Bekuyindatshana exakile ekhasini lokuqala le-New York Times: Ujenene wase-U.S., uMichael K. Nagata, umkhuzi wamabutho e-American Special Operations e-Middle East, wayevuma ukuthi i-Pentagon ilwa nesitha engayiboni. 'uqonde, futhi uye wafuna ubuchwepheshe ngaphandle kwezempi ukuze asize ukuthola ukuthi yini abhekene nayo.
Uthi uNagata, "Asiwuqondi umnyakazo, futhi kuze kube yilapho sikwenza, ngeke siwunqobe," esho, ngokusho kwemizuzu eyimfihlo yocingo lwengqungquthela alubambe nochwepheshe. โAsikawuhluli umqondo. Asiwuqondi ngisho nombono lowo.โ
Ugcine nini ukuzwa umkhuzi omkhulu evuma ukuthi ulahlekile, njengoba ukuqhunyiswa kwamabhomu kwe-Islamic State kuqhubeka nezigidigidi ezengeziwe ukuze kuqedwe lesi sihlava esibonakala sikhula ngamandla naphezu kwawo wonke amandla ase-U.S.
Kanjani futhi kungani uMongameli Obama ememezele impi esitheni esingasiqondi? Ngokwaleli โphephandaba lomlando,โ izikhulu ziyavuma ukuthi azikaphumeleli emkhankasweni omkhulu, osethathe isikhathi eside wokubulala imibono egqugquzela le nhlangano yamaphekula.
Enye ingxenye kahulumeni izishaya isifuba ngokuthi siyawina; omunye akanaso isiqiniseko.
Njengoba usosayensi wezombangazwe uMichael Brenner echaza, akukho okunengqondo okwenzekayo uma kubhekwa amaqiniso akhona. Kusikhumbuza iVietnam lapho izikhulu zakha khona โukukhanya ekugcineni komhubhe.โ
UBrenner uyabhala: โPho kungani iWashington izanelisa futhi izanelise? Phela, kusafanele izabalaze namaqiniso angenakunqandeka amelwe yilokhu okulandelayo: i-ISIL ezoba amandla amakhulu kakhulu njengoba iso lingabona; isikhonzi sikhula usongo lwezenzo zobuphekula; uhulumeni waseBaghdad okungenzeka ukuthi awusekho engozini kodwa umbhalo wawo ungaphezu kwengxenye yezwe; ukungezwani okungakaxazululwa kwama-Arab-Kurd; iTurkey eyisicefe ngaphansi kuka-Erdogan okhulayo osebenza nhlangothi zombili zomgwaqo; U-Assad wangena eDamaseku ngaleso sikhathi isitha futhi waba umngane vis a vis ISIL; ukucwaswa kwamabutho asekela intando yeningi aseNtshonalanga esifundeni sonke; iYemen esiphithiphithini esingaphenduleki kancane ezimfuno zaseMelika; futhi, vele, ukwehla kobudlelwano be-Israel-Palestine. Nokho iWashington ngandlela thize ibonakala yanelisekile yikho konke lokhu futhi ayiboni isisusa sokufinyelela indawo yokuhlala ne-Iran.โ
Naphezu kwakho konke ukuzenzisa nokuzikhukhumeza e-White House, naphezu kweqiniso lokuthi lena yimpi eheha ukwesekwa endaweni yonke, kusukela kuma-pro-war Christian nationalists agxeka i-Islam ngakwesokudla kanye namaDemocrats ngakwesobunxele" abacasulwe yi-ISIL. โUkunqunywa kwamakhanda, inqubekela phambili ihamba kancane uma nje kungenxa yokuthi amandla omoya ewodwa angenza umonakalo kodwa angaphumeleli.
Sekuyiminyaka eyi-13 sishaya i-Afghanistan ngokuqhunyiswa kwamabhomu kanye nokudonsa amanzi, kodwa leyo mpi isekude ukuphela. Sekudlule isikhathi eside kuneMpi Yezwe II.
Futhi kuthiwani โngempiโ nenhlangano ezibiza nge-Daesh, igama ongakaze ulibone emaphephandabeni ase-U.S. Kumhlaziyi wezepolitiki uGareth Porter, le "mpi" ingeyezepolitiki - hhayi eyezempi:
"Impi yase-US ku-'Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant' noma i-ISIL, eyaziwa nangokuthi i-Islamic State of IS - intuthuko enkulu kunazo zonke kunqubomgomo yezangaphandle yase-U.S. ngo-2014 - iyaqhubeka nokudida labo abafuna amasu ayo. Kodwa isixazululo sendida sisekucatshangelweni okungahlangene nokuphendula okuphusile ezintweni ezingokoqobo emhlabeni.
Eqinisweni, konke lokhu kusho mayelana nezintshisakalo zezepolitiki kanye nezinhlaka zasekhaya.
Ngokusobala umzamo wezempi oholwa yi-US uhloselwe "ukuhlakaza" "i-Islamic State" njengosongo ekuzinzeni kweMpumalanga Ephakathi kanye nokuphepha kwe-U.S. Kepha akekho umhlaziyi wezempi ozimele noma ophikisana nobushokobezi okholelwa ukuthi amasosha asetshenziswa e-Iraq naseSyria anethuba elincane lokufeza leyo nhloso.โ
I-Daily Beast iyabika: โI-Pentagon isanda kwethula uhlelo lwayo lokuqeqesha amasosha ase-Iraqi ukuthi alwe ne-ISISโfuthi inamasonto ayisithupha kuphela ubude. Ngisho nezikhulu zamasosha ziyavuma ukuthi lolu hlelo alwanele, kubika uNancy A. Youssef. Cishe ngemva konyaka, i-US ayikasondeli ekudaleni amandla aphansi adingekayo ukuze anqobe iqembu lamaphekula elihamba phambili emhlabeni. "
Kuleli qophelo, impi ifanekisela ukwedlula okwangempela, eklanyelwe ukukhombisa โukuphakamaโ kwempucuko yethu โempucukweniโ yethu, leyo, njengoba uGandhi ake asho, โkungaba umqondo omuhle.โ I-Al Jazeera isanda kukhipha umbiko nge-Daesh, njengoba nohulumeni waseQatar efakwe emkhankasweni wokuzama ukuyiqeda.
Nasi isiphetho sabahlaziyi babo. Ngokuqinisekile kuqinisekisa ukuhluleka kwethu "kwempi yokwesaba" futhi ikwenza kucace ukuthi ukubulawa kuka-bin Laden-uma lokho kwenzeka ngempela akuzange kubulale i-Al Qaeda noma inhlangano yeJihadi.
"I-Daesh manje isingumdlali wesifunda esiwela umngcele olawula izindawo ezinkulu futhi acekele phansi imingcele yamazwe ngamazwe ukuze axhumanise izindawo zaseSyria nase-Iraq ngaphansi kwethonya layo. Iphinde ibe nezikhali zezempi ezibalulekile, ezitholwa kakhulu ngesikhathi sezimpi zayo namabutho ase-Iraq naseSyria; inolwazi olunzulu lwezempi nokusebenza kahle kokulwa; futhi inengxenye yezempi elawula izimpi zayo ngobungcweti obuvelele. I-Daesh inemithombo eminingi yengcebo etholakala ezizindeni zikawoyela ezilawulayo, isebenzisana ngobuhlakani โnemakethe emnyamaโ ukuze ibalekele unswinyo olunzima oluye lwabekwa. Ngaphezu kwalokho, futhi mhlawumbe okubaluleke kakhulu, isebenzisa ngobuhlakani kokubili izingxabano zesifunda ezikhona kanye nezithakazelo ezingqubuzanayo zabalingisi bombuso besifunda nesomhlaba kuyilapho izuza kukhava yezenhlalo ekhiqizwe ukusabalala kwamahlelo, isiyaluyalu kanye negebe lezikhala lezombusazwe ezweni lama-Arab.
I-Daesh isandiso sombono se-al-Qaeda kanye nombono we-Jihad yomhlaba wonke kunesimo esiphambene noma esiyingqayizivele sokweqisa. Nakuba la maqembu amabili ehlukene ezindabeni ezithile zenqubo, ikakhulukazi mayelana nokusebenzisa unya, iqiniso liwukuthi womabili asuka esisekelweni esifanayo sokulwa nalabo โabami endleleni yokubusa ngezwi likaNkulunkulu.
I-Islamic State ikubeke kwacaca, ikakhulukazi ngemuva kokulahla "i-Iraq ne-Syria" egameni layo futhi imemezele i-caliphate, ukuthi ihlela ukunweba ithonya layo ngaphesheya kwesifunda se-MENA (Middle East neNyakatho Afrika). Eqinisweni, umkhondo walokhu ungabonakala emisebenzini ye-IS e-Caucuses nase-Asia Ephakathi, namalungu aseChechen nase-Azeri azibophezela ukuthi angalwi eSyria nase-Iraq kuphela kodwa futhi nokufinyelela emazweni akubo ngesikhathi esifanele. I-Russia ne-Iran, kanye ne-China, bakhathazeke kakhulu ngomthelela lokhu okuzoba nawo ekuvikelekeni kwabo.
Indlela eyodwa ayikwazi ukusetshenziselwa ukuchaza ukuvela kukaDaesh. Ngamanye amazwi, le dossier ithole ukuthi imvelaphi yeqembu ayikwazi ukumane ibalulwe ezincazelweni ezijwayelekile ezifana nezici zomongo, imibhalo yezenkolo esekelwe kuyo, izici zezenhlalo nezengqondo noma isiphakamiso sokuthi i-Islamic State iyisiphazamiso emlandweni. ye-jihad yomhlaba wonke. Kunalokho, noma yimuphi umcwaningi onethemba lokuqonda leli qembu kufanele acabangele izici zendawo, zesifunda, zomlando nezamazwe ngamazwe ukuze alandele umthelela weqembu futhi aqonde ukuthi liphokophelephi esikhathini esizayo.โ
Akekho osesikhundleni sezokuphepha kazwelonke saseMelika obona i-Daesh njengosongo lwangempela e-US. Ngakho-ke kungani zishisa kangaka uku-trot ukuze zithembise umshado? UGareth Porter uyaphikisana, kungenxa yezabelomali ezinkulu kanye nokukhula kwesikhungo:
"Ngaphambi kokuhamba okumangalisayo kwe-ISIL ku-2014, i-Pentagon kanye nezinsizakalo zezempi zabhekana nethemba lokwehla kwesabelomali sezokuvikela ngemuva kokuhoxiswa kwe-US e-Afghanistan. Manje i-Army, Air Force kanye ne-Special Operations Command yabona ukuthi kungenzeka ukubamba izindima zezempi ezintsha ekulweni ne-ISIL. I-Special Operations Command, okwakungoka-Obama "Ithuluzi elithandwayo" yokulwa nabashisekeli abangamaSulumane, ibizokuhlupheka ngesabelomali sayo sokuqala esiyingqophamlando ngemuva kweminyaka engu-13 yokunyuswa kwemali okuqhubekayo. Bekuyi kubika "ukukhungatheka" ngokwehliselwa endimeni evumela ama-airstrikes ase-US futhi alangazelele ukuthatha i-ISIL ngqo."
Iphuzu elibalulekile: Kuningi mayelana nemali njenganoma yini enye!
UDanny Schechter wenza iFilimu WMD (Izikhali Zokukhohlisa Kakhulu) mayelana nempi ka-2003 yase-Iraq. Uyahlela Mediachannel.org. Amazwana ku [i-imeyili ivikelwe].
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa kuphela ngokuphana kwabafundi bayo.
Nikela