Kunobva: The Intercept
The New York Times Guild, mubatanidzwa wevashandi vebepa rekodhi, tweeted kutongwa neSvondo yemumwe wavo, munyori wenhau Bret Stephens. Kutsoropodza kwavo kwakakanganiswa nemaitiro anonyadzisa uye zvakatonyanya zvakadaro nezvinosemesa uye zvine hutongi hwezvido zvekuongorora uye kukwidza zvichemo kuvatungamiriri kuti vatevedzere "mitemo" yekambani kune vamwe vatori venhau. Kutaura kuti izvi zvinoshamisa maitiro kubva kumubatanidzwa yevatori venhau, pavanhu vese, ndeyekurerutsa nyaya yacho zvinosiririsa.
Chatsamwisa mubatanidzwa nhasi was an yakanyorwa naStephens neChishanu iyo yakataura kushoropodza kwakawanda kwekuhwina Mubairo wePulitzer "1619 Project,โ rakabudiswa gore rapfuura neNew York Times Magazine uye richitungamirirwa nemutori wenhau Nikole Hannah-Jones. Imwe yenharo huru dzeProjekiti yakataurwa nemutongo wakadzimwa-chinyararire wakausuma: "kuti zuva rekuzvarwa renyika" harisi 1776, sezvagara zvichitendwa nevakawanda, asi mukupera kwa1619, apo, chinyorwa chinoti, varanda vekutanga veAfrica vakasvika pavhu reUS.
Zvisinei nePulitzer, iyo "1619 Project" yave gakava rinopisa rezvematongerwo enyika uye rezvedzidzo, nehutongi hwaTrump huchida block kuedza kubatanidza zvirevo zvaro muzvidzidzo zvechikoro, nepo nyanzvi dzakawanda dzenhoroondo mhosva kumonyanisa chokwadi chenhoroondo, nevamwe, vakadai seBrown University's Glenn Loury, kudaidzira kuPulitzer Board kuti ikanzure mubayiro wayo. Nyanzvi dzakaitawo kutsoropodzwa nezwi The Times for stealth edits yezvinyorwa zvakakosha zvechinyorwa nguva refu mushure mekuburitswa, pasina kana kucherechedza kune vaverengi kuti yakaita shanduko huru idzi ndoda kutsanangura kuti sei yakazviita.
Muchidimbu, gakava rezvematongerwo enyika, renhoroondo, uye renhau pamusoro pePurojekiti ye1619 rave gakava guru. Muchikamu chake cheChishanu, Stephens akataura gakava iri nekutanga kucherechedza zvipo zvakanaka zveProjekiti uye zvakaitwa, ndokuzoongorora zvakadzama kutsoropodza kwevanyori venhoroondo nedzimwe nyanzvi dzezvainotaura pakati, uye ndokutsigira vatsoropodzi varo nekukakavara kuti "nekuda kwese kunaka kwayo. , buzz, spinoffs uye Mubairo wePulitzer - iyo 1619 Project yakundikana.
Pasina kuyera pamusoro pezvakanakira kushoropodzwa kwaStephens, kumwe kwandinobvumirana nazvo uye kumwe kwandisingaite, hazvigone kupokana kuti kukurukura kwake iyi gakava rine simba rakawanda riri mukati mebasa rake semunyori wezvematongerwo enyika. bepanhau renyika. Stephens pachake akatsanangura kuti akatora danho risina kujairika rekutsoropodza basa remushandirwi wake nekuti "Projekti ye1619 yave, pamwe nemagadzirirwo ayo uye pamwe nekuda kwezvikanganiso zvinodzivisika, nzvimbo yemhando yegakava guru renyika rinofanirwa kuvharwa nevanyori venhau. ,โ tichipikisa kuti kunzvenga kunyora nezvazvo tichiva neruremekedzo โkukanganisa basa reduโ rokutora rutivi mumakakatanwa makuru enzanga.
Asi vamwe vake muNew York Times Guild sezviri pachena havatendi kuti aive nekodzero ipi neipi yekutaura maonero ake pamagakava aya. Zvirokwazvo, vakatsamwa kuti akaita saizvozvo. Mune tweet isina kuverenga iyo kwete kamwe chete asi kaviri vakatadza kupereta izwi rekuti โzvayoโ seโndizvoโ - kwete nhanho yekusaziva kwevanyori vebepanhau rine mukurumbira pasi rose - mubatanidzwa wacho wakashora Stefano uye bepa pacharo nezvikonzero izvi:
Iyo ipfupi tweet, sematweets anoenda, asi ivo vakakwanisa kurongedza nezvakawanda zvisirizvo, manyepo, uye zvisungo zvakajairwa nemudzvinyiriri. Pamusoro pezvimwe zvese, chirevo ichi, uye hunhu hwachinoratidza, hahuna hukama hwakadzama.
Kutanga, iyi inyaya yevatapi venhau vanoshandisa mubatanidzwa wavo kuti vasade rusununguko rwakakura rwekunyora kana rusununguko rwevatapi venhau - chimwe chinhu chaungatarisira kubva kumubatanidzwa wevatori venhau - asi vachida zvinopesana: kuti vanyori veNew York Times varambidzwe nevatungamiriri. kubva pakutaura maonero avo uye maonero avo pamusoro pemakakatanwa akapoteredza 1619 Project. Nemamwe mazwi: Vari kuda kuti vavanotamba navo vanyaradzwe uye vaongororwe. Vatapi venhau verudzii vanoteterera manejimendi kuti varambidze zvakanyanya kutaura kwevatapi venhau kwete kushoma?
Sezviri pachena, mhinduro ndeyeNew York Times vatori venhau. Zvirokwazvo, aka hakasi kekutanga vachiteterera pachena manejimendi emakambani kuti adzivise rusununguko rwekutaura uye rusununguko rwekupepeta rwevamwe vavo vatori venhau. Pakupera kwaChikunguru, Sangano rakaburitsa zvakateerana, chimwe chazvo yaive yekuti "kunzwa kuverenga kunofanirwa kuitika pakutanga kwekuburitswa, nemubhadharo kune vanozviita."
Kune avo vasina kujairana ne "sensitivity kuverenga": zvione uine rombo rakanaka. Sezvakaita New York Times pachayo yakashuma muna 2017, โvaverengi vanonzwisisaโ vakashandiswa nevabudisi vemabhuku kuti vatsigire mabhuku akatsoropodzwa, kuitira kuti โvaone rondedzero yemafungiro akaipa uye kuchinja kunokarakadzwa.โ The Guardian yakatsanangurwa muna 2018 kuti "vaverengi vanonzwisisa" iindasitiri iri kukura nekukurumidza munyika yekutsikisa bhuku kubvisa chero rusaruro rwuri pachena kana zvinhu zvinopokana - kwete munganonyorwa chete asi kunyangwe muvatambi. Yakatora munyori Lionel Shriver nezve njodzi dziri pachena: pane, akadaro, "mutsara mutete pakati pekubatanidza nezvinyorwa kune chero chinhu chingave chinopesana nemapoka madiki uye censorship yezvematongerwo enyika."
Sezvinotyisa sekuti "vaverengi vanonzwisisa" ndezvekunyora kwengano uye mamwe minda yekutsikisa, ine muchetura usingatsananguriki kune. journalism, izvo zvinongobvunza kana kukwenya pane kukotamira zvitsvene zvinokosheswa zvikuru. Kuti zvive zvakakosha, zvinofanirwa kuburitsa zvinyorwa - zvekushuma uye zvidimbu zvemaonero - izvo zvinogona "kupokana" kune ese marudzi emapoka ane simba, kusanganisira ehutsika hegemonic liberals.
Asi iri ibasa iro New York Times Union inoda kwete kungodzivirira kuzadzisa ivo pachavo asi, zvakatoipisisa, kuramba vamwe vatori venhau. Vanoshuva runyoro rutsva rwekunyora hoop-kusvetuka kuti ribudiswe, inorema, inodzvanyirira itsva protocol yekudhirowa mitsara inomanikidza kutenderedza izvo zvinogona uye zvisingagoni kutaurwa kunze kwezvirambidzo zvakatotemerwa neyakajairwa orthodoxies yeTimes uye yavo. toni-flattening zvinyorwa zvinorambidzwa.
Kana vatapi venhau vachishandisa masangano avo zvisirizvo kuti vasade mihoro iri nani, kukwidziridzwa, kuchengetedzeka kwemabasa kana rusununguko rwakakura rwevatapi venhau asi sechimbo chekutsoropodza vavanoshanda navo vevatori venhau, ipapo pfungwa yemubatanidzwa - uye kutapa nhau - yakatsveyamiswa.
Kozotiwo tattletale petulance yakaiswa muchichemo cheMubatanidzwa. Mukuda kutevedzerwa kwe "mitemo" yepabasa nemaneja pamusoro pemumwe mutori wenhau - havatsanangure kuti ndeupi "mutemo" unonzi Stephens akatyorwa - nhengo dzemubatanidzwa idzi dzinonzwika semamaneja anobatsira vanhu kana vazivisi vepabasa kupfuura zvavanoita vatori venhau vasina hunhu. Kubva rinhi masangano erudzi rwupi zvawo, asi kunyanya masangano evatori venhau, akabatana achigununโuna kuti vatungamiri vemakambani nevakuru vavo vapepeta too lax mukutevedzwa kwemitemo inodzora izvo vadiki vavo vanogona uye vasingagone kutaura?
Hunyengeri hwechichemo cheMubatanidzwa hunenge hwakanyanya kujeka zvekusatombonetsa kuburitsa, uye ndicho chidiki chezvivi zvayo. Nhengo dzemubatanidzwa dzinoshoropodza Stephens nebepa ne "kutevera mumwe wavo" uyezve, mukufema kunotevera, vonyomba paruzhinji koramu yevanoshanda navo nekuti, mumaonero avo erudite, "inodedera." Uyu ndiwo mubatanidzwa mumwe chete une nhengo, mwedzi mishoma yadarika, dzakaratidzira kuratidzira kwemazuva mazhinji - kwaiitika veruzhinji - nehasha nekuti mupepeti weOpinion Editor webepa, James Bennet, akaburitsa chinyorwa na. US Senator Tom Cotton achikurudzira kutumirwa kwemauto eUS kuti adzivise kuratidzira nemhirizhonga mumaguta eUS; Bennet akarasikirwa nebasa rake mukudonha. Uye vazhinji venhengo dzakafanana dzemubatanidzwa - zvino varikumira sevadzivisi, vakarurama vanopikisa "kutevera" pachena vamwe vavanoshanda navo - vachinyomba, kunyomba, kunyomba, nekushorwa, kutanga pachivande uyezve pachena, mumwe waanoshanda naye, Bari Weiss, kudzamara asiya basa. bepa, vachitaura kurwisa kusingagumi uku.
Zviripachena kuti uyu hausi mubatanidzwa usingade kushorwa neveruzhinji kwevaunoshanda navo. Chero โnheyoโ iri kuvakurudzira, zviri pachena kuti handizvo.
Ndave nenguva refu a mutsoropodzi ane hasha yaStephens (uye Weiss's) utori venhau uye kunyora pfungwa. Asi zvaisazombofa zvakaitika kwandiri kuti nditore matanho ekuedza kuvanyararidza. Dai vaive vandaishanda navo uye vakaburitsa chinyorwa chandaisafarira kana kutaura maonero andakaona akashata, ini ndaisazochema kune maneja kuti vakatyora "mitemo" uye nekusimbirira kuti havafanirwe kubvumidzwa kutaura zvavanotenda.
Imhaka yekuti ndiri mutori wenhau, uye ndinoziva kuti kutapa nhau kunogona kuve neukoshi chete kana kuchikurudzira maonero akasiyana uye kutsvaga kuwedzera pane kuderedza rusununguko rwekutaura uye kutaura kunobvumidzwa nenzanga uye nevashandirwi. Uye chero munhu anoda kutaura nezve basa raStephens uye rekodhi yekunyora - uye ndakave nezvakawanda zvakaipa zvekutaura nezvazvo - kushoropodza nehasha yewaunoshandira Pulitzer-akahwina akatevedzana, anodiwa nevezvenhau vane simba, vezvematongerwo enyika netsika, imhando ye "denho kusimba" iyo vatori venhau vazhinji vasina chavanongoita kunze kwekutaura zvinofadza, vamwari vakakurumbira vanoda kuratidza sekubatanidzwa.
Hakuna kumbove nenhepfenyuro kwandakamboshanda kana kwandakabudiswa iyo isingawanzo buditsa pfungwa dzandisingabvumirani nazvo uye zvinyorwa zvandisingadi, kusanganisira yandiri kunyora izvozvi. Ini ndaingoshandisa mapuratifomu angu kushoropodza zvakaburitswa, asi zvaisazomboitika kwandiri kutora matanho ekuyedza kudzivirira kuburitswa kana, zvakatonyanya, kupa zvichemo zveveruzhinji kumaneja kuti chimwe Chinhu Ngachiitweโข. Kana iwe uchida kudzikamisa miganhu yekutaura, sei ungasarudza journalism yemitsara yese yebasa? Zvingaite semumwe munhu anotenda kuti kufamba kwemuchadenga kupambadza zviwanikwa achisarudza kuve muzivi wemuchadenga weNASA.
Zvichida zvikamu zvetawdry izvi zvinofanira kunge zvisingashamisi. Mushure mezvose, chimwe chikonzero chikuru chekuti makambani enhau dzezvemagariro evanhu - ayo aisamboda chisungo chekuongorora asi akatsvaga kuve akarerekera-asina kwazvakarerekera mapuratifomu ekufambisa kwekutaurirana muforoma yeAT&T - akashandurwa kuita matauriro anoshanda ekutaura yaive nekuti veruzhinji, vaiwanzotungamira. nevatori venhau, vakatanga kuda kuti vatarise zvakanyanya. Vamwe vatori venhau vanotopa zvikamu zvakakosha zvebasa ravo vachinyunyuta pachena kuti Facebook ne Twitter vari kutadza kutevedzera "mitemo" yavo nekusaongorora zvakasimba zvakakwana.
Kutenda mutsika dzokutaura zvakasununguka kwaimbova musimboti wepfungwa yokunyora nhau. Masangano nemasangano akarwa achipokana nekutonga kwevapepeti, zvisingadiwe kuti mari zhinji dzitemerwe nevatungamiriri. Vakadzivirira vavanoshanda navo pavakapomerwa nevakuru vehurumende kana vemakambani ekutyorwa kwe "mitemo", kwete kutaurirwa pachena uye kukokwa, kunyange kutsigirwa, matanho ekuranga kubasa.
Asi kudavira mukutaura kwakasununguka kuri kukurumidza kudzikatirwa muzvikamu zvakawanda zvenzanga nokutenda muunhu hweutarisiri hwepamusoro-soro, kunyararidza, uye kurangwa kwepabasa kwakawedzerwa nokuda kwokufunga nokukanganisa kutaura. Sezvinoratidzwa nekushorwa uku kwakashata asi kusinganzwisisike kweNew York Times Guild, maitiro aya anogona kuoneka zvakajeka, uye nekuparadza zvakanyanya, munhau dzeAmerica. Hapana chinokanganisa basa guru rekutapa nhau kupfuura mafungiro aya.
Kwidziridzo: Gumiguru. 11, 2020, 8:40 pm ET
Iyo New York Times Guild nguva dzapfuura yakadzima tweet yayo ichishora Stephens nebepa, uyezve akaisa izvi:
Kunyangwe zvazvo Guild isina kutsanangura kuti ndeipi "kukanganisa" kwakavaita kuti vape mhosva iyi, mutori wenhau webepa, Ben Smith, akati: "Mumwewo munhu anoshanda muTimes Union anondiudza kuti mutungamiri wechitsauko, anomhanyisa account, akatumira panharembozha yaStephens pasina kana hurukuro yemukati, zvichikonzera mhirizhonga muSlack uye kukwevera kupokana kubva kune vamwe muGuild, zvichitungamira izviโ kudzima uye kukumbira ruregerero.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta