Kukho iingxabano ezimbini ezidibeneyo ezidlalayo ngoku kwa-Israyeli, kodwa akukho nanye, ngaphandle kwe-Western liberal spin, enxulumene nokutshabalala kwedemokhrasi yakwaSirayeli. Loo nkxalabo icingela ukuba i-Israel yayiyidemokhrasi de kwafika iliza lamva nje lenkohlakalo evela kurhulumente omtsha wase-Israel okhokelwa nguNetanyahu 'kuhlaziyo lwezomthetho.' Intetho yomlomo yafihla injongo yesenzo esinjalo, esasikukunciphisa ukuzimela kwenkundla ngokunika i-Knesset amagunya okunyanzelisa intando yesininzi sepalamente yokungahoyi izigqibo zenkundla ngesininzi esilula kwaye isebenzise ulawulo olukhulu ekuqeshweni kweejaji. Ngokuqinisekileyo, ezi yayiziintshukumo zokumisela ulawulo lwe-autocracy olungqingqwa kwa-Israel njengoko luza kuguqula inkangeleko ethile yokwahlulwa kwamagunya, kodwa ingekuko ukutshitshiswa kwedemokhrasi njengoko kubonakaliswe kakuhle ngokuqinisekisa amalungelo alinganayo abo bonke abemi nokuba bangooluphi uhlanga okanye inkolo.
Ukuba liLizwe lamaYuda elinikezela ngoMthetho walo oSisiseko we-2018 ilungelo elikhethekileyo lokuzilawula ngokukodwa kubantu bamaYuda kwaye liqinisekisa ukongama ngeendleko zegcuntswana lasePalestina elingaphezulu kwe-1.7 yezigidi zabantu lijongela phantsi ibango likaSirayeli lokuba yidemokhrasi, ubuncinane ngokubhekisele kubemi bebonke. Kananjalo, abantu basePalestine kudala benyamezele imithetho nezenzo zocalucalulo kwimiba engundoqo eyathi ekuhambeni kwexesha yafumana inkqubo yoburhulumente bayo ichongwe ngokubanzi njengolawulo localucalulo olusebenza kuzo zombini iiNdawo zasePalestine eziHlangeneyo kunye noSirayeli uqobo. Ukuba ulwimi lunwenwele ukuya kuthi ga kwimida yalo, kuyenzeka ukuba uSirayeli athathwe njengedemokhrasi yobuhlanga okanye idemokhrasi yolawulo lobuthixo, kodwa loo magama ayimizekeliso ecacileyo yemimoya yezopolitiko.
Ukususela ekusekweni kwayo njengombuso ngo-1948, i-Israel iwakhanyele amalungelo alinganayo kwigcuntswana layo lasePalestina. Ide yalikhanyela naliphi na ilungelo lokubuyela kuma-750,000 asePalestine anyanzelwa ukuba ahambe ngexesha leMfazwe ye-1947, kwaye banelungelo lomthetho wamazwe ngamazwe ukuba babuyele ekhaya, ubuncinci emva kokuba ukulwa kuphelile. Umlo wangoku okrakra phakathi kwamaYuda enkolo kunye nawehlabathi ogxile kwinkululeko yeenkundla zakwaSirayeli uvela kwiindawo ezininzi zasePalestine zengxwabangxwaba yangaphakathi, njengoko iinkundla eziphakamileyo zakwaSirayeli ukutyhubela iminyaka ziye zaxhasa kakhulu ezona ntshukumo ziphikisanayo kumazwe ngamazwe 'ngokungekho mthethweni' ezithintela abantu basePalestine, kubandakanywa nemfazwe. ukusekwa kweendawo zokuhlala, ukwalelwa ilungelo lokubuya, udonga lokwahlulwa, isohlwayo esihlanganyelweyo, ukuthinjwa kweYerusalem eseMpuma, ukudilizwa kwezindlu, nokuxhatshazwa kwamabanjwa.
Kumatyeli ambalwa, ngakumbi ngokubhekisele ekuthembeleni kubuchule bokungcungcuthekisa obusetyenziswa kumabanjwa asePalestina, inkundla ibonise amasuntswana amancinane ethemba lokuba inokusingatha isikhalazo sasePalestina ngendlela elungeleleneyo, kodwa emva kweminyaka engaphezu kwama-75 yobukho bakwaSirayeli kunye neminyaka engama-56. ngokuthimba kwayo imimandla yasePalestina eyayiphantsi kowe-1967, eli themba liye labhanga.
Nangona kunjalo, ulawulo lukaSirayeli lwengxelo yezopolitiko eyenze uluvo lukawonke-wonke lwavumela ilizwe ukuba libe semthethweni, lide libhiyozelwe ngentetho ye-hyperbolic 'njengedemokhrasi kuphela kuMbindi Mpuma,' kwaye ke, ilizwe elinye kuMbindi Mpuma apho uMntla kunye naye. IMelika kunye neYurophu zabelana ngexabiso kunye nezinto ezinomdla. Ngokwenyani, uBiden wayiqinisekisa le canard kumbhalo weSibhengezo saseJerusalem ngokudibeneyo kunye noYair Lapid, iNkulumbuso ngelo xesha, kutyelelo lukamongameli waseMelika ngo-Agasti ophelileyo. Kumhlathi wokuvula, ezi mvakalelo zichaziwe: "Isabelo sase-United States kunye ne-Israel kukuzinikela okungagungqiyo kwidemokhrasi..."
Kwiminyaka engaphambi konyulo lukaSirayeli ngoNovemba ophelileyo lubangele urhulumente wobumbano othathwa njengowona mbutho wasekunene kwimbali yelizwe, urhulumente wase-US kunye ne-diaspora Jewry bebesezintlungwini zokungayihoyi imvisiswano etshabalalisayo yoluntu yokuba uSirayeli wayenetyala lokubangela ucalucalulo. Urhulumente ukugcina ulawulo lwakhe lobuhlanga wayecinezela kwaye exhaphaza amaPalestina ahlala kwi-Occupied Palestine kunye ne-Israel. Ucalucalulo lupheliswe ngumthetho wamazwe ngamazwe wamalungelo oluntu, kwaye kumthetho wamazwe ngamazwe luphathwa njengolwaphulo-mthetho olunoburhalarhume okwesibini emva kokubulawa kwabantu. Abachasi abaziwayo bobuhlanga obugqithisileyo eMzantsi Afrika, kuquka uNelson Mandela, uDesmond Tutu, kunye noJohn Dugard baye baphawula ukuba ucalucalulo lwakwa-Israel lubaphatha kakubi abantu basePalestine kunenkohlakalo eyenziwa nguMzantsi Afrika kuninzi lwabantu base-Afrika, eyagwetywa kwi-UN nakuwo wonke. ihlabathi njengobuhlanga obunganyamezelekiyo kumazwe ngamazwe. Izityholo zocalucalulo lwakwaSirayeli zibhalwe kuthotho lweengxelo ezigunyazisiweyo: IKomishoni yezoQoqosho neNtlalo ye-UN yeNtshona Asia (2017), i-Human Rights Watch (2021), iB'Tselem (2021), kunye ne-Amnesty International (2022). Ngaphandle kwezi zigwebo, uRhulumente wase-US kunye nee-NGO ze-liberal ezixhasa u-Israel zikunqande nokukhankanywa kocalucalulo lwelizwe lakwa-Israeli, zingenabuganga bokuvula umba wengxoxo ngokuphikisa izityholo. Njengoko uDugard wabonisayo xa wayebuzwa ukuba ngowuphi umahluko omkhulu phakathi kokulwa ucalucalulo eMzantsi Afrika nakwaSirayeli, waphendula wathi: “.. Oku kuye kwabonakaliswa ngokwam amava. Kwabakho inkcaso kumkhosi ochasene nocalucalulo ngokubhekisele kuMzantsi Afrika kodwa akuzange kuzame ukuzama ukubiza aba majoni njengabenzi bobubi, nkqu 'nabaphuli-mthetho.'
Ngokwale mbono, yintoni esemngciphekweni kuqhanqalazo, kukuba ngaba i-Israel iza kuphathwa njengedemokhrasi engekho mthethweni yohlobo olwenziwe eHungary nguViktor Orban, ethomalalisa umgangatho wedemokhrasi yenkqubo ebisebenza ku-Israel J.i-ews Ukusukela ngo-1948. Ujiko olutsha kwaSirayeli lubhekisa kuhlobo lolawulo olukhulu oluye lwesamela kule minyaka ilishumi idlulileyo eTurkey, ebandakanya isilayidi esisingise kulawulo lwe-autocracy lwangaphakathi lwamaYuda. Nangona kunjalo kufuneka siqaphele ukuba eHungary okanye eTurkey akukho zakhiwo zolawulo zocalucalulo ziye zavela, nangona omabini la mazwe anemiba enzima ebandakanya ucalucalulo oluchasene nabancinci. I-Turkey kangangamashumi eminyaka iwakhabile amabango asuka kwigcuntswana layo lamaKurd lamalungelo alinganayo kunye ne-statehood eyahlukileyo, okanye ubuncinci inguqulelo eyomeleleyo yokuzimela. Ezi ziganeko zongenelelo kumalungelo oluntu asisiseko ubuncinci azizange zenzeke ngaphakathi kwesakhelo sobukoloniyali babahlali abathi kwaSirayeli benze abantu basePalestine abasemzini, abaphambukeli, kwilizwe labo apho bahlala khona kangangeenkulungwane. Ubuhlanga ayisosizathu sodwa sokuchasana nengxoxo yedemokhrasi-esemngciphekweni, ukuhluthwa komhlaba kunokuba yeyona nto ibalulekileyo. Ukuba abantu bomthonyama bebenokubuzwa ukuba ngaba banexhala na malunga nokukhukuliseka komhlaba okanye ukulahlwa kwedemokhrasi kubahlali abanje ngempumelelo yobukoloniyali njengeCanada, iOstreliya, iNew Zealand, kunye ne-US umbuzo ngokwawo ubungayi kuba nanto ikhoyo ngoku ebomini babo. . Izizwe zomthonyama azizange zenzelwe ukuba zibandakanywe kwigunya ledemokhrasi elathi ezi nkcubeko zezizwe ezingenelelayo zamkelwa ngokuzingca. Ishwangusha labo elibuhlungu lavalwa nje bakufika abahlali bamathanga. Kwimeko nganye yayiyeyokujongelwa phantsi, ukuhluthwa, kunye nokucinezelwa. Lo mzabalazo wemveli 'wokuphila nje' njengabantu abahlukileyo abanenkcubeko ephilayo kunye neendlela zokuphila ezizenzele zona. Ukutshatyalaliswa kwayo kufana nento uLawrence Davidson ayibiza ngokuba 'yimbubhiso yenkcubeko' kwincwadi yakhe ehlasimlis' umzimba ka-2012, ekwaquka nesahluko esigxeka impatho kaSirayeli kuluntu lwasePalestine.
Ngaphantsi kwendibano phakathi kwamaYuda akwa-Israeli, ekutyholwa ukuba adiza umsantsa onzulu ngokoyikelisa imfazwe yamakhaya kwa-Israyeli kukho ikamva leprojekthi yobukoloniyali kwaSirayeli. Njengoko abo bafunde ukuhluthwa kobuhlanga kwezinye iimeko zobukoloniyali baye bagqiba, ngaphandle kokuba abahlali bayakwazi ukuzinzisa ukongama kwabo kunye nokunciphisa amanyathelo omanyano lwamazwe ngamazwe, ekugqibeleni baya kuphulukana nolawulo njengoko kwenzekileyo eMzantsi Afrika naseAlgeria phantsi kwezicwangciso ezahluke kakhulu zolawulo lwabahlali. Yile ngqiqo yokuba uqhanqalazo lukaSirayeli oluqhubekayo lufuna ukutolikwa njengokujongana kabini. Eyona nto isengozini kukuhlangana okukrakra phakathi kwamaYuda angokwenkolo kunye nakweyona nkolo isiphumo esifanelekileyo kwinto amaPalestine anokulindela ukuba ibe likamva labo ukuya phambili. Kukwakho nentaphane phakathi kwabo bathanda ukugcinwa kwamalungiselelo ocalucalulo akhoyo axhomekeke kulawulo localucalulo kodwa ngaphandle kokunyanzelisa uhlengahlengiso lwemimandla kunye nabemi kunye nabo bajonge ukusebenzisa iindlela zobundlobongela ukucima 'ubukho' basePalestine njengalo naluphi na uhlobo lwesithintelo. ukuhlanjululwa ngakumbi kwelizwe lamaJuda njengokubandakanya iWest Bank, kwaye ekugqibeleni kuzalisekise umbono we-Israel njengoko uphela kunye 'nelizwe lesithembiso' lichazwa njengelungelo lebhayibhile lamaYuda njengoko litolikwa ngendlela yeZionist optic.
Yimfihlakalo apho uNetanyahu, i-pragmatic extremist, emi khona, kwaye mhlawumbi kusafuneka enze isigqibo. UThomas Friedman, eyona ndawo ithembekileyo yemozulu yeZionism ekhululekileyo ilinganisa nebango lokuba uNetanyahu okokuqala ngqa kwikhondo lakhe elide lezopolitiko uye waba yinkokeli 'engenangqondo' engasathembakaliyo ngokwembono yaseWashington ngenxa yokuba ukunyamezela kwakhe ubugqwirha bamaYuda. ukubeka emngciphekweni ubudlelwane obubalulekileyo kunye ne-US kunye nokugxeka inkohliso yokufikelela kwisisombululo soxolo sengxabano nge-diplomacy kunye nesisombululo samazwe amabini. Imithetho elolo hlobo yenkululeko kudala yenziwa yaphelelwa kukuhlala kwamaSirayeli kunye nokuhluthwa komhlaba ngaphaya komgca oluhlaza we-1948.
Ngokwezopolitiko, uNetanyahu wayedinga inkxaso yeZionism yeNkolo ukuze aphinde afumane amandla kwaye afumane inkxaso yohlaziyo lwezomthetho ukuze aphephe ukuthweswa uxanduva lomntu ngobuqhetseba, urhwaphilizo, kunye nokungcatsha intembeko yoluntu. Nangona kunjalo, ndiyakrokrela ukuba uNetanyahu akakhululekanga kwimeko ethandwa ngabantu abafana no-Itamar Ben-Gvir kunye noBenezel Smotrich njengoko esenza ngathi. Imvumela ukuba abeke ityala ngezenzo ezimdaka ekusebenzisaneni namaPalestina. Ukunqanda iziphumo ezoyikisayo zaseMzantsi Afrika, uNetanyahu ubonakala ngathi akanakuchasa omnye umjikelo wokugqibela wokuhluthwa kunye nokujongelwa phantsi kwabantu basePalestina ngelixa u-Israel egqibezele inguqulelo enkulu yeProjekthi yeZionist. Okwangoku, uNetanyahu ubonakala ewakhwele omabini amahashe, edlala indima yokumodareyitha ngokubhekiselele kumlo wamaYuda malunga nohlaziyo lwezomthetho, ngelixa ejongana ngamehlo abo bangazifihliyo kwisigqibo sabo sokuhenda umzuzwana. nakba (ngesiArabhu, 'intlekele'), gama elo elalisetyenziswa ngokungqalileyo ekugxothweni kowe-1948. Kwabaninzi basePalestina, i nakba sinamava njengenkqubo eqhubekayo kunesiganeko esilinganiselweyo lixesha kunye nendawo enokuphakama nokuhla.
Uqikelelo lwam lwelokuba uNetanyahu, naye wayengoobaxiweyo xa wayethetha nama-Israeli ngesiHebhere, akakasithathi isigqibo sokuba angaqhubeka nokuwanyusa amahashe omabini okanye makakhawuleze akhethe ukuba akhwele eliphi na. Emva kokumisela uBen-Gvir kunye noSmotrich kwizikhundla eziphambili zokulawula abantu basePalestine kwaye njengabalawuli abaziintloko bobundlobongela babahlali buyinto engaqondakaliyo ukuthathela ingqalelo uNetanyahu njengohamba engxakini yezopolitiko okanye azifumane engumthinjwa wamaqabane akhe omanyano. Oko akwenzayo kukuvumela ukuba kwenzeke, ukugxeka ilungelo lenkolo ngokugqithisileyo, kodwa engonwabanga ngamaqhinga abo okufuna ukuphela kweProjekthi yeZionist.
IZionist zeLiberal kufuneka zixhalabe ngokunzulu malunga nenqanaba olu phuhliso lwakwaSirayeli luvelisa igagasi elitsha lokuchasana nokwenyani, nto leyo echasene nohlobo lwezixhobo olusetyenziswa nguSirayeli kunye nabaxhasi bakhe kwihlabathi liphela njengepropaganda yombuso ngokuchasene nabagxeki. imigaqo-nkqubo karhulumente kunye nezenzo. Aba bagxeki ekujoliswe kubo bakwaSirayeli abanabutshaba nangayiphi na indlela kumaYuda njengabantu kwaye baziva benentlonipho kubuYuda njengenkolo enkulu yehlabathi. Kunokuba aphendule ngokubonakalayo kwizigxeko zokuziphatha kwakhe, u-Israel uneminyaka engaphezu kweshumi eyiphambukile kwingxoxo yesenzo sakhe esigwenxa ngokukhomba umnwe kubagxeki bakhe kunye namaziko athile, ngakumbi i-UN kunye neNkundla yoLwaphulo-mthetho yaMazwe ngaMazwe, apho izityholo zobuhlanga kunye nolwaphulo-mthetho zakwa-Israel ziye zahlala khona. yenziwe ngokwesiseko sobungqina kunye nokuthotyelwa ngokucokisekileyo kwimigangatho ekhoyo yolawulo lomthetho. Indlela enjalo, egxininisa ukuphunyezwa komthetho wamazwe ngamazwe, iyaphikisana nokungakhathali kwe-Israel ukuphepha izityholo ezibambekayo ngokubeka ukuhlaselwa kwabagxeki kunokuba bathobele izithethe ezisebenzayo okanye ukuzibandakanya ngokubalulekileyo ngokugxininisa ukuba izenzo zabo kubantu basePalestina zifanelekile ngenxa iinkxalabo zokhuseleko ezisemthethweni, eyayiyeyona ndlela iphambili kumashumi eminyaka yokuqala yobukho bazo.
Ngale ndlela, iziganeko zakutsha nje kwaSirayeli zibonakalisa amaJuda ngokuyingozi njengezikrelemnqa zobuhlanga kwindlela aziphethe ngayo kumaPalestina aboyisiweyo, enziwa ngeentsikelelo zikarhulumente. Ubundlobongela obungohlwaywa babahlali basePalestine bade baqinisekiswa ngamagosa karhulumente afanelekileyo njengoko kutshatyalaliswe ngabom ilali encinci yaseHuwara (kufuphi neNablus). Ifoto erekhodiweyo emva kokuba abahlali bedanisa kumbhiyozo phakathi kwamabhodlo elali ngokuqinisekileyo luhlobo lweKristallnacht, engenzelwanga ukunciphisa ukoyikeka kwembubhiso yamaNazi, kodwa ngelishwa imema ukuthelekisa kunye nemibuzo ephazamisayo. Angenza njani amaYuda ngobundlobongela obungaka kubantu bomthonyama abahlala phakathi kwawo, ukanti evinjwa amalungelo asisiseko? Ngaba olu hlobo lomboniso woyikekayo aluyi kuphembelela ngokugqwethekileyo amaqela amaNazi ukuba awalahle amaYuda? Ngokwenyani, uSirayeli ngowokubini uthoba isisongelo sokwenyani sokuchasa abantu kule nkqubo yokuncamathelisa ileyibhile apho ingekhoyo kwaye kwangaxeshanye ivusa intiyo yamaYuda ngeenguqulelo ezibhaliweyo zokuziphatha kwawo okukhohlakeleyo ngakubantu abalahlwe ngenkani kwilizwe labo lokuzalwa. . Ngokwenza ngolo hlobo, u-Israel uzibeka esichengeni ngendlela enokonakalisa amaJuda kuyo yonke indawo, nto leyo eyinto engenakuthintelwa kwihlabathi liphela ukusuka kweli phulo likarhulumente waseNetanyahu lokuxhaphaza ngakumbi abantu basePalestine, ejolise ekungeniseni kwabo ngokupheleleyo, okanye ngcono ukumka.
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa ngemali kuphela ngesisa sabafundi bayo.
Nikela