Ukususela ekuzalweni kwethu ngowe-1776 nasekuzalweni ngokutsha kukaSirayeli ngowe-1948, ezi zizwe zibini ziye zaba nezinto ezibalulekileyo ezifanayo. Okona kubaluleke kakhulu kwiinjongo zangoku kukuba kuwo omabini la mazwe uninzi lwabantu babo - ukuba abazange bonke - babone ukuzalwa kwesizwe sabo njengesenzo sembali yobugorha; yaye uhlanga lwabo baye balubona lungenakungcikivwa.
Iqaqobana eliphikisayo belisoloko lincinci, lincinci kakhulu e-USA kunakwaSirayeli, kude kube ngoku. Kuluncedo ukujonga ubuncinci kwezinye zezinto ezifanayo, ngaphandle kokulibala ukuba ezi zizwe zibini zahluke kangakanani kwaye zahlala.
Into efika kuqala kukuba yomibini yabakho ngokugxotha ngenkohlakalo abantu ababelapho ngaphambi, ngexesha nasemva kokuzalwa kwabo: amaPalestina, kwaSirayeli, intaphane yezizwe โzamaIndiyaโ kuMntla Merika. Kuyo nayiphi na imeko abantu abaninzi balo naluphi na uhlanga bakha babuqonda ubugwenxa obunzulu - ubugebenga bemfazwe? - bazinikele kubo bonke abantu bantlandlolo.
Eneneni, into efana nechasi yokuqonda ichaza izimo zengqondo zenkoliso yabemi bala mazwe omabini. E-USA izimo zengqondo ezinjalo ziye zaboniswa ixesha elide kwaye ngokuqhubekayo kwiincwadi kunye neefilimu, zimiliselwe ezingqondweni zethu ukususela ebuntwaneni ukuya phambili, apho "izikhumba ezibomvu" zenziwe nge-caricatured kwaye zihlanjululwe njengezilwanyana, ababulali babo banikwa iwonga lobuqhawe.
KwaSirayeli, abantu basePalestina abalwa nokuphulukana nomhlaba wabo, amalungelo abo nobomi babo, ngokufanayo bamelwa kakubi xa phantse bechazwa ngokufanayo โnjengabanqolobi.โ Kwimihla yethu yamandulo, abo babefuna ukugxotha amaBritane babebizwa ngokuba โngamathandazweโ; abo baqhushumba iHotele yaseJerusalem iKing David Hotel ngowe-1947 yaye bajongwa njengamagorha ngamaSirayeli, kodwa eso senzo sachazwa ngamaBritane โnjengohlaselo lwabanqolobiโ: uhlaselo lokuqala olurekhodiweyo lweli gama. Ubugrogrisi, njengobuhle, busemehlweni obukeleyo.
Ubani unokuqhubeka aze aqhube nentetho enjalo ephathelele izinto ezifanayo. Kodwa makhe ndiphendulele kwezinye iiyantlukwano. AmaYuda awadala umbutho wamaZiyoni ngaphezu kwenkulungwane eyadlulayo nawo aqalisa ngokuthe ngcembe ukuzinza apho ekuqaleni kwamashumi eminyaka enkulungwane yama-20. Loo nkqubo yakhawuleziswa kakhulu yaye amanani ayo anda kakhulu emva kweMfazwe Yehlabathi II.
Abahlali bokuqala babenezizathu ezivakalayo zokuyishiya imihlaba ababegcinwe kuyo, abo bathe ukusukela ngeminyaka yoo-1930s ababejongene nokubulawa kwabantu abaninzi babenezizathu ezinamandla ngakumbi. AmaYuda awayefudukele kuzo zombini ezi meko akwazi ukuzibona ebuyela kumazwe ooyisemkhulu.
Akukho nto efana naleyo yayiyinyani kwabo badala i-American Revolution, kunjalo. Noko ke, kuzo zombini ezi meko, โabasandulโ ukufikaโ babesiba imihlaba yaye besonakalisa ubomi babo babesele belapho.
Kwaye ngoku sinokubona uthelekiso olusondele kakhulu phakathi โkokususwa kwamaIndiyaโ kuyo yonke inkulungwane ye-19 kunye nokususwa kwamaPalestine, emva kokuhlala ngo-1967, kubonwa njengento engekho mthethweni ngabo bonke ngaphandle kwe-USA kunye noSirayeli. โAmaIndiya asusiweyoโ ahluthwa oko ayekubona njengemihlaba yawo engcwele nezithethe noorhulumente abanxulumene nawo.
โUkususwaโ kwakwandulela, kwakhatshwa kwaza kwalandelwa ziimfazwe ezibakho ngamaxesha athile. Phakathi kweemfazwe nemiphumo engqalileyo nengangqalanga yokufuduswa kwawo, kuqikelelwa ukuba izigidi ezisi-6 ukusa kwezisi-9 โzabemi bomthonyamaโ baphulukana nobomi babo, ngenxa yendlala, ukugula okanye ukubulawa; yaye abo basindayo kumxholo othi โugcinoโ babenobomi obufutshane nobuphantsi.
Ezo nkqubo zasasazeka kwiinkulungwane ezintathu. USirayeli ebekho kangangesiqingatha senkulungwane. Kodwa khawucinge ngoko kuye kwenzeka kubantu basePalestina kuloo siqingatha senkulungwane, okwenzekayo kubo namhlanje, noko kuya kwenzeka kubo ngomso.
Abazange โbaphulukaneโ nenxalenye entle yomhlaba wabo, nto leyo eyintlekele ngokwaneleyo. Baye baphulukana nezinto zabo zokuziphilisa, baphulukene namandla okulawula ikamva labo njengabantu ngabanye okanye njengabantu; kwaye baphulukene nenkululeko nesidima sabo. Ngawaphi amathemba abantu basePalestina abanokuba nawo ngoku, ngaphandle nje kokulwa? Kwaye banokulwa njani kwaye baphumelele ngokuchasene nesikhulu - i-US ebonelelweyo - izixhobo zakwaSirayeli?
Umlo wenziwa ubukhulu becala ngamadoda aselula, nangabantwana abaninzi kakhulu. Abazali babo kunye nootatomkhulu babo babenobomi obungcono obabiwa phantsi kweenyawo zabo. Ootatomkhulu noomakhulu babo babenokuba nethemba elikhulu lokuba oko kwakubonakala kuyintlekele engakholelekiyo kwakuya kuba kokwexeshana, okanye, okona kubi, kulinganiselwe kummandla wayo.
Abazali babo bafumanisa ukuba izinto zazimbi kakhulu kunasemva kowe-1967. Ukubiwa okukhulu kwemihlaba yabo kwakhatshwa ngamajoni, ukwanda kokubekwโ esweni nogonyamelo: izinto ezazisenziwa ngamapolisa.
Emva ko-1967, kwakusoloko kuphawulwa ukuba umahluko phakathi kobomi bemihla ngemihla benkoliso yabantu basePalestina kunye nobo bantsundu baseMzantsi Afrika ubuthande ukungabonakali. Kodwa unyaka ngamnye owawulandela usizisa kweli xesha langoku, abemi boMzantsi Afrika babesondela ekujuleni phezu kwabacinezeli babo, lo gama ingcinezelo yamaPalestina, ukuba ngamaphanyazo ethemba, yayisiba nzulu.
Xa kujongwa umva, kucacile ukuba ukuze uSirayeli agcine umkhosi wakhe wokuhlala emkhosini kwimihlaba yasePalestine, ingeyiyo loo mihlaba kuphela kodwa noSirayeli ngokwawo wayeya kuba ngomkhosi ngokungenakunqandwa kwaye engazi, ngokwezimo zengqondo nakwizenzo; njengoko kwenzekile kwizimo zengqondo kunye nezenzo zase-USA, ngenxa yoko, kutsha nje, kwiMfazwe yoMlomo.
Ngoko yaba ngumcimbi nje wexesha de uSirayeli amamkele uNjengele uSharon ongumbulali njengeNkulumbuso yakhe; de ibe isilogeni sayo sibe yiCry Havoc! izinja zityibilike;
Ngaba le nto amaYuda ekupheleni kwenkulungwane ye-19 ayenayo engqondweni xa edala umbutho weZionist? Akunjalo kwaphela, kunjalo. Ngaba irhamncwa elinomkhosi onjengoSharon luhlobo lomntu ebenokuze limvumele ukuba โabakhokeleโ? Akunjalongo noko.
Loo maYuda angaphambili ayeza kufumana iiyantlukwano ezininzi phakathi kwe-ghettoization kunye nayo yonke into edibeneyo kunye nento ekudala isenzeka kumaPalestina. Kodwa ngaba loo mahluko ayeza kwanela kuloo maYuda angoovulindlela ukuba athi โIshkabibble? (Umama wayengumYuda; ndinelungelo lokusebenzisa elo gama.)
Kwaye oko kusibuyisela e-USA. Ngaphambili, ndiye ndaqaphela ukuba ukuza kuka-Israyeli kuxhomekeke kwinkxaso ye-USA. Inkxaso eqhubekayo ye-USA yezoqoqosho, yomkhosi, kunye nezopolitiko kumashumi eminyaka ibe njalo, ukuza kuthi ga ngoku. Yintoni ekhuthaze i-USA? Kwaye kwakulula njani kuthi ukwenza lula uSirayeli ukuya kuMbindi Mpuma?
Iimpembelelo zazininzi, kodwa ezimbini ezazibaluleke kakhulu 1) ukuba uMbindi Mpuma yimbiza yeoli yehlabathi. 2) Yenye yeendawo ezishushu zejografi emhlabeni. Oko kwakukudala kunjalo, kungekudala emva kweeMfazwe Zomnqamlezo.
I-oyile kunye neMfazwe ebandayo yasebenza ukuguqula ezo zinto zimbini zibe yingxakeko engenakuthintelwa yi-USA ukulawula indawo. Yintoni eyayinokuba nzima ngaphambi kokuba iMfazwe Yehlabathi II ibe lula ngokwentelekiso ekupheleni kwayo. IBritani kwakukudala iligunya leMeditera, yaye, ngokubhekisele kwiPalestina, kwaba njalo ngokuthe ngqo emva kowe-1917.
Kodwa iMfazwe Yehlabathi II yayitshabalalisa iBritani ekhaya nakwamanye amazwe; ukuba ibithe tyaba emqolo, kwezoqoqosho, kwezomkhosi, kwezopolitiko, efuna ngamandla isibonelelo sezigidi ngezigidi zeedola eMelika ukuze siphile. Yafunyanwa, ngo-1947.
Ngexabiso - kanye xa amaSirayeli awayeza kuba kungekudala aqalisa ukuvukela. Kwaye ayebizwa ngokuba "ngabanqolobi" yiBritane. Iza kuba amaSirayeli anokuba nethuba ngaphandle koncedo lwe-US, kodwa i-50-50 eyona nto ingcono.
Oko bekungayi kufuna nje inkalipho kunye nemipu kunye neziqhushumbisi zezandla, kodwa izixhobo ezinzima - ukusuka kwiitanki ukuya phezulu. Ukusukela ngo-1948 ukuya phambili, amaSirayeli afumana kanye oko ayekufuna kweso sixhobo kunye nenkxaso yezopolitiko kwi-UN naseYurophu, e-USA.
Kwaye bebefumana yonke loo nto ukusukela oko, izixhobo zomoya kunye nomhlaba kwaye, ngokuqinisekileyo, ii-nukes. Yonke loo nto yasimahla evela e-USA, kunye neebhiliyoni minyaka le kuncedo olungelulo olwasemkhosini: U-Israel ube # 1 kuluhlu lwezipho e-USA ukusukela kwi-WWII. Kwaye i-USA ayizange ibonise iintloni kwirekhodi yayo ye-UN yokuba ihlala ingumxhasi wedwa wemigaqo-nkqubo yobundlobongela bakwaSirayeli malunga namaPalestina - phakathi kwabanye abasondeleyo - kutsha nje kwi-veto yayo kwiBhunga lezoKhuseleko malunga nesindululo esinengqondo sokwenza uxolo. indawo..
Izinto ezibuhlungu. Ngaphezu kokudanisa, nangona kunjalo, njengoko intlekele iqhubeka kwaye isiya isiba nzulu kubantu basePalestine - njengoko isenza kumaSirayeli amaninzi abuleweyo okanye abandezelekileyo, nokuba axhasa uhlobo lukaSirayeli abanalo ngoku.
Ngoku kuyacaca ukuba uSharon uzimisele "ukuzinzisa" umbuzo wasePalestina nangayiphi na indlela eyimfuneko. "I-intifada yesibini" eyaqala ngoSeptemba, i-2000 ibulele ngaphantsi kwe-1,000 yasePalestina, kwaye isondele kwi-300 yamaSirayeli. Loo nto ivunywa ngabantu abaninzi, yayicatshukiswa ngabom nguSharon. Iqhinga elidala.
Iqhinga lakhe elitsha kukubiza uArafat โakunamsebenzi.โ Oku kuhambisana nethuba lokuba u-Arafat agxothwe, okanye ade abulawe - macala omabini. Ukuba okanye xa esihla, kunokwenzeka ukuba iHamas iya kuba namandla asebenzayo kumaPalestina: Yintoni kanye ayifunayo uSharon?
Uya kwandula ke abe nezizathu ezingakumbi zokwandisa ugonyamelo lwakhe. Umbuzo ke ngoku ngowokuba uzakuhamba kude kangakanani? USharon eyile nto ayiyo, impendulo inokufumaneka kwintliziyo yobumnyama kaConrad. Ngokungakumbi uzisa uKurtz kaConrad engqondweni; UKurtz, owayenikele ubomi bakhe ekuphuculeni abantu baseCongo, kodwa ekugqibeleni wabhala wathi, โZitshabalalise iindlavini!โ Ngaphandle nje kokuba uSharon akanalo โubuvangeli basemazweniโ njengesizathu sokuthethelela.
Kodwa uSharon unokuhamba kuphela phambi kwe-Egypt, iSaudi Arabia, iJordan, neSiriya, ukuba angathethi nto nge-Iraq ne-Iran, baya kuzifumana betyhalwa okanye bakhuthazeke ukuba bathathe inyathelo eliqinileyo ngokuchasene ne-USA, baphelise naziphi na izivumelwano abanazo nathi. Okanye ukujongana neziphumo zangaphakathi. Kwaye ke yintoni? Akunakwenzeka ukwazi, kodwa ezona zinto zinokwenzeka ziyoyikeka.
Ebhala ngaphambi kweMfazwe Yehlabathi I, njengoko ubuZionism babusiya busiba ngumbutho ekwakufuneka uthatyathwe nzulu, uThorstein Veblen wabhala isincoko esifutshane esinomxholo othi โOn the Intellectual Pre-eminence of the Jews in Modern Europe.โ
(Inokufumaneka kwingqokelela ka-1945 iVeblen ephathekayo, ehlelwe nguMax Lerner.)
AmaYuda โayesediasporaโ ukususela ekuqaleni kwawo kuMbindi Mpuma kamsinya nje emva kokuqalisa kwexesha lobuKristu; okona kubaluleke kakhulu, kwaye, ngeenjongo zangoku, ngokufanelekileyo, ukususela kwixesha laphakathi ukuya phambili, xa baqala ukuhlala kwizixeko zombini empuma nasentshona Yurophu.
Kuzo zonke ezo zixeko, zazigcinwe kwi-ghettoized. Ukutyhubela iinkulungwane ukuya kuthi ga ekuqaleni kweZiyonism, isizukulwana ngasinye samaYuda saphila ubomi obubini: obunye kwindawo yabo yokuhlala, enye kwizixeko ezihlala ziguquguquka ngokukhawuleza, utshintsho oluye lwenzeka ekuveleni okukhawulezileyo kwento eyaba yiYurophu yanamhlanje.
Kwi-ghetto, apho urabhi wayesongamela kokubini imfundo namandla, iTorah yeminyaka eliwaka ubudala yaseka isiseko esipheleleyo nesingaguqukiyo semfundiso yakhe. Kodwa kobunye ubomi obungaphandle kweghetto uluntu lwanamhlanje lwalubaleka phambili. Umahluko obukhali wemihla ngemihla, uVeblen waxoxa, akunakunceda kodwa ukudala ukuthandabuza ngenxalenye enkulu yesizukulwana ngasinye.
Kwaye ukuthandabuza - ukubuza, ukuzibuza, ukubuza, ukucinga, ukutya kunye nokondliwa ngabanye - yi-sine qua non yamandla engqondo avelisa isayensi, ubugcisa, uncwadi kunye nomculo. Ngaloo ndlela amaYuda aseYurophu, awayesoloko eliqaqobana labemi bakhona, anikela ngepesenti engalinganiyo yokukhula kwawo kwezenzululwazi nenkcubeko.
Kolo hlalutyo, uVeblen wahlabela mgama ezibuza ukuba: โIngaba kwaye nini amaYuda aphumelela ukuba nelizwe lawo?โ Emva koko, wathi, baya kuba njengazo zonke ezinye izizwe-abanyolukele ubutyebi namandla, ubuzwe, ukwanda, ukulwa. Ufana nemfazwe. Enjani yona intlungu ebenyanisile.
Ngaba ikho into enokwenziwa? Enye into ngaphezu kwabanye. AmaSirayeli kufuneka enziwe amiswe kwaye aguqule imbali yawo ePalestine; ngelixa, ngokutshintshiselana, amaPalestina kufuneka ajongane nenyaniso yokuba i-Israel yangaphambi kwe-1967 ikhona ukuba ihlale.
I-USA kufuneka ithathe amanyathelo okuqala, kwaye ikwenze oko ngamandla kunye nokuzithemba. Nangona kunjalo, okwangoku sisizwe esinye esingenakwenza njalo, ngakumbi uBush kunye nabalingani bakhe kulawulo.
Kodwa imilo enyukayo ibisoloko ijongene nathi, kuyo yonke into ekufanele siyilwele. Kwaye, kule meko, "thina" sincinci kunesiqhelo; kwaye inkqubo enjalo yayiza kufumana ubuncinane isithathu kwaye kakhulu mhlawumbi ngaphezu kwesiqingatha sabantu baseIxraeli.
Ngoku iyalityalwa ukuba phambi kwe-intifada yesibini, ezo pesenti zamaSirayeli zazixhasa ukurhoxa kuka-Israeli kwiindawo ezithinjiweyo kunye nobukho belizwe lokwenyani lasePalestine. Ngoku baninzi abambalwa, boyika kakhulu ubundlobongela obukhulayo; kodwa olo loyiko lunokuba nemveliso yengqiqo elungileyo, lunikwe isiqingatha sethuba.
Uninzi lwamaSirayeli ayazi ukuba ukushiyeka ngaphandle kokuqhubeka nenkxaso yase-US abanakubambelela ngonaphakade, kwaye banokukhetha enye indlela enesidima "kukupheliswa kwamabhulu." I-USA, ukuba ibinokwazisa ngesikhundla esitsha, kufuneka kwangaxeshanye ivakalise ukuqonda kwayo ukuba i-USA ngokwayo ayinakuba yinxalenye elawulayo kuzo naziphi na iinkqubo eziqhubekayo zokuzinzisa. Oko kunokwenziwa kuphela nge-UN. Kwaye kuqinisekile ukuba i-UN iya kuyivotela.
Kodwa le USA ayizukwenza siphakamiso sinjalo. Ngoko ke kuxhomekeke kuthi, kwaye nabanye abaninzi esingabaziyo ukuba benze esinako ukwenza oko kwenzeke, ukunciphisa amathuba. Asisodwa. Kwaye nokuba besikhona?
I-ZNetwork ixhaswa ngemali kuphela ngesisa sabafundi bayo.
Nikela