostĀly empĀty rhetoric around sharedĀ sacrifice.ā
In These Times reached out to the uniĀverĀsiĀty adminĀisĀtraĀtion and did not hear back by the time of pubĀliĀcaĀtion. In aĀ DecemĀber 1Ā artiĀcle in Patch, aĀ uniĀverĀsiĀty spokesperĀson said, āāThroughĀout this difĀfiĀcult year, ColumĀbia has remained focused on preĀservĀing the health and safeĀty of our comĀmuĀniĀty, fulĀfillĀing our comĀmitĀment to anti-racism, proĀvidĀing the eduĀcaĀtion sought by our stuĀdents, and conĀtinĀuĀing the sciĀenĀtifĀic and othĀer research needĀed to overĀcome sociĀetyās seriĀousĀ challenges.ā
BecĀca Roskill, aĀ junior in Columbiaās school of engiĀneerĀing and secĀreĀtary of ColumĀbia-Barnard YDSA, says that the camĀpaign has been careĀful to frame the tuition strike as aĀ means of addressĀing the ongoĀing stuĀdent debt criĀsis and not just worsĀenĀing conĀdiĀtions under Covid-19. āāWe wantĀed to shift the conĀverĀsaĀtion away from payĀing less because of online classĀes and shift the conĀverĀsaĀtion toward aĀ criĀsis thatās emerged from the fact that weāre treatĀing eduĀcaĀtion as aĀ comĀmodĀiĀty in the firstĀ place.ā
LeadĀing up to the strikeās announceĀment, stuĀdents orgaĀnized aĀ petiĀtion for parĀtial tuition reimĀburseĀment (difĀferĀent from the one listĀed above), an email camĀpaign and phone zaps, aĀ presĀsure tacĀtic used to flood office lines, to impress upon adminĀisĀtraĀtors the burĀdens of the universityās excesĀsive costs. Before the start of the Fall semesĀter, aĀ tuition freeze was issued for the universityās two main underĀgradĀuĀate schools, ColumĀbia ColĀlege and the Fu FounĀdaĀtion School of EngiĀneerĀing and Applied SciĀenceāāāconĀcesĀsions that BenĀnett believes were aĀ direct response to stuĀdent orgaĀnizĀing over the sumĀmer. But supĀport for stuĀdents and workĀers across camĀpus, BenĀnett says, has been uneven, and the tuition strike is aimed at much more than just highĀ tuition.
In addiĀtion to lowĀerĀing the cost of attenĀdance and increasĀing finanĀcial aid, the tuition strike has includĀed demands to put an end to camĀpus expanĀsion, invest in the surĀroundĀing West Harlem comĀmuĀniĀty, defund the universityās DepartĀment of PubĀlic SafeĀty (the camĀpus law enforceĀment body), comĀmit to transĀparenĀcy around the universityās finanĀcial investĀments, and barĀgain in good faith with unions onĀ campus.
āWe just felt like the only way to pressure a university that is structured around the profit motive would be to directly impact their bottom line,ā āEmmaline Bennett, student at Columbiaās Teachers College.
āThe stuĀdents orgaĀnizĀing the tuition strike view it as aĀ last-resort tacĀtic to comĀpel the uniĀverĀsiĀty to lisĀten to demands that stuĀdents have been orgaĀnizĀing around for the past few years,ā reads aĀ stateĀment released MonĀday. The tuition strike has received wide supĀport in part by buildĀing coaliĀtions with othĀer groups on camĀpus that have put forĀward their own demands in the past. This includes refĀerĀenĀdums votĀed on by the stuĀdent body, which the demands letĀter says should be respectĀed andĀ enforced.
A refĀerĀenĀdum that was passed in SepĀtemĀber demandĀing the uniĀverĀsiĀty divest from comĀpaĀnies that profĀit from or supĀport Israelās human rights abusĀes against PalesĀtiniĀans was the culĀmiĀnaĀtion of years of orgaĀnizĀing from memĀbers of StuĀdents for JusĀtice in PalesĀtine and JewĀish Voice for Peace. The refĀerĀenĀdum has been all but disĀmissed by the adminĀisĀtraĀtion despite being passed by the stuĀdent body. SimĀiĀlarĀly, adminĀisĀtraĀtors have been slow to respond to stuĀdent demands to divest the schoolās endowĀment from fosĀsil fuels, aĀ camĀpaign that has been waged on camĀpus since 2015. YDSA has been busy buildĀing ties with the camĀpus chapĀters of ExtincĀtion RebelĀlion and the SunĀriseĀ Movement.
The tuition strike has also includĀed demands from MobiĀlized African DiasĀpoĀra (MAD), aĀ coaliĀtion of Black stuĀdent activists on camĀpus that sent its own detailed list of demands to ColumĀbia PresĀiĀdent Lee Bollinger. After spendĀing the sumĀmer mobiĀlizĀing against police vioĀlence, MAD called for the uniĀverĀsiĀty to comĀmit to anti-racism and proĀvide employĀment and affordĀable housĀing to the surĀroundĀing Harlem comĀmuĀniĀty, end the universityās relaĀtionĀship with the New York Police DepartĀment, cut fundĀing from the universityās DepartĀment of PubĀlic SafeĀty and increase supĀport for BlackĀ students.
On DecemĀber 3, mere days after the strikeās announceĀment, Barnard ColĀlege canĀceled its search for aĀ new execĀuĀtive direcĀtor of PubĀlic SafeĀty and announced it would restrucĀture the office to focus on comĀmuĀniĀty safeĀty under the new ComĀmuĀniĀty AccountĀabilĀiĀty, Response, and EmerĀgency SerĀvices office. BenĀnett says MAD has been aĀ major coaliĀtion partĀner, and the groupās demands to repair harm to the surĀroundĀing comĀmuĀniĀty and invest in comĀmuĀniĀty safeĀty soluĀtions are reflectĀed in the tuitionĀ strike.
YDSAās letĀter to the adminĀisĀtraĀtion also includes aĀ demand to barĀgain in good faith with unions on camĀpus for increased benĀeĀfits and comĀpenĀsaĀtion in addiĀtion to proĀtecĀtions for interĀnaĀtionĀal stuĀdents. StateĀments from the tuition strike camĀpaign have emphaĀsized that cuts to cost of attenĀdance āāshould not come at the expense of instrucĀtor or workĀer pay, but rather at the expense of bloatĀed adminĀisĀtraĀtive salaries, expanĀsion projects, and othĀer expensĀes that donāt benĀeĀfit stuĀdents andĀ workers.ā
The GradĀuĀate WorkĀers of ColumĀbia-UnitĀed Auto WorkĀers Local 2110 (GWC-UAW), which has been the recipĀiĀent of strike supĀport and solĀiĀdarĀiĀty from YDSA, will be askĀing its memĀberĀship to pledge their supĀport for the strike. This would include disĀtribĀutĀing tuition strike mateĀriĀals to stuĀdents and conĀtinĀuĀing to teach stuĀdents who plan on withĀholdĀing tuition even if told not to by uniĀverĀsiĀtyĀ officials.
SusanĀnah GlickĀman, aĀ fifth year PhD stuĀdent in hisĀtoĀry at Columbiaās GradĀuĀate School of Arts and SciĀences and aĀ memĀber of GWCās barĀgainĀing comĀmitĀtee, says YDSA and the union have been workĀing closeĀly to supĀport each othĀer. āāItās good that stuĀdents recĀogĀnize that they have some powĀer to influĀence the conĀverĀsaĀtion [around corĀpoĀrate govĀerĀnance], even if theyāre not employĀees,ā GlickĀman said. āāThey probĀaĀbly have more [powĀer] because theyāre the finanĀcial base of theĀ university.ā
Tuition strike orgaĀnizĀers say the idea for aĀ tuition strike preĀcedĀed the panĀdemĀic, but was in part inspired by the UniĀverĀsiĀty of ChicaĀgo where 200 stuĀdents withĀheld payĀments in late April with aĀ numĀber of demands, includĀing aĀ 50% reducĀtion in tuition. By the end of their tuition strike in mid-May, UniĀverĀsiĀty of ChicaĀgo stuĀdents had won aĀ freeze on tuition, which is now over $57,000 aĀ yearāāāāāāsecĀond only to ColumĀbia. Today, the total cost of attenĀdance at the UniĀverĀsiĀty of ChicaĀgo is estiĀmatĀed to be upwards of $80,000 aĀ year when includĀing fees, room and board, perĀsonĀal expensĀes andĀ books.
With over 1,700 stuĀdents signed on, Columbiaās tuition strike next spring could repĀreĀsent the largest tuition strike since 1973, when stuĀdents at the UniĀverĀsiĀty of MichiĀgan withĀheld payĀments in oppoĀsiĀtion to aĀ 24% increase in tuition from the year before. About 2,500 signed up for aĀ tuition strike which coinĀcidĀed with aĀ wave of labor orgaĀnizĀing on the part of teachĀing felĀlows and othĀer gradĀuĀate employĀees. While the stuĀdent tuition strike alone was not enough to win conĀcesĀsions from the UniĀverĀsiĀty of Michiganās adminĀisĀtraĀtion, the GradĀuĀate EmployĀeesā OrgaĀniĀzaĀtion (GEO), which repĀreĀsents gradĀuĀate workĀers on camĀpus, was ultiĀmateĀly able to win aĀ tuition reducĀtion and increased pay and benĀeĀfits through conĀtract negoĀtiĀaĀtions after more than half of underĀgradĀuĀate stuĀdents joined GEO memĀbers in aĀ pickĀet line in FebĀruĀaryĀ 1975.
As stuĀdents conĀtinĀue to mobiĀlize toward next semesterās tuition strike, YDSA orgaĀnizĀers report an increase in memĀberĀship and parĀticĀiĀpaĀtion withĀin their chapĀter, which some believe has been strengthĀened by their abilĀiĀty to orgaĀnizeĀ digitally.
āI think weāve seen aĀ strengthĀenĀing in our comĀmuĀniĀty that we didĀnāt expect to be able to cater to over Zoom,ā says Roskill. āāAnd weāre realĀly hopeĀful that socialĀist polĀiĀtics will proĀvide an answer to the politĀiĀcal quesĀtions that werenāt being answered by Biden or Trump, parĀticĀuĀlarĀly on stuĀdent debtĀ advocacy.ā
IndiĀgo OliviĀer is an In These Times GoodĀman InvesĀtigaĀtiveĀ Fellow.
ZNetwork is funded solely through the generosity of its readers.
Donate