In Louisiana, newly disclosed documents reveal a state intelligence agency regularly spied on activists opposing construction of the Bayou Bridge pipeline, which would carry nearly a half-million barrels of oil per day across Louisianaās wetlands. The documents show the Louisiana Governorās Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness regularly drafted intelligence memos on anti-pipeline activists, including a gathering of indigenous-led water protectors whoāve set up a protest encampment along the pipelineās route. Other newly revealed documents show close coordination between Louisiana regulators and the company building the pipeline, Energy Transfer Partners. This comes just one week after a U.S. district judge in Baton Rouge ordered a temporary injunction against construction of the Bayou Bridge pipeline in order to āprevent further irreparable harmā to the regionās delicate ecosystems, while court challenges proceed. For more, we speak with Pastor Harry Joseph of the Mount Triumph Baptist Church. We also speak with Pamela Spees of the Center for Constitutional Rights and Anne Rolfes, founding director of the Louisiana Bucket Brigade.
JUAN GONZĆLEZ: In Louisiana, newly disclosed documents reveal a state intelligence agency regularly spied on activists opposing construction of the Bayou Bridge pipeline, which would carry nearly a half-million barrels of oil per day across Louisianaās wetlands. The documents show the Louisiana Governorās Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness regularly drafted intelligence memos on anti-pipeline activists, including a gathering of indigenous-led water protectors who set up a protest encampment along the pipelineās route.
AMY GOODMAN: Other newly revealed documents show close coordination between Louisiana regulators and the company building the pipeline, Energy Transfer Partners. In some cases, state regulators used language drafted by the pipeline company in its public documents. This comes just one week after a U.S. district judge in Baton Rouge ordered a temporary injunction against the construction of the Bayou Bridge pipeline in order to prevent further irreparable harm to the regionās delicate ecosystems, while court challenges proceed.
Critics of the pipeline include retired Lieutenant General Russel HonorĆ©, who led the relief efforts in New Orleans after Katrina. Heās featured in a new short film by the Louisiana Bucket Brigade about the pipeline.
RUSSEL HONORĆ: Iām Russel HonorĆ©, lieutenant general of the United States Army. I spent 37 years, three months and three days in the United States Army, retired in 2008 as the 33rd commander, and I moved back to Louisiana, my home state. Most people have some reference to me in Hurricane Katrina as the joint task force commander.
LT. GEN. RUSSEL HONORĆ: Weapons down! Weapons down, damn it!
RUSSEL HONORĆ: The state of Louisiana has been blessed with natural resources. We call it the sportsmanās paradise. But weāre the second-largest energy producer in America. That comes at a cost. Wealth from the oil and gas industry has hijacked our democracy.
UNIDENTIFIED: Over time, our wetlands have been destroyed, much by the exploration industry. And, of course, between New Orleans and Baton Rouge, weāve got a hundred chemical plants, all of them trying to do the minimum when it comes to clean air. When you go west from Baton Rouge, you get off into the oil patch. And you work your way toward Lake Charles, which has turned into a production corridor of oil and gas with refineries and chemical plants.
RUSSEL HONORĆ: The other issue we have is pipelines, when you had 170,000 miles already in your state. My big concern with pipelines is, we donāt have the laws, we donāt have the people, we donāt have the regulation, and we donāt have fines and penalties that motivate companies to prevent oil spills. You know how they replace pipeline now? When it breaks. And it breaks in towns, in communities. It breaks out in the swampland. It breaks next to lakes and rivers here in Louisiana. And in the case of this Bayou Bridge pipeline, Energy Transfer Partners do not have a good history. They have multiple spills way too frequently. Itās time for the people of Louisiana to stand up; otherwise, people a century from now will be cursing us because we watched this happen in plain sight.
AMY GOODMAN: Thatās retired Lieutenant General Russel HonorĆ©, who led the relief efforts in New Orleans after Katrina. Other opponents of the Bayou Bridge pipeline include members of the Mount Triumph Baptist Church in St. James, Louisiana.
CONGREGANTS: [singing] Friends donāt treat me like they used to
Since I laid my burden down.
CHURCH ADMINISTRATOR: Freetown is actually a historical black community, which is in St. James Parish on the west bank of the Mississippi River. The actual township was founded after slavery. Iām church administrator, also usher. My mom was baptized here. My grandmother was a member here. So it runs deep. Thirty years ago, we were designated industrial land use area. Currently, there are approximately 118 tanks in this area. We know that the pipelines leak. We know that the tanks do have emissions. We know that it causes cancer. We know you get upper respiratory. We know that there is asthma. We know we have skin irritations, stomach, headaches, you name it.
PASTOR HARRY JOSEPH: The Bayou Bridge pipeline is going to come in. That means that weāre going to have more tanks. We canāt afford to have nothing else in this area. Thatās just going to destroy what we have. I think they have put us underneath the bus. And this aināt nothing new. Itās always the poorest, the black and the Indians or the Hispanics. They just figure they can just walk over people. The few whites that was here, they have been bought out already. Weāre going to be the ones that suffer the burdens.
CHURCH ADMINISTRATOR: They build on top of African-American communities. Well, they donāt expect a fight. And thereās no such thing as this pipeline is never going to leak. Itās going to happen. Itās just a matter of when.
AMY GOODMAN: That piece produced by the Louisiana Bucket Brigades.
And for more, weāre joined by three guests. You saw in that video Pastor Harry Joseph of the more than century-old, more than 130-year-old Mount Triumph Baptist Church in St. James. Anne Rolfes is with us, founding director of the Louisiana Bucket Brigade, which is producing these videos. And Pamela Spees of the Center for Constitutional Rights, senior staff attorney on the #NoBayouBridge project, she also is from Louisiana, from Lake Charles.
Youāre the beginning of the pipeline, and, Reverend, youāre the end of this pipeline.
PASTOR HARRY JOSEPH: Correct.
AMY GOODMAN: Letās begin with Pam. Youāre from there, and youāre bringing this lawsuit. And as we started this piece talking about the surveillance of the activists, people like the reverend, people like Anne, talk about what you have found and the significance of this pipeline project.
PAMELA SPEES: Well, you know, what we found, there are a number of lawsuits that we have filed on behalf of the groups who are opposing this pipeline. And one of them was against the Department of Environmental Quality for these records.
And what was so astonishing to see, probably not surprising for folks who have lived in Louisiana, but the fact of the surveillance, that it was confirmed, that you have intelligence officers in the Governorās Office of Homeland Security who are doing these assessments of these small groupsāright?āwho are doing everything they can to engage in civil disobedience and protest this project and try to stop it, you know, before the permits. And then, you know, those assessments are being sent to all of the other law enforcement agencies and to the heads of the environmental regulatory agencies.
And yet, what we did not see in the emails that we got from this agency is any discussion of the pipeline companyās history of accidents, right? So, here you have a pipeline company which is notorious in the industry for its record of leaks and spills, and yet we didnāt see anything in these records that showed any concern, any discussion about that. And yet, what the concern is, is the folks who are opposing it.
JUAN GONZĆLEZ: Well, the extraordinary record of these emails and the surveillance that you uncovered, itās as if they were like investigating a criminal operation hereā
PAMELA SPEES: Right.
JUAN GONZĆLEZ: ājust because you were opposing the pipeline. Buren āRicā Moore, the intelligence officer who offered the emails, at one point says, quote, āIn the case of terrorism, to wait for an indication of crime before investigating it is to wait too long. There is no guarantee of success, but there has to be a guarantee of effort. Letās make it hard to hurt us. If you see something suspicious, report it.ā Anne Rolfes, what do youāwhen you saw these emails, what was your reaction?
ANNE ROLFES: I do see something suspicious, and itās that Energy Transfer Partners has polluted drinking water around the country. They have a track record of accidents. And thatās what the agencies clearly ought to be investigating, and not regular people who are exercising our First Amendment rights. You know, on the one hand, itās a pretty ridiculous situation, and yet theyāre forwarding a picture of me to the FBI and to the Department of Homeāand to, you know, other agencies and to the National Guard. And then, when I see footage from North Dakota and from Standing Rock of the National Guard, on site, using rubber bullets on people and tear gas, I mean, itās chilling, which is exactly what they intend.
AMY GOODMAN: Now, of course, the Dakota Access pipeline in North Dakota, thatāalso owned by Energy Transfer Partners, as is the Bayou Bridge pipeline.
ANNE ROLFES: Yes, and the Bayou Bridge pipeline is the southern leg of the Dakota Access pipeline. So, itās connected in every way, clearly, including their surveillance techniques.
AMY GOODMAN: And what about the connection of the sheriffs in Louisiana to whatās happening in North Dakota? Youāve spoken about visits.
ANNE ROLFES: Yes. So, thereās a parish called St. Charles Parish, where the sheriff, who is Greg Champagne, was president of the National Sheriffsā Association. And so, he took a trip to Standing Rock to help the Morton County, which is where the pipeline wasāthe Morton County Sheriffās Department, and came back and had a very aggressive Facebook post saying that the people who were objecting to the pipeline were violent, and castigating opponents as people who deserved law enforcement watching them. And so, again, thatās concerning for us. What we then see Sheriff Champagne do is stand in front of a gas pipeline explosion in Louisiana, just shortly thereafter, when a man was killed, saying, āNo problem here.ā Major, major fire in the swamp, but āNothing to see here,ā talking to the news cameras as if this is normal and as if this is OK.
JUAN GONZĆLEZ: And, Pastor Harry Joseph, the impact of, first of all, the overall industry, the energy industry, on Louisiana and specifically on your community, and your concerns about this pipeline?
PASTOR HARRY JOSEPH: Well, we already have a lot of stuff in our area. We have plants, and we have the tank farm already there. And with this pipeline coming in, thatās just telling me there are going to be some more tanks. And with the tanks that they have, they are not very much protected, because there are leaks, and they bleed. And when they bleed those tanks, we breathe whateverās coming out. And what Iām concerned about with this one is that we donāt know what weāre going toāwhatās coming through the pipe. We donāt know what weāre going to be breathing. And we already have peopleālike you heard already, that we are sick. People have got cancer. People are dying with cancer. Nobody wants to take responsibility for what is going on now. So, whoās going to take responsibility for whatās going to go on in the future, you know?
AMY GOODMAN: Talk about what youāre facing right now.
PASTOR HARRY JOSEPH: Well, right now weāre facingālike I said, we are facing that weāre in a community where we donāt have a routeway out if something do happen. We have the Sunshine Bridge, and then we have a little town called Moonshine. And between the Sunshine Bridge and Moontown, youāre talking at least about 30 miles. And between that, theyāve got plants already there. Theyāve got oil field areasāwell, oil tanks. And we have people that live there. We had the land called burden land, which we have between them. That was our exit route. The plant bought that and shut it off. So now people canāt get out if they have to get out. And weāve been fighting for at least twoāat least three years to get a routeway. And our local government canāt give us a routeway.
AMY GOODMAN: Was your community consulted and your church consulted when it came to the building of this pipeline?
PASTOR HARRY JOSEPH: Yeah. Like I said, the community, we all went toāwe went to court. We went to the community. We went to our local meetings. And we went in high numbers to let them know that we didnāt want any of this. But they still voted it in, because in our community we have a seven panel of councilmen, and, in our area, of three blacks and four whites. And when they voted that out, a lot of people was hurting because we had a 4-3 vote. And we just knew we was going to win this battle, but we lost it.
AMY GOODMAN: And the 4-3 vote was along color lines?
PASTOR HARRY JOSEPH: Voting four white and three blacks. And we knew we had it won, because one of the councilmen, in, I want to say, the 3rd District, he asked the question: What comes through the pipe? And they told him that they couldnāt tell him that.
AMY GOODMAN: He said, āWhat oil would go through the pipe?ā
PASTOR HARRY JOSEPH: Through the pipe, and they told him that they couldnāt. The pipeline company told him that they couldnāt tell him. And I knew then that we had won. But at the end, he still voted yeah.
JUAN GONZĆLEZ: And, Pamela Spees, in terms of theāwhat yourāthe way that the companies have worked together with local officials and even the state to craft regulations and legislation on this, could you talk about that, as well?
PAMELA SPEES: Well, I think thereāsāyou know, what weāre seeing in the records is the working together on the approval process for these projects. But we know that thereās a massive lobbying effort and, you know, that the corporate interests, the oil and gas interests, are baked into the political process. Itās justāitās the go-to concernāright?āas opposed to folks showing up and trying to bring a different voice into the discussion. And so, the deck is really stacked. And I think what wasāand thatāsāyou know, for folks who are from Louisiana, who grew up there, itās something that was sort of in the air that you breathed, and you understood that that was the case. But what I think is changing now is that folks are beginning to question it, I think, after the BP spill and watching what happened at Standing Rock. And then the growing awareness about this pipeline and whoās behind it is actually bringing more folks to awareness.
JUAN GONZĆLEZ: And what about the argument that the companies say, that theyāre creating jobs, that theyāre making it possible for the economy of Louisiana to thrive?
PAMELA SPEES: Well, whatās been so interesting about that is what these folks have documented on the job sites, right? So, all of the workers who are constructing this pipeline appear to be from out of state. You know, thatās something that these folks have documented and tried to bring to the attention of Governor John Bel Edwards, who has used this as a rallying point for support for this project.
AMY GOODMAN: I want to turn to clip from CERAWeek, an annual energy conference in Houston. This is the CEO of Energy Transfer Partners, Kelcy Warren.
KELCY WARREN: Youāre talking about somebody that needs to be removed from the gene pool, we had people drilling holes in our pipe, drilling holes. Now, they didnāt know that we didnāt have oil in the pipe at the time, but had they, they would have found out in a very, very bad way. And so, you know, itās just theāweāre combating something thatās relatively new, but itās all of our problems. And we were slow to respond. I think I mentioned to you, Dan, when we talked earlier, that we were slow to respond to social media. We had a CEOāmeāthat was kind of out of touch with that a little bit, behind on that. And we donāt do that anymore. We monitor social media. And thereās constant lies being said about our company that weāreāthat weāre having to police.
AMY GOODMAN: If you can talk aboutāAnne Rolfes, if you can respond to what Kelcy Warren said, the CEO of Energy Transfer Partners, who he was referring to?
ANNE ROLFES: In Louisiana, we are standing up to stop their pipeline. There is nobody who has their hands on the equipment, who is fooling with the equipment. And I think thatās really a distraction from the issue. You know, we understand who the violent party is. And the violent party is Energy Transfer Partners. Yes, some people have taken particular action along publicāalong other pipeline routes to stop the pipeline. That has happened, but that has been very rare. And what we are doing in Louisiana is peaceful civil disobedience that is within our rights. Right? And I should say that, you know, there is a reason people are taking action like that: because the systems that are supposed to be protecting us are clearly failing, as weāre seeing in Louisiana.
AMY GOODMAN: Thereās a protest outside Ciprianiās todayā
ANNE ROLFES: Yes.
AMY GOODMAN: āwhere U.S. Bank is being honored.
ANNE ROLFES: Yes.
AMY GOODMAN: Why?
ANNE ROLFES: Because U.S. Bank is receiving an award for being a good corporate citizen, when in fact they are funding and fueling the violence by Energy Transfer Partners. So weāll be there to encourage U.S. Bank to keep the promise that it once made not to fund the pipeline, because itās their cash flow thatās perpetuating the harm and the abuse in Louisiana. I mean, we have serious violations happening already in our state, where they are going in and chopping down cypress that are hundreds of years old, where they are going into a community that is already overwhelmed by pollution, that is already overwhelmed by racism, and adding to that problem.
JUAN GONZĆLEZ: And, Pastor Harry Joseph, what are you hoping to get accomplished in your presence here and in the continuing protest there?
PASTOR HARRY JOSEPH: Well, Iām hoping somebody listeningāsomebody hear us that we already have enough in our community and we donāt need nothing else, because we have people thatās living there now that are trying to figure out how theyāre going to get out, because people there, weāre not rich, we are poor people, and they have already bought the white out. And we, as blacks, are there wondering what weāre going to do, because weāve got to raise our kids. And we have our children coming up sick. So, they got a lot of people that would love to get out of this community, because there are no other things that are coming in.
AMY GOODMAN: Well, we have to leave it there, but we will certainly continue to follow this story. Pastor Harry Joseph, Anne Rolfes of Louisiana Bucket Brigade and Pamela Spees of the Center for Constitutional Rights.
ZNetwork is funded solely through the generosity of its readers.
Donate