Elaine Bernard
One
of the more entertaining pieces of email to cross my screen in the last few
weeks, was a cover letter with a "Guide to the Seattle Meltdown: A
Compendium of Activists at the WTO Ministerial." The letter noted that the
"perceived success" of the groups in disrupting the WTO meetings in
Seattle would be a boon to anti-corporate protesters. In particular, it would
heighten their visibility and "substantially enhance fundraising
capability," deepen already existing coalitions and contribute to the
broadening of the coalitions "to include non-traditional allies" and
with a Presidential election campaign and key trade votes coming up, provide
activists with "golden opportunities to seek wider recognition and gain
additional strength." Finally, these "high profile battles will allow
activists to further institutionalize and consolidate their gains, increase
coordination, gain greater media attention and expand their targeting of
business interests."
Hard
to disagree with this. The punch line, however, is who sent out the letter and
guide: one Gardner Peckham, of "Black, Kelly, Scruggs & Healy, A Burson
Marsteller Company." Burson Marsteller is one of the big Washington
corporate advertising, image, and public relations firms. You got to love the
business community – every action, every criticism, every turn of events is
just another business opportunity.
Below
is letter in full. It’s fascinating to see who is listed and who is not in the
guide. For example, I’m grossly insulted that they missed out ZNet, one of the
more effective and up-to-date activists website. Similarly, I’m sure that many
in the labor movement will be insulted that while they chose to highlight the
Steelworkers, Autoworkers, Machinists, Teamsters, UNITE, the Sheetmetal workers,
the AFL-CIO and what surely must be a first, the historically very conservative
International Confederation of Free Trade Unions, they insultingly left off, the
small but effective UE (United Electrical Workers) who have long been involved
in North/South solidarity, and especially work with unionists in Mexico.
On
the other hand, they did list the "French Peasants Confederation," in
fact the only non-US labor organization (other than the ICFTU). The French
Peasants Confederation, they explain, is lead by Jose Bove "a French goat
farmer who tore up a McDonald’s restaurant with a tractor to protest US trade
sanctions on Rocquefort cheese."
Much
to my surprise, they list the "Humane Society" as another group to
watch out for. These rebels plan to "collect 2001 signatures by the end of
2001 calling on all governments to stop the WTO from interfering with national
environmental and health and safety laws." I now know I made the right
decision when I decided to give the local cat/dog shelter a donation this year.
The
guide tends not to have many of the communities of faith on their list – the
notable exception being "Christian Aid," an organization of British
and Irish churches "engaged in relief work in more than 60 countries to
improve lives and tackle the causes of poverty and injustice." However,
USAS, the United Students Against Sweatshops, one of the newest organizations,
will be pleased to see that they made the list – along with well-known,
campaigning organizations such as Public Citizen,’s Global Trade Watch, 50 Years
is Enough, Friends of the Earth, National Labor Committee, Greenpeace, Global
Exchange and the Rainforest Network
"What
is less understood – but perhaps more significant – is the potential ability
of the emerging coalition of these groups to seriously impact broader,
longer-term corporate interests."
———–
Black,
Kelly, Scruggs & Healy A Burson Marsteller Company 1801 K Street, N.W.,Suite
901-L,Washington, D.C. 20006-1201 (202) 530-0500, (202) 530-4800
January
14, 2000
Dear
[Corporate Client]:
Enclosed
is our "Guide to the Seattle Meltdown: A Compendium of Activists at the WTO
Ministerial". The "Guide" is a comprehensive listing of the
activist groups which protested against the WTO Ministerial in Seattle this past
November. It lists the groups and their leaders we were able to identify,
descriptions of their ethos (largely in their own words), as well as web site
addresses and other useful information. We wanted to share this
"Guide" with you, not so much as a retrospective on the past, but as
an alarming window on the future.
The
spectacle created in Seattle during the WTO Ministerial meeting by a diverse
collection of activists may have significant short-term ramifications for the
business community. The perceived success of these groups in disrupting Seattle
and in contributing to the failure of the WTO meeting will be a dramatic boon to
them in several ways. First, their victory and heightened visibility will lead
to substantially enhanced fundraising capability. Second, the smell of victory
will lead to a deepening of already existing coalitions and will strengthen the
recognition that broadening such coalitions to include non-traditional allies
exponentially increases effectiveness. Third, the Presidential election campaign
and several likely trade votes in Congress this year will give activists golden
opportunities to seek wider recognition and gain additional strength. These high
profile battles will allow activists to further institutionalize and consolidate
their gains, increase coordination, gamier greater media attention and expand
their targeting of business interests.
What
is less understood — but perhaps more significant — is the potential ability
of the emerging coalition of these groups to seriously impact broader,
longer-term corporate interests. Seattle was not an anomaly and the consistent
anti-corporate message of virtually all the groups who participated there in
November is not a temporary phenomenon. Many have traditionally highlighted
alleged corporate misconduct in mass mail fund raising campaigns. More recently,
some environmental groups have resorted to targeting corporations for
contributions in return for suspending their public ire.
At
Black, Kelly, Scruggs & Healey, we have developed a capability direction of
these groups, as well as to defend clients against their attacks. I hope you
find the enclosed "Guide" useful and if you have any questions, please
call me at: (202)530-4805.
Sincerely,
Gardner
G. Peckham Managing Director