Iyo Twitter yakaenzana nevakaroorana vari kupopotedzana, pane imwe yenguva yavo ye Twitter inopfira munyori wepepanhau re Times David Aaronovitch uye Huffington Post Political Editor Mehdi Hasan munguva pfupi yapfuura vakabvumirana. Kupinda kweUS / NATO kuAfghanistan kwaive "UN [United Nations] yakatenderwa", ivo vaviri vakadaro. Asi vakarurama here? Nemauto eBritain achipa zviri pamutemo mauto eHelmand kumauto eUS, zvinoita sechinhu chakanaka kutarisa mamiriro emutemo ekubhomba nekupinda muna Gumiguru 2001.
Yakanyorwa muna 2010, iyo yepamutemo House of Commons Library pfupiso bepa pamusoro penyaya yacho inopa kuverenga kunonakidza: "Hondo yemauto muAfghanistan haina kupihwa neUN, asi yaionekwa zvakanyanya (kunyangwe zvisiri pasi rose) senzira yepamutemo yekuzvimiririra. kudzivirira pasi peUN Charter. " Bepa rinoenderera mberi richitsanangura kuti Chisungo 2 (4) cheUN Charter chinorambidza "kutyisidzira kana kushandiswa kwechisimba kupokana nekuvimbika kwenzvimbo kana rusununguko rwezvematongerwo enyika chero nyika". Izvo zvinogamuchirwa kunze kweizvi ndezvekuti Security Council inobvumidza kuita zvechiuto, kana kwairi kuzvidzivirira pasi peChikamu 51 cheChata.
Sezvinorehwa nebepa, United Nations Security Council haina kubvumidza kurwiswa kwemauto kuAfghanistan. Uyezve, pane chikonzero chekutenda kuti US neUK kutaurwa kweChinyorwa 51 kunofungidzirwawo.
Achinyora mwedzi mukurwiswa uku, Marjorie Cohn, Purofesa weMutemo kuCalifornia Thomas Jefferson School of Law uye aimbove mutungamiri weUS National Lawyers Guild, akatsanangura kurwiswa kweUS neUK se "kushandiswa zvisiri pamutemo kwemauto." Kubhomba kwacho kwaisava nzira yepamutemo yekuzvidzivirira pasi peChisungo 51 nekuda kwezvikonzero zviviri, sekureva kwaCohn. Kutanga, โkurwiswa kwakaitika muNew York neWashington D.C. kwaiva kurwiswa nematsotsi, kwete โkurwiswa nezvomboโ neimwe nyika.โ Chokwadi, sekutaura kunoita Frank Ledwidge mubhuku rake idzva Investment muRopa. Mutengo Wechokwadi weHondo yeBritain yeAfghan, "VaTaliban zvechokwadi vanga vasingazive nezvechirongwa cha9/11, uye zvakaenzana vangadai vasina kubvuma kunyangwe vanga vadaro." Kutsoropodza kwechipiri kwaCohn "kwakanga kusiri kutyisidzira kwekurwiswa nehondo kuUS mushure mekunge. September 11, kana kuti US ingadai isina kumirira mavhiki matatu isati yatanga mushandirapamwe wayo wekubhomba." Michael Mandel, Purofesa weMutemo paOsgoode Hall Law School, ari kubvumirana pane yekupedzisira, achiti "kodzero yekuzvidzivirira isina kubatana haisanganisi kodzero yekutsiva kana kurwisa kwamira."
Kunyangwe kana munhu akabvuma kurwiswa kweWest kwaive pamutemo pasi peChisungo 51, Imba yeCommons Library bepa rinoratidza kuenzana kuri pakati pekushandiswa kwesimba mukuzvidzivirira. โZvinogona kusarangarirwa kuva zvakaenzana kugadzira kukuvadza kwakafananaโ sokurwisa kwokutanga, rinodaro bepa. Kunyora muna Mbudzi 2001, Brian Foley, Muzvinafundo weMutemo kuFlorida Coastal Chikoro cheMutemo, akaramba "uku kurwiswa kweAfghanistan hakugone kumira sekuenderana nekutyisidzira kwehugandanga pavhu reUS." Mushure mekuita ongororo yakarongeka yemishumo yenhau uye maakaundi ezvapupu, Muzvinafundo Marc Herold kubva kuYunivhesiti yeHamphire akawana vanhu vazhinji vakaurayiwa panguva ye 'Operation Enduring Freedom' pane kufa pa9/11.
Zvakare, bepa rekupfupisa reImba yeCommons Library rinoratidza nekusaziva gwara renyaya: "USA ingangove yakawana rutsigiro rwemutemo kubva kuSecurity Council nezvekuita kwayo muAfghanistan, asi pakupedzisira haina kutsvaga Chisarudzo." Nenyika zhinji dzakamira mukunzwira tsitsi padivi peUS, nei US isina kuedza kuwana UN Security Council mvumo yekurwisa kwavo Afghanistan? "Chinodiwa mushure me9/11 chaive chekudzoreredza mukurumbira wehumambo nekukurumidza uye zvine mutsindo", vanopokana Sonali Kolhatkar naJames Ingalls mubhuku ravo. Kubuda ropa Afghanistan. Washington, Warlords uye Propaganda yekunyarara. Achitaura mushure mekunge bhomba ratanga mutungamiri weanopokana neTaliban Afghan Abdul Haq akabvumirana nechikonzero ichi chekurwisa: "US iri kuyedza kuratidza mhasuru yayo, kukunda uye kutyisidzira munhu wese pasirese." Chinhu chekupedzisira nyika iri kuedza "kudzoreredza mukurumbira wehumambo" yaizoda kuonekwa ichiita kukumbira United Nations mvumo yekuita - chiratidzo chechokwadi chekushaya simba kune inoona nyika.
Izvo zvingangove zvisiri pamutemo zvekurwiswa kwe2001 kuAfghanistan kunoramba kuri chimwe chezvakavanzika zvikuru zvezvinonzi 'hondo yekutyisa'. Hapana kuongororwa kwakajeka kunodiwa - kungova tsika yehungwaru uye kutapanhau kunotungamirwa nemakambani uko (kunowanzopisa) nhaurirano mukati mechikamu chakatetepa chemiganhu yechokwadi uye yepfungwa. Asi kunyange zvazvo zvichida kwakarurama kukanganwira avo vakarasikirwa nemasimba avo akakomba mumazuva iwayo emanzwiro akakwirira pakarepo mushure me9/11, tinofanira kutonga sei kusaziva kwevatapi venhau vaviri vakahwina mubairo vanodzokorora hunyengeri hwepamutemo makore gumi nematatu gare gare?
Ian Sinclair munyori akazvimirira anogara muLondon uye munyori we Iyo Kurume Yakazunza Blair: Nhoroondo Yemuromo ye15 Kukadzi 2003, rakabudiswa nePeace News Press. Anogona kubatika pa [email inodzivirirwa] uye https://twitter.com/IanJSinclair.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta