Kunobva: The Intercept
Imwe yezvinonyadzisa nhau dzehutori venhau dzenguva yaTrump akatamba musi waZvita 8, 2017, kutanga paCNN uyezve paMSNBC. Chiratidziro chakatanga neChishanu mangwanani na11 am apo CNN, ichishandisa mimhanzi yayo inonzwika uye magirafu akagadzirirwa kuratidza kuti zvechokwadi bhomba rakanga rava kuda kudonhedzwa, rakazivisa kuti masosi asingazivikanwe akange apa network nepfuti yekuputa zvichiratidza kurangana kwaTrump / Russia zvachose: Munguva yemushandirapamwe we2016, Donald Trump Jr. akange agamuchira email yaGunyana 4 ine kiyi yakavanzika izvo zvakamupa enderera upindo kumaseva eWikiLeaks ane maemail eDNC ayo boka raizozoburitsa kune veruzhinji mazuva gumi gare gare. Nhau dzetambo uye online midhiya yakangoerekana yapiswa, sezvavanowanzoita, mukukatyamadzwa, kushushikana uye kutya pamusoro pehumbowo uhu hwekuti WikiLeaks naTrump vaive mune cahoots.
CNN yakave nechokwadi chekuti hapana mavhidhiyo emhemberero aripo paYouTube kuti chero munhu aone. Imhaka yekuti kutaura kwacho kwaive kwenhema zvachose mukuremekedza kwayo kwakakosha. CNN yakataura zvisizvo zuva rekuputa email kwaTrump Jr.: Pane kutumirwa kwaari munaGunyana 4 - mazuva gumi. mushure kune WikiLeaks 'kuburitswa pachena, nekudaro kugonesa kupinda muchivande - iyo email yakangotumirwa nenhengo yeruzhinji. pashure kuburitswa kwevanhu neWikiLeaks (Gunyana 14), vachikurudzira Trump Jr.
Kunyangwe iyo yekutanga nhema rondedzero isingagone kutariswa zvakare (kunze kwezvimedu zvidiki kubva kune mamwe ma network, kunyanya Fox, vachikurukura nezvekupokana kweCNN), munhu anogona kuona vhidhiyo inokonzeresa yemutori wenhau mukuru weCNN Manu Raju achitsanangura, mushure meWashington Post. akademba nyaya, kuti "tiri kururamisa" kutaura, tichiita nepaanogona napo kuti tidzikisire chaive kukanganisa kukuru uku (kunyangwe zvinhu zvese zvakanaka, mutsara wandinoda ndipo apo Raju anoti, pasina kushomeka kushoma," Izvi zvinoita sezviri kuchinja. manzwisisiro enyaya iyi,” zvichiteverwa ne, “Zvichida manzwisisiro ekutanga ekuti iyi email yaive yei, pamwe haina kukosha kubva pane zvatinoziva iye zvino”):
The CNN peji iyo yakatanga kuburitswa iyo blockbuster nyaya ine uku kururamisa kwakakosha kumusoro:
Washington (CNN) Kururamisa: Nyaya iyi yakagadziridzwa kuti itaure kuti zuva reemail raiva September 14, 2016, kwete September 4, 2016. Nyaya yacho yakashandurawo musoro wenyaya uye yakabvisa tweet kubva kuna Donald Trump Jr., uyo akatumira shoko pamusoro peWikiLeaks munaSeptember. 4, 2016.
Saka kukanganisa kunoitika munhau, kunyangwe hombe uye zvinonyadzisa. Kunze kweimwe petty schadenfreude, nei izvi zvakakodzera kuyeuka? Chikonzero ndechekuti chiitiko chehurombo chinoratidza nzira yakajairika asi ine hutsinye hwehunyengeri hwevatori venhau.
Nguva pfupi yapfuura CNN akafumura nyaya yaro yenhema, mutauriri wesangano rehungwaru reMSNBC Ken Dilanian akaenda pamhepo ndokutaura achifemereka kuti akange awana. independent chisimbiso kuti nyaya yeCNN yaive yechokwadi. Mune a vhidhiyo chikamu ini handikwanise kukurudzira zvakanyanya zvakakwana, Dilanian akaunzwa naHallie Jackson akafara zvisingaite - uyo akakurudzira Dilanian kuti "tiudze zvatichangobva kudzidza," achiwedzera, "Ndinoziva kuti iwe nevamwe vatinoshanda navo makasimbisa mamwe emashoko aya: Chii?" Dilanian akabva aenderera mberi nekutsanangura zvaainge adzidza.
Ndizvozvo, Hallie. Zvinyorwa zviviri zvine ruzivo rwakananga nezveizvi zviri kutiudza kuti vaongorori vekongiresi vakawana email kubva kumurume anonzi "Mike Erickson" - zviri pachena kuti havazive kana ndiro zita rake chairo - vachipa Donald Trump nemwanakomana wake Donald Trump Jr. WikiLeaks zvinyorwa. … Zvinoenda pamwoyo wemubvunzo wekunyepedzera. … Mumwe wemibvunzo mikuru ndewekuti: [Trump Mudiki] akafonera FBI?
Izvozvo zvingaitika sei? MSNBC yaigona sei kutaura simbisa nyaya yenhema kubva kuCNN? Nguva pfupi yapfuura, CBS News zvakare inonzi "yakasimbisa" iyo imwe nyaya yenhema: kuti Trump Jr. akagamuchira ruzivo rwepamusoro kune zvinyorwa zveWikiLeaks. Chinhu chimwe kuti mushambadzi wenhau aite chikanganiso mukutaura, semuenzaniso, kusarevera zvisizvo zuva reemail nekudaro kuita kuti nyaya yacho ive isiriyo zvachose. Asi zvinogoneka sei kuti zvimwe zvitoro zvakawanda zvinogona "kusimbisa" chirevo chimwe chete chenhema?
Zvinogoneka nekuti nhepfenyuro dzenhau dzakamonyanisa zvachose izwi rekuti "kusimbisa" kupfuura kuzivikanwa kwese. Zvirokwazvo, ivo zvino vanoishandisa kureva zvakapesana chaizvo nezvazvinoreva, nekudaro vachizvikwevera mumbiri yenhau yavasina kuwana uye, zvakatonyanya, kunyengedza veruzhinji kuti vatende kuti chirevo chisina kusimbiswa, chave chichiratidzwa. Neiyi nzira yekusaziva, vari kuita zvakapesana chaizvo nezvinofanirwa kuitwa nevatapi venhau, pahwaro hwayo: kupatsanura chokwadi kubva mukufungidzira.
Neiyi nzira yekusaziva, vari kuita zvakapesana chaizvo nezvinofanirwa kuitwa nevatapi venhau, pahwaro hwayo: kupatsanura chokwadi kubva mukufungidzira.
CNN pakupedzisira akapomera manyuko aro asingazivikanwi nekuda kwechikanganiso ichi, asi akaramba kuvaburitsa nekusimbirira kuti yaive neimwe nzira kukanganisa kwekutenda kwete nemaune disinformation (sei "kutenda kwakanaka" kwakawanda "kwakaverenga netsaona" zuva reemail nenzira imwechete? CNN, mweya wenhau dzinoramba kupa kuzvidavirira uye kubuda pachena kwavanoda kubva kune vamwe, anoramba kusvika nhasi chaiye kutaura mubvunzo iwoyo).
Asi zviri pachena ndezvekuti "kusimbisa" iyo MSNBC neCBS yavakati yaive yawana yenyaya iyi chaive chinhu asi: Zvese zvakaitika ndezvekuti mamwe masosi akazevezera izvi zvisingazivikanwe. zvirevo zvisina kusimbiswa, zvenhema kuCNN yakabva yaenda ndokudzokorora zviya zvisina kusimbiswa, zvenhema zvirevo kune zvimwe zvitoro, izvo zvakabva zvataura kuti "vakazvimiririra vakasimbisa" nyaya kunyangwe ivo vasina kuita chinhu chakadaro.
Zvinoita sokuti nzira imwe chete inotsausa iye zvino ari kutyaira zvakanyanya mbeveve asi zvinopedza zvese nhau kutenderera kwakanangana nekuti Mutungamiriri Trump, sekutanga kutaurwa nemupepeti-mukuru weAtlantic Jeffrey Goldberg, akataura zvinozvidza nezveMauto. Goldberg anoti "vanhu vana vane ruzivo rwekutanga rwenhaurirano zuva iro" - avo magazini anoramba kudoma zita nekuti vanotya "matweets akatsamwa" - vakamuudza kuti Trump akataura izvi. Trump, pamwe nevaimbove vabatsiri vaivepo zuva iroro (kusanganisira Sarah Huckabee Sanders uye John Bolton), kuramba kuti mushumo ndeyechokwadi.
Saka isu tine masosi asingazivikanwe anoita zvichemo kune rimwe divi, uye VaTrump nevaimbova vabatsiri (kusanganisira Bolton, zvino mutsoropodzi waTrump ane hutsinye) vachisimbirira kuti nyaya iyi haina chokwadi. Pamusoro pekusarudza kuti votenda here kana kusatenda nyaya yaGoldberg zvichibva pane zvinofambisira mberi zvido zvezvematongerwo enyika, munhu angagadzirisa sei kupokana kwechokwadi? Kana mamwe ma media enhau aigona simbisa zvirevo zvepakutanga kubva kuGoldberg, izvo zvingave zviri pachena kufambira mberi kwakakosha kwenyaya.
Mamwe ma media enhau - kusanganisira Associated Press uye Fox News - ikozvino vanoti vakaita izvo chaizvo: "vakasimbisa" nyaya yeAtlantic. Asi kana munhu akatarisa zvavakaita chaizvo, pane izvo “simbiso” iyi inosanganisirwa nazvo, zvinopesana neizvo izwi irori raizoreva, kana kuti rinofanira kureva, munzira ipi neipi ine mutoro. AP, semuenzaniso, inongotaura kuti "mukuru weDziviriro weDhipatimendi ane ruzivo chairwo rwezviitiko uye mukuru weUS Marine Corps akaudzwa nezvezvakataurwa naTrump akasimbisa mamwe emashoko kuThe Associated Press," Fox achingoti "aimbove. mukuru mukuru wehutongi hwaTrump anga ari kuFrance achifamba nemutungamiri wenyika muna Mbudzi 2018 akasimbisa zvimwe nezverwendo urwu. "
Mune mamwe mazwi, zvese zvingangoitika ndezvekuti masosi mamwe chete aiti kuna Jeffrey Goldberg, pasina humbowo, kuti Trump akati izvi zvakaenda kune zvimwe zvitoro uye akadzokorora zvirevo zvakafanana - zano rimwe chete rakagonesa MSNBC neCBS kuti vataure " yakasimbisa" nyaya yenhema yeCNN pamusoro paTrump Jr. achiwana mukana wepamusoro kudura reWikiLeaks. Kana kuti pamwe aive akasiyana masosi anoenderana neaya ekutanga masosi uye kugovera ajenda yavo vakadzokorora zvirevo izvi. Tichifunga kuti hapana chero masosi anoita zvirevo izvi ane ushingi hwekuzvizivisa ivo, nekuda kwekutya kwavo matweets anoreva, hazvibviri kuziva.
Asi chero zvakaitika, hapana AP kana Fox vakawana chero chinhu chakafanana ne "kusimbisa." Vakangonzwa zvirevo zvakafanana zvakanzwiwa naGoldberg, vangangove kubva kumadenderedzwa mamwe chete kana vasiri vanhu vakafanana, uye vari kushandisa zvisizvo izwi rekuti "kusimbisa" kureva "zvisimbiso zvisingabvumirwe" kana "zvisingabvumirwe zvirevo" (chokwadi, Fox zvino anoti "mbiri. masosi aive parwendo achipokana naTrump akaramba thesis huru yekushuma kweThe Atlantic ").
Zvinofanira kuenda pasina kutaura kuti hapana chimwe cheizvi chinoreva kuti VaTrump havana kutaura mashoko aya kana mamwe akafanana navo. Akaita zvirevo zveruzhinji munguva yakapfuura izvo zvinenge zviri muchadenga chakafanana nezvakataurwa neAtlantic, uye zvinotendwa kuti angadai akataura chimwe chinhu chakadai (kunyangwe munhu wekupedzisira anofanirwa kuvimbwa nechero chinhu, kunyanya kududzira zvirevo kubva kusingazivikanwe masosi, ndiJeffrey Goldberg, akasimuka kusvika kune imwe yeanonyanya kukosha mukutapa nhau kunyangwe - kana, zvakanyanya nekuda kwe - imwe yezvinonyadzisa zvikuru uye zvinyorwa zvinokuvadza zvekuparadzira disinformation mukushandira Pentagon uye intelligence community's agenda).
Asi kutapa nhau hakufanirwe kuve kwakavakirwa pakuti chimwe chinhu “chinotendwa” kana kuti “chinoita sechingave chokwadi.” Chinangwa chayo chikuru, chinhu chega chinoita kuti ive yakakosha kana kukosha, kutaura chii is chokwadi, kana kuti chii umboo inoratidza. Uye basa iroro rinokanganiswa zvachose apo vezvenhau vanoti "vakasimbisa" chirevo chekare apo hapana chavakaita kunze kwekungotaura nevanhu vakafanana avo vasingazivikanwe zvinhu zvakafanana kwavari sezvakazevezerwa kune yekutanga.
Kunze kweiyi nyaya chaiyo yekuti Trump anoda The Troops, kupesanisa pfungwa yakakosha yevatapi venhau ye "kusimbisa" ne "kunzwa makuhwa mamwe chete asina maturo" kana "zvisina kuvimbiswa" ibasa guru. Icho chishandiso chekuparadzira, kwete kushuma. Uye kushandiswa kwayo kwakaramba kuchinyengera pane kuzivisa vanhu. Chero ani zvake anopokana izvozvo anofanira kuongorora kuti zvakamira sei kuti MSNBC neCBS vese vakati "vakasimbisa" chirevo cheCNN icho chakazove chenhema uye nekuseka. Zviripachena, izwi rekuti “kusimbisa” rakarasa zvarinoreva munhau.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta