Ndiyavuma ukuba ndiziva ndonwabile ngenxa yokuba uKen Roth waye waqeshwa njengoMntu oPhezulu kwiZiko leCarr lamaLungelo oLuntu weHarvard's Kennedy School of Government. Emva kokusebenza iminyaka eyi-29 njengoMlawuli we-Human Rights Watch, intlangano ehamba phambili yehlabathi ejongene nokuphulwa kwamalungelo oluntu, uRoth wayefaneleke kakhulu kwaye enelungelo lokuqeshwa. Kwaye ngekhe ndibenayo kodwa ngenxa yokusetyenziswa kwempembelelo yabaxhasi beZionist eHarvard. Ngaphandle kwento enje ngasemva eli ziko lemfundo elihlonitshwayo ngokungathandabuzekiyo liya kuba nebhongo ngobukho bukaRoth. [UChris McGreal, โUHarvard Uvala Indima Yowayesakuba YiNtloko Yokujongwa KwamaLungelo Oluntu phezu kokugxekwa kuka-Israel,โ The Guardian, Jan. 6, 2023] Emva kwexesha elide nelibalaseleyo e-HRW Roth uye waba ngusaziwayo kuluntu. Esi siganeko sesinye isiboniso sokuba kwanawona maziko ahlonitshwayo natyebileyo emfundo ephakamileyo akakhuselwanga ngokupheleleyo kuxinzelelo lweengcamango neengqikelelo zobugorha ezichasene nemishini yawo ayibhengezileyo.
Isigqebelo sokuphathwa kakubi kukaRoth sikhumbula i-anecdote ethile ekhanyayo ebonakala ifanelekile kangangokuba andinakuchasa ukubhengezwa kwayo. Kwiminyaka elishumi edlulileyo bendililungu lekomiti yeengcebiso ye-HRW yalapha eSanta Barbara apho ndihlala khona. Ngenye imini ndafowunelwa ngumhlobo wam owayengusihlalo wale komiti. Uye wandazisa ngokususwa kwam kulo mbutho ngenxa yokungqubana kwemidla okuvela ekubeni ndibambe isikhundla sokuba nguMthetheli oKhethekileyo we-UN wokunyhashwa kwamaLungelo oLuntu kwaSirayeli kwiPalestine eHlangeneyo. Ndiyicinge into engaqhelekanga ukuba lo mgaqo wobuchwephesha, unikwe isicelo sawo esithandabuzekayo apha, bekufanele ukuba ubizwe ngequbuliso kwiminyaka ethile emva kokuba ndithathe isikhundla se-UN, nto leyo eyandikhokelela ekubeni ndijonge ngakumbi ngeyona njongo yokususwa kwam ngequbuliso.
Kwaye ndicinga ukuba ngokungathandabuzekiyo, akuzange kundithathe ixesha elide ukufumana inkcazo eyinyani yokugxothwa kwam. I-UN Watch, i-NGO ka-Israel engoonopopi e-Geneva yakhalaza ku-HRW ukuba kwakungekho ngqiqweni ukugcina kwitshathi yombutho wabo umntu oneembono ezimbi njengam. YayinguKen Roth, ndaxelelwa ukuba ngubani owenze inyathelo lokundigxotha. impendulo, Yintoni eyalandelayo yayinokulindelwa, i-UN Watch yabamba isiganeko ukuba iqhayise ngempembelelo yabo, ibhengeza olu luhlu lwabamnyama 'loyiso' kwiwebhusayithi yabo kunye nokukhutshwa kweendaba. I-HRW yathi cwaka ekuphenduleni, ivumela umbono wokuba ndikhutshiwe kwikomiti yabo ngenxa yentiyo yam. Ndicele ukuba i-HRW ikhuphe isitatimenti esicacisa ukususwa kwam kwikomiti ngezizathu zabo ezichaziweyo, endicinga ukuba sisicelo sesiqhelo, kwaye ndafunda ukuba ixhaswe ngabasebenzi abaphezulu be-HRW, kodwa yaliwe nguRoth. Esi siganeko sibe neziphumo ezibi kubomi bam bezemfundo: izimemo zezifundo ziye zarhoxiswa okanye zarhoxiswa, kwaye ndiye ndafumana iziphumo ezingathandekiyo zokuba โyimpikiswano engamkelekanga.โ
Ngokuzenzekelayo, kwiiveki ezimbalwa kamva mna noRoth savela kwiqela elinye leYunivesithi yaseDenver, ndaza ndamxelela ukuba ndenzakaliswa yindlela okwasingathwa ngayo ukushenxiswa kwam kwiKomiti yeSB, nto leyo eyayinika i-UN Watch izizathu zokubonisa ukuba ndandinjalo. kugqithise kakhulu kwizigxeko zam zika-Israyeli nakwi-HRW. URoth wandityabula ngala mazwi ahlekisayo angalibalekiyoโโakukho mntu uhoyayo okuthethwa yiUN Watch.โ Ngobulungisa, ndiyabuvuma ubugorha obungakhathaliyo obalandelayo be-HRW kwiminyaka kamva ekuzibandakanyeni no-Amnesty International kunye ne-BโTselem ekufumaniseni ukuba u-Israel wayeseke ulawulo localucalulo xa kuthethwa ngabantu basePalestina. [Jonga โI-Treshold Crossed: Abasemagunyeni bakwaSirayeli kunye noLwaphulo-mthetho loCalucalulo neNtshutshiso,โ Human Rights Watch, Aprili 27, 2021; jonga kwakhona ingxelo yangaphambili kaRichard Falk kunye noVirginia Tilley, "Ii-Israeli Pactics Towards the Palestinian People and the Question of Apartheid," UN ESCWA, MRCH 15, 2017.] Kwakuyingxelo enye phakathi kwamakhulu akhutshwe ngexesha elide likaRoth elibangele ngokwaneleyo. umva wenza ukuba uHarvard anikezele.
Ndinqwenela ukuba bekuyinyani ukuba i-smears yi-UN Watch kunye nabantu abacinga njengaye kunye nemibutho baswele amandla abanawo ukuvelisa iziphumo ezingafanelekanga ngokupheleleyo njengoko kunyanzeliswe iRoth. Ndiyakrokrela ukuba into eyakhuthaza uRoth kwimeko yam yayiyilungu leZionist elinempembelelo kwiBhodi ye-HRW. Njengomntwana, ndandimazi uBob Bernstein, umseki we-HRW, njengomhlobo wosapho e-NYC, kwaye ndatya isidlo sangokuhlwa esingemnandanga kunye naye apha eSanta Barbara kwiminyaka embalwa ngaphambi kwesehlo ngelixa wayengummeli ophambili wakwa-Israel kwiBhodi ye-HRW. . Ndifunde ukuba yena kunye namanye amalungu ebhodi babengabaxhasi bakwa-Israel abangenamiqathango nabangazange bakhuphe iinyembezi kunyango lwam kwiminyaka embalwa emva koko.
Amava kaRoth akhumbula umbongo odumileyo wowe-1946 womfundisi wezakwalizwi nomfundisi waseJamani, uMartin Niemรถller, owawubonisa ngokucacileyo iingxaki ezivela kutyekelo lwabantu abakhululekileyo phantsi koxinzelelo lokuncama imigaqo ukuze bafumane inzuzo yemali okanye bavuselele ukuziphatha okuhle. Lo mbongo ngokungathandabuzekiyo waphefumlelwa bubomi bukaMfundisi uNiemรถller, ngakumbi utshintsho ukusuka ekubeni ngumntu othetha ngokungafihlisiyo wamaNazi kwiminyaka yakhe yokuqala ukuya ekubeni ngumchasi ochasene namaNazi owayevalelwe kamva ebomini:
Baqala Beza
โOkokuqala eza kumaKomanisi, yaye andizange ndithetheโkuba ndandingeloKomanisi.
Bandula ke beza kubalandeli bobusoshiyali, yaye andizange ndithetheโkuba ndandingengobusoshiyali.
Emva koko beza kwiimanyano zabasebenzi, yaye andizange ndithetheโkuba ndandingenguye umbutho wabasebenzi.
Emva koko beza kumaYuda, yaye andizange ndithetheโkuba ndandingenguye umYuda.
Baza ke beza kumโkwaye akwasala namnye ukuba undithethelele.
Umfundisi uMartin Niemรถller
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa ngemali kuphela ngesisa sabafundi bayo.
Nikela