The New York Times ' yakatumidza Margaret Sullivan semupepeti wayo wechishanu munaGunyana wegore rino. Semunhu akabudirira kuita basa racho basa rake ndeyekuferefeta "nyaya dzekusatendeka kwevatapi venhau" nekushanda "ndakazvimirira" uye "kunze kwekutaura nekugadzirisa chimiro chepepanhau."
Kusvika pari zvino, uye aine makwapa mashoma, akaita basa remuenzaniso. Iye munguva pfupi yapfuura akaongorora shefu vake Arthur Sulzberger, Jr. Sarudzo yekuhaya aimbove BBC Director General Mark Thompson semutambi Times ' CEO mutsva. Nezvekunyomba kwepedophilia kwakazunungusa sangano reveruzhinji uye kuti Thompson akatarisira chikamu chebasa rake, Margaret akabvunza "Zvingaite sei kuti hapana chaaiziva?" Akanyorawo kuti โZvakakodzera kufunga iye zvino kana ari iye munhu akakodzera pabasa racho.โ
Mamwe emamwe mabasa ake anga akati piriviri. Nepo kubvuma "mifungo yakaumbwa nehafu" yemukuru weJerusarema Bureau Jodi Rudoren's chauvinistic Facebook zvinyorwa zvaakashandisawo. mutauro wakarerekera divi rimwe chete kutsanangura weAtlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg uye Electronic Intifada co-muvambi Ali Abunimah - mutauro waifarira wekutanga uchibvisa-mutemo wekupedzisira.
Asi pazvose Margaret akaita basa rakanaka. The Times saizi uye kubuda kunofanirwa kuita kuti basa rake sePublic Editor riite basa rinotyisa kuzadza - kana risiri risingagoneke - kunyangwe nerubatsiro rwemubatsiri wake Joseph Burgess. Vhiki rapfuura rinopa muenzaniso wakanaka.
Musi waNovember 28th Margaret akanyorera vaverengi vake kuti โachange asiri pagridiโ kusvika pakati pesvondo rino ndokutivimbisa kuti โkune nyaya dzakawanda dziri kunetsa kunze uko, uye ndinotarisira kudzoka kuzotaura dzimwe dzacho. โ
Musi waNovember 29th, rimwe zuva pashure pokunge Margaret aenda, bepa rake rakabudiswa a pfupi Associated Press (AP) chinyorwa pane peji A3 yeiyo kudhindwa edition ichiona kuti Pfc. Bradley Manning - uyo "ari kupomerwa mhosva yekuburitswa kukuru kwemagwaro akaburitswa munhoroondo yeUnited States" uye anotorwa nevakawanda pasi rese semusungwa mukuru wemazuva ano arikungwarisa - akatanga zuva rake rechitatu reuchapupu.
kunyange zvazvo Times akatadza kutumira mutori wenhau kutongwa kwaManning, uye Margaret akange asiri pagridi, vaverengi vazhinji vakatsamwiswa Times ' kuzivisa uye ivo pachavo vakatsvaga kupa tsananguro yakaoma uye ongororo yekuparara kwebepanhau.
Pano paNYT eXaminer, muna Mbudzi 30th, takaburitsa chinyorwa chaChris Floyd, โBlanking Bradley Manning: NYT uye AP Launch Operation Amnesia,โ izvo zvaida chinangwa chinouraya pa Times ' kukundikana kwevatori venhau kuburikidza, pakati pezvimwe zvinotsoropodza, kuenzanisa kuburitswa kwemapepa kwaBradley Manning nekutaura kwavo nezvevasungwa vekuRussia vehana Pussy Riot. Chris anonongedza kuti Pussy Riot yakawana kufukidzwa kwakanyanya kupfuura Manning.
Zvino musi wa5 Decemberth, takaburitsa Murray Polner's โBradley Manning & The Times, Chikamu IIโ iyo yakanyora kuyedza kwake "email the Times ' Public Editor vachibvunza kuti sei bepa riine nyaya shoma. "
Zvakare musi wa5 Zvitath, Margaret akadzokera kuhofisi yake ndokuisa gwaro rePublic Editor's Journal, โThe Times Anofanira Kuve neReporter paBradley Manning Hearingโ maakaita kurumbidzwa kwakakodzera - asi kuri pachena - kutaura kuti "Mukutadza kutumira mutori wenhau wake kuti avhare humbowo hunonakidza uye hwakakosha hwekutanga kwaBradley Manning, The New York Times akapotsa chikepe.โ
Dambudziko iri, zvisinei, rinotangira kuzorora kwaMargaret neanenge mazuva maviri asati aenda, apo, saiye Timesโ Nyaya yeAP inotsanangura, Manning โakatanga zuva rake rechitatu rokupupura.โ Mukuwedzera, sekuziva kwedu, kwete Times' Editor akaenda mberi Margaret asati aenda kana kuti paakanga asipo kuti agadzirise kutadza kwebepa ravo. Vachazviita iye zvino here?
Kudiwa kwePublic Editor kwakajeka uye iyo Times inofanira kurumbidzwa nokuda kwokuva nayo. Asi nguva yezviitiko inoratidza kuti kunyangwe asati aenda Public Editor Margaret haana hanya nekuona kutongwa kwaManning.
Panguva iyo Margaret akacherechedza kusabuda kwebepa rake nhau dzakawanda uye vatori venhau vakanga vatokunda bepa racho. The Guardian's Ed Pilkington, Alexa O'Brien uye zvakare Kevin Gosztola, pakati pezvimwe, zvakapa basa rinokosha kuburikidza nekunyora nyaya dzedare raManning zvakajeka uye kuburikidza nemeso evanhu.
Asi, thanks zvikuru kune Times ' kutadza kuzivisa zviri kuitika, Times' vaverengi nevamwe vanhu vazhinji muUS havangazive kuti zviri kuitika kana kuti kodzero dzevanhu dzaBradley Manning dzakatyorwa sei.
Izvo zvakakosha kune chero munhu ari mukati me Times kuuya kumberi uye kuona, sezvakaita Margaret, kuti Times aifanira kutumira mutori wenhau kudare. Zvisinei, the Times ' kutadza kutaura zvine hunyanzvi paManning kwenguva refu kunotangira basa raMargaret kuPublic Editor post.
Muna Zvita wapfuura 2011, NYT eXaminer Zvinonzi kuti sei Times akazvidza kuvhurwa kwematare edzimhosva aManning mumwedzi iwoyo, Kisimusi isati yasvika uye panguva imwe chete apo nhau dzekubuda kweUS muIraq dzakatora misoro yenhau.
Mumwe wevashoma Times ' nyaya dzinozonyorwa dzichitaura kutongwa kwekutanga, โYakazvimiririra muWikiLeaks Kusora Nyaya Inoenda kuDareโ rakanyorwa naScott Shane, rakatora mashoko aEugene R. Fidell, mudzidzisi wezvemitemo yemauto kuYale achitaura, โIyi ndeimwe yenyaya dzechiuto dzinonakidza kwazvo mumakore makumi maviri apfuuraโฆโ
Mukupesana kukuru ne Times' achishuma nhasi, Shane akanyora ipapo kuti, "Vatori venhau kubva pasirese vari kuburitsa nyaya iyi, gumi nevaviri panguva mudare diki uye vamwe vangangosvika makumi mashanu vachitevera zvaiitika pavhidhiyo link kubva kune imwe nzvimbo yenhau."
Nhoroondo yaShane yakapa vaverengi tariro ipapo kuti bepa rake rakatora kutongwa kwaManning zvakakomba uye raizorivhara zvine mutsindo mune ramangwana. Nekudaro, ichangopfuura mwedzi mitanhatu gare gare, muna Chikumi 2012, NYT eXaminer's Marie Burns akabvunza, โChii Chakaitika kuna Bradley Manning?โ Akapindura kuti:
โSezviri pachena, hapana. Kana kuti saka iwe waizofunga kana iwe uchivimba neNew York Times 'kuvhara. Bradley Manning, sevaverengi veTimes vanogona kuyeuka kana vakabvunza michina yavo yekudzokera kumashure, musoja wekuAmerica uyo akapomerwa nemauto eUS nemhosva dzine chekuita nekupfuudza kwake zvinhu zvakasarudzwa kuWikiLeaks. โฆ Dare rake remauto, riri kuitirwa kuFort Meadeโฆโ
Margaret Sullivan akasaina kondirakiti neiyo Times kwemakore mana. Achiri mugore rake rekutanga anofanira kucherechedza kuti bepa rake rakanga ratotadza sei kuvhara Bradley Manning nguva refu asati agamuchirwa kuti apinde. Izvi zvichaita kuti zvive nyore kwaari kuona maitiro ebepa rake rekutaura nezveManning panguva yaanenge asara ikoko.
Margaret anonyora mubhuku rake rejenari kuti Times akaburitsa mamwe emagwaro aya anonzi Manning akapa kuWikiLeaks - zvinyorwa zvinosanganisira mazana maviri nemakumi mashanu ezviuru etambo dzeEmbassy yeUS dzinozivikanwa se "Cablegate," iyo Afghan War Dairies, Iraq War Logs uye vhidhiyo yeCollateral Murder.
Mhedzisiro yekuona kwake - kunyangwe Margaret asingataure zvakadaro - ndeyekuti, kune iwo magwaro ayo Times akaita kudhinda, Manning aive sosi yebepa. Maererano neAtlantic,ingangoita hafu ya2011's New York Times nyaya dzakatsamira paWikiLeaks.
Saka sei zvichiita Times kufuratira uye pasi-kushuma Manning ndiani mumwe wavo akakosha masosi kubva kunaDaniel Ellsberg wePentagon Mapepa? Muna 2011 NYT eXaminer yakabvunzurudza WikiLeaks 'Mupepeti Julian Assange nezve Times kurapwa kwaManning. Assange akati:
Ini ndinofunga iyo New York Times inobata yayo yepamusoro-yepamusoro-nhanho masimba ezvematongerwo enyika zviri nani. Muchokwadi zvinovapa spin yavanoda kana vapa chimwe chinhu kuti vatevedze ajenda yavo. Manning, ndinofungidzira, anoonekwa neNew York Times semurwi wepasi. Uye saka hazvina basa. Kana ari sosi yeNew York Times hazvina basa nekuti anogona kungotsvairwa padivi. Haana simba rezvematongerwo enyika. Haana chero chaanobatanidzwa.
Mugwaro rake rePublic Editor's Journal, Margaret akataura nezvechidimbu kubva kuAssociated Press kuti Timesakamhanya achiona kuti bepa harina kufuratira kutongwa kwaManning kwazvino. Nekusagutsikana, akabvunza mukuru wehofisi yeWashington David Leonhardt chikonzero nei Times haana kutumira mutori wenhau kune ichangoburwa Fort Meade kunzwa.
Mhinduro yemukuru wehofisi kumubvunzo waMargaret wekuti, "sezvimwewo chero nyaya yepamutemo, hatisi kuzobata nyaya yese," inosiyana zvakanyanya nemushumo waScott Shane kubva mukutongwa kwegore rapfuura achiburitsa maonero ekuti nyaya yaManning ndiyo inonyanya kukosha nyaya yemauto. makumi maviri emakore apfuura uye kuti vatori venhau kubva kumativi ese enyika vaipinda mudare nevamwe vazhinji vachitevera vhidhiyo link mune imwe kamuri.
Mhinduro yaDavid inoratidza dambudziko guru ne Times ' kuva nehanya kwenhema. Kupfurikidza nokutaura kuti vakafukidza Manning uye โuye vacharamba vachidaroโ kunoreva kuti ivo vachazviita nenzira yakati kuzvidza ukoshi hwemhaka yake. Semuenzaniso, anoti nyaya yaManning haikodzeri kuve nemutori wenhau akazvipira nekuti โinyaya yakatwasukaโ.
Parizvino, iyo Times vakaita zvishoma zvavo kuti vavhare nyaya yaManning - kungotaura kuti vadaro. Tingatarisira kuti muenzaniso iwoyo uchinje woga here?
Sezvo NYT eXaminer yakakakavadzana zvakadzama Kukadzi wegore rino, "Iyo Yechina Estate Inorasa Yayo Yega Press Rusununguko: WikiLeaks & Iyo New York Times,โ nyaya iyi ine zvakawanda zviri mubumbiro uye zvemutemo zvakatangira zvine chekuita nerusununguko rwekuburitswa kwemashoko nekusununguka kutaura. The Times inofanirwa kuve yakavharika uye yakakomba nyaya yeManning nekuda kwezvikonzero izvi, kana zvisiri nekuti Times yakawana purofiti yakawanda kubva kuWikiLeaks 'zvinhu.
Kuti mukuru wehofisi yeWashington anovimbisa "vaverengi vanogona kutarisira zvakanyanya kuvharwa kwaVaManning mumavhiki anouya" ingangove yechokwadi. Asi vaverengi ve Times anogonawo zvechokwadi kutarisira kuona ingi yakawanda yakadururwa mumapeji bepa uye "digital ingi" paIndaneti pamusoro mwaka uno zororo kudya kwemanheru resipi pane pamusoro Manning.
Margaret Sullivan anoti iyo Times anofanira kuva nemutori wenhau pakutongwa kwaManning. Ehe. Ari right. Zvakamuitira zvakanaka nekuona izvi. Asi haana kudzika zvakakwana mukuongorora kwake dambudziko racho. Zvichida basa rake rakawandisa kune mumwe munhu uye mubatsiri. Tese tinofanirwa kuve Veruzhinji Vapepeti kubata iyo Times, uye mamwe ma media enhau, ane mhosva kune nyaya dzekutendeseka kwevatapi venhau.
Chris Spannos ndiye Muvambi uye Mupepeti weNYT eXaminer (NYTX). Unogona kuziva zvakawanda nezve NYTX pane yedu Website. Kutsigira basa redu ndapota ipai.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta