A cikin littafin tarihin George Orwell na dystopian 1984, Winston Smith, babban jarumi, magatakarda ne na Sashen Rubuce-rubuce a Ma'aikatar Gaskiya. Ayyukan Winston shine sake rubuta tarihin Oceania, labarin labarai ta labarin labarai, yayin da manufofin jam'iyyar hukuma suka canza. Maganganun "ƙasa da ramin ƙwaƙwalwar ajiya" ya fito ne daga wannan ɓangaren littafin Orwell kuma yana nufin lalata ƙoƙarin Winston, bayan yin bita.
Lokacin da mutum ya san cewa duk wata takarda ta lalace, ko ma idan ya ga tarkacen takarda yana kwance, sai a yi ta atomatik ya ɗaga murfin rami mafi kusa da shi ya jefar da shi, daga nan sai a juye shi. iska mai dumi zuwa ga manyan tanderun da aka ɓoye a wani wuri a cikin wuraren ginin. - George Orwell, 1984, Babi na 4
The yanar NewsDiffs.org yana nuna mana yadda wannan aikin ke wanzuwa a yau, a cikin duniyar gaske, inda ake saurin bitar labaran da manyan kungiyoyin labarai suka yi sau da yawa bayan bugawa kuma ba tare da masu gyara suna ba da wani bayani ba. Ta hanyar kwatantawa da bambanta waɗannan bita-bita, abin da ke ƙasa da ramin ƙwaƙwalwar karin magana, tare da abin da kawai bai sanya shi a buga ba, ana ba wa masu karatu kyakkyawar fahimta game da yadda manyan kantunan labarai ke aiki a matsayin Sashen Rubuce-rubuce don manyan tsarin iko a Yamma. .
Dauki, misali, da New York Times ' labarin kan zargin amfani da makami mai guba a Syria, "Kerry Ya Bada Shaidar Bayyanar Amfani da Makamin Sinadari. "
A cewar NewsDiffs labarin ya wuce 22 sake dubawa tun jiya. Yayin da wasu daga cikinsu sun kasance don gyaran nahawu mai sauƙi, kamar canza "zuwa" zuwa "kuma,” da yawa daga cikin sauye-sauyen sun yi yawa, kuma sun ba da kakkausar murya, yaƙi, son kai ga Amurka da ƙawayenta na Yamma, musamman abokan hulɗar Washington na yau da kullun: Burtaniya da Isra'ila.
The babban canji na farko Karin wannan tsokaci ne da Sakataren Harkokin Wajen Birtaniya William Hague ya yi: "Shin zai yiwu a mayar da martani ga makami mai guba ba tare da cikakken hadin kai kan Kwamitin Tsaro na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ba? Zan yi jayayya da eh haka ne, in ba haka ba, yana iya yiwuwa a ba da amsa ga irin wannan fushin, irin waɗannan laifuffuka, kuma ba na tsammanin wannan lamari ne mai karɓuwa."
Tuni masu karatu za su iya ganin yadda "takardar rikodin" ke tsara labarin a matsayin wani yanki na hulda da jama'a a madadin wadanda suka yi aiki ba tare da gajiyawa ba tsawon shekaru a kan kawar da gwamnati a Siriya. Mafi muni, babu wani fili da zai nuna cewa, sai dai idan an mayar da martani ga wani harin da aka kai da makami, yin amfani da karfi ba tare da umarnin Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ba haramun ne. Haka kuma ba a ba da sarari don tambayar bambanci tsakanin "mai yiwuwa" da "shari'a." Shin zai yiwu kasashen Yamma su keta dokokin kasa da kasa? Rubutun tarihi yana da tabbaci.
The na gaba gagarumin bita sun hada da maganganun da jami'an Isra'ila suka kara da cewa "a bayyane yake" cewa sojojin Assad sun yi amfani da makamai masu guba. Shaida? Babu ko ɗaya da aka bayar.
Manyan bita guda biyu na gaba sune sabuntawa game da yadda tawagar masu sa ido ta Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ta shiga cikin wuta na maharbi (nan da kuma nan). Yayin da gyare-gyaren biyu ke nuna ruɗani game da ko su wane ne ke da alhakin kai hare-haren, an lura da cewa "jami'an tsaron Siriya ne ke rakiyar ayarin na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya." Ba a bayar da wani sharhi kan ko menene muradin 'yan tawayen ke da shi wajen hana gudanar da binciken ba. Wannan zai iya zama muhimmin lokaci don yin hakan, musamman idan aka yi la'akari da cewa Jaridar Wall Street Journal ta ruwaito a baya cewa Amurka na kokarin dakatar da binciken.
Sannan akwai abubuwan da suka faru a baya da muka ba da rahoto a kai: Washington ta sanya hannu kan wani shiri na amfani da makamai masu guba sannan kuma ta dora alhakinsa kan gwamnatin Syria, da kuma mayakan ‘yan tawaye da suka kama da iskar sarin jijiyoyi a Turkiyya (duba nan da kuma nan).
A wani gagarumin bita An ba da sararin samaniya ga Sakataren Tsaron Amurka Chuck Hagel da kuma hujjarsa na shiga tsakani: "Idan akwai wani mataki da aka dauka, zai kasance tare da al'ummomin duniya da kuma cikin tsarin tabbatar da doka."
Tsarin ya ci gaba: da NYT labarin shine hujjar morphing don yaki.
The bayan canji ya bai wa Rasha sararin yin gargadi game da amfani da karfin soji da kuma nuna cewa mai yiwuwa 'yan tawayen ne suka kai harin da ake zargin an kai mata masu guba. Amma, wannan, kamar asusun Siriya, bai kai ga gyara na ƙarshe da muke da shi a yau ba.
Lokacin da NYT yana kusa da miƙawa iyakacin sarari ga gwamnatin Siriya har yanzu suna iya jujjuya sakin layi cikin izgili:
[Shugaba Assad] ya ce da sojojin gwamnati sun yi kasadar kashe sojojinsu idan sun yi amfani da makamai masu guba. "Wannan ya saba wa tunani na farko," rahotannin labarai sun ambato shi yana cewa. “Ba mu bane makiyanmu ne ke amfani da makami mai guba,” in ji shi, yana mai nuni da hakan. kamar yadda ya saba yi, ga ‘yan tawayen da ke adawa da gwamnati a matsayin “’yan ta’adda.” [an kara jaddadawa]
Kuma a cikin gyara na gaba Duk abin da ke sama ya kau, ba tare da barin wani sarari ga gwamnatin Siriya don yin tsokaci kan lamarin ba. Yayin da kusan dukkanin labarin an bai wa jami'an adawa da Assad yin barazana, ko kuma zubar da hawayen kada kan mummunan halin da yakin ya janyo, sai dai akwai sakin layi guda daya da ke nuni da yiwuwar 'yan tawaye ne suka kai harin. har ma an gina shi a hankali don sanya shakku akan:
"Jami'an gwamnatin Obama sun ce an kididdige kalaman Mr. Kerry don karyata iƙirarin da Siriya da daɗaɗɗen majiɓinta, Rasha, suka yi na cewa 'yan tawayen ne. ko ta yaya da alhakin harin makami mai guba, ko kuma Mista Assad ya yi wani muhimmin rangwame ta hanyar bai wa masu binciken Majalisar Dinkin Duniya damar shiga." [an kara jaddadawa]
A ƙarshe, an ji kan labarin a matsayin “Kerry ya kawo hujjoji . . .,” amma sake fasalin na ƙarshe ya ce: “A cikin kwanaki masu zuwa, jami’ai sun ce, hukumomin leƙen asirin ƙasar za su bayyana wasu bayanai don ƙarfafa shari’arsu cewa sojojin Mr. Assad sun yi amfani da makamai masu guba.” Wato, ba a taɓa kawo wata shaida ba, kawai an yi alƙawarin za a ba da ita daga baya, kamar yadda aka faɗa tare da zargi na ƙarshe wanda ya zama marar amfani.
Abin da muke shaida shine juyin halitta na labarin, ba cikin ɗan jarida na gaskiya ba, gaskiya, ko ɗaukar hoto ba tare da son kai ba, amma a cikin bakin ga waɗanda ke son yaki, kuma sun saka hannun jari a cikin shekaru. Rikicin Syria ya shafe kusan shekaru uku ana gwabzawa, wanda dukkansu Amurka da kawayenta ke neman kawo karshen gwamnatin Assad, tare da rufe idanuwa kan laifukan ‘yan tawaye, tare da dakile yunkurin da ake yi na ganin an cimma sulhu cikin lumana. The NYT Ya zuwa yanzu an sake yin bitar labarin tare da sake rubutawa kusan sau dozin biyu, tare da samar da sarari kaɗan kawai ga abin da za a iya kwatanta shi a matsayin ɓangaren "maƙiyi" na rikici, kuma an yi shi da raini, yana nuna cewa kamar yadda Washington ta dauki bangare a cikin rikici. , haka ma New York Times.
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi