Kunobva: Chokwadi
Mufananidzo naVic Hinterlang/Shutterstock
Mukuputika kwake dhizaini maonero in Dobbs v. Jackson Vakadzi Hutano Sangano, iyo yakasvitswa Politico, Samuel Alito anotonga Roe v. Wade uye Yakarongwa Mubereki v. Casey. Chinyorwa chavo chinoti kubvisa pamuviri haisisiri kodzero yebumbiro remitemo uye kunosiya magumo evari kuda kubvisa pamuviri ari mugwara remitemo yenyika.
"Saka isu tinoti Bumbiro reMitemo haripi kodzero yekubvisa nhumbu," anonyora Alito. “nemharapara uye Casey kunofanira kudziviswa, uye simba rekudzora kubviswa kwepamuviri rinofanira kudzorerwa kuvanhu nevamiriri vavakasarudzwa.”
Kana dzimwe nhengo ina dzeDare Repamusorosoro dzikatambira kunyorwa kwaAlito, mamwe akawanda ekuvanzika kodzero dzatinokoshesa achange ari munjodzi. Dzinosanganisira kodzero dzekudzivirira kubata pamuviri uye kuroorana kwevanhukadzi, pakati pezvimwe.
Muna Zvita, Clarence Thomas, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh naAmy Coney Barrett vakavhota naAlito mushure. nharo dzemuromo uye vanoramba vakabata chinzvimbo ichocho, maererano Politico. Ndiwo ruzhinji-nhengo shanu kana vakasaina kune Alito's dhizaini pfungwa mukupera kwaJune.
Inenge hafu yezana ramakore yapfuura, Dare Repamusorosoro rakatonga nemharapara kuti Bumbiro reMitemo rinodzivirira “chisarudzo chomukadzi chokubvisa kana kuti kusabvisa pamuviri pake.” Dare racho raivimba nezvakaitika kare zvaiti “pfungwa yeFourteenth Amendment yerusununguko rwemunhu” inorambidza hurumende kupindira muzvisarudzo zvevanhu nezvewanano, kudzivirira kubata pamuviri, kubereka, ukama hwemhuri, kurera vana uye dzidzo.
Makore makumi maviri gare gare, muna Casey, dare rakasimbisa kubata kwepakati kwe nemharapara - kuti mukadzi ane pamuviri ane kodzero yekubvisa mimba isati yatanga kushanda (paanenge masvondo makumi maviri nematatu emimba). Casey yakasimbisa nheyo “yakagadzikiswa” yokuti “Bumbiro reMitemo rinoisa ganhuriro pakodzero yeHurumende kudzongonyedza zvisarudzo zvikurusa zvomunhu pamusoro pemhuri noubereki … pamwe chete nokutendeseka kwomuviri.”
Dare rakataura Casey nemvumo mu Washington v. Glucksberg, umo rakaronga maruramiro oku“bvisa pamuviri” nekodzero “dzekuroora,” “kushandisa nzira dzokudzivirira kubata pamuviri,” “kuva navana” uye “kuperevedza kwomuviri,” izvo zvinozivikanwa mu“mutsara wakareba wemhaka” inodudzira Due Process Clause. Zvinoda hurongwa hwakakodzera hurumende isati yabvisa munhu hupenyu, rusununguko kana pfuma.
In Lawrence v. Texas, dare raivimba nazvo Casey kutaura kuti nyika hadzigone kuita "hungochani" mhosva. The Lawrence dare rakati "kodzero yerusununguko pasi peDue Process Clause" inovimbisa "nzvimbo yerusununguko iyo hurumende inogona kusapinda."
Dare rakashandisa zvirevo zvimwechetezvo kubata Obergefell v. Hodges kuti Bumbiro reMitemo rinodzivirira wanano yeungochani: “Sezvisarudzo zvine chokuita nokudzivirira kubata pamuviri, ukama hwemhuri, kubereka, uye kurera vana, zvisarudzo zvine chokuita newanano ndezvimwe zvezvinonyanya kuitwa nomunhu,” uye naizvozvo “zvakavakirwa papfungwa yokuzvitonga kwomunhu” yakachengetedzwa neDue Process Clause.
Mune maonero ake ekunyora Dobbs, Alito anonyora, “Tinosimbisa kuti chisarudzo chedu chine chekuita nekodzero yebumbiro remutemo yekubvisa pamuviri uye hapana imwe kodzero. Hapana chinhu mumaonero aya chinofanira kunzwisiswa kupa kusava nechokwadi nezvemienzaniso isinganei nekubvisa pamuviri. "
Zvakangodaro, Alito anoburitsa izvo zvakakosha pasi pekodzero dzekudzivirira kubata pamuviri, rusununguko rwepabonde uye kuroorana kweungochani. Anotaura kuti kubvisa pamuviri, uko kusina kutaurwa zvakananga muBumbiro reMitemo, hakuna “kudzika midzi munhoroondo yenyika ino netsika” uye “hakuna kujeka mupfungwa yerusununguko rwakarayirwa.”
“Mukupesana,” Alito anonyora kudaro, “gamuchidzanwa risingaputsiki rokurambidza kubvisa pamuviri pamarwadzo echirango choutsotsi rakapfuurira kubvira pamazuva okutanga-tanga emutemo wavose kutozosvikira 1973 [apo. nemharapara yakasarudzwa]."
Alito anonyatsotsoropodza Lawrence uye Oberge
Mune maonero ake ekunyora, Alito "anoramba mutsara wese wehutongi pairi nemharapara zororo: kuvapo kwe'kodzero dzisina kuverengerwa' dzinochengetedza rusununguko rwemunhu kubva mukupambwa nehurumende," Mark Joseph Stern. akanyora at Slate. "Alito anoti kodzero ipi neipi yakadaro inofanira 'kudzika midzi' munhoroondo yenyika uye tsika, uye kuwana kubvisa pamuviri hakuna midzi yakadaro."
Kana dare raramba nemharapara, inenge hafu yenyika ichaita kunze kwemutemo kana zvakanyanya ganhurira kubvisa pamuviri. Nyika gumi nenhatu dzine “trigger laws” dzaizokurumidza kurambidza kubvisa pamuviri. Nyika shanu dzine pre-nemharapara kurambidza kubvisa pamuviri kwaigona zvakare kuita kuti zviitwe. Uye matunhu gumi nemana aizorambidza kubvisa nhumbu isati yakwana. Kurambidza uye zvirambidzo pakubvisa pamuviri zvingadaro disproportionately impact vakadzi varombo nevanhu vane ruvara.
Vanhu vachitambura kutanga mimba kana ectopic pregnancy inogona kukanganisa zvakanyanya kana nemharapara yakapidiguka. Maitiro ekubereka akadai se-in-vitro fertilization (IVF), kubviswa kwemazai uye stem cell maitiro anogona kurambidzwa.
Dzimwe kodzero “dzisina kuverengwa” dzisina kunyorwa muBumbiro reMitemo dzingakanganiswa, kusanganisira kodzero yekufamba, kodzero yekuvhota uye kodzero yekuroorana kwemarudzi akasiyana.
Zvikonzero zvemutongo weSupreme Court wakapedzwa nemharapara zvisinganzwisisike. Kwete chete kuti vanhu vachanyimwa kodzero yekubvisa pamuviri, avo vanoda mamwe maitiro ekurapa vangave vari panjodzi. Uye kodzero dzekuvanzika dzatinotora sedzekare dzinogona kupera.
Sezvo United States inofamba, zvinotyisa, yakananga kuhutongi hwechiKristu hwakabata uye pakupedzisira hutongi hweDare Repamusorosoro, tinofanira kuramba takasvinura nekutora matanho. Izvi zvinosanganisira kutaura, kubata nhengo dzeCongress neWhite House, kunyora op-eds uye tsamba kumupepeti, uye kuratidza sezviri kuita zviuru zvevanhu munyika yose.
Copyright Zvakashata. Yakadhindwazve nemvumo.
Marjorie Cohn purofesa ari kubuda paThomas Jefferson Chikoro cheMutemo, aimbova mutungamiri weNational Lawyers Guild, uye inhengo yemabhodhi enyika Assange Defense uye Veterans For Peace, uye hofisi yeInternational Association of Democratic Lawyers. Mabhuku ake anosanganisira Drones uye Kuuraya Kwakananga: Zvemutemo, Zvetsika uye Geopolitical Matambudziko. Ndiye mubatsiri we "Mutemo uye Kusagadzikana” redhiyo.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta