Da fatan za a Taimaka ZNet
Source: Glenn Greenwald
Don tabbatar da asarar Hillary Clinton ta 2016 ga Donald Trump, da ke jagorantar 'yan jam'iyyar Democrat da manyan abokan aikinsu na kafofin watsa labarai na tsawon shekaru suna gogayya da juna don nuna abin da suka kira "shigin da Rasha ta yi a zabukanmu" a cikin mafi kyawu. Sun ki amincewa da ra'ayin Tarayyar Rasha da Shugaba Obama ya yi ta maimaitawa - cewa shi ne raunin ikon yanki tare da tattalin arzikin ƙasa da Italiya mai iya yin barazana kawai ga makwabta amma ba Amurka ba - kuma a maimakon haka ya jefa Moscow a matsayin kabari, har ma da wanzuwa, barazana ga dimokuradiyyar Amurka, tare da ayyukanta sun yi daidai da mafi munin tsaro a tarihin Amurka.
Wannan mania bayan 2016 ya ƙare tare da manyan 'yan siyasa masu sassaucin ra'ayi da 'yan jarida (da kuma John McCain) ayyana ayyukan Rasha da ke kewaye da 2016 a matsayin "aikin yaki" wanda, da yawa daga cikinsu suka nace, ya kasance. kwatankwacin Pearl Harbor da harin 9/11 - hare-hare guda biyu mafi muni a tarihin Amurka na zamani wanda duka suka haifar da yakin zalunci da barna na tsawon shekaru, da dai sauransu.
Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH) akai-akai nema cewa "tsangwama" na Rasha na 2016 ana ɗaukarsa a matsayin "aikin yaki." Hillary Clinton aka bayyana Hacking na Rasha a matsayin "Cyber 9/11." Kuma a nan ne Wakilin Jerry Nadler (D-NY) a kan MSNBC a farkon Fabrairu, 2018, yana furta Rasha "Ƙarfin Ƙasashen waje" wanda 2016 tsoma baki ya kasance "daidai" na Pearl Harbor, "sosai a daidai" tare da "tsanani". " na harin 1941 a Hawaii wanda ya taimaka wajen shiga shekaru hudu na Amurka a yakin duniya.
Tare da 'yan jam'iyyar Democrat, karkashin Joe Biden, 'yan makonni kadan daga karbar ikon fadar White House da sojojin Amurka da manufofin kasashen waje da ke tafiya tare da shi, maganganun da suka fito daga su da abokansu na kafofin watsa labaru game da Rasha na zama mafi rashin hankali da haɗari. An tabbatar da alhakin da ake zargi da Moscow game da bayanan da aka bayyana kwanan nan, haɗe-haɗe da yawa na hukumomin Gwamnatin Amurka da sabar kamfanoni daban-daban - duk da cewa ba ɗimbin shaida ba, a zahiri, har yanzu an gabatar da su - kamar yadda ba kawai tabbatar da gaskiya ba, amma kamar yadda a zahiri gaskiya ne cewa ba shi da iyaka daga shakka ko tambaya.
Duk wata tambaya game da wannan da'awar za a tozarta ta daga masu magana da yawun 'yan jarida na 'yan Democrat musamman a matsayin cin amanar kasa. “Yanzu shugaban bai yi shiru ba a kan Rasha da kuma kutse. Da gangan yana gudanar da tsaro ga Kremlin ta hanyar saba wa nasa Sakataren Harkokin Wajen kan alhakin Rasha." furta Wakilin tsaron kasa na CNN Jim Sciutto, wanda makon da ya gabata aka kwatanta Yunkurin janye sojojin da Trump ya yi daga Siriya da Jamus a matsayin "yankin da ke yawo" da kuma ba da "kyauta" ga Putin. Mafi firgita, duka maganganun da aka yi don bayyana hack da kuma ramuwar gayya da ake yi wa barazana suna ci gaba da zazzagewa cikin hanzari.
'Yan jam'iyyar Democrat (tare da wasu 'yan Republican da suka dade suna damuwa da Barazana na Rasha, irin su Mitt Romney) suna yin sabon zarge-zargen da Moscow ta yi a cikin mafi yawan sharuɗɗan da zai yiwu, suna tabbatar da cewa Biden zai shiga Fadar White House tare da tashin hankali tare da Rasha kuma yana fuskantar Rasha. matsananciyar matsananciyar ramako mai tsanani. Manyan mashawartan tsaron kasa na Biden kuma yanzu Biden da kansa ya yi, ba tare da wata shaida da aka nuna wa jama'a ba, ya yi barazanar daukar fansa a kan kasar tare da tarin makaman nukiliya mafi girma na biyu a duniya.
Dan majalisa Jason Crow (D-CO) - daya daga cikin 'yan Democrat masu goyon bayan yaki a kan Kwamitin Ayyuka na Majalisar wanda a farkon wannan shekara Haɗa tare da Rep. Liz Cheney (R-WY) don hana shirin Trump na janye sojoji daga Afghanistan - sanar"Wannan zai iya zama zamaninmu na zamani, mai kwatankwacin Intanet na Pearl Harbor," ƙara: "Al'ummarmu na fuskantar hari." Dan Democrat mai matsayi na biyu, Dick Durbin (D-IL), furta: "Wannan kusan shelar yaki ce ta Rasha."
A halin da ake ciki, Sen. Mitt Romney (R-UT), wanda ya shafe shekaru yana jefa kasar Rasha a matsayin babbar barazana ga Amurka yayin da 'yan jam'iyyar Democrat suka yi masa ba'a a matsayin wani abin tarihi na yakin cacar baka (kafin su kwafi sannan su wuce shi). ya bayyana sabon hack a matsayin "daidai da masu fashewar bama-bamai na Rasha da ke tashi ba tare da gano su ba a duk fadin kasar." Dan takarar shugaban kasa na GOP na 2012 shi ma ya caccaki Trump saboda gazawarsa na yin “fada da nuna rashin amincewa da daukar matakin hukunci,” ko da yake - kamar kusan duk wani fitaccen mutum da ke neman “ramuwar gayya” - Romney ya kasa tantance abin da ya ke a ransa zai kasance. isashen ramuwar gayya ga "kwatankwacin 'yan kunar bakin wake na Rasha da ke tashi ba tare da an gano su ba a duk fadin kasar."
Ga waɗanda ke kiyaye waƙa a gida: wannan keɓance “Pearl Harbors” guda biyu a cikin ƙasa da shekaru huɗu daga Moscow (ko, idan kun fi so, Pearl Harbor ɗaya da ɗaya 9/11). Idan da gaske 'yan jam'iyyar Democrat sun yi imani da hakan, yana da mahimmanci cewa za su yi marmarin rungumar manufar yaƙi da ta'addanci ga Rasha. Da yawa daga cikinsu suna neman hakan kai tsaye, suna yin ba'a ga Trump saboda gazawa wajen kai wa Rasha hari - duk da babu wata shaida da ke nuna cewa suna da hannu - yayin da suke garke mai sassaucin ra'ayi da horarwa is bayar da shawara cewa rashin amsawa ya ƙunshi wani nau'i na "high treason."
Tabbas, ƙungiyar Biden ta kasance tana nuna cewa suna da niyyar cika buƙatun ramuwar gayya cikin sauri. The New York Times ya ruwaito a ranar Talata Biden "ya zargi Shugaba Trump [] da 'rashin hankali'" na kutse yayin da "ya gargadi Rasha cewa ba zai bari kutsen ya kasance ba tare da amsa ba" bayan ya hau kan karagar mulki. Biden ya jaddada cewa da zarar an kammala tantance bayanan, "za mu ba da amsa, kuma da alama za mu ba da amsa ta irin wannan."
Barazana da ramuwar gayya tsakanin Amurka da Rasha koyaushe suna da haɗari, amma musamman yanzu. Daya daga cikin muhimman yarjejeniyoyin makaman nukiliya tsakanin kasashen biyu masu makamin nukiliya, New START yarjejeniya, zai kare a watan Fabrairu sai dai idan Putin da Biden ba za su iya yin nasarar yin shawarwarin sabuntawa ba: kwanaki goma sha shida bayan an shirya Biden zai fara aiki. "Hakan zai tilasta Mr. Biden ya kulla yarjejeniya don hana wata barazana - tseren makamin nukiliya - tare da yin barazanar daukar fansa kan wani," in ji sanarwar. Lokaci.
Wannan zance mai tada hankali daga Washington game da Rasha, da kuma sakamakon yanayi na tashin hankali, yana da haɗari a cikin matsanancin. Haka nan sun ginu a cikin tatsuniyoyi, yaudara da karya:
Na farko, kwata-kwata babu wata shaida ta kowace irin wacce aka gabatar don bayar da shawarar, balle a tabbatar, cewa Rasha ce ke da alhakin wadannan kutse. Ba tare da faɗin cewa yana da kyau sosai cewa Rasha za ta iya yin wannan: irin wannan abu ne da kowane babban ƙarfi daga China da Iran zuwa Amurka da Rasha ke da ikon yin da kuma yin amfani da su a kusan kowace ƙasa ciki har da juna.
Amma idan ba mu koyi wani abu ba a cikin shekaru da dama da suka gabata, ya kamata mu sani cewa karɓar iƙirarin da ke fitowa daga ƙungiyar leƙen asirin Amurka game da abokan gaba ba tare da gunaguni ba shine hauka na tsari mafi girma. Mun sami tunatarwa mai haske game da mahimmancin wannan doka: 'yan makonni kafin zaɓen, manyan kafofin watsa labaru da yawa sun yi watsi da da'awar ƙarya ta cewa takaddun daga kwamfutar tafi-da-gidanka Hunter Biden. sun kasance "Rashin bayanan Rasha," kawai don jami'ai su yarda da zarar an yi cutar da cewa babu wata shaida - sifili - na shigar Rasha.
Amma duk da haka ainihin abin da mafi yawan kafofin watsa labaru ke sake yi: suna tabbatar da cewa Rasha ce ke bayan waɗannan kutse duk da cewa ba ta da wata shaida ta gaskiyarta. The New York Times' Michael Barbaro, babban mashahuran jaridar Jaridar Daily podcast, ya tambayi abokin aikinsa, mai ba da rahoto kan harkokin tsaron kasa David Sanger, wace shaida ta wanzu don tabbatar da cewa Rasha ta yi haka. Kamar yadda Barbaro ya sanya shi, ko da Sanger yana "ba da izinin cewa farkon yanke shawara na iya zama kuskure, amma yana da shakka." Tabbas, Sanger ya yarda da Barbaro cewa ba su da wata hujja, maimakon haka cewa tushen da ya dogara da shi shi ne cewa Rasha ta mallaki kwarewa don aiwatar da irin wannan kutse (kamar yadda wasu kasashe da dama suka yi), tare da ikirarin cewa kutse. yana da abin da ya kira "alama" na masu fashin kwamfuta na Rasha.
Amma wannan dabara ta kasance daidai tsofaffin jami'an leken asiri ne ke amfani da su, kamar yadda waɗannan kafofin watsa labaru iri ɗaya suka yi, don yada da'awar ƙarya kafin zaɓen cewa takaddun daga kwamfutar tafi-da-gidanka na Hunter Biden sune "Rayuwar Rasha": wato, sun furta a cikin kulle-kulle, kayan daga kwamfutar tafi-da-gidanka na Hunter "yana da duk manyan alamun kunne na Rashanci. bayanan aiki." Wannan kuma shi ne ainihin dabarar da hukumomin leken asirin Amurka suka yi amfani da su a cikin 2001 yin karya da zargin Iraki da harin anthrax, suna iƙirarin cewa bincikensu na sinadarai ya nuna wani abu da ke “alamar kasuwanci ta shirin makaman yaƙi na Iraqi.”
Wadannan kafafen yada labarai, idan aka matsa musu, za su amince da rashin hujjar da ke nuna cewa Rasha ta aikata hakan. Duk da wannan rashin hujja da aka yarda, kafofin watsa labaru suna ta bayyana alhakin Rasha a matsayin tabbataccen gaskiya.
"Isalin Hacking na Rasha ya bayyana a sarari: Hukumomin Amurka da dama sun buge," daya New York Times kanun labarai da aka yi shelar, kuma layin farko na wannan labarin, wanda Sanger ya rubuta tare, ya faɗi tabbatacce: Hacking injiniya daya daga Rasha Hukumomin leken asiri na farko sun kara bayyana a ranar Litinin." The Washington Post ya mamaye jama'a tare da wasu kanun labarai iri ɗaya:
Babu wani a cikin gwamnati da ya taka muhimmiyar rawa wajen tabbatar da alhakin Rasha kamar kafafen yada labarai na kamfanoni. Ko da Sakataren Harkokin Wajen Trump, Mike Pompeo, ya kirga zargin da ya yi wa Moscow tare da caveats da rashin tabbas: "Ina jin haka lamarin yake cewa yanzu za mu iya cewa kyakkyawa a fili cewa 'yan Rasha ne suka yi wannan aikin."
Idan ainihin hujja a ƙarshe ta fito da ke nuna alhakin Rasha, ba zai canza yadda haɗarin yake ba - ƙasa da shekaru ashirin bayan rikicin WMD na Iraki da ƙasa da shekaru biyu bayan amincewar kafofin watsa labarai m Rashagate ƙarya - Kafafen yada labarai masu tasiri na ci gaba da tafka kura-kurai a matsayin Gaskiya duk abin da al'umma masu hankali ke ciyar da su, ba tare da bukatar ganin wata shaida da ke nuna cewa abin da suke ikirarin gaskiya ne ba. Abin da ya fi ban tsoro shi ne, manyan sassan jama'a da ke girmama waɗannan kantuna suna ci gaba da gaskata cewa abin da suka ji daga gare su dole ne ya zama gaskiya, ko da sau nawa suka ci amanar wannan amana. Sauƙin da CIA za ta iya yada duk wani saƙon da take so ta hanyar kafofin watsa labaru na abokantaka yana da ban mamaki.
Na biyu, ainihin ra'ayin cewa wannan hack za a iya kwatanta shi da ɗan damfara da abubuwan da ba su da kyau kamar Pearl Harbor ko harin 9/11 yana da ban dariya a fuskarsa. Dole ne mutum ya nutse cikin rudani marar iyaka don yin imani da cewa wannan hack - ko, don wannan al'amari, 2016 "tsangwama na zaɓe" - wani tsattsauran ra'ayi ne daga ƙa'idodin ƙasa da ƙasa sabanin cikakken tunanin su.
Kamar dai yadda ya kasance a cikin shafukan Facebook na bogi na 2016 da kuma bots na Twitter, ba ƙari ba ne a ce gwamnatin Amurka tana aiwatar da hare-hare irin wannan, kuma waɗanda suka fi mamayewa, a kan kusan kowace ƙasa a duniya, ciki har da Rasha, a kan. a mako-mako akai akai. Wannan ba yana nufin cewa irin wannan hacking ko dai ya dace ko kuma bai dace ba. Yana nufin, duk da haka, kwatanta shi a matsayin wani abu na musamman na ban tsoro da rashin misaltuwa wanda ke buƙatar babban ramuwar gayya yana buƙatar matakin rashin hankali da ruɗani da ke da ruɗani a gani.
Rahoton NSA da Edward Snowden ya bayar da kansa ya tabbatar da cewa NSA na leken asiri kusan kowa zai iya. Hakika, bayan na yi nazari a kan ma'ajiyar tarihin a baya a cikin 2013, na yanke shawarar cewa ba zan bayar da rahoto game da kutsen da Amurka ta yi na manyan kasashen da ke gaba da juna kamar China da Rasha ba saboda ya zama ruwan dare ga dukkan wadannan kasashe su rika yin kutse a junansu da tsauri da kutsawa. za su iya cewa da wuya a ba da rahoto game da wannan (banda kawai lokacin da akwai wani dalili mai mahimmanci na kallon irin wannan leƙen asiri a matsayin mai ba da labari, kamar su. Haɗin gwiwar Sweden tare da NSA don leken asirin Rasha wanda ya saba wa karyar da jami'an Sweden suka bayyana wa jama'a).
Sauran gidajen labarai waɗanda ke da damar yin amfani da takaddun Snowden, musamman The New York Times, ba su yi kusan cikawa ba wajen fallasa leƙen asirin da Amurka ke yi kan manyan abokan gaba na ƙasa. Sakamakon haka, akwai kwararan hujjoji da waɗancan gidajen yanar gizon suka buga (wani lokaci suna tsokanar ƙin jinin Snowden) cewa Amurka tana yin daidai abin da ake zargin Rasha da aikatawa a nan - kuma mafi muni.
"Ko da Amurka ta ba da sanarwar jama'a game da haɗarin sayan daga Huawei na [China], takaddun sirri sun nuna cewa Hukumar Tsaro ta ƙasa tana ƙirƙira kofofin bayanta - kai tsaye a cikin hanyoyin sadarwar Huawei." ruwaito The New York Times' David Sanger da Nicole Perlroth a cikin 2013, ya kara da cewa "Hukumar ta shiga cikin sabar a hedkwatar Huawei da ke Shenzhen, zuciyar masana'antar China."
A shekarar 2013, da Guardian saukar "Kokarin NSA na sauraron shugaban Rasha, Dmitry Medvedev, yayin da kiran wayarsa ya wuce ta hanyar tauraron dan adam zuwa Moscow," ya kuma kara da cewa: "'yan siyasa da jami'an kasashen waje da suka shiga cikin biyu G20 Taron koli da aka yi a Landan a shekara ta 2009 an sa ido a kan kwamfutocinsu kuma an katse kiran wayarsu bisa umarnin jami’an gwamnatinsu na Burtaniya.” A halin da ake ciki, "Sweden ta kasance babbar abokiyar kawance ga Amurka wajen leken asirin Rasha da shugabancinta, in ji gidan talabijin na Sweden a ranar Alhamis." in ji Reuters, yana ambaton abin da wata takardar NSA ta bayyana a matsayin “tari na musamman kan manyan manufofin Rasha, kamar jagoranci, siyasa na cikin gida.”
Wasu rahotanni sun nuna cewa Amurka na da hacked cikin tsarin sadarwa na Brazil don tattara bayanai akan dukan jama'a, kuma ya kasance leken asiri Manyan jagororin Brazil (ciki har da shugabar kasar Dilma Rousseff a lokacin) da kuma manyan kamfanoninta irin su katafaren kamfanin mai na Petrobras da ma'aikatar ma'adinai da makamashi. The Washington Post ruwaito: “Hukumar Tsaro ta ƙasa tana taruwa kusan 5 biliyan rikodin a rana akan inda wayoyin salula suke a duniya, bisa ga wasu manyan takardu na sirri da hirarraki da jami'an leken asirin Amurka, da ke baiwa hukumar damar bin diddigin motsin mutane - da kuma taswirar dangantakarsu - ta hanyoyin da a baya ba za a iya misalta su ba." Kuma gaba da gaba.
[Wani abin ban mamaki ko da yake ba a yarda da shi ba wanda ya danganci wannan duka: iri ɗaya ne New York Times 'yar jaridar da ta bayyana cikakken bayani game da kutsen da hukumar leken asiri ta NSA ta yi wa gwamnatin China da masana'antu, Nicole Perlroth, daga baya ta bukaci (a cikin tweets da ta goge) cewa kada a yafe Snowden saboda a cewarta, ya bayyana halastaccen leken asiri na NSA akan abokan adawar Amurka. . A hakikanin gaskiya, ita ce Perlorth, ba Snowden ba, wanda ya zabi ya fallasa leken asirin NSA kan kasar Sin, wanda ya haifar da fushin Snowden a lokacin da ta yi hakan bisa ga ra'ayinsa wannan ya saba wa tsarin da ya kirkiro don abin da ya kamata kuma bai kamata ba. bayyana; a wasu kalmomi, ba kawai Perlroth ba ta bukaci a gurfanar da wata majiya da ita kanta ta dogara da shi, wani abu mai matukar ban mamaki ga kowane dan jarida ya yi, amma mafi muni, ta yi haka ne ta hanyar yin zargin karya cewa tushen yin wani abu da ita, Perlroth, ta yi da kanta: wato. ya bayyana yawan kutsen da Amurka ta yi wa China].
Abin da duk wannan ya bayyana a sarari shi ne cewa kawai wanda ya fi ruɗu kuma wanda ba shi da masaniya zai iya gaskata cewa kutse na Rasha na hukumomin Amurka da kamfanoni - idan ya faru - wani abu ne banda gaba ɗaya dabi'a na gama gari tsakanin waɗannan ƙasashe. Farfesa Farfesa Harvard kuma tsohon jami'in Bush DOJ Jack Goldsmith, yana nazarin buƙatun haɓaka don ramuwar gayya, ya rubuta kyakkyawan labarin makon da ya gabata mai taken “Ruwan Kai Kan Hack din Rasha: Amurka a kai a kai na yin kutse na tsarin kwamfuta na gwamnatocin kasashen waje a kan wani ma'auni mai girma":
Rashin sanin kai a cikin waɗannan da makamantansu game da cin zarafi na Rasha yana da ban mamaki. Gwamnatin Amurka ba ta da wani tushe mai tushe da za ta koka game da kutsen da Rasha ta yi, da ma rage ramuwar gayya a kanta ta hanyar soji, tun bayan da gwamnatin Amurka ke yin kutse a cibiyoyin sadarwa na kasashen ketare a kowace rana. Lalle ne, martanin soja ga hack na Rasha zai keta dokar kasa da kasa . . . .
Kamar yadda bayanan leken asiri daga Edward Snowden ya fito karara, Amurka a kai a kai na kutsa kai cikin tsarin kwamfuta na gwamnatocin kasashen waje a kan wani ma'auni mai yawa, sau da yawa (kamar yadda ake yin kutse a Rasha) tare da taimakon wasu kamfanoni masu zaman kansu ba da gangan ba, don dalilai na leken asiri. Kusan tabbas shine jagoran duniya a cikin wannan aikin, mai yiwuwa da yawa. Takardun Snowden sun ba da shawarar sosai, kamar yadda NSA ke da yiwuwar kasafin kuɗi. A cikin 2016, bayan lura da "matsalolin da ke tattare da kutse ta yanar gizo daga Rasha," Obama ya yi fahariya cewa Amurka tana da "mafi ƙarfi fiye da kowa… da fushi" . . . .
Saboda ayyukanta, gwamnatin Amurka a al'adance ta yarda da halaccin leƙen asiri na gwamnatocin ƙasashen waje a cikin cibiyoyin sadarwar gwamnatin Amurka. Bayan da China ta yi katsalandan kan kutse a ofishin kula da bayanan jama'a, daraktan hukumar leken asiri ta kasar a lokacin James Clapper ya ce: "Dole ne ku jinjina wa Sinawa kan abin da suka yi. Idan mun sami damar yin hakan, ba na tsammanin za mu yi jinkiri na minti daya. " Ita ma hukumar ta Rasha wacce da alama ta yi kutse a wannan makon ta kuma yi kutse cikin sakwannin imel da ba a tantance ba a fadar White House da tsaro da ma'aikatar harkokin wajen Amurka a tsakanin shekarun 2014-2015. Gwamnatin Obama ta ɗauki leƙen asiri na gargajiya kuma ba ta rama ba. "Tarin bayanai ne, wanda shi ne abin da jihohi - ciki har da Amurka - suke yi," in ji mai kula da harkokin tsaro ta yanar gizo na gwamnatin Obama Michael Daniel a wannan makon.
Amma a cikin shekaru huɗu da suka gabata, Amurkawa, musamman waɗanda ke ciyar da kafofin watsa labaru masu sassaucin ra'ayi, sun nutse cikin tatsuniyoyi masu yawa game da Amurka da Rasha ta yadda ba su da ikon tantance iƙirarin da ake yi, kuma - kamar yadda aka jagorance su. don yin imani game da "shigin da Rasha ta yi a 2016 a cikin Zabukanmu masu tsarki" - suna da sauƙin gamsuwa cewa abin da Rasha ta yi wani abu ne mai ban mamaki da kuma mummunan laifi wanda ba a iya ganin irin su a cikin dangantakar kasa da kasa. A hakikanin gaskiya, gwamnatinsu ita ce zaratan duniya da ba a tantama a kan aikata wadannan ayyuka, kuma sun yi shekaru idan ba shekaru da dama ba.
Na uku, waɗannan buƙatun na "ramuwar gayya" ba su da hankali sosai domin kusan ko da yaushe ba su tare da kowane takamaiman bayani ba. Ko da an nuna alhakin Moscow, menene ya kamata Amurka ta yi don mayar da martani? Idan amsar ku ita ce su yi wa Rasha kutse, ku tabbata NSA da CIA koyaushe suna ƙoƙarin yin kutse a Rasha gwargwadon abin da za ta iya, tun kafin wannan taron.
Idan amsar ta kasance ƙarin takunkumi, wannan zai zama kawai aiki da rashin ma'ana, baya ga munafunci. Duk wani ramuwar gayya mafi muni fiye da hakan ba zai wuce sakaci ba, musamman tare da buƙatar sabunta yarjejeniyoyin sarrafa makaman nukiliya da ke gabatowa. Kuma idan kai mai neman ramuwar gayya ne, shin ka yarda cewa Rasha, China, Brazil da duk sauran kasashen da masu satar bayanan sirrin NSA suka mamaye suna da hakkin daukar fansa akan Amurka, ko kuma Amurka ta mamaye wani wuri na musamman da hakki na musamman wanda duk sauran sauran kasashen. kasa kasa?
Abin da muke da shi a nan, duk da haka, shine aikin al'ada na al'ummar leken asirin da ke ciyar da manyan zarge-zarge game da ikon mallakar makaman nukiliya zuwa kafofin watsa labaru na kamfanoni masu kishi, tare da kafofin watsa labaru ba tare da yin la'akari da yada shi ba tare da shaida ba, duk don tayar da tashin hankali tsakanin waɗannan makaman nukiliya guda biyu. -ikon makamai da ƙarfafa tatsuniyoyi na Amurka a matsayin babban wanda aka azabtar amma ba mai laifi ba.
Idan kun taɓa samun kanku kuna mamakin yadda manyan kasafin kuɗi na soja da kuma yanayin Yaƙin Ƙarshen Yaƙi da alama ba za su iya fuskantar ƙalubale ba, wannan ɗabi'a ta cuta - daga ƙungiyar leƙen asiri ta yanzu, kafofin watsa labarai na kamfanoni, da Jam'iyyar Dimokuradiyya - tana ba da babban yanki guda ɗaya. na wuyar warwarewa.
Sabuntawa, Disamba 24, 2020, 7:36 na safe ET: Kodayake tweets daga The New York TimesNicole Perlroth da aka ambata a sama ta share ta, kamar yadda aka nuna, mai karanta faɗakarwa ya lura cewa. a POLITICO labarin a lokacin nace wani bangare na musanya da ita, wanda fushi ya jawo Washington Post 'yan jarida kan wani edita ta takarda nasu wanda ya yi jayayya da afuwar Snowden, kodayake wannan takarda ta ba da rahoto sosai kan takardun Snowden kuma ta sami Pulitzer don yin haka:
Editan ba komai bane idan ba uzuri mai kyau ga muhawarar Twitter ba. Wasu ‘yan jarida sun ci gaba da nuna bacin ransu a jiya kan yadda hukumar editoci ta kare Snowden, yayin da wasu ko dai sun amince da hujjar hukumar ko kuma a kalla sun kare hakkinta na daukar matakin da ta san ko shakka babu zai sa mutane da yawa a dakin labarai na Post. A cikin ɗaya daga cikin fitattun musaya, ɗan jaridar New York Times ɗan jaridar cybersecurity Nicole Perlroth ya haɗu da Glenn Greenwald, wanda ya karya labarin Snowden/NSA na The Guardian.
Perlroth: "Dole a ce na yarda w/ wapo. @Snowden ya fitar da dubun dubatan takardu wadanda basu da alaka da keta sirrin sirri." http://bit.ly/2cLPeLY
Greenwald: "Za su iya fara kulob na Agusta: 'Yan Jaridu a Favor of Criminal Prosecution For Our Sources" http://bit.ly/2cLLIRz
Wannan shine ainihin abin da nake magana a nan. Abin takaici ne sosai cewa Perlroth ta ba da shawarar a daure tushenta a gidan yari saboda ya fitar da wasu takardu "wadanda ba su da alaka da keta sirrin sirri" lokacin da ita, Perlroth, ta yanke shawarar bayyana bayanan leken asirin NSA kan China, wanda ya fusata Snowden. tsari. Danna mahaɗin da ke sama zuwa tweet ɗin ta yana nuna cewa tun da ta goge shi.
Batu ɗaya na ƙarshe: akwai fitaccen op-ed a ranar Alhamis New York Times game da bacin rai game da kutsen da ake zargin Rasha da Paul Kolbe, wanda ya yi aiki a matsayin babban jami'in leken asirin CIA na tsawon shekaru 25, kuma yanzu shi ne darektan Hukumar Leken Asiri a Makarantar Harvard Kennedy, mai taken "Tare da Hacking, Amurka na Bukatar Dakatar da Wasa. ” Ya ba da cikakken bayani cewa "Amurka, ba shakka, tana yin irin wannan nau'in ayyuka a ma'auni mafi girma" don haka "lokaci ya yi da Amurka za ta daina yin mamaki kuma ta daina sanyawa."
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi