M’gulu lomangidwa pa mabodza, kufunafuna choonadi ndi masewera.
Ganizirani za mkangano wokhudza 'zowopseza' zomwe zimawopseza 'kudziyimira pawokha' kwa BBC, monganso BBC yomwe malipoti wa tcheyamani wake wotuluka:
"Ponena za kuchoka kwa Mr Sharp, ndikumvetsa kuti zokambirana pakati pa BBC ndi boma zakhala zikuchitika masiku ano. Inu mungayembekezere zimenezo.
'Mtsogoleri wa BBC ndi chisankho cha ndale.'
Ngati izi sizilungamitsa Twitter kutcha mtolankhani aliyense wa BBC 'UK media media media', sitikudziwa zomwe amachita.
Kapena ganizirani momwe, kapu m'manja, Guardian tsopano ikudziwonetsera ngati ntchito ya Media Lens, kulengeza kumapeto kwa zolemba zake:
'Monga bungwe lazankhani lothandizidwa ndi owerenga, timadalira kuwolowa manja kwanu. Chonde perekani zomwe mungathe, kuti anthu mamiliyoni ambiri apindule ndi kupereka malipoti abwino kwambiri okhudza zochitika padziko lapansi.'
Tikudabwa kuti ndi owerenga angati omwe amapereka ndalama zankhondoyi akudziwa kuti, chaka chatha, mkonzi wa Guardian, Kath Viner, analandira kukwera kwa malipiro kwa 42 peresenti ya £150,000, kutengera malipiro ake kufika pa £509,850. Brazen amati kuti Guardian 'ndi yopanda chikoka cha malonda' amawonekera m'masamba a nyuzipepala yodzaza ndi zotsatsa zamakampani zomwe zimadalira kwambiri. Chaka chatha, kusindikiza ndi kutsatsa kudatulutsa ndalama zokwana £71.5m ndi £73.7m motsatana. The Guardian ndi ya Scott Trust, yomwe imayendetsa ndalama zokwana £1.3bn.
Ngakhale titayesa kulingalira atolankhani amakampani akukwera pamwamba pazachabechabe izi, ndizosatheka kuganiza za iwo akuwunika zozama za kukondera kwa media.
Kumbukirani momwe nkhani ndi ndemanga zimawonekera: tsunami ya 24/7 malonda amakampani omwe sangakambirane chilichonse chokhudza kukondera kwake. Pokhapokha titavomereza kuti zotsatsazi ziyenera kukhala zogwirizana ndi tsunami yotsutsana ndi malonda, palibe funso la kupanda tsankho pazifukwa izi zokha.
Koma izi zikungokanda pamwamba. M'gulu lathu lamakampani, kupambana kwakukulu kwaulimi wamakampani sizomwe zimasefedwa m'nyuzipepala zatsiku ndi tsiku kapena nkhani zausiku; ndi us, lingaliro lathu la yemwe ife tiri, za tanthauzo la kukhala munthu. Titha kunyoza Dzuwa ndikudandaula ndi Mail, koma yang'anani pagalasi - we ndi zotsatira zomaliza za mabodza.
Erich Fromm analemba za lingaliro la munthu la iye ndi iyemwini mu gulu la capitalist:
'Thupi lake, malingaliro ake ndi moyo wake ndizo likulu lake, ndipo ntchito yake m'moyo ndikuyiyika bwino kuti adzipindule yekha.' (Erich Fromm, 'The Sane Society', Routledge, 1991, p.138)
Kufunika kwake sikunganenedwe mopambanitsa: ngati mamiliyoni aamuna ndi akazi amabizinesi amadziona ngati zinthu zomwe ziyenera kugulitsidwa pamsika wantchito, funso losagwirizana, lazovuta zamabizinesi, silimabuka. Lingaliro siliri lopanda ntchito, ndikuwopseza kutsata zomwe zimathandizira 'kupambana'. Zotsatira zake ndi zoipa kwambiri:
'Umunthu wopatulidwa womwe ukugulitsidwa uyenera kutaya ulemu wochuluka womwe uli ndi chikhalidwe cha munthu ngakhale m'zikhalidwe zakale. Ayenera kutaya pafupifupi kudzimva konse kwaumwini, kudziyesa yekha monga munthu wapadera ndi wosatembenuzidwa.' (Kuchokera, p.138)
Pamenepa, si kuti ndife wokondera pa nkhani inayake monga momwe lipoti la nyuzipepala; lingaliro lenilenilo lakuti tiyenera kufunafuna ndi kuchitapo kanthu pa chowonadi, kuti ndife oimira makhalidwe, limakhala lopusa, loseketsa. Ndipo uwu, ndiye mutu wofunikira wankhani zambiri za tabloid ndi media zina zolunjika kumanzere ndi olimbikitsa obiriwira.
Pagulu lamtunduwu, Fromm adalemba kuti, chowonadi sichidetsa nkhawa:
'Chofunika kwambiri n'chakuti palibe chinthu chovuta kwambiri, kuti wina asinthane malingaliro, ndi kuti ali wokonzeka kuvomereza lingaliro lililonse kapena kukhudzika (ngati pali chinthu choterocho) kukhala wabwino ngati winayo.' (tsamba 152)
Fromm akamanena kuti 'palibe chovuta kwambiri' amatanthauza kuti ndife mphwayi kwenikweni.
Kodi tingaloze umboni? Sabata yatha, zinali inanena kuti kutentha kwakukulu kwa Epulo komwe kunalembedwapo ku Spain - mtundu wa mbiri yomwe mwina, m'mbiri yakale, idasweka ndi kagawo kakang'ono ka digiri - idawombedwa ndi kukwera kwa 5C.
Chizindikiro chaposachedwachi cha tsoka lomwe likubwera la nyengo chinanenedwa mwachidule kenako kuiwalika. Idalandira gawo laling'ono la chidwi ndi nkhawa - osati kuchokera kwa atolankhani komanso kwa anthu. Chinali chitsanzo chimodzi chokha cha mmene ‘munthu wamakono amasonyezera kusoŵeka modabwitsa kwa zinthu zonse zofunika. Tanthauzo la moyo ndi imfa, chimwemwe ndi kuzunzika, kumva ndi kulingalira mozama'. (Kuchokera, p.166)
Mosafunikira kunena, utolankhani wamakampani ndi kwawo kwachilengedwe kwa Corporate Man chifukwa ntchito yake yeniyeni ndikuteteza momwe zinthu ziliri.
Pomwe akugwira ntchito ngati mkonzi wamkulu wandale ku New Statesman, Mehdi Hasan - yemwe tsopano akuwonetsa Mehdi Hasan Show pa Peacock ndi MSNBC - analemba ndemanga zotsatirazi mu kalata yopita kwa Lord Dacre, eni ake a Daily Mail:
'Ngakhale kuti ndili kumanzere kwa ndale, ndipo sindimagwirizana ndi zomwe alemba a Mail pa nkhani zosiyanasiyana, ndakhala ndikusilira chidwi cha pepalali, kukhwima, kulimba mtima komanso, ndithudi, nkhani zankhani. Ndikukhulupirira kuti Mail ili ndi gawo lofunikira kwambiri pakukangana kwadziko lonse, ndipo ndikusilira kuyang'ana kwanu kosalekeza pakufunika kosunga umphumphu ndi makhalidwe abwino pagulu, komanso kuteteza chikhulupiriro chanu, ndi chikhalidwe chachikhristu, poyang'anizana ndi zitsutso zochokera. zigawenga zosakhulupirira kuti kuli Mulungu komanso osakhulupirira zachipembedzo. Ndikhulupiliranso… kuti ndikhoza kukhala watsopano komanso wokonda, osatchulapo zotsutsana ndi zotsutsana, mawu pa ndemanga ndi masamba a nyuzipepala yanu yopambana mphoto.'
Hasan anawonjezera kuti:
'Choncho ndikhoza kulemba zidutswa za Mail yotsutsa Labor ndi kumanzere, kuchokera "mkati" Ntchito ndi kumanzere (monga mkonzi wamkulu wa ndale ku New Statesman).'
Munthu sangaganizire chitsanzo chabwino kwambiri cha 'munthu wolekanitsidwa wa Fromm yemwe akugulitsidwa' (p.138), pomwe Hasan akuwonetsa mawonekedwe, zabwino ndi zabwino zamkati mwake kumanzere zidziwitso zowukira kumanzere.
