Mushure mekunge Dare Repamusorosoro rapa pfungwa yaro yanga yakamirirwa kwenguva refu, ichitsigira kodzero dzehabeas corpus dzevasungwa veGuantánamo, ndakakokwa kuti ndioneke paThe O'Reilly Factor nemuenzi wemuenzi Laura Ingraham. Kunyangwe ari gweta uye aimbove mabharani wemutemo weJustice Clarence Thomas, Ingraham haashandise bazi redu rekutonga rehurumende, achiona kuti vatongi "havana kusarudzwa." Zvechokwadi, akatsigira kuti Bush aputse mutemo uye akazvidza mutongo weDare mukati Boumediene v. Bush:
"Marjorie, ndanga ndichiedza kufunga ndega, tarisa, dai ndaiva Mutungamiri Bush, uye ndakanga ndanzwa kuti nyaya iyi yasvika, uye ndiri kunze kwechigaro mumwedzi mishomanana. pasi, ndingadai ndakataura panguva ino, zvinofadza zvikuru kuti dare rakasarudza izvi, asi handisi kuzoremekedza mutongo wedare nokuti basa rangu nderekuchengetedza nyika ino. "
Dare rakasarudza chii chakatsamwa Ingraham (uyo achangobva kupihwa mubairo nekuda kwemaonero ake "akanaka uye akaenzana" neshoo yake pa. Fox News)? Sarudzo iyi ichaisa pangozi kuchengeteka kwedu here? Uye achadaro Boumediene yava nyaya musarudzo yemutungamiri wenyika?
Dare Repamusorosoro rakapa mutongo we5-4 wekuti vasungwa vekuGuantánamo vane kodzero yebumbiro remutemo rekuita habeas corpus, uye kuti chirongwa chekuongorora mazita e'muvengi' ari pasi peCombatant Status Review Tribunals hachina kukwana kutsiva habeas corpus, mhedzisiro I. zvakafanotaurwa muchinyorwa chaDecember 3, 2007. (http://marjoriecohn.com/2007/12/guantnamo-detainees-fate-at-stake-in.html).
Vasungwa veGuantánamo vane kodzero yebumbiro remitemo yehabeas corpus
Chisungo 1, Chikamu 9, Chikamu 2 yeBumbiro reMitemo rinozivikanwa se Suspension Clause. Inoti, "Ropafadzo yeChinyorwa cheHabeas Corpus haizomiswa, kunze kwekunge muNyaya dzeKumukira kana Kupinda Kuchengetedzwa kweveruzhinji kuchida." Muchikamu 7(a) cheMilitary Commissions Act ya2006, Congress yainzi ichabvisa kodzero dzehabeas kubva kuvasungwa veGuantánamo nekugadzirisa mutemo wehabeas corpus (28 USCA § 2241(e)). In Boumediene, Dare rakati chikamu chemutemo ichi hachienderane nebumbiro remutemo, rikazivisa kuti vasungwa vachiri nekodzero iri mubumbiro remutemo rekuita habeas corpus.
Mutongi Kennedy, achinyorera ruzhinji, akadzokorora zvakawanikwa neDare Rasul v. Bush kuti kunyange
Kennedy ainetsekana kuti mapazi ezvematongerwo enyika anogona "kuva nesimba rekuchinja Bumbiro kana kudzima pakuda" izvo "zvaizotungamira kune hutongi umo ivo, kwete Dare iri, vanoti 'mutemo chii.'
Nokudaro, Kennedy akacherechedza, "zvinyorwa zvehabeas corpus pachazvo inzira inokosha yekuongorora kuparadzaniswa kwemasimba." Zvechokwadi, habeas corpus yaiva imwe yekodzero shoma dzevanhu Baba Vokutanga vakainyora muBumbiro rekutanga, makore vasati vaita Bhiri reKodzero.
"Muedzo wekuona chiyero che [habeas corpus] gadziriro," Kennedy akanyora, "haifanire kuve pasi pekushandiswa neavo vane simba rakagadzirirwa kudzora." Kunyengedza kwakadaro uko Laura Ingraham aizoenderera mberi. Yakanga iri Republican-inodzorwa Congress, ichishanda ruoko-mu-girovhosi naBush, yakaedza kubvisa kodzero dzehabeas corpus kubva kuvasungwa veGuantánamo muMutemo weMauto Komisheni. Dare Repamusorosoro rakasarudza kuti kuedza uku kuve kunopesana nemutemo. Richizadzisa basa raro rebumbiro remutemo rekuongorora nekudzikamisa mamwe mapazi maviri, Dare rakaita basa raro rekududzira Bumbiro reMitemo uye kutaura kuti "mutemo chii."
Hapana chinotsiva chakakwana chehabeas corpus
Raona kuti vasungwa vekuGuantánamo vakachengeta kodzero yebumbiro remitemo yehabeas corpus, Dare rakatendeukira kunyaya yekuti pakanga paine chinotsiva chakakwana chekuongorora habeas. Bush akagadza Combatant Status Review Tribunals ("CSRTs") kuti aone kana musungwa ari "murwi wemuvengi." Matare ekangaroo aya haapi kodzero yekupa zano, asi "mumiririri wega," asina chikwereti chekuchengeta zvakavanzika kumutengi wake uye kazhinji haatombomiriri musungwa; mumwe akatopikisa nyaya yehurumende. Musungwa haana kodzero yekuona humbowo hwakawanda hunomupikisa uye humbowo hushoma hwaanogona kupa.
MaCSRTs akashoropodzwa nevari muchiuto muhurongwa uhu. Lt Col. Stephen Abraham, mhare ye
Kunyange zvazvo Dare rakaramba kusarudza kuti maCSRTs anogutsa here zvinodiwa nemaitiro, rakagumisa kuti "kunyange kana mapato ose ane chekuita nechirongwa ichi akaita zvine hungwaru uye nekutenda kwakanaka, pane njodzi huru yekukanganisa pane zvakawanikwa nedare." Dare rakazofanira kuona kana nzira yekuongorora kwevatongi mazita eCSRTs ekuti "muvengi anorwa" aimiririra zvakakwana kutsiva habeas corpus wongororo.
"Kuti magwaro ehabeas corpus, kana kuti anotsiva, ashande semushonga unoshanda uye wakakodzera mumamiriro ezvinhu aya," Kennedy akanyora, "dare rinotungamira hurongwa hwehabeas rinofanira kunge riine nzira dzekugadzirisa zvikanganiso zvakaitika panguva yeCSRT. Izvi zvinosanganisira chiremera chekuongorora kukwana kwehumbowo hweHurumende pamusoro pemusungwa.
Asi mumutemo weDetainee Treatment Act ("DTA"), Congress yakaganhurwa nedare redunhu ongororo yezvakatemerwa neCSRT kuti CSRT inotevedzera here maitiro ayo. Dare redunhu rakanga risina mvumo yekunzwa humbowo huchangobva kuwanikwa kana kutsvaga kuti musungwa akanga asarudzwa zvisiri izvo semurwi wemuvengi.
Dare Repamusorosoro rakaona kuti "kana simba rekutonga rekuburitsa habeas corpus rikapinzwa zvakanaka mutongi wedare anofanirwa kunge aine simba rakakwana rekuita mutongo maererano nemutemo uripo uye chokwadi uye kugadzira uye kupa mirairo yakakodzera yekuyamura, kusanganisira, kana zvichidikanwa. , murayiro wairayira kuti musungwa asunungurwe. Sezvo chirongwa cheDTA chekuongorora zvakatemerwa neCSRTs chisina kupa mvumo iyi, Dare rakati rakanga risiri rakaringana kutsiva habeas corpus nokudaro chikamu chechinomwe cheMilitary Commissions Act chakaita "sekumiswa kwegwaro zvisiri pamutemo."
Boumediene hazvina kukanganisa
Mukupikisa kwake, Justice Scalia akaridza alarm yekuti Boumediene chisarudzo "chichaita kuti vanhu vakawanda vekuAmerica vaurawe." Saizvozvowo, the Wall St. Journal yakanyorwa, "Tinogona kutaura nechivimbo chinotyisa kuti vanhu vakawanda vekuAmerica vangangofa semugumisiro." Kufanotaura kwavo, zvisinei, hakuna kubva muchokwadi.
Lakhdar Boumediene nevamwe vashanu vasungwa vekuAlgeria kubva
Vazhinji vevarume nevakomana vepaGuantánamo vakatengeswa semubhadharo kune
The Boumediene Sarudzo haizokanganisa zvakananga nyaya dzemhosva dzinopokana naKhalid Sheikh Mohammed nevamwe vashoma vachatongwa mumakomisheni emauto. Varume 211 vakamhan'ara zvichemo zvehabeas corpus vachipokana nemazita avo ekuti "muvengi murwi" vanozobatsirwa nemutongo uyu. Hapana achasunungurwa otomatiki. Vanozongopihwa mukana wekunzwa zvakanaka. Vazhinji vekuAmerica havangapokane nechisungo chekuti hurumende yedu iratidze munhu ane mhosva tisati tamuisa mujeri nekusingaperi.
Kunyangwe Justice Jackson, muchuchisi mukuru pa
Kennedy akatora mashoko aAlexander Hamilton, uyo akanyora muFederalist 84 kuti "kupfigirwa mutorongo kwave kuri, mumazera ose, zviridzwa zvinofarirwa uye zvinotyisa zvikuru zveudzvinyiriri." Mutongi Souter akacheka kumhanyirira mumaonero ake akasiyana, achitaura "hurefu hwevasungwa vari kupokana, vamwe vasungwa vanomiririrwa pano nhasi vakavharirwa kwemakore matanhatu." Hapana kana mumwe wavo akapomerwa mhosva uye hapana akambomiswa pamberi pemutongi akanaka uye asina rusaruro.
"Mitemo neBumbiro reMitemo rakagadzirirwa kurarama, uye kuramba richishanda, munguva dzinoshamisa." Kennedy akanyora. "
"Chengetedzo inoramba iripo, zvakare, mukuvimbika kumitemo yekutanga yerusununguko," maererano naKennedy. “Mukuru pakati peizvi rusununguko kubva mukuzvibata zvisina tsarukano uye zvisiri pamutemo uye rusununguko rwemunhu rwunochengetwa nekutevedzera kupatsanurwa kwemasimba… kunzwa zvichemo kuchiremera cheExecutive kusunga munhu."
Mukupindura kune dichotomy yenhema yaLaura Ingraham pakati pekutichengeta takachengeteka uye kudzivirira habeas corpus, ndakatora kuraira kwaBenjamin Franklin: "Ivo vangasiya rusununguko rwakakosha rwekuchengetedza kwenguva pfupi, havakodzere rusununguko kana chengetedzo."
Kurwisa vatongi vachivanza kuchengetedzwa kwenyika
The Boumediene chisarudzo kupatsanurana pamwe chete nemitsara yezvematongerwo enyika nevanozviti vatongi verusununguko - Ginsburg, Stevens, Souter naBreyer - muruzhinji, uye vatongi vana vanochengetedza - Scalia, Thomas, Roberts naAlito - mukupokana. Kennedy, iyo swing vote, akatyora tie. Curt Levy kubva kuKomiti yeJustice, iyo inotsvaga kuzadza matare nevatongi vekurudyi, yakanyora kuti Boumediene "yakamisa nyaya yeDare Repamusorosoro zvakanaka kune GOP"
Chokwadi, John McCain akatozvibata senyaya yemushandirapamwe. Musi wakabuda pfungwa iyi, McCain akati, "Zviri pachena kuti zvine chekuita neni ... asi mutongo wakatorwa neDare Repamusorosoro. Iye zvino tinofanira kuenderera mberi. Sezvaunoziva, ndaigara ndichifarira kuvhara.
Barack Obama, anobatanidza kuchengetedzeka kwenyika yedu nemabatirwo atinoitwa nedzimwe nyika, akaratidzira Boumediene sarudzo se "danho rakakosha rekugadzirisa zvakare kuvimbika kwedu senyika yakazvipira kumutemo, uye kuramba sarudzo yenhema pakati pekurwisa hugandanga uye kuremekedza habeas corpus."
Zvinogoneka kuti mutungamiri anotevera achaita kanenge kamwechete, uye pamwe maviri, kuDare Repamusorosoro. Boumediene ndiye mwana weposita wekuti Dare rave nekudzikama sei, uye mhedzisiro yakaipa kune dzidziso yekuparadzaniswa-kwe-masimba akatimirira kana Mutungamiri McCain akaita zvakanaka pavimbiso yake yekugadza vatongi muforoma yaRoberts naAlito.
Marjorie Cohn ndiye mutungamiri weNational Lawyers Guild uye purofesa paThomas Jefferson School of Law. Ndiye munyori we
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta