Pakagumbuka nemukana wekuita nhoroondo, Press Council yeIndia yakaita bongozozo panzvimbo. Iyo PCI yakangobvongodzwa pamabvi pamberi pedambudziko re 'Paid News.' [Ona yaSainath scoop panhau dzakatengwa muIndia pane ino saiti muna Mbudzi wapfuura] musarudzo yaChikunguru 30 yekumisa chirevo chekomiti diki - iyo yakadoma nekunyadzisa vapari venhau dzakabhadharwa - ichadzika sechimwe chezvitsauko zvinosuruvarisa munhoroondo yayo. Chitsauko chisingazokanganwiki uye icho chinokonzera kukanganisa kusingaenzaniswi mukurwisana nehuori hukuru mukati meIndia media. Chitsauko chakaona PCI ichidzokera pasi mukurwisana nekuderedzwa kwevezvenhau nesimba remari, kunyange zvazvo 'mushumo wekupedzisira' unonyepedzera kurwisana nawo mumafashama emashoko. Ichi chitsauko chinokuvadza zvakanyanya kumufananidzo uye kuvimbika kwePCI pachayo. Siya padivi kukuvadza kwayakaita kune veruzhinji. Kana kune ramangwana reIndia media seyakasununguka uye yakatendeseka institution.
Sachigaro wePress Council uyo akatsigira zvakasimba kufumurwa kwevapari venhau dzakabhadharwa akakundwa neboka revaparidzi rine simba zvikuru. Yokupedzisira yakanga ine nzira yayo nevakawanda vashoma. Mutongi GN Ray aingove nguva yese yegwaro rekomiti diki (iro rakadoma nekunyadzisa vane mhosva) richiiswa kune 'yekupedzisira'. Iye zvino anozviwana azere nechinzvimbo 'chehurumende' chakanga chisiri chake asi chaanofanira kudzivirira sechake.
Hapana kunyomba kwakazunungusa vezvenhau veIndia mumakumi emakore achangopfuura kupfuura aya 'nhau dzakabhadharwa,' kunyanya pazvakabuda munguva yekupedzisira yeLok Sabha uye sarudzo dzakazotevera dzeMaharashtra kuti mazana emamiriyoni emadhora akashandiswa kutenga 'nhau' muhukuru. zuva nezuva uye zviteshi zveterevhizheni. Mapato makuru nevamiriri vanodarika miganho yekushandisa poll kakawanda pamusoro pemutengo mumwe chete uyu. Yakanga iri uye inoramba iri nzira yekusvotwa yehuori. Sekutaura kweMutevedzeri weMutungamiriri Hamid Ansari, nhau dzakabhadharwa hadzingogadzirisi hwaro hwenhau dzakanaka uye dzakadzikama, dzinokanganisa maitiro esarudzo nenzira yakadzama.
Hasha dzakakura pamusoro pepfungwa yekuti vezvenhau vanoita semakororo - iro izwi iro rakashandiswa nevazhinji kutsanangura maitiro e "nhau dzakabhadharwa" munguva yekupedzisira yeLok Sabha sarudzo. Chokwadi, vashoma vezvematongerwo enyika vakanyunyuta nezvazvo mumashoko iwayo. Boka rezvematongerwo enyika harina, sekufunga kunoita vamwe, kubuda uye 'kunyengedza' vezvenhau. Vezvenhau vakabuda vakatsvaga 'zvibvumirano zvepackage' kwavari izvo zvakavapa mazakwatira emari - kana kuti vakangovharwa kunze kwekuvhara bepa kana chiteshi. Iwo 'kutengesa' mapoinzi aive: neiyi nzira, unogona kushandisa yakawanda sezvaunoda uye kwete kubatwa neElection Commission yeIndia yekuseka muganho wekushandisa. Nenzira iyi, unokwanisa kuendesa mushandirapamwe wako kumamiriyoni evavhoti - (kumamiriyoni emadhora). Iwe unogona zvakare kuita kuti mudzvanyiriri wako avharwe kunze - kana kuraswa, kana iwe ukabhadhara icho chidiki chekuwedzera. Uye isu kana iwe kana isu hatikwezve kugogodza kwemuteresi pane iyi-yese-mari kutengeserana.
Nekuita nekuchimbidza panguva iyoyo, Press Council yeIndia suo motu yakamisa komiti diki kuti iongorore chiitiko chenhau dzakabhadharwa. Nhengo mbiri dzekomiti diki yeParanjoy Guha Thakurta naK. Sreenivas Reddy yakaburitsa mushumo wairwadza, uyo waiona zvese tsika netsika zvaungade pachiitiko chakadaro. Yakanga isina kana fungidziro imwechete isina kupihwa zvizere. Hazvina kutora mukana we "sting" journalism, kuenda kunobvunzurudza zvakakwana pane kudaro. Izvo hazvina kushanda nesimba kuwana mhinduro dzemapoka anopomerwa kutamba mutambo wenhau unobhadharwa. Kuisa mhosva pamberi pavo, zvakavapa kodzero yakakwana ye - uye nzvimbo yeku - kupindura. Yakarekodha depositions kubva kuvanhu vakawanda. Mune chimwe chiitiko, rimwe sangano renhau rakakumbira ruregerero nokuda kwezvarakaita. Mune imwe, mumiriri kubva kuAndhra Pradesh akaisa rekodhi mhedzisiro yeyake 'sting' kurwisa boka guru renhau. Zvimwe zvezvinyorwa izvi zvaive muchimiro chezvinyorwa.
Iyo diki-komiti inowana kutaurwa kwenguva pfupi mu 'yekupedzisira' mushumo. Nhamburiko yayo yakatanhamara inomira yakaderedzwa kusvika kumashoko omuzasi (hungu, mashoko omuzasi) mumushumo iwoyo. Chinyorwa chepasi chinoti chirevo chekomiti diki "chinogona kuramba chiri parekodhi yeKanzuru segwaro rereferenzi." Izvo ndizvo. Inoenda kune archive. Iko hakuna chiratidzo cheichi "reference gwaro" pawebhusaiti yePress Council. Iyi ndiyo chiyero iyo PCI inoseta yeIndia media?
Uye saka komiti "yakazara" yekunyora yakatanga kushanda pamushumo 'wekupedzisira'. Kwemwedzi yakati wandei kubva pakarova fan, dzimwe nhengo dzePCI - kunyanya idzo dzinomiririra varidzi venhau - dzakashanda kuputsa chirevo chepakutanga.
Vaive nenyaya mbiri huru nazvo. Kutanga: Sei mazita emazita? Sei uchipinda mukushata kweizvozvo? Izvi, panguva iyo vezvenhau vari kuda mazita neropa pamusoro pehuwori huri muCommonwealth Games chitsotsi. Saka isu tava nembiri yemhando. Kuratidzwa kwehuori muMitambo, kuvanzika kwayo mukati menhau. Chechipiri: vakapokana nehasha chero kutaurwa kweWorking Journalists Act. Mune izvi, vakaita sevaridzi nevashandirwi, kwete senhengo dzePCI vachichengetedza kutendeseka kwenhau uye zviyero zvayo.
Nyaya mbiri idzi dzakabviswa zvisina tsitsi kubva mushumo 'yekupedzisira'. Uye imwezve yakavharwa. Saka chekutanga, hapana kana zita rimwechete remumwe wevapari vemhosva vanozivikanwa. Vashandi venhau dzakabhadharwa vanoenda pasina kuburitswa pachena.
Chechipiri: zvese zvinongedzo kuThe Working Journalists Act zvakadzimwa. Izvi, zvisinei nekuti kukanganiswa kwemutemo uyu nekushandiswa kwekondirakiti yebasa kwakabatsira zvikuru mukumisa kusununguka kwevatori venhau, zvichivamanikidza kuti vatore danho rekutungamira. Zvekare, zvakaderedzwa kusvika kuzasi - imwe chete imwe mumushumo. Izvi zvinoti: โRakarongawo kuti nyaya yekusimbaradza mutemo weWorking Journalists Act itorwe zvakasiyana.
Chechitatu, hurongwa hwe 'private treaties' hunorambwa mumitsara miviri. Usambofa wakarangarira basa ravo mukugadzirisa danho renhau dzakabhadharwa. Imwe yemitsara iyi inongoti izvi "zvakaziviswa" nePCI neSecurities Exchange Board yeIndia (SEBI). Zvibvumirano Zvepachivande yaive nyaya yekurukurirano kare SEBI isati yanyora tsamba yakanaka kuPCI (ona The Hindu June 19, 2010). Chokwadi, iyo SEBI tsamba yaifanira kunge iri yekuwedzera kune mushumo?
Vanyori vegwaro rekomiti diki vaive nechido chekuti basa ravo rinoshamisa ribatanidzwe sechikamu che'kupedzisira.' Zvisinei pfungwa isinganzwisisike, zvirinani nenzira iyoyo yaigona kuona chiedza chezuva. Asi kunyange izvozvo zvakabviswa.
Misiyano pakati pechinyorwa chizere chekomiti diki uye 'yekupedzisira' yePress Council yakawanda. Yekutanga (36,000 mazwi) yakavakirwa pakuferefeta kunorwadza, kubvunza, kutsvagisa, kubvunzurudza uye kuisa. Yechipiri (isingasviki mazwi e3600) yaive yakavakirwa pamhepo inopisa - zvishoma pane basa reboka revanhu vachibvisa kubvunza kwavasina kushanda uye vaisada. Chero chipi zvacho chainacho chakatorwa kubva kune chepakutanga, semuenzaniso chikamu chezvikumbiro. Zvimwe zvacho ishanduro yakadiridzwa zvakanyanya, yakadimburwa zvisina kunaka yechinhu chaicho. Zvakatoipisisa, censorship iyi inotakura chiseko chemubereko unopokana: kuvanza mazita uye zvitupa zvevanonyanya kushandisa nhau dzakabhadharwa kubva kuruzhinji. Saka boka rakapihwa "Kuchengetedza rusununguko rweVatori venhau nekuvandudza mwero wenhau muIndia" rakaisa mwero unotyisa. Muchengetedzi werusununguko rwenhau anomira semuongorori wezvechokwadi wenhau. Yakaita zvishoma se "watchdog yevatori venhau" iyo inoshevedzera vavariro dzayo], uye zvakanyanya senge lapdog yevaridzi venhau vane simba vakamira kuti vaburitswe neshumo yekomiti yavo diki. Chokwadi, chiratidzo chekutanga chekuita kwePCI kune iwo masimba ane simba: usazvinetse, wakachengeteka. Takagadzirisa izvozvo.
Kutaura: isu hatina kudzvanyirira chirevo chekomiti diki, takangochisiya kudura redu kuitira kuti tiwedzere kunyomba kune kukuvara. Kurumbidza vanyori vepakutanga (sezvakaitika mumusangano wavo waChikunguru 30) nokuda kwekuedza kwavo uye ipapo kuguma kwechigumisiro chebasa rekupayona, kwaiva unyengeri hwepamusoro. Kuti ndiratidze zvakasara zvakasara segwara rekurwisa kuvharwa kwenhau dzakabhadharwa kunyangwe iwo mabhenji ekusavimbika. Veruzhinji chokwadi vanokodzera zviri nani.
Izvo zvinyorwa uye nzira dzaive dzisiri chikamu chebhizinesi rakashata re 'nhau dzakabhadharwa' dzinofanirwa kuita. Kutanga, vanogona kuisa 'referensi' gwaro pamawebhusaiti avo vodaidza veruzhinji kuti vatarise kwazviri nemisoro, kwete zvinyorwa zvepasi.
P. Sainath ndiye mupepeti wenhau dzekumaruwa weThe Hindu, panowanikwa chidimbu ichi, uye ndiye munyori we Wese Munhu Anoda Kusanaya Kwakanaka: Nhau Dzinobva kuIndia's Poorest Districts. Anogona kuwanikwa pa: [email inodzivirirwa]
ZNetwork inopihwa mari chete kuburikidza nerupo rwevaverengi vayo.
dhoneta