Chitsanzo china chabwino cha mtundu wa umunthu uwu wochitira chowonadi ngati masewera ndi wolemba nkhani wamkulu wa Guardian Jonathan Freedland. Katswiri wa ndale, Norman Finkelstein, yemwe amayi ake anapulumuka ku Warsaw Ghetto, ndende yozunzirako anthu ya Majdanek ndi ndende ziwiri zozunzirako akapolo, komanso amene bambo ake anapulumuka ku Warsaw Ghetto ndi msasa wachibalo wa Auschwitz, Ndemanga ku Freedland:
'… pamene buku langa, The Holocaust Industry, linatuluka mu 2000, Freedland analemba kuti ndinali "pafupi ndi anthu omwe adayambitsa Holocaust kusiyana ndi omwe adavutika nawo". Ngakhale kuti akuwoneka kukhala wolondola pazandale tsopano, sanaone kukhala kosayenera kunena kuti ndinali wofanana ndi Anazi amene anapha banja langa ndi mpweya.'
Finkelstein ananena mfundo yofunika kwambiri:
'Tinawonekera limodzi pa pulogalamu ya pa TV. Pulogalamu isanakwane, anandiyandikira kuti andigwire chanza. Nditakana, iye anangoti phee modabwa. Bwanji ine sindikanagwira dzanja lake? Iye sankakhoza kuzimvetsa izo. Imakuwuzani china chake chokhudza zokwawa zopanda nzeru izi. Zoyipa, zamwano - kwa iwo, zonse ndi ntchito ya tsiku limodzi. N’chifukwa chiyani aliyense ayenera kukwiya? Pambuyo pake, pa pulogalamuyo, zidanenedwa kuti Guardian, komwe adagwira ntchito, adasindikiza The Holocaust Industry pamitundu iwiri. Adafunsidwa ndi wowonetsa, ngati bukhu langa ndi lofanana ndi la Mein Kampf, angasiye papepala? Inde sichoncho. Kodi owonetsa sadazindikire kuti zonse ndi masewera?'
Zonse ndi masewera oti asewedwe kuti apindule - palibe chomwe chiyenera 'kunyalanyazidwa' ndi anthu amakampani omwe amawonetsa 'kusazindikira modabwitsa' pa chilichonse chofunikira.
'Plainly A War Crime' - Chorley Akufunsa Chomsky
Matt Chorley, yemwe kale anali wa Taunton Times, amawonetsa wailesi pa Rupert Murdoch's Times Radio. Pa 26 Epulo, Chorley tweeted Kanema wa kutengera kwake kwa 'Zippy', chidole mu pulogalamu ya ana yaku UK, Rainbow, yomwe idatenga zaka makumi awiri kuchokera 1972-1992. Kanemayo adawonetsanso a Tim Shipman, wothirira ndemanga wamkulu pazandale ku Sunday Times, akuyankha motengera ngati 'George', mvuu yapinki yochokera pachiwonetsero chomwechi.
Inde, palibe cholakwika ndi kusangalala pang’ono. Koma m'malo mwake kuyankhulana ndi Noam Chomsky, kuchuluka kwa utolankhani wa Chorley sikunakwere kwambiri. Monga Hasan ndi Freedland, komanso utolankhani wambiri wamakampani, Chorley ndi munthu yemwe amatsata 'njira yotsatsa' ya Fromm.
Timaphunzira zambiri pamene amakonda Chorley akukumana ndi Chomsky ndi ena otsutsa omwe miyoyo yawo sigulitsidwa; osati chifukwa chakuti a Chorley ali ndi zambiri zoti anene, koma chifukwa chakuti ndife mboni, osati chabe kusagwirizana kwa malingaliro ndi zikhalidwe, koma za makhalidwe. Ndi mkangano pakati pa kuona mtima ndi fakery, momveka bwino ndi obfuscation, chinkhoswe ndi mphwayi, chifundo ndi egotism.
Nthawi zambiri, mikangano imeneyi imakhudza wofunsa mafunso pakampani yemwe amangoyang'ana, osati kufunsa mafunso enieni, koma kuponya misampha panjira ya Chomsky. Cholinga sikufuna kudziwa zimene akuganiza koma kumugwira mwa njira inayake, kusonyeza kuti wapusitsidwa, kapena kuti ndi woukira boma. Zowonadi, atatha kuyankhulana, Chorley akufotokozedwa cholinga chake polankhula ndi Chomsky:
'Onani momwe wokonda ku Russia wanthawi yayitali akufotokozera Ukraine.'
Izi zikufotokozeranso ndemanga yosadziwika bwino ya Chorley muzoyankhulana, kutanthauza kuti Chomsky's 'anti-West udindo':
'… anakutsogolerani ku mgwirizano ndi Vladimir Putin, yemwe anali mtundu watsopano wa mtsogoleri wa Russia. Ndipo zonse zinali zonyansa, mpaka pomwe adalowa ku Ukraine, ndipo tsopano mukuyesera kuti mutsimikizire ndi khomo lakumbuyo - ali. akugwetseni pansi, Vladimir Putin.'
Aliyense amene amadziwa chilichonse chokhudza Chomsky, amadziwa kuti ali nacho konse ndakhala 'okonda kwanthawi yayitali' ku Russia Bolshevism, Russian Communism, Stalinism, nkhanza za boma la Soviet nthawi zonse, osati kwa Putin. Vuto, tikuganiza, ndikuti Chorley sadziwa kuti anarcho-syndicalism ndi chiyani, kapena chomwe Chomsky amatanthauza akamalankhula. limati iye ndi 'wochokera mnzako woyendayenda' wa anarchism. Ndipo kotero, kuyankhulana konseko kudachokera pamalingaliro abodza a ndale za Chomsky.
Chorley anayamba mwachikondi, akufunsa mafunso opanda vuto okhudza ntchito ya Chomsky ndi maganizo ake pa lingaliro la 'wanzeru pagulu'; kaya anadziika yekha m’gulu limenelo. Podziwa mtundu wa munthu yemwe anali kuchita naye - Chorley amagwira ntchito kwa Murdoch, pambuyo pake - Chomsky nthawi yomweyo adanyamula galasi kuti awonetsere momwe Chorley amaonera dziko lapansi, ndikuzindikira kuti iye ndi Chorley anali ndi mwayi wolowa m'malo a anthu onse ndikukhala ndi zotsatira zochepa. pa nkhani ya onse. Ndi udindo wamwayi umene umadza ndi udindo weniweni wamakhalidwe abwino. Izi zidawonetsa kale phompho lomwe limalekanitsa Chomsky ndi kusayanjanitsika kwa utolankhani wamakampani.
Chorley adafunsa ngati Chomsky amaganiza kuti tikukhala mu 'nthawi zowopsa komanso zosokoneza' kuposa mibadwo yam'mbuyomu. Chomsky adayankha kuti nthawi yathu ndi 'yowopsa kwambiri', pofotokoza momwe Wotchi ya Doomsday Clock imadziwikanso, osati mphindi mpaka pakati pausiku, koma m'masekondi mpaka pakati pausiku (pakali pano, masekondi 90). Ziwopsezo zomwe zikuchulukirachulukira zikuphatikiza chiwopsezo cha nkhondo yanyukiliya, koma koposa zonse zoopsa zachilengedwe:
'Tikuthamangira kumtunda wowononga chilengedwe. Tili ndi zaka makumi angapo zomwe titha kuzichepetsa kapena kuziwongolera, koma tikuthamangira kwina - palibe chomwe chingakhale chowopsa kuposa pamenepo. Izi zikutanthauza kufikira nsonga zosasinthika, panthawi yomwe, kungotsika pang'onopang'ono ku chiwonongeko cha moyo wa anthu Padziko Lapansi. Sitinakumanepo ndi zimenezo kale. Kwenikweni, takhala tikukumana nazo m'njira kuyambira pa Ogasiti 6th, 1945, koma osati pangozi yotereyi.'
Nthawi zambiri pa utolankhani wodzipatula ngati uwu, Chorley adayankha kutsutsa koyipa ngati kuti sanamve zomwe zanenedwa, akuyankha: 'N'zosangalatsa kuti; ndimati ndikufunseni…'. 'Ndizosangalatsa' sizinali kuyankha mwamphamvu ku mphamvu ya zomwe Chomsky adanena. Chorley adazindikira mwachidwi kuti andale sakuwoneka kuti ali ndi chidwi chofuna kuthana ndi vuto la nyengo. Kwa ife tonse, iye anati, ‘timathera nthaŵi yathu kulankhula za zinthu zazing’ono’.
Tiyerekeze kuti Chomsky adanena kuti sukulu ikuyaka ndipo mazana a ana akuwotchedwa amoyo. Kodi tingatani ngati wina atayankha kuti nkhaniyo ndi yosangalatsa, tisanadziwe kuti akuluakulu a boma akuwoneka kuti alibe chidwi chochita zambiri pa nkhaniyi, pamene anthu akuwoneka kuti akuda nkhawa kwambiri ndi zazing'ono?
Katswiri wakale, inde, pakufinya malingaliro osasangalatsa kudzera m'mawu awa, Chomsky adatchula zovuta zina zomwe sizinali zazing'ono zomwe. ndi anakambitsirana: nkhondo ya Ukraine, nkhondo ya Yemen, ‘kuwonongedwa kotheratu kwa Iraq, kukuchitikabe; zonsezi ndi nkhani zovuta kwambiri'.
Ananenanso kuti, chaka chatha, mafuta opangira mafuta adakula - US ikukulitsa minda yatsopano yamafuta, kutsegulira mayiko a federal kuti afufuze ndikugwiritsa ntchito zaka zambiri zikubwerazi. Ndi nthabwala zake zakuda, Chomsky anawonjezera:
'Makampani opangira mafuta oyaka mafuta ali okondwa ndi chiyembekezo chowonjezera chithandizo cha anthu pantchito yawo yowononga moyo padziko lapansi. Choncho, sizikuwoneka bwino.'
Chorley ndiye adadzutsa nkhani yaku Ukraine:
'Ndithu, ku UK, kumanzere - makamaka pansi pa anthu ngati Jeremy Corbyn - ankatsutsa kuti si Russia yomwe inali mdani, ndi US yomwe inali kusokoneza dziko lapansi. Koma kenako Russia ilanda dziko lodziyimira pawokha, la demokalase pamalire ake, kuyambitsa mkangano womwe wapha anthu masauzande ambiri osalakwa. Kodi zimenezo sizikumveketsa bwino lomwe amene ali chiwopsezo chenicheni ku dziko? Si US, monga akumanzere akhala akukangana kwa nthawi yaitali; ndi Russia ya Vladimir Putin.'
Pambuyo pa Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Syria, Yemen, ndi zitsanzo zina zambiri monga momwe munthu angaganizire, izi zinali ndemanga zachibwana. Chomsky anayankha kuti:
'Chabwino, kuwukira kwa Ukraine mwachiwonekere ndi mlandu wankhondo. Simungachiike m’gulu lofanana ndi milandu yankhondo yokulirapo, koma ndi yaikulu kwambiri.’
Ndi milandu iti yomwe Chomsky ankaganizira? Ananenanso kuti UN ndi Pentagon akuyerekeza kuti pafupifupi anthu wamba 8,000 aphedwa ku Ukraine:
'Ndiwo anthu ambiri, zomwe United States ndi Britain amachita usiku wonse.'
Zachidziwikire, chiwerengero cha 8,000 'chingakhale chocheperako', Chomsky adawonjezera, asanapereke zoyeserera zingapo:
'Tiye tinene kuti ndi kuwirikiza kawiri - zomwe zingaike pamlingo wa [1982] mothandizidwa ndi US, Israeli akuukira Lebanon, komwe kudapha anthu pafupifupi 20,000. Tinene kuti yatha ndi gawo la khumi… Zachidziwikire, Iraq ndi gawo lina chabe.
'Choncho, ndi mlandu waukulu, mlandu wowopsa. Koma mutha kumvetsetsa chifukwa chomwe a Global South samaganizira mozama ziwonetsero zamayiko akumadzulo za "zochitika zapadera m'mbiri". Iwo akhala akuzunzidwa kwambiri. Mwinamwake anthu a ku Russia adzapitirira mpaka pamlingo wathu… Mwinamwake akhoza kufika mpaka pokumbukira nkhanza zawo zoipitsitsa, monga Mariupol.'
Chomsky adanena kuti imodzi mwamilandu yoipitsitsa ku US ku Iraq inali kuwonongedwa kwa mzinda wachitatu wokongola wa Iraq, Fallujah. Ananenanso kuti gulu lankhondo la US Navy posachedwapa latcha chombo chake chaposachedwa chankhondo, USS Fallujah, 'polemekeza kuukira kwa Marine komwe kunachitika chimodzi mwazankhanza kwambiri ku Iraq. Chabwino, mwinamwake Achirasha adzafika pamenepa, nawonso, tsiku lina.'
Chorley anati:
'Ndizosangalatsa komabe, Noam Chomsky; tikumva zomwezi kuchokera kumanzere kuno ku UK…'
Chomsky adasokoneza:
'Palibe chochita ndi kumanzere…'
Izi, ndithudi, ndi zowona - pafupifupi ziwerengero za imfa ndizodziwika bwino, zodalirika kwambiri. Ophawa amadziwika. Palibe kukondera pamalingaliro awa. Apo is kukondera pamalingaliro akuti mfundo izi mwanjira ina ndi 'zamanzere'.
Chorley anati:
'Izi ndikuyesera kupanga kufanana, malo odana ndi Kumadzulo… Mwangoyerekeza kufanana ndi chiwerengero cha imfa m'malo osiyanasiyana… Izi sizikupanga zomwe Vladimir Putin anachita, sichoncho?'
Zindikirani kuti, atamva Chomsky akutchula ziwopsezo zazikulu kwambiri zakufa kwa milandu yaku Western, Chorley adadabwa kuti Chomsky atha kunena kuti Kumadzulo ndi pa ndime ndi Putin. Zinali zosatheka kwa iye kuti Kumadzulo kungakhale zoipa. Zindikiraninso, kuti Chorley adanenanso kuti Chomsky amagwiritsa ntchito mafananidwe awa zifukwa Kuwukira kwa Russia pamasekondi angapo atadzudzula mwamphamvu kuwukirako ngati 'mlandu wankhondo', 'mlandu wowopsa'.
Chomsky anayankha kuti:
'Inde sichoncho. Ndinati ndi mlandu waukulu, koma palibe kufanana - ndiko kutsatira ndondomeko ya chipani. Ndinapereka ziwerengero. Palibe kufanana. Mwina anthu ovulala ndi ochuluka kuwirikiza kakhumi kuposa momwe akuyembekezeredwa. Izi zitha kukhala ngati zolakwa za Reagan ku El Salvador. Izi sizofanana.'
Izi zidatsatiridwa ndi chete chonena chochokera kwa Chorley, yemwe pomalizira pake adazindikira kuti Chomsky amavomereza kuti kunali kulakwa kunena za 'kufanana', koma osati pazifukwa zomwe Chorley anali nazo.
Kuwukira kwa 'moral equivalence' - cholinga chake kukhala chofunikira kwambiri pa zokambiranazi - ndi gawo lodziwika bwino lazofunsana ndi a Chomsky ndi ena otsutsa. Cholinga chake ndikuwonetsa otsutsa mfundo za azungu ngati opepesera opotoka kwa adani aku Western. Mu 2004, kuyankhulana kwa BBC, Jeremy Paxman adadabwa kwambiri Ndemanga ku Chomsky:
'Mukuwoneka kuti mukunena, kapena mukutanthauza - mwina sindikuchita chilungamo - koma mukuwoneka kuti mukutanthauza kuti pali kufanana pakati pa atsogoleri osankhidwa mwa demokalase monga George Bush, kapena Prime Minister ngati Tony Blair, ndi maboma m'malo ena. ngati Iraq.'
Kufunsa yemwe kale anali Mlembi Wamkulu wa UN, a Denis Halliday, mu zokambirana za wailesi ya BBC mu 2001, Michael Buerk wokwiyitsidwa. anati:
'Simungathe…simungathe mwinamwake jambulani kufanana kwamakhalidwe pakati pa Saddam Hussein ndi George Bush Senior, sichoncho?'
Mosalephera - kunyalanyazanso zomwe Chomsky adanena mobwerezabwereza - Chorley adapitiliza kukangana mosatopa. zotsogola ndi zokonda za Guardian's George Monbiot:
'Koma…Ndikuganiza, anthu ena omvetsera izi angaganize kuti mukufuna kutero pepani zomwe Vladimir Putin anachita.'
Mtsutsowu ndi womveka - ngati mtolankhani sangakambirane za milandu 'yathu' - sangaganize kuti zolakwa za 'zathu' zikhoza kukhala zoipitsitsa kuposa 'zawo' - koma sangatsutse mfundo zosatsutsika zomwe zimasonyeza kuti ndi choncho, tulukani. Ya Jail Free khadi ndikuwonetsa kuti munthu amene akupanga mfundozi ali mobisa kumbali ya The Bad Guys choncho sayenera kutengedwa mozama. Kuchoka ku mfundo kupita ku zolinga kumapangitsa chidwi cha anthu kutali ndi zenizeni. Chomsky anayankha kuti:
'Ayi, ndiye kupanga wa phiko lakumanja; Sindikufuna kuwiringula kalikonse. Ndinati ndi mlandu woopsa wankhondo; kumeneko sikukukhululukira kalikonse. Ndikulankhula za chinyengo chambiri cha zonena za momwe izi zilili zoyipitsitsa zomwe zidachitikapo, pomwe ndi gawo la zomwe timachita nthawi zonse. Ndicho chifukwa chake Global South ikuyang'ana moseka pamene olemba ndemanga odzitukumula a Kumadzulo akuyesa kuwafotokozera kuti: "Bwanji osagwirizana nafe potsutsa upandu woopsawu?" … Amaseka monyodola: “Izi ndi zimene mwakhala mukutichitira mpaka kalekale!”
Koma 'bwanji dziko la Ukraine silingagwirizane ndi Nato?', anafunsa Chorley. Chomsky anayankha kuti:
'Kodi chingachitike ndi chiyani ngati dziko la Mexico litasankha kulowa nawo m'gulu lankhondo lapadziko lonse lapansi loyendetsedwa ndi China, kutumiza zida zamphamvu ku Mexico zolunjika ku United States?… Kodi chikanachitika bwanji ku Mexico? Izo zikanaphulitsidwa. Inu mukudziwa zimenezo.'
Chorley adabwereranso pamutu wa 'equivalence':
'Koma ndiye mukufanizira pakati pa Nato ndi China ndi Russia; mukuwona kufanana pakati pawo…'
Apanso, Chomsky anakana zonenazo:
'Ayi, sinditero; Nato ndi mgwirizano wovuta kwambiri. Nato idalanda Yugoslavia, idalanda Libya, idaukira Ukraine - idathandizira kuwukira kwa Ukraine - idathandizira kuwukira kwa Afghanistan. Ndi mgwirizano wankhondo wankhanza. Aliyense kunja kwa Kumadzulo akhoza kuziwona. Kumadzulo, sitiloledwa kuganiza chifukwa timalamuliridwa kwambiri ndi kutsata ndondomeko ya chipani. Koma anthu ena onse akuona.'
Apanso, Chorley adasinthitsa mutu womwe ukunena kuti Chomsky anali wotsatira wa Putin:
'Zikumveka kwa ine ngati iwe ndi kulungamitsa kuukira kwa Russia ku Ukraine.'
Kenako Chorley anafunsa za Jeremy Corbyn. Pambuyo pake adapanga gawo lalikulu lazoyankhulana pa Twitter, mosasamala kutanthauza kuti wofunsidwa yemwe adamuzungulira pa nkhani iliyonse adapusitsidwa mokwanira kuti akhulupirire kuti Corbyn adapambana chisankho cha 2017.
M'malo mwake, Chomsky atanena kuti Corbyn "wapambana kwambiri" mu 2017, amatanthawuza kupanga "kugwedezeka" kwakukulu m'malo mwa Labor ngakhale pali zovuta zamkati ndi kunja kwa Kukhazikitsidwa. Mu 2017, Independent inanena kuti Corbyn 'anawonjezera gawo la mavoti a Labour kuposa atsogoleri ena onse achipanichi kuyambira 1945' ndi 'kusintha kwakukulu kuyambira… nkhondo yachiwiri yapadziko lonse itangotha'.
Mufunso lomaliza, lodabwitsa lomwe likuwonetsa momwe adadziyikira komanso kuti analibe chidwi panthawi yonse yofunsa mafunso, Chorley adafunsa:
'Potsiriza, ndiye, tiyeni tichite izi; tiyeni tiyese kukhala ndi chiyembekezo… Kodi zaka zana zikubwerazi zidzakhala zabwinoko kuposa zapitazi?'
Apanso, zinali ngati Chorley sanamve zomwe Chomsky adanena. Mwachidziwitso, Chomsky anakhalabe woleza mtima kwa masekondi angapo:
'Sipadzakhalanso moyo wadongosolo waumunthu zaka zana kuchokera pano, pokhapokha titasintha njira yomwe utsogoleri ukupita pakuthamanga pa phiri la kuwonongeka kwa nyengo.'
Mwa nthabwala yaying'ono yomaliza, Chomsky adawonjezera:
'Mwawerenga lipoti laposachedwa la IPCC, ndikutsimikiza.'
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama