Kudemocracy, verenga fantasy. Iraq iri kuita zvakashata kuvatungamiriri vedu vakuru mazuva ano zvekuti chero chinhu - uye chero munhu - achakandwa imbwa kuti dziponese. Iyo BBC, CIA, British intelligence - chero mutori wenhau anotsunga kutaura manyepo akatiendesa kuhondo - anokandirwa dzimwe nhema. Iyo nguva yatinokurudzira kuti Iraq haina kumbobvira yaita ivhu rakaorera reWestern democracy, tinopomerwa mhosva yekusarura. Tinofunga kuti maArabu haakwanisi kuburitsa democracy, tinobvunzwa? Tinofunga kuti havasi vanhu here?
Rudzi urwu rwetoshi runobva kumhuri imwechete yekushungurudzwa seiyo inonyora zvese uye kutsoropodza kwese kweIsrael anti-Semitic. Kana isu tikatomboyeuchidza pasirese kuti cabal yeneo-conservative, pro-Israeli vatendeuki - Messers Perle, Wolfowitz, Feith, Kristol, et al - vakabatsira kukurudzira Mutungamiri Bush neMunyori weDziviriro weUS, Donald Rumsfeld muhondo iyi nehuporofita husina chokwadi hwe Middle East itsva yedemocracy, pro-Israel Arab states, tinoudzwa kuti tine rusaruraganda kunyange kutaura mazita avo. Saka ngatirangarirei zvaitaurirwa neveneo-cons kare mumatsutso endarama muna 2002 apo Tony airwisana naGeorge kuti aparadze Hitler wekuBaghdad.
Ivo vaizogadzira patsva mepu yeMiddle East uye kuunza democracy mudunhu. Vadzvanyiriri vaizodonha kana kuuya parutivi - nekudaro kukosha kwekunyengetedza nyika izvozvi kuti Gaddafi ane hunyanzvi "statesman" (ndatenda, Jack Straw) nekusiya zvishuwo zvake zvenyukireya - uye demokrasi yaizotumbuka kubva kuna Nile kuenda kurwizi. Yufratesi. MaArabu aida demokrasi. Vaizoibata. Tingadiwa, kugamuchirwa, kurumbidzwa, kukumbundirwa nekuunza ichi chinodiwa zvikuru munharaunda. Ehe, iyo neo-cons yakakanganisa.
Mupiro wekupedzisira mukudzivirira kwevarume ava wakabva kuna David Brooks mu The New York Times. "Chokwadi," anonyora kudaro, "vanhu vanonzi 'neo-cons' ... havanyatso kudyidzana ... 'ndakaudzwa nevakuru vakuru vehurumende kuti haana kuita misangano yakakosha naBush kana Cheney kubva pavakatora chigaro ...
Zvakanaka kuti vakuru vakuru "vakuru" vatizivise izvi - tisiye nyaya yekusaziva kuti Mr Bush vanosvika pamhedziso vari voga. Brooks anotoedza kudzima izwi rekuti "neo-conservative" kubva murondedzero yehondo yeIraq nemutsara usina musoro wekuti "con ipfupi ku'conservative" uye neo ipfupi ye'Jewish'". Parizvino, kungoshandiswa kwemutsara wekuti "neo-conservative" kunogona kuve kunopesana neSemitic: Brooks anopedzisa chinyorwa chake nekuzivisa kuti "anti-Semitism iri kudzoka".
Kana vari ivo vatsoropodzi vakanyanya vanogona kutyisidzirwa, ipapo Messers Wolfowitz, Perle nevamwe vese vari kumhanya. Havana kuti democracy yaizoshanda. Havana kufurira Mutungamiri Bush. Vakanga vasina simba. Havana kumbotaura naye. Neo-conservatives? WHO? Asi vaive maNeo-cons avo vaive - pamwe neIsrael pachayo - pakati pevamiriri vane shungu dzekurwiswa kweIraq.
Vakanga vabata chokwadi chinoparadza uye chechokwadi chechokwadi chehupenyu munzvimbo zhinji dzeMiddle East: kuti nyika dzemaArabu dzine hudzvanyiriri husina kunaka, huwori, hune hutsinye. Hapana chinoshamisa ipapo. Isu takagadzira vazhinji vevadzvanyiriri ava. Takatanga nemadzimambo nemachinda uye - kana vasina kushandisa simba rakakwana pamusoro pechaunga - takabva tatsigira boka rinosiririsa revakuru vemauto nemakoloni, vazhinji vacho vaipfeka yunifomu yehondo yeBritish ine makondo pachinzvimbo chekorona paheti yavo. mabheji.
Saka Mambo Farouk akatsiviwa, zvisina kunanga, naColonel Nasser (uye naGeneral Sadat neAir Force General Mubarak), Mambo Idris naColonel Gaddafi - Hofisi Yekune dzimwe nyika yakada mudiki Gaddafi - uye humambo hwaMambo Faisal mushure meHondo Yenyika Yekutanga muIraq hwakatsiviwa. , pakupedzisira, neBaath Party naSaddam Hussein.
Saka hatina kumboda kuti maArabu ave nedemocracy. Apo maEgypt pavakaedza izvi mumakore ekuma1930 uye vakaita sekunge vabvisa Farouk, maBritish akaombera vaipikisa mujeri. Isu vekuMadokero takadhirowa miganhu yemarudzi mazhinji echiArabu, takagadzira nyika dzawo uye tikatsigira vatungamiriri vavo vanoteerera - tichivabhomba, hongu, kana vakapa Suez Canal nyika, vakabatsira IRA kana kupinda muKuwait. Asi maNeo-cons naVaBush - uyezve, zvisingaite, VaBlair - vaida kuti vave nehutongi hwejekerere.
Ikozvino kune maArabu mazhinji angade chimwe chinhu chakakosha ichi chinonzi democracy. Zvirokwazvo, kana vatamira kuMadokero vogara neUS kana Briteni kana French kana chero imwe pasipoti yekuMadokero, vanoratidza kugona kwakafanana nekwedu kwe "democracy". MaIraqi eDearborn, Michigan, akafanana nevamwe vanhu vekuAmerica, uye vanovhota - kunyanya maDemocrat - uye vanotamba nekushanda sevamwe vagari vemuUS vanoda rusununguko. Saka hapana genetic pamusoro pekusakwanisa kwenyika yeArab kutora democracy.
Dambudziko harisi vanhu. Dambudziko ndere nharaunda, magadzirirwo enzanga yemadzitateguru uye - zvakanyanya kukosha - nyika dzekugadzira dzatakavagadzirira. Ivo havagone uye havagone kuburitsa democracy. Vadzvanyiriri vatakabhadhara uye vakapakata zvombo uye nekupuruzira vaitonga nekurwadzisa uye nedzinza. Vakatarisana nenyika dzavaisatenda mazviri kakawanda, maArabu aivimba nemarudzi avo chete. Madzimambo aive emadzinza - maHashemite aibva kuchamhembe-kumabvazuva kweiyo yatinoti zvino Saudi Arabia - uye vadzvinyiriri vaive vedzinza. Saddam, sekutaurwa kwazvinoitwa nyika yese, yaive Tikriti. Uye varume vane utsinye ava vakabata masimba kuburikidza nemubatanidzwa wemadzinza nemasekete.
Patakapinda munyika yavo, hongu, takaudza maIraqi kuti taizovapa democracy. Vaizoita sarudzo dzakasununguka. Ndinoyeuka nguva yokutanga yandakaziva kuti vimbiso iyi yakanga isina kutendeseka. Paive apo Paul Bremer, mutungamiriri weAmerica akakundikana muIraq, akarega kutaura nezve democracy ndokutanga kutaura nezve "hurumende inomiririra" - izvo zvisiri chinhu chimwe chete. Ndipo apo vanhu vakaita saDaniel Pipes, hama yekurudyi yevaneo-cons vatisisataure, vakatanga kutsigira kwete "democracy" yeIraq asi "mutongi ane pfungwa dzegutsaruzhinji".
Bremer anoti hapangavi nesarudzo pamberi peJune "kupihwa" kwe "huchangamire" - pachayo nhema nekuti "kupa" kuchapa ngano "huchangamire" hweIraq kuboka reIraqi rakasarudzwa nevaAmerica neBritish. Vacha - minamato yava kudanwa - vozoita sarudzo dzedemocracy dzatakavimbisa zvenhema vanhu veIraqi uye idzo maIraqi Shias ave kuda nemoyo wese. Uye kunyangwe sarudzo idzi dzikaitwa, vazhinji vekuIraq vanovhota zvinoenderana nedzinza nechitendero. Ndiwo mashandiro aita hurongwa hwavo hwezvematongerwo enyika kwemakore anoda kusvika zana uye ndiwo mashandiro anoita "interim council" yakasarudzwa neAmerica nhasi.
Uye saka toenda zvakare. Hapana zvombo zvekuparadza kukuru. Hapana hukama pakati peSaddam ne11 Gunyana. Hapana democracy. Mhoresa vezvenhau. Kupomera BBC mhosva. Mhoresa maspooks. Asi usape mhosva Messers Bush naBlair. Uye usape mhosva maAmerican neo-conservatives vakabatsira kusundira US munjodzi iyi. Havatombovapo. Uye kana ukati vakaita, unoziva kuti uchanzi chii.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta