Nthawi zambiri, Dee waku New York akanamuyitanitsa Nkhani Yopangira Nkhanza kuchokera ku Amazon, koma izi si nthawi zabwinobwino. Amazon ili pa Tengani Chikwama Chanu list, kampeni yonyanyala ogulitsa omwe amagulitsa katundu wa banja la Trump, yomwe idayamba poyankha kanema kuwulula chidwi cha pulezidenti wathu wapano pakugwira akazi "pamphuno." Dee adagula bukhu lake kuchokera kwa ogulitsa ang'onoang'ono m'malo mwake.
Kuyambira chisankho cha Donald Trump mu Novembala, makamaka kuyambira pomwe adakhazikitsidwa mu Januwale, mabungwe ang'onoang'ono komanso ang'onoang'ono ayamba kutsutsa Purezidenti. Analowa m'magulu amagulu otsamira kumanzere ndi omasuka omwe akutsitsimutsa kale injini zawo kuti amenyane ndi utsogoleri. Mwanjira zonse zomwe mungafotokozere kutsutsa kwanu, pali njira imodzi yomwe Purezidentiyu amvetsetse: kukana zachuma kumangoyang'ana mabizinesi ake ndi ana ake. Iye sangatengeke ndi ziwonetsero zodzaza mโmisewu, koma amalankhula chinenero cha ndalama. Kupyolera mu njira zambiri - kuphatikizapo kunyalanyaza masitolo omwe amanyamula katundu wa Trump, kulanga makampani ndi otsatsa omwe amalemba ndondomeko ya kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe ka kayendetsedwe kake tsiku la kukana motsutsana ndi mtundu wake pa June 14.
Kusagwirizana pazachuma kotereku kumatha kukhala njira yoyenera kwambiri yokanira, makamaka kwa mamiliyoni aku America omwe amakhala m'maiko abuluu ndipo adalimbana ndi malingaliro opanda mphamvu pambuyo pa chisankho. Kupatula apo, sizodziwikiratu momwe angachitire ndale moyenera mwachizolowezi Njira yaku America pamene aphungu anu avomereza kale ndi inu. Koma zomwe anthu okhala m'boma la buluu alibe mphamvu pazandale zomwe amapanga pazachuma, popeza mayiko abuluu ali ndi ndalama zambiri zapakhomo komanso mphamvu zogulira kuposa anzawo akuboma. Zotsatira zakunyanyala kogwirizana za blue-state zitha kukhala zazikulu. Ndi chifukwa chake Tengani Chikwama Chanu, pamodzi ndi Mtundu wa kusintha, gulu losankhana mitundu, ndi mabungwe ena ambiri akulimbikitsa anthu kuona mphamvu zawo zogulira zinthu monga ndale.
"Kunali pafupi ndi zisankho, koma sikuli pafupi ndi kaundula wa ndalama," Shannon Coulter, woyambitsa Grab Your Wallet, adandiuza posachedwa.
Ndipo komabe, ngakhale unyinji wa mabungwe ndi anthu masauzande ambiri ataya mphamvu zawo pazachuma zomwe akufuna kufooketsa purezidenti, likadali funso lotseguka ngati kukana kwamtunduwu - kapena, makamaka, kukhazikitsidwa kwake - kungayambitse chilichonse. njira ya kusintha kwatanthauzo.
โMalo Okulirapo Otsutsaโ
Poyamba, Tengani Chikwama Chanu ndi tsamba laling'ono: tsamba la Google lomwe lili ndi mndandanda wamakampani pafupifupi 50 oti anyanyale. Kuphatikizidwa ndi masitolo ogulitsa Macy's, Bloomingdale's, ndi Lord & Taylor, komanso ogulitsa pa intaneti monga Overstock.com, Zappos, ndi Amazon, onse omwe amagulitsa mtundu wina wa Trump swag. (Chiwerengero chenicheni chamakampani omwe adatchulidwa chikupitilirabe kuchepa, pomwe ogulitsa akutaya mtundu wa Trump.) Tsambali limalandira alendo ochititsa chidwi mamiliyoni awiri mwezi uliwonse, ndipo nditalankhula ndi Coulter, adandiuza kuti ogulitsa 22 anali nawo. adagwa Zogulitsa za Trump kuyambira chiyambi cha kunyanyala. Amakhulupirira kuti ichi ndi chiyambi chabe.
"Sindikuganiza kuti tiwona zotsatira za kunyanyala mpaka chilimwe, chifukwa cha momwe malonda amagwirira ntchito," adatero. Malo ogulitsira a Nordstrom, mwachitsanzo, kampani yayikulu kwambiri mpaka pano yomwe idasiya mtundu wa Ivanka Trump, idagulitsidwa kudzera pazomwe zidalipo isananene kuti siikonzanso. Chilengezo chimenecho chinakopa chidwi cha pulezidenti yemwe tweeted: "Mwana wanga wamkazi Ivanka adachitiridwa zinthu mopanda chilungamo ndi @Nordstrom. Ndi munthu wamkulu - amandikakamiza nthawi zonse kuti ndichite zoyenera! Zowopsa!
Mtundu wa Kusintha wakhala ukugwiritsa ntchito njira zolimbana ndi chuma, makamaka potsata otsatsa omwe amalemba chidani. Popeza a Trump ali ku White House, a Rashad Robinson, wamkulu wa gululo, adandiuza kuti akuyang'ana kwambiri gawo la othandizira makampani "omwe apangitsa kuti izi zitheke." Adafotokozanso za njira yomwe bungwe lawo limasankhira mosamalitsa cholinga chakampani kenako ndikusonkhanitsa mamembala ake miliyoni kuti achite nawo kampeni yofuna kuipitsa dzina la kampaniyo - pokhapokha ngati oyang'anira ake apanga zisankho zoyenera zotsatsira. Mtundu wa Kusintha adasewera a udindo pakuthamangitsidwa kwaposachedwa kwa Bill O'Reilly ku Fox News pothandizira kukopa ena kuposa 50 otsatsa akuluakulu omwe adakoka thandizo lawo lazachuma kuchokera ku pulogalamu yake yapamwamba kwambiri. Otsatsa atathawa, Fox adapatsa O'Reilly boot.
Magulu opita patsogolo akuwonetsa kuti ali ndi luso popanga njira zoyendetsedwa ndi ogula. Center for Popular Democracy ndi gulu lomenyera ufulu wa anthu olowa m'dziko lina Make the Road New York posachedwa anayambitsa nawo kampeni yotchedwa Magulu Othandizira Chidani, yomwe imayang'ana Wells Fargo, JPMorgan Chase, The Walt Disney Company, ndi mabungwe ena ochepa omwe apereka njira zosiyanasiyana zothandizira Trump ndi ndondomeko yake. Mwachitsanzo, Wells Fargo wabwereka mamiliyoni ya madola kumakampani a Purezidenti, ndi wogulitsa m'mayiko ena malo otsekera imayendetsedwa ndi makontrakitala apadera, opeza phindu, ndipo yatero wobwereketsa ndalama kwa opanga ma Dongosolo Lapaapa la Dakota, paipi yamafuta ya makilomita 1,172 yomwe ikadutsa madera a Standing Rock Sioux Tribe ku North Dakota. (Trump adasaina a memo kuvomereza njira imeneyo pasanathe masiku atatenga udindo.) Webusaiti ya Corporate Backers of Hate imalola anthu ochita ziwonetsero kuti alambalale ogwira ntchito m'mabungwewa ndi kutumiza mauthenga. mwachindunji kwa mabwanamkubwa ndi mamembala a board kuti awonetse kusagwirizana kwawo.
Njira iyi yotsata ndalama zomwe zimachokera pa network ya Trump yapambana kale. Magulu angapo akhala akuyesera kuti achepetse ndalama zotsatsa malonda Breitbart, xenophobic nkhani zabodza malo omwe kale ankayendetsedwa ndi katswiri wamaphunziro a White House Steve Bannon. Amene akutsogolera ntchitoyi ndi gulu la Twitter, Zimphona Zogona, ndi lingaliro losavuta: limapempha otsatira kuti azijambula zotsatsa Breitbart - makamaka pafupi ndi mutu wokhumudwitsa - kenako tumizani chithunzicho ku kampani yomwe ili muzotsatsa pamodzi ndi uthenga waulemu woyipempha kuti asiye kulemba chidani. Njirayi yakhala yopambana kwambiri; malinga ndi Sleeping Giants, masauzande otsatsa atuluka Breitbart.
Nicholas Reville ndi wokonzekera bwino pa intaneti yemwe wakhala mtsogoleri wamkulu mu kampeni kupangitsa โchidani kukhala chopanda pakeโ monga akunena. Amakhulupirira kuti Sleeping Giants model of digital resistance imayimira mtundu watsopano komanso wofunikira wa ndale. "Ndizosowa kwambiri kuti mukhale ndi kampeni yolimbikitsa anthu kuchita zinthu zina osati kusaina pempho, kuwonetsa msonkhano, [kapena] kupereka ndalama," adandiuza. M'malo mwake, adanenanso, munthu tsopano akhoza kuchitapo kanthu pazida zake ndikuthandizira kupambana pamene wotsatsa atuluka. Breitbart.
Othandizira ena akupitilira zithunzi ndi ma tweets. Mtolankhani Naomi Klein posachedwapa anatulutsa a kanema kuwonetsa kuti a Trump chikuni ndi imodzi mwazinthu zofunika kwambiri zopezera ndalama ndikuwonetsa kuti "kusokoneza" chizindikirocho - pochitembenuza kuchokera kwa wopanga ndalama kukhala wotaya ndalama - kungakhale njira yamphamvu yotsutsa. Amatchulanso njira monga kutseka mafoni kumakampani a Trump kapena kupanga, kenako kuletsa, kusungitsa malo ku mahotela ake.
Womenyera ufulu wina yemwe wakhala akugwira ntchito yosokoneza mafoni a Trump, ndipo yemwe adalankhula nane mosadziwika, adati otsutsa ngati iye adazindikira kuti ndizosavuta kusokoneza mabizinesi a Purezidenti. "Mizere ya foni ilibe mphamvu yolumikizira kuyimba kwapakatikati," adatero, ndikunditsimikizira kuti pali kusokoneza kwa mafoni komwe kukukonzekera mtsogolo. Nditamufunsa zomwe akuyembekeza kukwaniritsa kudzera munjira imeneyi, adandiyankha kuti cholinga chake chinali kufooketsa Purezidenti Trump pazachuma, ndale, komanso mwanjira iliyonse yomwe mungaganizire.
"Njirazi ndizogwirizana ndi mitundu ina yakukonzekera," adatero. "Palibe njira imodzi yokha yomwe ingagwetse kayendetsedwe ka Trump ... si momwe zimagwirira ntchito. Ichi ndi gawo limodzi mwazovuta za kukana."
Zosavuta Kukana, Zovuta Kupambana
Unyinji wamagulu, makampeni, ndi anthu omwe amatsatira a Donald Trump, mabizinesi a Trump, ndi makampani omwe amamuthandizira kapena zomwe akufuna kuchita pazandale zimapangitsa kuti pakhale chipwirikiti chokanira. Ndimalandira mauthenga khumi ndi awiri osiyana, omwe nthawi zambiri amakhala osalumikizidwa mubokosi langa tsiku lililonse. Patangotha โโโโmasabata angapo pambuyo pa kutsegulira, ndinapeza mphamvu zonse zomwe zimandisangalatsa. Komabe, patapita miyezi ingapo ya kuyesayesa kosalekeza, ndinayamba kukayikira ngati khama limenelo lingagwiritsiridwe ntchito bwino pa ndawala zochepa, zogwirizanitsidwa bwino. Ngakhale otsutsa a Trump mosakayikira amasangalala ndi chisangalalo pamene Nordstrom agwetsa mzere wa Ivanka ndipo magulu ambiri otsatsa akutuluka. Breitbart, sizikudziwika ngati awa ndi masitepe opita ku ndale zomwe zasinthidwa, kapena ngati akungodzimva kuti ndi opambana omwe sangatsogolere kulikonse.
Vutoli mwina ndilobwino kwambiri chitsanzo ndi Boycott Trump app, yomwe idatsitsidwa nthawi 350,000. Lingaliro lakumbuyo kwake ndi lofanana ndi lomwe limapangitsa Grab Wallet Yanu. Pulogalamuyi kwenikweni ndi mndandanda wamakampani oti anyalanyaze, ngakhale akuphatikizapo oposa 250 aiwo, m'malo mwa ambiri pa Grab Your Wallet, ambiri chifukwa adathandizira chiwonetsero cha Trump cha NBC. The kuphunzira kumbuyo mu 2011. Ndinafunsa Nathan Lerner, yemwe akutsogolera bungwe lotchedwa Democratic Coalition Against Trump, lomwe limayang'anira pulogalamuyo, zomwe zimayeneretsa kampani kulembedwa, ndipo adanena kuti kampani iliyonse yokhudzana ndi pulezidenti iyenera kulembedwa. Kenako ndinafunsa ngati gulu lake likugwirizana ndi zoyesayesa zina zonyanyala.
Lerner anandiuza kuti: โTakhumudwitsidwa pangโono ndi kuyanjana. "Pakadali pano tikuwona chisangalalo chochuluka choletsa Trump, koma chagawika. Anthu akuyamba kuchita ntchito zabwino, koma akugwira okha. โ Izi zimawoneka ngati chidule cha zomwe zachitika, ndipo gulu la Lerner limawoneka ngati chitsanzo cha omwe akugwira ntchito "okha".
Pofunafuna mayankho, ndinaitana Marshall Ganz, amene mosakayika akanakhala mโbwalo lodziลตika bwino lolinganiza zinthu ngati akanakhalapo. Anagwira ntchito ndi Cesar Chavez m'zaka za m'ma 1960 kuti akonzekere ogwira ntchito m'mafamu ku California ndipo anali womanga mapulani a Barack Obama okonzekera ulendo wake wa pulezidenti mu 2007. monga "momwe timasinthira zomwe tili nazo kukhala zomwe tikufuna kuti tipeze zomwe tikufuna." Izi zikugwiranso ntchito pamalingaliro onyanyala a Trump, pomwe omenyera ufulu wawo akuyesera kusintha mphamvu zawo zogula kuti zikhale zokomera anthu onse kuti asinthe komwe dziko lathu likupita.
Nditauza Ganz kuti kunyanyala kosiyanasiyana kosiyanasiyana kotereku zikuchitika popanda kugwirizana kwambiri, iye anafotokoza vutolo motere: โNjira zoyambira chinthu changa, chinthu changa, chinthu changa, nโzosavuta kwambiri mโmlengalenga.โ Kubweretsa zoyesererazo palimodzi ndiye vuto. Monga adanenera, kumbuyo ku 2007 San Francisco Bay Area yokha inali ndi magulu a 54 osiyana a pro-Obama omwe adalembetsa pa intaneti; chovuta chinali kuwapangitsa kugwirira ntchito limodzi m'njira yotumizira mphamvu zawo ku cholinga chogawana. Zikafika polimbana ndi a Donald Trump, a Ganz adanenanso kuti zitha kukhala zanzeru kwambiri kuti magulu osiyanasiyana azinyanyala komanso okakamiza kuti agwirizane. Izi zikachitika, adati, gulu lodana ndi Trump litha kukhala lokhazikika, m'malo mochitapo kanthu.
Si akatswiri onse omwe amavomereza kuwunika kwake. LA Kaufman ndiye wolemba zaposachedwa buku, Kuchita Mwachindunji: Kutsutsa ndi Kubwezeretsanso kwa American Radicalism. "Ndikuganiza kuti kukana komwe kumathandizira kumapangitsa kuti ukhale wolimba," adandiuza poyankhulana pafoni. M'malingaliro ake, kuti zochitika zonsezi ndizoyambira ndipo zikuchitika kunja kwa Democratic Party ndi chizindikiro cha kuyambiranso kwa ndale mdziko muno. Ali ndi mfundo. Komabe ndizovuta kuwona momwe kukana kwachuma, chida choyenera cholimbana ndi wamalonda wamkulu, kumatha kukhala kothandiza popanda kugwirizana kwakukulu pakuchita zomwe mwagwirizana ndi zolinga.
Ndidafunsa Shannon Coulter ngati akugwirizana ndi makampeni ena, ndipo adanenanso kuti Grab Your Wallet tsopano ikugwirizana ndi omwe akukonzekera. March wa Akazi, chionetsero chachikulu pambuyo potsegulira chionetserocho anasesa dziko. Okonza omwewo ndi omwe adalimbikitsanso kukhazikitsidwa kwa magulu pafupifupi 5,500 a omenyera ufulu wawo omwe adakumana pambuyo pa ulendowu kuti aganizire za njira zomwe zikubwera zotsutsana ndi Trump. Mgwirizano umenewu unkawoneka ngati chizindikiro cholonjeza.
Pokumbukira zomwe Ganz adanena za kuphatikiza magulu omwe adathandizira Obama mu 2007, ndidafunsa Coulter ngati angaganize zophatikiza Grab Your Wallet kukhala bungwe lalikulu. Kwa izi, adayankha motsutsa. "Ndikunena choncho," adalongosola, "chifukwa Grab Your Wallet ndi m'modzi mwa otsogozedwa ndi azimayi okha omwe ali mgululi."
Si Coulter yekha amene amapereka malingaliro otere. Popeza gulu la anti-Trump ndi gulu lamagulu ambiri omwe akuyimira amayi, anthu amitundu, othawa kwawo, LGBTQ, ndi azungu ambiri owongoka, pali nkhawa kuti kuphatikiza zoyeserera kungayambitse kukana kolamuliridwa ndi amuna oyera omwe angasokoneze zoyambira. a magulu apadera ndi zigawo zawo. Kuti zikhale zogwira mtima, akutero a Rashad Robinson a Colour of Change, makampeni ayenera kukhala ndi "ulamuliro wamakhalidwe abwino m'dera lomwe lakhudzidwa." Analongosola zochitika zomwe magulu otsogozedwa ndi azungu adayesa kutsanzira makampeni otsogozedwa ndi Colour of Change - osazindikira kuti analibe ulamuliro wamakhalidwe abwino kuti achite bwino.
Mu 2014, Zeynep Tufekci, pulofesa ku yunivesite ya North Carolina yemwe amaphunzira za chikhalidwe cha anthu, Nkhani ya TED mutu wakuti โOnline social change: easy to organised, hard to win,โ mโmene iye anafotokozamo March on Washington mu 1963. Chochitika chosaiลตalika chimenecho, pamene Martin Luther King anakamba nkhani yake yotchuka ya โI have a Dreamโ, inakopa anthu 250,000. Tufekci anatsindika kufunika kokopa khamu la anthu ngati limeneli mu 1963, pamene okonza mapulani anagwiritsa ntchito mafoni apamtunda, mapepala, ndi mawu apakamwa, m'malo opanda zipangizo zamakono zamakono. Zaka makumi asanu zapitazo sizinali zochititsa mantha kukokera anthu kotala miliyoni ku National Mall. "Ngati muli ndi mphamvu," atero a Tufekci, "muzindikira kuti muyenera kutengera mphamvu yomwe idawonetsedwa ndi ulendowu, osati kuguba kokha, komanso mphamvu yomwe idasonyezedwa ndi ulendowu, mozama."
Gulu lotsutsana ndi Trump silinakwaniritse chilichonse chodabwitsa kwambiri. Pafupifupi theka la milioni anthu adasonkhana ku Washington pa Marichi Akazi - chiwerengero chomwe chidakwera oposa miliyoni pamene zionetsero zonse kuzungulira dziko zinawonjezeredwa - koma ndi sizikumveka konse kuti manambala oterowo ali ndi kulemera kofananako lerolino monga mmene makamu angโonoangโono ankachitira mโnthaลตi zakale. Ngakhale ochita zionetsero adadzaza misewu ku Washington patatha tsiku limodzi kutsegulira, zochita zotsutsana ndi Trump zikadali zogawikana miyezi ingapo kuti akhale nthawi yake.
Ndipo zikafika polimbana ndi Purezidenti wa mabiliyoniyu, funso lofunika kwambiri ndilakuti anthu osawerengeka m'dziko lonselo, monga Dee waku New York, omwe akusintha momwe amawonongera ndalama, kutumiza ma tweets kwa otsatsa, kulumikizana ndi oyang'anira akuluakulu, komanso kuyitanitsa mafoni ku Trump. mabizinesi, adzachita izi m'njira yosinthira zochita zawo zodziwikiratu kukhala chikoka chenicheni ndi mphamvu.
Cakali kubikkila maano kapati.
Mattea Kramer, ndi TomDispatch zonse, akulemba ndemanga za chikhalidwe. Mutsatireni iye Twitter.
Nkhaniyi idawonekera koyamba pa TomDispatch.com, tsamba lawebusayiti la Nation Institute, lomwe limapereka kusuntha kwazinthu zina, nkhani, ndi malingaliro kuchokera kwa Tom Engelhardt, mkonzi wanthawi yayitali pakusindikiza, woyambitsa nawo American Empire Project, wolemba Mapeto a Chikhalidwe Chogonjetsa, monga za novel, Masiku Otsiriza a Kusindikiza. Buku lake laposachedwa ndi Gulu lamagulu: Kuwoneka, Nkhondo Zachibvundi, ndi Global Security State mu Dziko Lokha Lopambana (Mabuku a Haymarket).
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama