"Yakanakisa inoshaya zvese zvinotendwa, nepo zvakanyanya / Zvakazara neshungu!"
Pane rondedzero iri nani yezviri kuitika muIsraeri zvino here?
Zvakadaro mazwi aya akanyorwa, angangoita makore zana apfuura, nemunyori weIrish WB Yeats.
Yeats akanga achinyora nguva pfupi pashure pokupondwa kunotyisa nokuparadzwa kweHondo Yenyika I. Aidavira kuti nyika yakanga yava kusvika kumugumo, uye aitarisira kuuya kwechipiri kwaMesiya.
Sechikamu chemhirizhonga, akafanoona mudetembo rimwechete kuti "pakati haigone kubata". Ndinotenda kuti akatora dimikira iri kubva munhandare dzehondo dzemazera ekare, apo mauto aipikisana akanga akashongedzwa mumitsara miviri yakatarisana, ine simba guru pakati, uye mativi maviri achiidzivirira.
Muhondo yemhando yepamusoro, divi rimwe nerimwe rakaedza kuparadza rumwe rutivi rwemuvengi kuitira kuti ritenderere pakati nekurirwisa. Chero bedzi muzinda wakaramba uripo, hondo yacho yakanga isina kusarudzwa.
MuIsrael, semumademocracy mazhinji emazuva ano, nzvimbo yacho inoumbwa nemapato maviri kana anopfuura ekutanga, kuruboshwe zvishoma uye kurudyi zvishoma. Wekuruboshwe ndiye bato rekare reLabour, rava kuhwanda kuseri kwezita rekuti “Musasa weZionist” (iro rinongosiya vashoma maArabu, mamwe 20% yevavhoti.) Ane kodzero yevavhoti ndiLikud, chimiro chemazuva ano chebato rekare re“Revisionist” rakavambwa. makore angangoita zana apfuura naVladimir Jabotinsky, rusununguko rwenyika, mumutauro weItaly Risorgimento.
Iyi yaive nzvimbo yeIsrael, ichitsigirwa nemamwe mapato akaberekwa akabatana.
Yakatonga Israeri kubva pazuva rokuvambwa kwayo. Rimwe bato raiumba hurumende, rimwe vaiita sevanopikisa vakavimbika, uye vaichinjana mabasa makore mashoma ega ega, sezvavaifanira kuita muutongi hwezvido zvevanhu.
Kurutivi rworuboshwe kwaiva neMapato eArab (ava kubatanidzwa mukumanikidzwa), Meretz diki asi ine misimboti kuruboshwe, uye mapato akati wandei echitendero neechiFascist kurudyi.
Yakanga iri "yakajairika" set-up, senge mune dzimwe nyika dzakawanda dzedemocracy.
Hapachina.
Pakati-kuruboshwe, mafungiro ekusiya uye kukundwa anotonga. Bato rekare rawira mumaoko evakawanda vezvematongerwo enyika, vane kukakavara pakati pavo kunobvisa mamwe mabasa aro ese.
Mutungamiriri wazvino, Yitzhak Herzog, mutsigiri wemhuri yakanaka, anotakura nemutemo zita rine mbiri rokuti “Mutungamiriri Wevanopikisa”, asi haatombozivi kuti kupikiswa chii. Vamwe vanodana bato rake "Likud 2". Panyaya dzose dzinokosha - dzakadai serugare nevanhu vePalestine uye nyika yeArabhu, kururamisira kwevanhu, kodzero dzevanhu, democracy, kupatsanurwa pakati pehurumende nechitendero, huori - bato iri mbeveve. Nokuda kwezvinangwa zvose zvinoshanda, inofa kana kuti yakaipa.
“Zvakanakisisa hazvina chivimbo chose,” sokuchema kwakaita Yeats. Zvinhu zvakanakisa zvenzanga yeIsrael zvakapererwa, kukundwa, mbeveve.
Pakati-kurudyi, mufananidzo wacho wakatonyanya kuipa, uye une ngozi zvikuru. Iyo Likud, yaimbova yerusununguko, yegutsaruzhinji bato rekurudyi, yakawira munjodzi yekutorwa kwechisimba. Bapiro rayo rekunyanyisa rakasundira munhu wese kunze, uye rave kutonga bato zvachose. Mupfungwa yedimikira rimwe chete, bango rekurudyi ratora pakati.
"Yakaipisisa izere nekusimba". Aya marightist radicals ave kuchema zvizere. Vanodzika mitemo yakashata muKnesset. Vanotsigira uye vanokurudzira zvinhu zvinosemesa zvinoitwa nemapurisa nemasoja. Vanoedza kukanganisa Dare Repamusorosoro uye Mauto Command. Vane chinangwa chekuvaka misha yakawanda uye yakakura. Aya mabarbarian ane njodzi zvechokwadi "azere nekusimba".
Kuwedzerwa kwaAvigdor Lieberman kuhurumende kunopedzisa mufananidzo unotyisa. Kunyangwe aimbova Mutungamiriri, Ehud Barak, wezvematongerwo enyika akayerwa, akazivisa pachena kuti hurumende iyi inosanganisira zvinhu zvefascist.
Sei izvi zvaitika? Chii chinokonzeresa?
Mhinduro yakajairika ndeyekuti "vanhu vatamira kurudyi". Asi izvozvo hazvitsananguri chinhu. Nei vafamba zvakanaka? Sei?
Vamwe vanotsvaga tsananguro mukusawirirana kwevanhu munharaunda yemaJuda yeIsrael. MaJuda ane mhuri dzinobva kunyika dzechiIslam (dzinonzi Mizrahim) vanowanzovhotera Likud, maJuda ane mhuri dzinobva kuEurope (Ashkenazim) vanoenda kuruboshwe.
Izvi hazvitsananguri Lieberman, ane bato rine vanhu vanobva kune yaimbova Soviet Union, vangangoita miriyoni nehafu, vanowanzonzi "Russian". Sei vazhinji vavo vari vechokwadi vanonyanya kururamisa, rusaruraganda uye vanovenga maArabu?
Kirasi vari voga vechidiki vari kuruboshwe, vanoramba kutsigira chero bato. Pane kudaro, vanotendeukira kune kusiri kwebato rekuratidzira, vachigara vachigadzira mapoka matsva ekodzero dzevanhu nerunyararo. Vanotsigira maPalestine munzvimbo dzakagarwa, kurwira "kuchena kwemaoko edu" muuto, uye kuita basa rinoshamisa nekuda kwezvikonzero zvakafanana.
Kune makumi, zvichida mazana emasangano akadaro, mazhinji acho achitsigirwa nemari yekunze, anoita basa rinoshamisa. Asi vanovenga nhandare yezvematongerwo enyika, havazojoinhi bato ripi zvaro, ndoda kubatana nechinangwa ichi.
Ndinotenda kuti chiitiko ichi chinoswedera pedyo nekutsanangurwa kwemaitiro. Vanhu vakawanda, kunyanya vechidiki, vanofuratira “zvematongerwo enyika” – izvo zvavanoreva zvematongerwo enyika zvemapato – zvachose. "Havana kushaya zvese zvinotendwa", asi vanotenda kuti mapato ezvematongerwo enyika haana chokwadi chese uye havadi chekuita navo.
Havaone kuti mapato ezvematongerwo enyika ndicho chinhu chakakosha pakuunza shanduko mugutsaruzhinji. Vanovaona samapoka evanyengeri vane uori, vasina zvitendero chaizvo, uye vasingadi kuonekwa vari muboka rakadaro.
Nokudaro tinosvika pachokwadi chinokatyamadza: zviri kuitika muIsrael zvakafanana nemaitiro mune dzimwe nyika dzakawanda, izvo zvisina chekuita nematambudziko edu chaiwo.
Mazuva mashoma apfuura kwaive nesarudzo dzemutungamiri weAustria. Kusvika ikozvino, mutungamiri weAustria, hofisi yemhemberero seIsrael, yakapfuura pakati pemapato maviri makuru. Panguva ino chimwe chinhu chisati chamboitika chakaitika: vaviri vekupedzisira vamiriri vakabva kurudyi uye maGreens. Vavhoti vakangobvisa vese vavhoti kubva panzvimbo yepakati. Zvakatonyanya, mumiriri wepedyo-fascist anongorasikirwa nediki.
Ositiriya? Inyika yakagamuchira nemufaro (weAustria) Adolf Hitler makore makumi masere chete apfuura, uye akatambura zvizere?
Tsananguro chete ndeyekuti maAustrians, seIsrael, vakadyiswa nemapato akamiswa. Marudzi maviri, ehukuru hwakaenzana, asina chimwe chinhu chakafanana, anonzwa zvakafanana.
MuFrance, wezvematongerwo enyika ari kure-kurudyi anopokana nekumisikidzwa Marine Le Pen arikupemberera. MuSpain, Holland nedzimwe nyika dzeScandinavia mapato anopikisa ari kukunda.
MuUK, amai vedemocracy, veruzhinji vave kuda kuvhotera kana kupokana neBrexit, chikonzero chakazivikanwa nekugadzwa. Kusiya European Union kunotarisa (kwandiri, zvirinani) zvisina musoro zvachose. Asi mukana wekuti zviitike unoita sewechokwadi.
Asi nei tichingotaura nezvenyika diki? Zvakadini nemasimba masimba ari oga, United States of America?
Kwemwedzi yakawanda ikozvino, veruzhinji vepasirese vanga vachiona nekushamisika kuri kukura kukwira kunoshamisa kwaDonald Trump. Zuva nezuva, dhirama, iro rakatanga sekomedhi, rinowedzera kutyisa.
Chii, nokuda kwaMwari, chakaitika kuurwu rudzi rukuru? Mamiriyoni nemamiriyoni angadirana sei kumureza wemumiriri ane ruzha, anonyadzisira, asingazivi, ane chikuru - uye pamwe chete - pfuma iri chinhambwe chake kubva kumapato ese ezvematongerwo enyika? Aigona sei kukunda, kunyatsoparadza, Grand Old Party, chikamu chenhoroondo yeAmerica?
Kune rimwe divi kune Bernie Sanders, anonyanya kufadza hunhu, asi mumwe anovengwawo nebato rake, aine hurongwa huri kure neruzhinji rwevanhu vekuAmerica.
Pane kufanana kumwechete pakati pezviviri izvi: vanosema mapato avo uye mapato avo anovasema.
Izvi zvinoratidzika kuva maitiro enyika yose. MuSouth America mose, kwete kare kare rusvingo rwekuruboshwe, mapato eruboshwe anokandwa kunze, uye nhamba dzevakarurama dzinotora nzvimbo.
Tichifunga kuti izvi zviri kuitika panguva imwe chete munyika dzakawanda, huru nediki, dzisina chimwe chinhu chakafanana - matambudziko akasiyana, nyaya dzakasiyana, mamiriro akasiyana - ichi hachisi chinhu chinoshamisa.
Kwandiri, ichi chirahwe. Mumakumi mashoma emakore ega ega, mazano matsva anouya uye anokanganisa chikamu chikuru chevanhu. Democracy, liberalism, anarchism, social-democracy, communism, fascism, democracy zvakare, uye ikozvino rudzi urwu rwemhirizhonga, kunyanya radical-wing-wing, maitiro enyika yose. Havasati vava nezita.
Ndine chokwadi chekuti vanhu vazhinji, veMarx nevamwe, vane tsananguro yakagadzirira. Ini handina kugutsikana. Ndangovhiringika.
Kudzoka kwatiri isu varombo veIsrael: Ndichangobva kuburitsa muHaaretz chirongwa chinoshanda chekumisa mafashama nekuisundidzira kumashure.
Ndichiri kuzvipira kuva netariro.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta
1 komenda
Mumwe haafanire kukanganisa zviratidzo - mapato ezvematongerwo enyika - kune chirwere, kusatenderwa kwevamiriri mafomu ekutonga. Vanhu pasi rose vane nzara yekuzvitonga, kutonga kwegutsaruzhinji kwakanangana nekutora chikamu, pane kuita kuti vanhu vakasarudzwa ve oligarchy, shill nema lackey vatonge ivo uye pamusoro pavo. Idzi inguva dzinokatyamadza zvechokwadi, kupindirana, apo zvematongerwo enyika ezvekumiririrwa kwevakuru vezvematongerwo enyika zvave kufa uye hutongi hwejekerere hutsva hwakatsetseka husati hwazvarwa - muNyika-Nyika (idzo dzakaita sehutongi hwevamiriri dzakarasikirwa nemvumo).