Being a muckracking political writer often makes me feel like a custodian in a horse barn, constantly shoveling manure. Itās a messy, stinky jobĀ ā but on the bright side, the stuff is plentiful, so the work is steady. Indeed, Iām now a certified equine excrement engineer, having developed a narrow but importantĀ Ā professional specialty: cleaning off the horse stuff that careless politicos and sloppy media types keep dumping on the word āpopulist.ā
As you might imagine, in this year of global turmoil, Iāve been especially busy. Populism ā a luminous term denoting both an uplifting doctrine of egalitarianism and a political-economic-cultural movement with deep roots in Americaās progressive history ā has been routinely sullied throughout 2016 by elites misusing it as synonym for ignorance and bigotry:
When right-wing, anti-Muslim mobs in a few European nations literally went to their national borders to block desperate Syrian war refugees from getting safe passing into Europe, most mainline media labeled the boisterous reactionaries āpopulists.ā
Flummoxed elites in Great Britain, frantic over Brexit, blindly blamed their peopleās vote to exit the European Union on the āpopulistā bigotry of working-class Brits.
When in the United States, the unreal reality show āThe Donaldā spooked representativesĀ of the corporateĀ andĀ political establishment, which denied that Trump harnessed public fury toward them, smugly attributed his rise solely to āpopulistā bumpkins who embraced his demeaning attacks on women, Mexicans, Muslims, union members, immigrants, people with disabilities and veterans, among others. Indeed, the power elites sneeringly branded Trump himself a āpopulist.ā
Excuse me, but if that bilious billionaire blowhard is a populist, then Iām a contender in his Miss Universe contest.
Populism is not a styleĀ āĀ and this is important to note in this moment of āThe DonaldāĀ ā nor is it a synonym for āpopular outrage.ā Populism is a historically grounded political doctrine that supports ordinary folks in their ongoing democratic struggle for power over their lives.
This past June, I was pleasantly surprised that out of the blue a major player in this yearās presidential race gave me a big helping hand in cleaning the manure off the democratic ideal of genuine populism. āIām not prepared to concede the notion that some of the rhetoric thatās been popping up is populist,ā said my fellow scrubber. He added that a politico doesnāt āsuddenly become a populistā by denigrating people of other races, cultures, religions and nations.
āThatās not the measure of populism. Thatās nativism or xenophobia or worse. Or itās just cynicism. So I would just advise everybody to be careful about suddenly attributing to whoever pops up at a time of economic anxiety the label that theyāre a āpopulist.ā Where have they been? Have they been on the front lines for working people? Have they been [laboring] to open up opportunity for more people?ā
You tell āem, Bernie! But wait.Ā That wasnāt Sanders. It was Barack Obama delivering an impromptu tutorial on populist doctrine at aĀ June 29Ā press conference.
Granted, Obama himself has hardly been a practicing populist. But he was nonetheless right about what populism is not. He also noted that real populists embrace the inclusive democratic values of egalitarianism and pluralism, which are presently under a ferocious assault by a horde of faux populists led by Trump, Sen. Ted Cruz, and other foam-at-the-mouth immigrant bashers.
While the incitement of anti-immigrant prejudice for political gain is shameful and socially explosive, it is certainly not new or uncommon in our country. Nor is it unbeatable. For more than two centuries, the U.S. has experienced periodic eruptions of such ugliness from within our body politic, yet generations of Americans have successfully overcome the xenophobic furies of their times by countering the bigotry with our societyās prevailing ethic that all people are created equal.Ā And after all, almost all of our families came from somewhere else.
Jim Hightower is a national radio commentator, writer, public speaker and author of the book Swim Against the Current: Even a Dead Fish Can Go With the FlowĀ (Wiley, March 2008). He publishes the monthly Hightower Lowdown, co-edited by Phillip Frazer.
ZNetwork is funded solely through the generosity of its readers.
Donate