Kunobva: FAIR
New York Times munyori wenhau Paul Krugman (Twitter, 12/29/20) yakatsanangura cheki yekubatsira Covid 2,000 se "inoparadzanisa," kunyangwe makumi manomwe neshanu muzana evaAmerica (uye makumi manomwe neshanu muzana evaRepublicans) aida hurumende kuti ikoshese kumwe kubhadhara kwepasi rose. Kazhinji kazhinji, mashoko akadai sa“kupesanisa,” “kukakavara” kana kuti “kukakavadzana” anongoshandiswa semashoko ekodheyo ezvinobudisa nhau anoreva “pfungwa dzisingafarirwi nevakuru vanotonga”—chipi FAIR kudana "hazvigoneki munhau."
Medicare for All muenzaniso wakanaka weizvi. Kubva pakatanga nyaya iyi kutariswa nevezvenhau munyika nekuda kweSen. Bernie Sanders '2016 mutungamiriri wenyika, a. vazhinji veAmerica vakatsigira imwe nzira yenyika, inotsigirwa nemari yehutano hwehutano. Dzimwe sarudzo dzakaita akawanikwa vangangosvika vatatu muzvina vanotsigira pfungwa iyi, kusanganisira ruzhinji rwevavhoti veRepublican. Zvakadaro vezvenhau vemakambani vanoramba vachizvidza inishuwarenzi yehutano hweveruzhinji, vachiidaidza kuti "kuparadzanisa" (Axios, 2/14/20), “zvinonetsa” (Christian Science Monitor, 6/4/19; nguva, 10/24/19; New York Times, 1/1/20) kana kuti “ine ngozi mune zvematongerwo enyika” (Associated Press, 3/25/19).
Mune chinyorwa chine musoro unoti "Medicare for All Is Divisive (muDemocratic Party)," the New York Times (3/18/19) vakatsanangura kupa vanhu hutano hwemahara "kukakavara kukuru," vachiutaura sekubheja kune njodzi uye kunodhura zvakanyanya uko vakuru venzvimbo dzemaswing havangakwanise kuita sarudzo dziri kuuya. Chokwadi, chokwadi, chaive chakapesana: Wese mumiriri weDemocratic munharaunda inotenderera akatsigira Medicare kune Vese. akakunda musarudzo muna 2020. Zvimwe chete hazvigoni kutaurwa kune avo vasina kuitsigira.
Panogona kuve nemaitiro mashoma angangobatsira zvakananga uye nekukasira vanhu vazhinji vekuAmerica sekukwidza muhoro wepasi kusvika kumadhora gumi nemashanu (kunyangwe zvichiri hazvina kukwana kuwana rendi munzvimbo zhinji dzeUS). Zvikamu makumi mana kubva muzana zvenyika Akaudzwa Reuters/Ipsos vanovhota muna Kukadzi kuti ivo kana mumwe munhu ari pedyo navo angave akabatwa zvakanaka neshanduko yakadai. Ongororo imwe chete iyi yakaona kuti vatsigiri vekukwidza muhoro wepasi vakapfuura vanopikisa nezvikamu makumi maviri nezvishanu kubva muzana. Zvisinei, kuwedzera kunowanzotsanangurwa se "kuparadzanisa" (semuenzaniso, Bloomberg, 10/2/17; Politico, 3/16/21; Delaware News Journal, 3/10/21).
The Hill, semuenzaniso, yakaburitsa maonero (9/15/17) vachiti vanotsigira muripo wekurarama “kwakanga kusiri kwekare, kwakarasika uye kwaipesanisa.” Nepo $15 paawa ichinzwika zvakanaka pabepa kune vanhu "vasina kuziviswa nezvemhedzisiro," mutemo uyu warasa mavhoti makuru, akasimbirira Michael Saltsman wesangano rinopihwa mari neEmployment Policies Institute.
Saltsman ndiye aive huchenjeri hwaive kumashure kwekuratidzira kwakashata kupikisa kukwidza muhoro wepasi muCalifornia; akaisa bhodhi rezviziviso muSan Francisco achityisidzira vashandi kuti vachatsiviwa nemaPads kana vakada kubhadharwa zvakaringana pabasa ravo. Akatsanangurwa nemunyori wenhau weBay Area Paul Bradley Carr (panda, 7/21/14) se "dhongi riri kuseri kwechikwangwani chinotyisa cheSan Francisco." Chiyero che "kuparadzanisa" chakabvumidzwa nevavhoti veguta vane 77% rutsigiro (CNN Mari, 11/5/14).
The Green New Deal-chirongwa chikuru chemabasa chinozoshandura US kuenda kuhupfumi hwemagetsi hwakachena, hwakatsanangurwa se chirongwa chakabatana chete kuchengetedza US kubva mukuparara kwemamiriro ekunze-inogara ichinyorwa seyakakakavara kushanda (Reuters, 3/21/19; Atlantic, 6/12/19). CNBC (3/12/19), semuenzaniso, yakashuma nezve "nyaya" iyo vatariri vemafuta emafuta muHouston vakadzinga chirongwa chakasundirwa naSanders, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez uye co. se "zvisingaite, zvisingashande uye zvinopesanisa zvematongerwo enyika." Pane kudaro, vanopa zano "zvine chekuita nemusika mhinduro" kudambudziko.
Ndatenda nekunzwisisa kunoshamisa, CNBC! Zvimwe ungazotevera kutijekesera pane izvo vatengesi veWall Street vanofunga nezve zano rekutsvaga matsotsi mumaitiro avo muna 2008? (Kupa nzvimbo kune mabhirioni emagetsi mabhosi kuti arase marara ezvakatipoteredza chimwe chinhu chetsika pa CNBC-FAIR.org, 2/3/20).
Panguva iyo, imwe muchengeti chinyorwa (12/29/18) akacherekedza kuti 81% yevavhoti vekuAmerica vakadzosera chirongwa cheGreen New Deal, asi zvakadaro vakakwanisa kuchiburitsa sechikumbiro "chekuparadzanisa" icho "chisina rutsigiro rwakakosha mune zvematongerwo enyika," nekudaro vachisimbisa kuti zvido zvevanhu hazvina basa sei kune vanogadzira mitemo - kana. elite media.
Hupfumi hwevapfumi-soro hwakakwira mumakore achangopfuura, nemabhirioni epasi kuwedzera hupfumi hwavo ne55% kubva pakatanga matanho ekuvhara Kurume apfuura. Ruzhinji rwevanhu vekuAmerica, kusanganisira vanopfuura hafu yeRepublicans, tsigira vachiwedzera mutero kuvapfumi. Pasinei neizvi, mutero une mwero wepfuma, wakafanana neuyu kuisa mberi naSenerenda weMassachusetts Elizabeth Warren—2% kune avo vane mari inodarika madhora 50 miriyoni, uye 3% papfuma inodarika bhiriyoni imwe—inogara ichidzikisirwa sezvo inoparadzanisa zvikuru kushanda.FiveThirtyEight, 10/28/19; Bloomberg, 3/1/21).
Kunyora mu Washington Post (2/5/19), munyori wenhau Steven Pearlstein akarasa pfungwa dzekuruboshwe dzekubhadharisa vapfumi, hutano hwemahara uye Green New Deal semupendero, zvikanganiso uye zvinopatsanura. Kunyangwe apo mamwe mabhirioni ivo pachavo vaive kubvunza kubhadhariswa mutero wakawanda, The Vhiki (8/15/11) vachiri kutsanangura pfungwa se "kuparadzanisa" mumusoro wenyaya. Isu tonyatsotenda here kuti pane kushingaira kwakadaro pakati pevoruzhinji pamusoro pevanhu vakapfuma kwazvo munyika vanova vapfumi zvishoma?
Vese vevazhinji, pro-working kirasi marongero akatsanangurwa pamusoro anonakidzwa nerutsigiro rwakakosha neruzhinji. Netsanangudzo yeduramazwi, hadzina nharo. Uye zvakadaro nguva nenguva, vanorwiswa sevanokakavara zvikuru kana kuti vanokamuranisa kushanda.
Nepo vezvenhau vane mabhiriyoniire vaigona kungobuda vachiti, "Tinopikisa zvirevo izvi nekuda kwezvikonzero zvepfungwa," nzira iri nani yekutaura ndeyekuzviratidza sevacherechedzi vasina kwavakarerekera, vachingonetsekana nekushanda kwemutemo wakadaro.
Nguva inotevera paunonzwa zvirevo zvezvematongerwo enyika zvaunofarira zvichinzi "zvinopesanisa," "kukakavara" kana "kupopotera" kushanda, tarisa sarudzo kutanga. Ungave uri kutengeswa bhiri yezvinhu nevatsinhiri vasina kutendeseka vachiedza kudira mvura inotonhora pamoto unopfuurira.
Alan MacLeod @AlanRMacLeod inhengo yeGlasgow University Media Group. Bhuku rake razvino, Propaganda muzera Reruzivo: Zvichiri Kugadzirwa Kwemvumo, rakabudiswa na Routledge muna May 2019.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta