A Hungarian Joke: Munguva yehondo yaJune 1967, muHungary anosangana neshamwari yake. “Nei uchiratidzika kufara kudaro?” anobvunza. "Ndakanzwa kuti maIsrael apfura maMiG matanhatu akagadzirwa neSoviet nhasi," shamwari yake inopindura.
Mangwana acho, shamwari yacho inotowedzera kufara. "VaIsrael vakadonhedza mamwe maMiG masere," anozivisa kudaro.
Pazuva rechitatu, shamwari iri crestfallen. "Chii chaitika? MaIsrael havana kudzika maMiGs nhasi?" murume anobvunza. “Vakadaro,” shamwari yacho inopindura kudaro, “Asi nhasi mumwe munhu andiudza kuti vaIsraeri vaJudha!”
Iyi ndiyo nyaya yese muchidimbu.
Anti-Semite anovenga maJuda nekuti maJuda, zvisinei nezviito zvavo. VaJudha vangavengwa nemhaka yokuti vakapfuma uye vanozvitutumadza kana kuti nemhaka yokuti varombo uye vanogara muumbozha. Nemhaka yokuti vakaita rutivi rukuru mukumukira kweBolshevik kana kuti nemhaka yokuti vamwe vavo vakapfuma zvikuru pashure pokuparara kwoutongi hwechiKomonisiti. Nokuti vakarovera Jesu pamuchinjikwa kana kuti vakatapura tsika dzokuMadokero ne“tsika dzechiKristu dzetsitsi”. Nekuti havana nyika yemadzibaba kana nekuti vakasika Nyika yeIsrael.
Izvo zviri muchimiro chemarudzi ese erusaruraganda uye chauvinism: Mumwe anovenga mumwe munhu nekuda kwekuva muJudha, Arab, mukadzi, mutema, muIndia, muMuslim, muHindu. Hunhu hwake, zviito, kubudirira hazvina kukosha. Kana ari werudzi runonyangadza, chitendero kana murume kana mukadzi, vachavengwa.
Mhinduro kumibvunzo yese ine chekuita nekupokana neSemitism dzinotevera kubva pane ichi chakakosha chokwadi. Semuyenzaniso:
Munhu wese anotsoropodza Israeri ndewe anti-Semite here?
Kwete. Mumwe munhu anoshoropodza Israeri nekuda kwezvimwe zviito zvedu haagone kupomerwa mhosva yekupokana neSemitism nekuda kweizvozvo. Asi mumwe munhu anovenga Israeri nekuti inyika yechiJudha, semuHungarian mujee, anopikisa maSemite. Hazvisi nyore nguva dzose kusiyanisa pakati pemhando mbiri, nekuti vakangwara vanopesana nemaSemite vanomira se bona fide vatsoropodzi vezviito zveIsraeri. Asi kuratidza vatsoropodzi vese veIsrael sevanopesana neSemite hazvina kunaka uye zvinopesana nezvibereko, zvinokuvadza kurwisa anti-Semitism.
Vanhu vazhinji vane hunhu hwakadzama, runako rwevanhu, vanoshoropodza maitiro edu munzvimbo dzakatorwa. Hupenzi kuvapomera mhosva yekurwisa Semitism.
Ko munhu angave anti-Zionist pasina kuve anti-Semite?
Hongu zvachose. Zionism ichitendero chezvematongerwo enyika uye inofanira kubatwa sevamwe. Mumwe anogona kuva anti-Communist asina kupesana neChinese, anti-Capitalist pasina anti-America, anti-Globalist, anti-Chese. Asi, zvakare, hazvisi nyore nguva dzose kutora mutsara, nokuti maanti-Semite chaiwo anowanzoita se "anti-Zionists". Havafanirwe kubatsirwa nekudzima musiyano.
Munhu angave anti-Semite uye Zionist here?
Chokwadi, hongu. Muvambi weZionism yemazuva ano, Theodor Herzl, akatoedza kutsvaga rutsigiro rwevaRussia vane mukurumbira wakashata vanopikisa Semite, achivavimbisa kubvisa maJuda mumaoko avo. Hondo Yenyika II isati yatanga, sangano repachivande reZionist IZL rakatanga misasa yemauto muPoland richitungamirirwa nevakuru vemauto vaipikisa vaJudha, avo vaidawo kubvisa vaJudha. Mazuvano, maZionist akanyanya Kurudyi anogamuchira uye anogashira rutsigiro rwakakura kubva kuAmerican fundamentalist evhangeri, avo ruzhinji rwemaJuda eAmerica, maererano nesarudzo yakabudiswa svondo rino, vanofunga zvakanyanya anti-Semitic. Dzidziso yavo yebhaibheri inoporofita kuti manheru ekuuya kwechipiri kwaKristu, maJuda ese anofanira kutendeukira kuchiKristu kana kubviswa.
MuJudha angave anopesana nevaSemite here?
Zvinoita seoxymoron. Asi nhoroondo yakaziva zvimwe zviitiko zvevaJudha vakava vavengi vechiJudha vane utsinye. Mukuru weSpain Inquisitor, Torquemada, akanga ari wedzinza rechiJudha. Karl Marx akanyora zvimwe zvinhu zvakaipa kwazvo pamusoro pevaJudha, sezvakaita Otto Weininger, munyori anokosha wechiJudha mubhuku. fin-de-siecle Vienna. Herzl, akararama panguva imwe chete naye uye muViennese, akanyora mumadhayari ake mamwe mashoko asingaenzaniswi pamusoro pevaJudha.
Kana munhu akatsoropodza Israeri kupfuura dzimwe nyika dzinoita zvimwe chetezvo, iye munhu anopikisa Semite here?
Kwete hazvo. Chokwadi, panofanira kuva nemwero mumwe chetewo wetsika wenyika dzose nevanhu vose. Zviito zveRussia muChechnya hazvisi nani pane zvedu muNablus, uye zvingave zvakanyanya kuipa. Dambudziko nderekuti maJuda anofananidzirwa uye vanozvifananidza (uye zvechokwadi vaive) "rudzi rwevakabatwa". Naizvozvo, nyika inokatyamadzwa kuti vakabatwa nezuro ndivo vanyajambwa vanhasi. Mupimo wetsika wakakwirira unodiwa kwatiri kupfuura kuvamwe vanhu. Uye zvakakodzera kudaro.
Ko Europe yave anti-Semitic zvakare here?
Kwete saizvozvo. Nhamba yevanopesana nemaSemite muEurope haina kukura, zvichida yakatodonha. Izvo zvawedzera huwandu hwekutsoropodza maitiro eIsrael kune maPalestine, avo vanoita se "vakabatwa nevakabatwa".
Mamiriro ezvinhu mune mamwe masabhabhu eParis, ayo anowanzo kutaurwa semuenzaniso wekusimuka kwekupokana neSemitism, inyaya yakatosiyana. Kana maMuslim ekuchamhembe kweAfrica anorwisana nemaJuda ekuchamhembe kweAfrica, vanenge vachiendesa gakava reIsrael nePalestine kuenda kuvhu reEurope. Kuenderera mberi kwegakava pakati pemaArabu nemaJuda rakatanga kuAlgeria apo maJuda akatsigira hutongi hweFrance uye maMosiremu akavatora sevashandirwi vevapambi vaivengwa.
Bva neiko vakawanda vokuEurope vakataura munzvero yemisi ichangobva kupfuura iyi kuti Israeri inoisa mungozi rugare rwenyika kupfuura imwe nyika ipi neipi?
Izvo zvine tsananguro yakapfava: VekuEurope vanoona paterevhizheni mazuva ese zviri kuitwa nemasoja edu munzvimbo dzinogarwa dzePalestine. Kurwisana uku kwakafukidzwa kupfuura mamwe makakatanwa ari pasi pano (pamwe chete neIraq, panguva ino), nokuti Israeri inonyanya "kufadza", tichifunga nezvenhoroondo refu yevaJudha muEurope uye nokuti Israeri iri pedyo neWestern. media kupfuura maMuslim kana nyika dzeAfrica. Kupokana kwePalestine, uko maIsrael anodaidzira kuti "hugandanga", kunoratidzika kune vazhinji vekuEurope zvakanyanya senge kupikisa kweFrance kutorwa kweGerman.
Zvakadini nekuratidzwa kweanopesana nevaSemite munyika yeArab?
Pasina kupokana, kazhinji zviratidzo zvekupokana neSemitic zvakapinda munguva pfupi yapfuura muhurukuro yeArabhu. Zvakakwana kutaura kuti iyo yakashata "Protocols yeVakuru veZion" yakabudiswa muchiArabic. Icho chinhu chakajairika cheEuropean import. MaProtocols akagadzirwa nemapurisa epachivande eCzarist Russia.
Chero zvipi zvipenyu zvingave zvichitaurwa nedzimwe "nyanzvi", hakuna kumbove kwakapararira Muslim anti-Semitism, sezvaivepo muChristian Europe. Mukati mokurwira kwake simba, muporofita Muhammad akarwisana nendudzi dzechiJudha dzakavakidzana, uye naizvozvo kune dzimwe ndima dzisina kunaka pamusoro pavaJudha muKorani. Asi hazvigone kufananidzwa nendima dzinopikisa maJuda muTestamente Itsva nyaya yekurovererwa kwaKristu iyo yakaisa chepfu munyika yechiKristu uye yakakonzera kutambura kusingaperi. Muslim Spain yakanga iri paradhiso yevaJudha, uye hakuna kumbova neKuparadza kukuru kwechiJudha munyika yechiMuslim. Kunyange pogrom yakanga isingawanzoitiki.
Muhammad akaraira kuti "Vanhu veBhuku" (MaJuda nemaKristu) vabatwe nemoyo murefu, zvichienderana nemamiriro ezvinhu aive akasununguka zvakanyanya kupfuura emuEurope yanhasi. VaMuslim havana kumbomanikidzira chitendero chavo nechisimba pavaJudha nevaKristu, sezvinoratidzwa neidi rokuti vanenge vaJudha vose vakadzingwa muSpain yechiKaturike vakagara munyika dzechiMuslim ndokubudirira imomo. Pashure pemazana emakore ekutonga kweMuslim, vaGiriki nevaSerb vakaramba vari vechiKristu zvachose.
Kana runyararo rwasimbiswa pakati peIsrael nenyika yeArab, michero ine chepfu yekupokana neSemitism ingangonyangarika kubva munyika yeArab (sezvichaita michero ine chepfu yekuvenga maArab munzanga yedu.)
Ko kutaura kweMutungamiriri weMalasia, Mahathir bin Muhammad, pamusoro pemaJuda ari kutonga pasi rose, haazi maSemitic here?
Hongu uye kwete. Ivo zvechokwadi vanoratidza kuoma kwekupinza anti-Semitism pasi. Mukuona kwechokwadi, murume wacho akanga akarurama apo akataura kuti vaJudha vane pesvedzero huru zvikuru kupfuura muzana yavo yechiverengero chavagari vapasi chenyika yoga yaizoda. Ichokwadi kuti maJuda ane simba guru pamitemo yeUnited States, iyo chete ine simba guru, pamwe chete nenhepfenyuro dzeAmerica nedzepasi rose. Mumwe haadi nhema "Protocols" kuti atarise chokwadi ichi uye kuongorora zvikonzero zvacho. Asi manzwi anoita mimhanzi, uye mimhanzi yaMahathir inonzwika chaizvo inopokana neSemitic.
Saka isu tinofanira kufuratira kupesana neSemitism here?
Kwete. Rusaruraganda rudzi rwehutachiona hunowanikwa munyika dzese uye mumunhu wese. Jean-Paul Sartre akati isu tose tiri vanhu vane rusaruraganda, musiyano uri wekuti vamwe vedu tinozviona uye vanorwisana nazvo, nepo vamwe vachikundwa nehuipi. Munguva dzakajairwa, kune vashoma vashoma vevasaruraganda vari pachena munyika dzese, asi munguva dzenhamo nhamba yavo inogona kuwanda nekukurumidza. Iyi injodzi isingaperi, uye vanhu vese vanofanira kurwisana nevanosarura pakati pavo.
Isu vaIsraeri takafanana nemamwe marudzi ose. Mumwe nomumwe wedu anogona kuwana rusarura chiduku mukati make, kana akatsvaga zvakakwana. Tine munyika medu vanovenga maArabu anovenga, uye kutarisana kwenhoroondo kunotonga hupenyu hwedu kunowedzera simba ravo neruremekedzo. Ibasa redu kurwisana navo, uye tosiira kuvaRungu nemaArabu kuti vagadzirise vanhu vavo voga.
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta