Mafambiro edu ekuchinja magariro akabatsirikana zvakanyanya kubva kubasa raNoam Chomsky. Simba rinoshamisa raanounza pakutaura nekunyora kwake zvinoreva kuti mamirioni akaoneswa ongororo yake yeUS yekune dzimwe nyika uye yepasi mutemo. Asi ane chimwe chinhu chaanofarira chekutaura chinogara chichindishungurudza. Anoratidza kuti chimwe chinhu chiri pachena. Zvichida haazivi kuti izvi zvinoisa vanhu vakawanda sei pakudzivirira. Mumwe haagone kubatsira asi kushamisika, "Asi ko kana zvisiri pachena kwandiri?"
Kana Chomsky achiona chimwe chinhu sechave pachena, asi ini ndichinetsekana nazvo, zvinoreva here kuti ndiri benzi? Somuenzaniso, tora mubvunzo waanobvunzwa panopera hurukuro imwe neimwe. Anoti anonyorerwa tsamba pamusoro pazvo zuva nezuva. Pandakashanda kuSouth End Press mu1980s, taimukumbira kuti abatanidze chimwe chinhu pamusoro pazvo pakupera kwekushora kwake kwenguva refu kwemutemo wehumambo hweUS muCentral America neMiddle East. Kana iwe ukaenda kumabhuku aya, uchawana, mushure memazana mazana matanhatu emapeji ekuongorora, ndima pfupi pamusoro pezvandiri kutaura nezvazvo.
Ndiwo mubvunzo weizvo vanhu vanogona kuita.
Uye Chomsky anofunga kuti zviri pachena. Mubvunzurudzo naDavid Barsamian mumagazini yaMay 2004 yeProgressive, anoti, โChokwadi ndechekuti, tinogona kuita chero chinhu. Hapana kuoma, kupi zvako kwaunenge uri, mukuwana mapoka ari kushanda nesimba pazvinhu zvine chokuita newe.โ
Kune rimwe divi, ari kutaura chokwadi. Hapana imwe nzira yekubatana nemapoka, izvo zvandinotora kureva kuronga. Uye pamazuva angu ane tariro, ndinofunga kuti zvechokwadi dambudziko nderekuti vanhu vazhinji havanzwisise chokwadi ichi chiri pachena. Vanofunga kuti kudzidzisa vana kugovana uye kunyima vanakomana vavo pfuti dzematoyi ibasa rezvematongerwo enyika. Vanofunga kuti kuzvipira panzvimbo yekuvanda uye kuita โzviito zvemutsa zvisina tsarukanoโ zvichaunza shanduko munharaunda. Ivo vanofunga kuti kupfeka hemp uye kuchovha mabhasikoro avo kune chikafu co-op kunogona kubatsira kuvaka nyika iri nani.
Kana vanhu vazhinji vachifunga izvi, uye isu tinokwanisa kusvika kwavari nekuvapwisa kuti shanduko yemagariro haizouyi nekungojairika uye kwemunhu - kana chiri icho chidimbu chiri kuvadzivisa kubva pakuronga chaiko - saka isu tine rombo rakanaka. . Basa redu rakananga. Isu tinongofanirwa kuita saChomsky tofamba tichiudza vanhu kuti vabatikane, nzira yakajeka, ruzhinji rwemasangano ekubatana kana kugadzira ari pachena.
Asi zvinondirwadza kuti handizvo zviri kudzosera vanhu kumashure. Zvinondibaya mwoyo kuti hazvisi pachena zvatinofanira kuita, uye kuti nekutaura kuti ndizvo, tinoisa panjodzi yekuita kuti vanhu vanzwe mapenzi, asi ivo vakanyatso kubvunza mubvunzo, "Ndoitei?"
Ndave ndichiziva zvematongerwo enyika uye ndichishanda kwemakore makumi maviri nemashanu uye zvakadaro ndichiri kunetseka nezve izvo chaizvo zvandinofanira kuita. Heano mamwe ematambudziko anoita kuti kuita shanduko yemagariro kusashande pane kuoneka.
Dambudziko reChikamu
Iri ndiro dambudziko rinouya kubva pakushanda munyika umo kusarongeka kunonzwa sekunge kusingayekwe pane chero chikero chingafungidzirwa. Iri ndiro dambudziko rinokutungamirira kuti ufunge, "Kutyisa kwemitemo yehumambo hweUS yakakura kwazvo, hapana chandingaite kuti ndiite mutsauko mavari." Kana iwe uchinzwisisa mashandiro anoita muchina wemauto eUS, unotanga kufunga nezvawo sechikara chihombe, chinokwanisa kutsakatisa vanhu vazhinji nekungofemera mukati nekubuda. Nzara dzayo dzakapinza dzinokonzera nyonganyonga mukuzvitarisira kwayo. Chiito chisingafungi, chakadai seswish yemuswe, chinosunungura kurasikirwa kunotyisa kwevanhu uye kuparadza kwezvakatipoteredza.
Chikara chinotyisa uye chine simba, uye semugari wechikara ichi unoshamisika zvaunofanira kuita. Iwe unotarisa-tarisa kuti uone zviri kuitwa nevamwe vagari nezvazvo. Iwe wakanzwa Chomsky achitaura, shure kwezvose, saka iwe unoziva kuti unofanira kuenda kujoina sangano.
Asi iwe uri mudiki kana uchienzaniswa nehukuru hwechikara. Hapana kana chikero chinogona kuyera iwe nemhuka. "Kujoinha sangano" kunoratidzika sekufunga kwemashiripiti, uye wakazvisiya pawaive nemakore matanhatu.
Iwe unofunga iwe pachako, kwete zvisina musoro, "Hapana chiito chandinogona kutora - kunyangwe nhevedzano yezviito, kunyangwe hupenyu hwese hwezviito - izvo zvinogona kuve chero mutambo webasa riripo." Ndiro dambudziko rehuwandu.
Dambudziko rehurongwa
Asi pamwe unosarudza kuve muratidziri zvakadaro. Chikara chakagadzirwa nemunhu. Kana isu takagadzira chinhu ichi, isu tinofanira kukwanisa kuchibvisa. Zvichida iwe uri kukanganisa, kwete pamusoro pekuti iwe uri muduku sei maererano nechikara (nokuti hapana kuchinja ikoko), asi mukuongorora kwako kuti une simba rakawanda sei kana kuti ungave uine, kunyanya kana iwe uchibatana nevamwe.
Saka unotanga kutarisa-tarisa. Vagari vemo vave vachinzvera kuti chikara chinoshanda sei, uye vanocherekedza pachinotambanudza nzwara dzacho, chinokuvadza vanhu, chinovauraya, chinovadzinga, chinovasiya vasingakwanisi kunyange kurarama. Iwe unoona kuti mapoka akasiyana-siyana ari kushanda nesimba kuunganidza vanhu vashoma vashoma kuti vawane zviwanikwa pamwechete kuti vacheke chigunwe chimwe chechikara chedu chine makuhwa mazhinji. Izvi zvaizorerutsa marwadzo nekutambura kwevanhu vanosangana nembara.
Zvinoita sezvine musoro kuita chiitiko ichi uchipihwa hukasha hwenhengo yakasungirirwa zvipikiri, asi iwe uri munhu uye unoona vanhu vachizobatsirikana zvishoma nediki diki nzwara, saka unosuduruka kuti ubatanidze kuedza. .
Asi, mira, vanhu vari kurwira kuti ndechipi chigunwe chingave chakanakisa kucheka uye sezvo vasingabvumirane, vakaparadzana uye vava kukwikwidza zviwanikwa zvekucheka zvigunwe. Wakanga usina chokwadi pekutanga nezvekuti kucheka kwezvigunwe kungave kwakanaka here, kunyanya sezvo muswe uchinyungudika, uye kubuda kwemhepo kunoenderera mberi kusingadzoreki, asi ikozvino unoona kuti pamwe haungaite kuchekerera zvigunwe sezvo paine. kusawirirana kwakawanda pamusoro pechigunwe chekugadzirisa.
Zvichakadaro, vamwe vari kuyedza kugadzira midziyo yekutakura muswe. Vamwewo vari kuyedza kugadzira mishonga yekufema mweya unouraya. Vamwe vakawana kuti kutenderera kweropa rechikara kunongoerekana kwakonzera kuti vanhu vabirwe uye vazvidzwe. Vari kukurudzira vanhu kupingudza chikara nenzira yekuti masisitimu acho anogona kupedzisira abviswa otsiviwa, asi havatauri kuti sei kana kuti nei.
Saka kunyange kana iwe ukakunda dambudziko rehuwandu, uye uchizvivimbisa kuti zvinokwanisika kukunda chikara, iwe unopinda munyika yevanoshandura shanduko yevanhu vose vari kushanda nenzira isina kurongeka pazvikamu zvakasiyana zvemuviri wechikara. Vanhu havatombotaudzane, kunze kwekunge vazodhumana vakamira mumutsara pahofisi yemubatsiri vakamirira kuwana modicum yavo yezvigunwe zvekukwenya zvigunwe. Unoziva kuti kune demo kumwe kuno kurumidza kuita basa rechigunwe - pamwe chigunwe chose! โ asi izvo zvinoda kuronga nekudzidziswa kushandisa demo. Ah zvakanaka. Ndiro dambudziko remazano.
Dambudziko rekuona
Asi unoona kuti zvinokwanisika kukunda dambudziko remazano. Iwe wakadzidza mafambiro emagariro uye wakaona kuti vanhu vakagadzira zvirongwa zvenguva refu uye vakahwina budiriro mumakore ekushanda nesimba. Iwe unoziva nezvevamwe vanoda kufunga uye kuita zvine hungwaru. Zvisinei, zvinosvika pauri, kuti kuti uve nehurongwa, unofanirwa kuziva zvauri kuedza kuita pakupedzisira. Paunotanga kukurukura nemubvunzo uyu nevanhu, unoona kuti chimwe chezvikonzero zvinoita kuti vanhu vasaronge mabatirwo edemo inyaya yekuti vanotya kuti vakarishandisa, chikara chinogona kuwira pasi.
"Tarisa uone, handizvo here?" unobvunza. Sezviri pachena kwete. Zvimwe kwete kuvanhu vose avo, vangave vachizviziva kana kuti kwete, vanorarama negadziriro chaidzo mukudzivirira chikara ichi. Vanofarira nzwara dzakapfava - pamwe kunyange chikara chakazara-chakazara - nekuti kukwenya kwakananga kunonyangadza uye mhere-mhere yainokonzera kunokanganisa. Vanhu ava vanotsamira pachikara kune dzimwe ropafadzo.
Vanoda kuti kufema kwayo uye kutenderera kwayo uye simba remakumbo nemakumbo zvirambe zvakatsiga, asi vanoda kuti migumisiro ine ropa yakawanda yezviito zvayo idzikamiswe. Iwe unoona nekutya kuti vamwe vevabatsiri vako vakanyanya kukosha mubasa re-de-clawing, avo vanopa mari purojekiti yako uye dzimwe nguva vanokupa 0.3 masekondi panguva yekutanga havasi vatsigiri zvachose kana zvasvika kune chiono chako chenyika iri nani.
Kunze kwezvo iwe hauna chiono chenyika iri nani zvakadaro. Unonyatsoziva kuti โimwe nyika inobvira.โ Iwe wakanzwa masirogani sezvakangoita vamwe vese vanopikisa chikara. Asi kune dzinenge dzisina nzvimbo dzekuona kuti imwe nyika iyi ingaite sei, uye zvakaoma kufungidzira kushandisa nguva pairi zvakadaro. Nzara dzichiri kudambuka, muswe uri kukwidibira, uye mwoyo wechikara unoramba uchirovera.
Iwe unogona zvakare kudzokera kukucheka zvigunwe, izvo zvine mhedzisiro inooneka, inoderedza marwadzo chaiwo, uye inoita kuti unzwe sekunge uri kuita chimwe chinhu chakakosha. Iwe unozofanirwa kufuratira kushanda kwechokwadi kwechikara uye pamwe uchatanga kutenga mune retionalizations kuti chikara ndiwo wega mutambo muguta. Iwe hausi kuda kuita iyi tradeoff, asi hazvisi nyore here pane kutarisana nenyaya yekuti vaunofungidzirwa kuti vanobatana ndivo vanobatsirwa nemhuka? Kana ukasangana nevabatsiri ava, haungangovatsaure here, ukaisa mungozi kuwana kwako zviwanikwa, uchizvishora zvakanyanya, uye woisa panjodzi chero kucheka zvigunwe kungaenderera kana ukangovhara muromo wako?
Ngatiti iwe wakaoma musoro. Iwe unoita sarudzo yehungwaru yekubatana nemhuka-rationalizers sezvinodiwa, asi iwe zvakare unozotevera chiono chenyika iri nani nevamwe vane pfungwa dzakafanana-vanopesana nemhuka. Unofanira kudaro. Makore echiitiko akakudzidzisa kuti pasina chiratidzo, haugone kuve nehurongwa, uye pasina zano, haungasvike chero kupi.
Hauna kuziva, zvisinei, kuti urwu ndirwo rwendo rwune njodzi pane ese - rwendo rwunogona kutanga kusawirirana kwehasha uye kusawirirana pakati pevaratidziri vanonyanya kufanana. Wakaona kugumbuka kunoita vanhu kana vasingabvumirani kuti chigunwe chipi chekuisa mumharadzano, uye pano uri kukumbira vanhu kuti vauye nechiono chakagovaniswa chekutsiva mafambisirwo eropa nekufema kwechikara.
Unoyedzwa zvakanyanya kuti udzoke kubva pane zvese. Hazvina kukwana here kuti wakakunda dambudziko rechikamu uye wakaita chinhu chiri pachena - wakawana boka raive "richishanda nesimba pazvinhu zvine chekuita newe"?
Aiwa, unoona. Hazvina kukwana. Kana iwe wakanyatso kukoshesa kutora chikara, iwe unofanirwa kuita zvakawanda. Saka wakatarisana nedzimwe sarudzo dzakakosha (hapana imwe yadzo ine mhinduro dziri pachena) nezve mashandisiro uye kupi kwekushandisa simba rako, nezvehondo dzipi dzinonyanya kukosha, nezve kuvaka mubatanidzwa mumapoka akakura, nezve maitiro ekuita zano uye chiratidzo kunyangwe iwe. tora nhanho dzemucheche kurwisa zvakaipisisa zvinokonzerwa nezvikwambo.
Mukuongorora kwebhuku reBoston Globe (Kubvumbi 25, 2004), George Scialabba akadana Chomsky "mugari weAmerica anonyanya kubatsira." Ini handipokane. Akafumura kushanda kwechikara uye akatsanangura kushanda kwacho - zvikamu zvakakosha zvebhokisi rekushandisa remuratidziri wekuchinja kwemagariro. Asi ndinoshuva kuti arege kutaura kuti mapinduriro anoita munhu pachikara ichi zviri pachena. Kana tichifunga kuti zviri pachena, hatizozvigadziriri matambudziko, kunyanya matatu makuru akatsanangurwa pamusoro apa. Hatizo shanda. Uye isu hatizotanga kuvaka rudzi rwemafambiro anozove machisi echikara kunze kwekunge isu tatora matambudziko aya zvakanyanya toagadzirisa.
Kuti uwane rumwe ruzivo nezve chiono uye zano, ongorora iyo znet (www.zmag.org) webhusaiti yekutanga, kunyanya www.parecon.org.