Ya kasance rabin karni da suka wuce, amma har yanzu ina tunawa da shi sosai. "Dole ne mu taimaki Kudancin Vietnam," in yi bayani. "Ƙasa ce mai cin gashin kanta da wata ƙasa ta mamaye, Arewacin Vietnam."
"A'a, a'a," abokina ya nuna rashin amincewa. “Akwai Vietnam guda ɗaya, daga arewa zuwa kudu, an raba ta ta hanyar wucin gadi. Yakin basasa ne. Kuma ba mu da kasuwanci mu shiga ciki. Muna kara dagula al’amura ga kowa.”
A lokacin, ban ji wani ya kwatanta yakin Vietnam haka ba. Idan na waiwaya baya, ina ganin shi a matsayin darasi na na farko a cikin ainihin gaskiyar rayuwar siyasa - cewa siyasa a kodayaushe fafatawar ce tsakanin labarai masu gasa. Karɓi wani labari na daban kuma za ku ga batun daban, wanda zai iya barin ku buɗe don tallafawa wata manufa ta daban. Wadanda ke sarrafa labarin, wato, suna iya sarrafa abin da aka yi, shi ya sa gwamnatoci a kai a kai suke tattara albarkatunsu - suna kiransa farfaganda ko kuma kiransa wani abu dabam - don kiyaye wannan labarin a hannunsu.
A halin yanzu, yayin da Amurkawa ke sanya ido kan kungiyar IS, akwai labarai guda biyu kawai masu gasa a can game da halin da ake ciki a Gabas ta Tsakiya: ku yi la'akari da su a matsayin kungiyar IS. manufa-creep da yi-da-hamada-haske labarai. Gwamnatin Obama ta ba da shawarar cewa dole ne mu "kare" Amurka ta hanyar haɓaka ƙoƙarinmu a hankali, tun daga hare-hare ta sama zuwa masu ba da shawara ga hare-hare na musamman a kan Daular Islama. Masu sukar gwamnati, musamman 'yan takarar Republican na shugaban kasa, suna roƙon mu da mu "kare" kanmu ta hanyar tayar da bama-bamai na IS ga masu kai hare-hare, tura dakaru masu yawa na sojojin Amurka, da kuma haɓaka ƙarfin soja. Duk da cewa Gwamnatin Obama da kuma Congress ci gaba da rawa a kusa da kalmar "yaki," duka nau'ikan biyu tabbas labaran yaki ne. Babu ainihin labarin zaman lafiya a gani.
Tabbas, masu fafutukar tabbatar da zaman lafiya sun shagaltu da yin ramuka a cikin labaran yakin biyu. Ba wuya. Kamar yadda su nunawa, matakin da Amurka ta dauka kan kungiyar IS na cin karensu babu babbaka ne. A fili take ba daular Musulunci daidai abin da take so. Don duk tunaninsa na yaƙin ƙarshe na apocalyptic tare da kafirai, wannan motsi ba a cikin wata ma'ana ta al'ada ba ne ko dai yana shirin kai hari ga Amurka ko kuma yana iya yin hakan. Maƙasudinsa na zahiri, ainihin duniya shine don cin nasara karin musulmi zuwa ga gefensa a ko'ina. Abubuwa kalilan ne suka fi aiwatar da wannan manufa fiye da hare-haren da Amurka ke kaiwa Musulmi a Gabas ta Tsakiya.
Idan kungiyar IS ta kai hare-hare lokaci-lokaci a Turai kuma ta yi kokarin zaburar da su a nan Amurka, abin ya fi daukar hankali ne. Yana so ya zama burin Washington na dindindin, wanda ke ba ta cachet, yana haɓaka gwagwarmaya. A duk lokacin da muka yi taho-mu-gama, muna ba wa Daular Islama wata nasara, muna taimaka mata girma da kaddamar da sabbin “hanyoyi” a wasu kasashen musulmi da suka fi yawa.
Wannan bincike ne mai ma'ana, wanda ke da nasaba da dalilai na ƙarin yaƙi. Bai taɓa isa ba, duk da haka, kawai don nuna cewa labarin da ya mamaye bai dace da gaskiya ba. Idan kuna son canza manufofin, kuna buƙatar sabon labari, wanda ya fi dacewa da gaskiya sosai saboda an gina shi akan sabon fage.
Tun shekaru aru-aru, masana kimiyya sun gano kowane irin aibi a cikin tsohon ra'ayi cewa rana tana kewaya duniya, amma ta ci gaba har sai Copernicus ya fito da wani sabon salo. Haka lamarin yake a siyasa. Abin da ake buƙata ba kawai labari mara kyau ba ne wanda ya ce, "Ga shi ya sa ra'ayoyinku da ayyukanku ba daidai ba ne," amma mai kyau wanda ya dace da gaskiya mafi kyau. Saboda an gina shi a kan wani sabon yanayi, yana iya nuna sabbin hanyoyin yin aiki a duniya, don haka ya haɗu da ingantacciyar motsi don neman canji.
A mafi kyawun su, ƙungiyoyin zaman lafiya a baya ko da yaushe suna wuce gona da iri don ba da labarun da suka bayyana rikice-rikice ta sabbin hanyoyi. A halin yanzu, duk da haka, har yanzu ƙungiyar tabbatar da zaman lafiya ta Amurka ba ta sami madadin labarin da yake buƙatar yin magana game da Daular Islama ba, wanda ya bar shi ba kawai inuwa ba a fagen siyasar Amurka.
Vietnam Redux
Wannan ba wai a ce yunkurin zaman lafiya ya makale ba-ba labari. Wani labari mai tasiri wanda zai iya dawo da shi rayuwa shine zaune a fili, a daidai lokacin da masu fafutukar zaman lafiya suka fi sukar yakin Amurka da Daular Islama.
Kungiyar IS ba ta yin yaki da Amurka, kamar yadda suka bayyana, ko kuma a Turai. Hare-haren sa na kai-kawo a kan wadancan kasashen “kafirai” na da nufin murkushe musulmin da ke zaune a wurin da fatan daukarsu aiki. Hakika, dukkan dabarun IS an tsara su ne domin samun nasarar musulmi a bangarenta da kuma samun karin karfin fada a ji a kasashen musulmi. A nan ne akasarin tashe-tashen hankulan da IS ke jagoranta ko kuma suka faru, duk abin da musulmi ke kira darul Islam, "gidan Musulunci," daga Najeriya zuwa Syria Indonesia.
Matsalar daular Musulunci: yawancin Musulmai masu adalci ne ba saye labarinsa. A gaskiya, IS ne yin makiya haka kuma abokai a duk inda ta shiga. Wato yana da hannu cikin yakin basasa a ciki darul Islam.
Duk wani mataki da muka dauka cikin wannan yakin basasa kuskure ne da zai kara mana rauni. Idan muka kara karfi wajen yaki da Daular Islama, haka nan za mu ba ta uzuri da karfafa gwiwa don kokarin kawo mana hari, kuma da sauki IS ta dauki mayaka don yin aikin. Hanya mafi kyau don kare rayukan Amurkawa ita ce mu wuce tsoronmu kuma mu ƙi shiga cikin yakin basasa na wani.
Wannan ita ce ingantacciyar labari da ake jira a fitar da ita daga nazarin yunkurin zaman lafiya. Ɗaya daga cikin manyan dalilan da ƙungiyoyin ke da irin wannan tasiri a cikin waɗannan shekaru: ba a taɓa fitar da wannan labarin na "yakin basasar musulmi" a fili ba, duk da cewa ya dace da gaskiyar fiye da ɗaya daga cikin labarun yakin da ake bayarwa. Yana canza tunaninmu game da halin da ake ciki ta hanyar musun ainihin jigo na babban labari - cewa IS na yaƙi da Amurka don haka dole ne mu sake yin yaƙi. Yana nuna sabon manufar rabuwa.
Kuma labari ne mai sauƙi, mai ƙarfi ga Amurkawa saboda sananne ne. Yana mayar da mu rabin karni da rabin duniya nesa - zuwa Vietnam. A wancan lokacin, abokina da (dan kadan daga baya) ni ma, na rungumi labarin cewa yakin basasa ya kama Vietnam. Wannan bayanin zai taka muhimmiyar rawa wajen bunkasa nasarar yunkurin zaman lafiya na sittin. A cikin 'yan shekaru, miliyoyin Amurkawa, 'yan ƙasa da sojoji iri ɗaya, sun ga rikici ta haka - kuma ba shekaru da yawa ba, duk sojojin Amurka sun tafi daga Vietnam.
Labarin kungiyar zaman lafiya a lokacin abu ne mai sauki kuma cikakke. A'a, in ji shi, ba mu ne mutanen kirki masu kare wata al'umma mai cin gashin kanta daga mamayewar wata al'umma ba. Haka nan ba ma fada da makiya da nufin su cutar da mu ba. Zakaran dambe Muhammad Ali samu daidai lokacin da ya ce: "Ba ni da wata jayayya da Viet Cong."
Shiga cikin yaƙin basasa na Vietnam ya jawo mana hasara fiye da 58,000 Amurka rayuwa da yayi barna da ba a tantance ba ga likitocin da suka tsira, ba don yin magana akan me ba ya yi ga miliyoyin Vietnamese. Ya nuna mana cewa, komai girman fasaharmu, ba za mu iya shiga cikin yakin basasa na wani ba. Shisgin mu ya kasance ya fi cutarwa fiye da alheri.
Shekaru XNUMX bayan haka, muna maimaita kuskuren kayar da kai. Matakin soja a kan Daular Islama yana kai mu cikin wani "rikici mai kama da Vietnam," a wannan karon a Iraki, Siriya, da sauran wurare a Gabas ta Tsakiya. Har wa yau, mun tsunduma kanmu a cikin wani hadadden yakin basasa a kasashen waje ba tare da wata dabarar da za ta kai ga nasara ba. Ba daidai ba ne a lokacin. Ba daidai ba ne yanzu.
A sanya shi a taƙaice, Amurka tana da ƙasa da kyakkyawan tarihi idan ana maganar shiga tsakani a cikin yaƙe-yaƙe na wasu mutane. Mun kuma yi shisshigi sosai da zaɓe. A cikin shekaru ashirin da suka gabata, mun daina tashe-tashen hankula a wurare irin su Congo da kuma Sri Lanka. Don haka shawarar ba za ta tsoma baki ta hanyar soja ba a yakin basasa na kasashen waje ya kamata Amurkawa ta saba da ita.
Yin tsaka-tsaki ba wai yin la'akari da mummunan zalunci da dabi'un daular Musulunci ba. Da kyar masu fafutukar neman zaman lafiya na karni na ashirin da daya za su baiwa IS wani abu kamar yadda masu zanga-zangar zamanin Vietnam da yawa suka yi wa masu tayar da kayar baya a wancan lokacin. A wannan yanayin, zama tsaka tsaki yana nufin ba da shawara cewa ba aikin Washington ba ne yaƙar mugunta a ko'ina. Aikinta shi ne ta yi amfani da dabarun da za a iya kiyaye lafiyar Amurkawa.
Wannan ra'ayi ne da yawancin Amirkawa suka yi riko da shi sosai. Don haka labarin "Yakin basasar Musulmi" na iya samun jin dadi a fagen jama'a.
Rikicin Rikicin Yakin Musulmi
Tabbas gwamnatin Musulunci ba ta da hannu a cikin abin da muka saba dauka a matsayin yakin basasa, inda bangarorin biyu ke fafutukar neman mallakar kasa daya. Hatta a cikin kasar Siriya, yawan bangarorin da ke da hannu a gwagwarmayar da suka hada da azzalumar gwamnatin Bashar al-Assad da kuma 'yan tawaye na kowane bangare daga al-Qaeda masu alaka da Saudiyya da ke da alaka da Amurka, abin mamaki ne. Tunda kungiyar IS na yaki ne ba wai Syria kadai ba amma na duka darul Islam, wasu ƙungiyoyi, ƙungiyoyi, da sojoji masu yawa suna shiga cikin wannan yaƙin basasa na musulmi.
Wasu masu kallo suna da sauri sosai don sauƙaƙa shi cikin yaƙin “masu gargajiya da masu zamani.” A cikin manyan kafofin watsa labarai na Amurka waɗanda galibi ke fassara zuwa sha'awar mu shiga tsakani a madadin masu sabuntar zamani. Thomas Friedman New York Times tabbas mai yiwuwa ne sanannen lauya na wannan ra'ayi. Wasu kuma sukan sauqaqa shi ya zama yaqin Ahlus-Sunnah da Shi’ah. Da yake Iran ita ce kan gaba wajen 'yan Shi'a, wadanda ke cikin kafafen yada labarai suna son Ahlus-Sunnah ne.
Duk waɗannan hotuna masu sauƙi an zana su don gina goyon baya ga gefe ɗaya ko wani. Irin zaman lafiya da suke son cimmawa shi ne wanda zai bar bangaren da suke so ya yi nasara.
A haƙiƙa, babu wani sassauƙan dichotomy da zai iya ɗaukar ruɗewar gwagwarmaya a ciki darul Islam. Mabiya addinin Sunna suna fada da sauran masu bin Sunna (misali, al-Qaeda da IS). Masu zamani suna haɗawa da ƴan gargajiya don yaƙar sauran ƴan gargajiya (misali, Turkiyya da Saudiyya a cikin wani kawance mara dadi don raunana IS). Sunni da Shi'a ma sun zama abokan kawance (misali, Kurdawa Sunni da mayakan Shi'a na Iraki kawance da IS). Amurka tana goyon bayan 'yan Shi'a (kamar gwamnatin Iraki) da 'yan Sunna (kamar kasashen Gulf masu arzikin man fetur), yayin da take adawa da karuwar karfin 'yan Shi'a (kamar Iran) da Sunna (kamar IS).
Ta hanyar jaddada ainihin rikitaccen yakin basasar musulmi, labarin yunkurin zaman lafiya na iya jefa wannan yakin a wani yanayi na daban. Daidai saboda babu bangarori biyu da aka keɓe a fili, ba ma'ana ba ne a jefa gefe ɗaya a matsayin mutanen kirki kuma mu kaddamar da jiragenmu da jirage marasa matuka don shafe mugayen mutane. Tabbas zai haifar da rashin jituwa da bala'i, musamman a irin wannan yanayi, inda Daular Islama, ko da yake yawancin Amurkawa sun kyamaci. tabbas ba mafi muni ba fiye da jiga-jigan kawayenmu, gidan sarautar Saudiyya.
Idan aka yi la’akari da ruɗani, wasu na iya cewa ruɗani, rikice-rikicen tsakanin musulmi, ba daidai ba ne a ci gaba da inganta tunanin Amurka na samar da tsari. ("Ba tare da tsari ba," Friedman ya rubuta, "babu wani abu mai kyau da zai iya faruwa.") Ɗaukar wannan hanya zuwa yanzu, tun lokacin da aka mamaye Iraki a 2003, haƙiƙa yana nufin ƙaddamar da hargitsi a muhimman sassa na Gabas ta Tsakiya. Babu wani dalili da zai sa a yi tunanin hanya ɗaya za ta kai ko'ina a nan gaba.
Kawo Samari, 'Yan Mata, Da Jiragen Saman Gida
Labarin yakin basasar musulmi yana kaiwa kai tsaye zuwa ga canji mai ma'ana a cikin manufofin: daina ƙoƙarin aiwatar da oda a Amurka. darul Islam. Bayar da shakku gamsuwa na wani yaƙi da “masu-tabbata” kuma. Maimakon haka, bayar da agajin jin kai na gaske, ba tare da wata boyayyar manufa ta siyasa ba, ga wadanda yakin basasa ya rutsa da su, musamman wadanda ke gudun tashin hankali a Syria da Amurka ta taimaka wajen dorewa. Amma a daina duk wani mataki na soji, da duk wani matsin tattalin arziki, da duk wani yunkuri na diflomasiyya ga kowane bangare a yakin basasar musulmi. Kasance, kamar yadda muke yi a wasu yaƙe-yaƙe na basasa, tsaka tsaki na gaske.
Don kiran wannan canji na labari da siyasa babban tsari shine rashin fahimta. Za a sami manyan runduna da za a yi gaba da ita, idan aka yi la'akari da yadda ake ci gaba da kai hare-hare ta hanyar kai hare-hare a kan Washington, wanda ya riga ya zaburar da daya. mummunan kisan gilla a kasar Amurka. Ba mu san lokacin da, ko kuma idan, wasu hare-haren za su yi nasara a nan gaba, ko IS ce ta shirya ko kuma ta hanyar “kerkeci kaɗai” waɗanda wannan kayan ya ƙarfafa su.
Muhimmin abin da ya kamata a tuna, shi ne, babu ɗaya daga cikin waɗannan da ke nuni da yaƙin da aka yi wa Amurka. Yafi yin dabara ne a yakin basasar musulmi. Ga Daular Islama, rayuwar Amurkawa da fargabar 'yan wasa ne kawai a wasan. Kuma duk da haka wannan gaskiyar a Gabas ta Tsakiya ta ci karo da wani abu da ke cikin tarihinmu. Shekaru aru-aru, yawancin Amurkawa sun yi imani cewa al'ummarmu ita ce cibiyar tarihin duniya, cewa duk abin da ya faru a ko'ina dole ne ya kasance a kanmu kai tsaye - kuma muna ci gaba da ganin kanmu a matsayin tauraron wasan kwaikwayo na duniya.
Yawancin Amurkawa kuma sun kasance sharadi shekaru da dama da suka wuce a yi imani da cewa abin da ke tattare da shi wani wasan kwaikwayo ne na rayuwa ko mutuwa wanda wasu abokan gaba, a wani wuri, ko da yaushe ke da niyya don lalata al'ummarmu. A halin yanzu kungiyar IS ita ce kadai 'yan takara a wannan matsayi kuma da wuya a yi tunanin jama'a su bar labarin da ke da tushe da nufin halaka mu. Amma rabin karni da suka wuce, yana da wuya a yi tunanin cewa labarin Vietnam zai zama kamar yadda ya canza sosai a cikin 'yan shekaru. Don haka abu ne mai tsayi, amma ba abin da ba za a iya tunani ba, don kwatanta Amurka, 'yan shekaru kadan daga yanzu, tana kuka da kukan da ke maimaita irin na zamanin Vietnam: “Amurka ta fita daga cikinta. darul Islam.” "Ku kawo yara maza - da 'yan mata da masu tayar da bama-bamai da jirage marasa matuka - gida."
Kuma idan wani ya ce kwatankwacin da ke tsakanin Vietnam da rikicin da ake yi a yanzu abu ne da za a iya cece-kuce, wannan shi ne kawai batun. Maimakon a hanzarta zuwa ƙarin yaƙi, lokaci ya yi da za a yi muhawara ta ƙasa ta gaske kan batun. Lokaci ya yi da za a bai wa jama'ar Amirka damar zaɓar tsakanin labarai guda biyu daban-daban. Aikin yunkurin zaman lafiya, a yanzu kamar ko da yaushe, shine samar da mafita ta gaskiya.
Ira Chernus, A TomDispatch yau da kullum, farfesa ne na nazarin addini a Jami'ar Colorado Boulder kuma marubucin intanet "MythicAmerica: Essays.” Ya yi blogs a MythicAmerica.us.
Wannan labarin ya fara bayyana akan TomDispatch.com, gidan yanar gizon Cibiyar ta Nation, wanda ke ba da ci gaba ta hanyar hanyoyin daban-daban, labarai, da ra'ayi daga Tom Engelhardt, editan dogon lokaci a cikin wallafe-wallafe, wanda ya kafa Cibiyar Daular Amurka, marubucin Ƙarshen Nasara Al'adu, kamar na novel, Kwanakin Karshen Bugawa. Sabon littafinsa shine Shadow Gwamnati: Kulawa, Wakilin Wuri, da Tsaro na Duniya a Ƙasar Kasuwanci (Littattafan Haymarket).
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi
1 Comment
A da daular mulkin mallaka na Amurka ya fuskanci turjiya ne kawai daga ƙungiyoyin da ba na addini ba da kuma a cikin ƙasashen Kirista daga sarakunan Roman Katolika .
Daular Amurka ta yau ta kai ta zuwa yankin musulmi gaba daya na duniya da Musulunci, sabanin sauran addinai biyu na Ibrahim ba wai kawai ya dace da kai hari ba amma ya umarce su.
Wannan umarni ya fito ne ga mutanen da suke yin addu’a sau biyar a rana kuma wadanda ba kamar Yahudawa da Musulmai ba, suna mai da addininsu wani muhimmin bangare na rayuwarsu ta yau da kullun kamar yadda ya dace da tunaninsu na kama-karya.
Wannan addini ya koyar da cewa hari daga Daular dole ne a hadu da daukar fansa .
Don haka lokacin da Amurka ta kashe yara 500,000 a cikin takunkumin Iraki kuma daruruwan dubunnan karin wadanda ba su ji ba ba su gani ba ko wadanda ba mayakan ba ne suka mutu sakamakon ayyukan da Amurka ke yi a duk fadin yankin da kuma duniyar musulmi, abin da CIA sharuddan buguwa ya yi matukar ta'azzara ta hanyar karin Musulunci.
Turawan mulkin mallaka na Amurka ya tashi daga daukar nauyin sojojinsa zuwa kisan gilla, hare-haren kwamandoji/Special Forces amma har yanzu suna aikata laifukan yaki wajen kai hare-hare a yankunan farar hula a hare-haren jiragen sama a kan wadanda za su biyo bayan harin ramuwar gayya na kisan abokai, dangi. kuma saboda addininsu ya gaya musu dole ne su yi.
Ba muna yakar ta'addancin Musulunci masu tsattsauran ra'ayi ba kamar yadda kafafen yada labarai na hannun dama suka ayyana shi amma muna yaki da abin da CIA ta kira "baya .
Zai fi sauƙi a gaya wa jama'ar Amirka ƙaryar cewa wani addini dabam ya ta'allaka ne a tushen waɗannan hare-haren ta'addanci yayin da gwamnatin Amurka ta sani sarai cewa kashe-kashen da Amurka ke yi wa masu adawa da shi ne ya jawo kiyayyar musulmi. duniya.
Haka ne kuma Musulunci mai kama-karya ne , mai kishin kasa , mai juya baya kuma mai cutarwa ga bil'adama , musamman mata kamar yadda sauran addinan Ibrahim guda biyu suka yi kadan a wannan lokaci a tarihin dan Adam akalla.
Abu ne mai mahimmanci amma ba shine ainihin dalilin busawa ba.
IMO