Asilikali a Israeli anapha anthu oposa zana limodzi la Palestine ndi kuvulaza oposa 700 pa February 29, 2024 panthawi yogawa chakudya chothandizira ku Gaza, ndikupangitsa kuti anthu a ku Palestina aphedwe. 30,000 kuyambira Okutobala 7, 2023. Kupha kothandizira chakudya kunali kolunjika pakufa kwake pomwe zida zankhondo za Israeli zidalunjika zida kwa anthu wamba aku Palestine osimidwa, anjala ndikupha ambiri aiwo. Zinali zomvekanso pankhani ya yemwe ali ndi firepower ndi yemwe alibe, komanso zogwirizana kwathunthu ndi nkhanza za Israeli, makamaka zomwe zidachitika kuyambira pa Okutobala 7, 2023.
Ndipo komabe, mitu yankhani yaku Western media idapita kukabisa ndikuteteza omwe adachita upandu wowopsawu. CNN inanena kuti pali "Kupha anthu ku Gaza komwe kumathandizira chakudya pakati pa Israeli,” ngati kuti anthu amene anaphedwawo analibe chochita ndi kuwomberana mfuti. Malowa sanavutikenso kutchula anthu aku Palestine.
The Washington Post inali yoipitsitsa, kulengeza kuti, "Kupereka thandizo kwachisokonezo kumakhala kowopsa pomwe Israeli, akuluakulu aku Gazan akugulitsa malonda.” Kugwiritsiridwa ntchito kwa liwu loti “chipwirikiti” kumasonyeza kuti zinthu zinali kunja kwa mphamvu ya aliyense. Ndipo, akuluakulu a Israeli kapena Gazan atha kukhala ndi mlandu.
The New York Times inatenga njira ya ndakatulo, kundandalika mndandanda wa zochitika zowoneka ngati zosagwirizana, ndi mutu wake wakuti, "Pamene Gazans Anjala Akukhamukira Gulu, Kuphwanyidwa Kwa Matupi, Mfuti za Israeli ndi Chiwopsezo Chakufa.” Ngati ziganizozo zinali ndi mapewa, uyu adangopunthwa mopanda nzeru chifukwa cha chinsinsi chodziwika bwino chakuphako.
Nkhani zina zidasiya Israeli ndi Palestine pamutu wonse kuti awoneke ngati akupewa kuimbidwa mlandu. Reuters idati, "Opitilira 100 aphedwa pofunafuna thandizo ku Gaza, chiwerengero cha anthu omwalira chikudutsa 30,000., "ndipo a NBC News omwe amati ndi omasuka adati,"Anthu ambiri aphedwa pakuwukira anthu omwe akudikirira thandizo, akuluakulu azaumoyo ku Gaza atero.” Ngakhale PBS sinathe kuzindikiritsa olakwa kapena ozunzidwa ndi mutu wake, "Anthu opitilira 100 aphedwa ku Gaza poyesa kupeza chakudya kuchokera kugulu lothandizira. "
Kugwiritsiridwa ntchito kwa mawu osagwira ntchito, chinenero chopangidwira kubisa ndi kupatsa wolakwayo phindu la kukayikira, ndi chinyengo chodziwika bwino chomwe chimagwiritsidwa ntchito ndi malo akuluakulu a nkhani pofotokoza za nkhanza za Israeli. Posiyana ndi momwe atolankhani adafotokozera kuukira kwa Hamas ku Israeli koyambirira kwa Okutobala 2023 pogwiritsa ntchito mawu omveka bwino ndikutchula wolakwira ndi wozunzidwayo, zimakhala zochititsa manyazi kwambiri kuti mabungwe aku Western media ali ndi kukhulupirika kwamphamvu pazandale kwa Israeli mosasamala kanthu za zomwe akunena. cholinga.
Tengani chitsanzo cha New York Times. M'malipoti atatu pamasiku atatu osiyana okhudza zomwe zinachitika pa Okutobala 7, 2023, akonzi a pepalalo adawonetsa kuti amadziwa kulemba mitu yankhani yosavuta komanso yowongoka. “'Tili Pankhondo,' Netanyahu Akutero Pambuyo pa Hamas Kuukira Israeli,”(October 7), “Momwe Kuukira kwa Hamas pa Israeli kudachitika,” (October 8), ndi “Hamas Yasiya Njira Yachiwopsezo ku Israeli,” (October 10). Pali kugwiritsidwa ntchito kwa liwu logwira ntchito ndikuzindikiritsa wolakwa ndi wozunzidwayo.
Pali kufanana kwakukulu pakati pa nkhani za anthu aku Palestine omwe akuzunzidwa ku Israeli ndi Black ndi Brown omwe adazunzidwa chifukwa cha tsankho, tcheru cha azungu, komanso apolisi ku US M'buku langa la 2023, Kuwuka: Mphamvu Yofotokozera Potsata Chilungamo Chamitundu, ndinasanthula nkhani zazikulu zimene oulutsira nkhani amalimbikitsira pofotokoza za mtundu ndi tsankho. Kulephera kuyika pakati pa umunthu wa anthu amitundu kwakhala kufooka kwanthawi zonse pamawayilesi aku US. Mtolankhani wopambana mphotho ya Pulitzer Wesley Lowery, mowopsa op-ed mu nyuzipepala ya New York Times mu Julayi 2020 inanena kuti, "anthu ambiri alola zomwe amawona kuti zoona zenizeni zigamulidwe ndi atolankhani achizungu komanso mabwana awo azungu."
Ndizosadabwitsa kuti utsogoleri wa azungu, womwe ukupitilirabe kufalitsa zipinda zofalitsa nkhani, upeza chifukwa chodziwika bwino ndi kukondera kwa Israeli. Dziko la Israeli linamangidwapo Utsogoleri wa mafuko ndi zipembedzo. Kulemera kowonjezera kwa ndale za nthawi yayitali za boma la US kukondera kwa Israeli zikutanthauza kuti takhala munkhondo yolimbana ndi ma Palestine. Chifukwa chake, zipinda zankhani zaku US ndizonyansidwa kuzindikira Israeli ngati wopha anthu, chiwonongeko, ndi kupha fuko.
Gulu loyang'anira media, Chilungamo ndi Zolondola pa Kufotokozera (FAIR), kwa zaka zambiri wakhala akufotokoza mfundo ziwiri zomwe atolankhani amayendera pa Israeli ndi Palestine. Kulemba kumayambiriro kwa February, Julia Hollar anasanthula Nkhani za New York Times ndi Washington Post za nkhondo ya Israeli pa Gaza, kuwonetsa ndendende momwe mapepala onsewa alili ochirikiza Israeli komanso momwe onse "adatsamira kwambiri pazokambirana zomwe Israeli amakonda komanso nkhawa zake."
Ngakhale kupha kwaposachedwa kwa Israeli kwa anthu aku Palestine pogawa chakudya ndi chitsanzo chimodzi chabe cha momwe malo osindikizira nkhani amapotozera nkhani zawo, kafukufuku akuwonetsa kuti izi zikuwonetsa kuti pali zinthu zambiri. Studies za kukondera kwa nkhani zofalitsa nkhani, kuphatikizapo kufufuza kwakukulu komwe kunachitika pogwiritsa ntchito luntha lochita kupanga, kumasonyeza kusagwirizana kwa Palestina m'madera akuluakulu. M'lingaliro limeneli, sikuti a US ali pankhondo yokhayo yolimbana ndi anthu a Palestina, koma akutenga nawo mbali polimbikitsa mabodza ophera anthu.
Mwamwayi anthu aku US alibe. Hollar analemba mu ZIMENEZI, "Mafunso omveka bwino oletsa kumenyana popanda zifukwa zomveka, pamene kuli kofala m'dziko lenileni, anali osowa m'mapepala." N'zochititsa chidwi kuti ngakhale akuyesera kuti asokoneze mkanganowu, anthu a ku America makamaka akugwirizana ndi kuthetsa nkhondo. Data for Progress's kafukufuku waposachedwa "Pafupifupi magawo awiri mwa atatu a ovota (67 peresenti) - kuphatikiza akuluakulu a Democrats (77 peresenti), odziyimira pawokha (69 peresenti), ndi ma Republican ( 56 peresenti) - amathandizira US kuyitanitsa kuyimitsa kwanthawi zonse komanso kutha kwa ziwawa. ku Gaza.” Nkhani zoulutsira nkhani zimatengera maganizo a anthu, ndipo zimachititsa kuti anthu aziganiza bwino. Pankhani ya nkhondo ya Israeli ku Gaza, zoulutsira nkhani zikuwoneka kuti sizikuyenda bwino ndi anthu aku America.
Lowery analemba m'buku lake 2020 op kuti kuti nyumba zofalitsa nkhani zisakhale ndi tsankho lonyozetsa anthu, “zidzafunika kumveketsa bwino makhalidwe abwino, zomwe zidzafuna kuti akonzi ndi atolankhani asiye kuchita zinthu monga kubisala mwachidwi zimene zimasokoneza choonadi, chifukwa chakuti takhala tikuchita motero. ”
Monga momwe kusintha kwa chiwerengero cha anthu m'dzikolo ndi zipinda zake zofalitsa nkhani zayambitsa kulingalira momwe zoulutsira nkhani zimafotokozera chilungamo cha mafuko, pali kusintha kwapang'onopang'ono kwa nyanja pakuwulutsa nkhani za anthu aku Palestine. Mu Disembala 2023, atolankhani opitilira chikwi aku US adasaina ku kalata yotseguka kupempha “kumveketsa bwino makhalidwe,” kulimbikitsa anzawo “kunena zoona zonse popanda mantha kapena kukondera,” ndi “kugwiritsira ntchito mawu olongosoka olongosoledwa bwino ndi mabungwe omenyera ufulu wa anthu padziko lonse, kuphatikizapo ‘tsankho,’ ‘kuyeretsa fuko,’ ndi 'kupha anthu.'
Kubisa upandu wa anthu osankhika komanso kubisala zakupha kumafuna khama komanso kudzipereka ku mphamvu za anthu osankhika. Zingakhale zophweka bwanji kutchula khasu n’kunena zoona?
Nkhaniyi idapangidwa ndi Economy for All, ntchito ya Independent Media Institute.
Sonali Kolhatkar ndi mtolankhani wopambana mphoto zambiri. Iye ndiye woyambitsa, wolandila, komanso wopanga wamkulu wa "Kudzuka Ndi Sonali,” pulogalamu ya mlungu ndi mlungu ya wailesi yakanema ndi wailesi imene imaulutsidwa pa wailesi ya Free Speech TV ndi Pacifica. Buku lake laposachedwapa ndi Kuwuka: Mphamvu Yofotokozera Potsata Chilungamo Chamitundu (Mabuku a City Lights, 2023). Iye ndi munthu wolemba kwa Economy for All polojekiti ku Independent Media Institute ndi mkonzi wa Racial Justice and Civil Liberties ku Inde! Magazini. Amagwira ntchito ngati co-director wa nonprofit solidarity Organisation Ntchito ya Afghan Women's Mission ndipo ndi wolemba nawo Kutuluka magazi ku Afghanistan. Amakhalanso pa board of directors Justice Action Center, bungwe loona za ufulu wa anthu othawa kwawo.
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama