Pansipa ndikuyankha kwanga ku mafunso a Michaels ndi (zotsutsa) zotsutsana. Mwina sizikuyankha mokwanira funso lomwe limabwerezedwa nthawi zambiri lokhudza p2p, mutu womwe ndingabwerere.
1.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"Mukunena kuti anzawo ndi "otsika" momwe "othandizira pa intaneti yofalitsidwa… amachita momasuka zinthu zomwe zimafanana" ndipo "mopanda chilolezo kuchitapo kanthu ndi maubale…. Kodi kalabu iliyonse ili ndi khalidweli? “
Kupanga anzawo ndikosavuta kukhazikitsa ndikuchita ngati mtengo wobereka ndi wocheperako. Izi zikuphatikizapo zomwe zili, mapulogalamu, mapangidwe. Koma ndikofunikira kwambiri kuti pasakhale kusefa kwa priori, mwachitsanzo, kuti simukuyenera kupempha chilolezo kuti muwonjezere chopereka chanu. M'manyuzipepala ambiri mwachitsanzo, mutha kulemba ngati mkonzi wanu wakufunsani kutero, ndipo ngati avomerezanso nkhani yanu. Mosiyana ndi izi, utolankhani wopangidwa ndi anzawo, ungavomereze zomwe mwapereka, ndipo umasefa kuti ukhale wopambana komanso wabwino "posteriori" pambuyo pake. Mabungwe ambiri a NGO mwachitsanzo, sangalole kupanga zinthu popanda chilolezo. Kotero izo zimadalira kwambiri malamulo a kalabu: 1) kodi aliyense angathe kutenga nawo mbali (kupanga kuti alowe nawo); 2) ndi njira ya kusefa nawo mbali ndi posteriori; 3) ndiye zotsatira zopezeka kwa onse popanda kupatula. Ngati zinthu zitatu zakwaniritsidwa, tilidi ndi anzathu.
2.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
“Ngati gulu lina likupanga zotuluka zomwe zimafunikira zolowa, liyenera kupeza zolowa. Ayenera kupeza ntchito. Anthu akanatha kunena kuti ayi. Zilolezo, mwinanso zogulira, zimakhudzidwa. Komanso, anzawo akuwoneka kuti akungopanga mabizinesi omwe alibe ndalama zambiri. Ndi choncho?”
Zolowetsazo ziyenera kukhala zotseguka komanso zaulere, ndipo mwachiwonekere, izi zimagwira ntchito pokhapokha ngati ndalama zoyankhulirana, kugwirizana, ndi kubereka zili zochepa, mwachitsanzo, m'dziko lopanga zinthu zopanda thupi. Koma chonde dziwani: zonse zomwe zimayenera kupangidwa mwakuthupi, motero zimafunikira njira zobwezera ndalama, zimakhala ndi gawo lokonzekera. Gawo lokonzekera ndilo 'losaoneka' (m'lingaliro lomwe timamvetsetsa), choncho, likhoza kupangidwa ndi anzawo. Chifukwa chake, zimakhala zosavuta kulingalira, ndipo izi zachitika kale (onani http://p2pfoundation.net/Product_Hacking) kuphatikiza njira yotseguka yopangidwira, ndi njira yosiyana yopangira thupi. Chifukwa chake mutha kuphatikiza izi 'mnzake kuti muyang'ane' (kapena mwa kuyankhula kwina, tanthauzo la Marx la chikominisi monga gawo lomaliza la mbiriyakale) mu gawo lokonzekera, ndi kunena, mgwirizano, pagawo lopanga.
Ngati muli ndi gawo lofananira ndi anzawo, ndiye kuti okonzawo amayamba kuganiza zopanga 'chinthucho' mosiyana kwambiri, m'njira zomwe zimayenderana, ndi zina zambiri… Zolinga za anzawo pakupanga mapangidwe, chifukwa amatsitsa mtengo wolowera pamakina akuthupi, ndikuthandizira kugawa ndi kugawa zofunika zazikulu, kubweza malingaliro a dongosolo lalikulu.
3.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"Ndikudabwa, ndi makhalidwe abwino ati omwe anzawo akuyesera kuwalanda? Kodi zopindula ndi zotani kuchokera ku zisankho? Ngati tingatchule zopindulazo, makamaka, kodi sitiyenera kuwona ngati tingakhale ndi phindu osati chifukwa cha zotsika mtengo komanso zodzipereka, komanso pazachuma zina zonse? ”
Peer to peer imaphatikiza kuthekera kwa aliyense kuti apereke zopereka zake mwachidwi (equipotentiality, onani http://p2pfoundation.net/Equipotentiality), kuti achite izi m'malo omwe safuna kuti anthu azilamulira, komanso kuti zotsatira zake zigawidwe mofanana ndi onse. Kupanga kotereku, chifukwa kumadalira zolimbikitsa kwambiri zomwe sizimakakamizidwa, zimatsogolera ku hyperproductivity, komanso kuyesetsa kukhala ndi khalidwe labwino, lomwe silingafanane ndi osewera amalonda okha omwe amadalira nzeru zotsekedwa. Nthawi zambiri, chifukwa cha nkhani yomwe mwalongosola bwino pamwambapa, mwachitsanzo, malingaliro osiyanasiyana okhudzana ndi kupanga zinthu zosaoneka ndi zinthu, malingaliro osakanizidwa ndi ogwirizana amawonekera kuphatikiza madera otseguka, osapindula ('opindulitsa') omwe amayang'anira zomangamanga. za mgwirizano, ndi chilengedwe cha mabizinesi omwe akupanga phindu lochepa pamsika.
4.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"Zikuwoneka kuti kuyitana mnzako wa projekiti kuti awone zomwe zatuluka kuyenera kupezeka paliponse koma sindikudziwa kuti zikutanthauza chiyani. Gulu lolemba zolemba ndikuziwonetsa popanda mtengo kwa owerenga zitha kuwoneka ngati zikugwirizana ndi zomwe muli nazo. Koma bwanji za gulu lopanga chakudya, titi, kapena violin, kapena china? Pazigawo ziwiri zingawoneke ngati zikulephera kukwaniritsa tanthauzo lanu. Choyamba, zinthuzo sizingakhale za aliyense, momveka bwino. Chachiwiri, zolowetsazo zikhala zokwera mtengo, kutanthauza zilolezo, kugula zinthu, ndi zina zotero. Kodi izi ndi zolondola?”
Inde, izi ndi zolondola. Kawirikawiri, monga m'mabwalo a dera la Arduino, kapena violin yanu yongoganizira, violin ingakhale malonda a msika, osinthanitsa ndi ndalama, koma mapangidwe ake adzakhalapo kwa onse, kotero kampani ina iliyonse ingakhalenso yaulere kuti ipange. Chimodzi mwazotsatira za izi ndikuwononga lendi ya monopoly pa kusowa kopanga.
5.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
Kodi makhalidwe abwino a anzanu omwe mumawakonda ndi ati? Komanso, kodi tingasunge zabwinozo ngakhale kupanga kumawononga ndalama zambiri ndikupanga zotuluka zomwe sizikhala zapadziko lonse lapansi? Ngati ndi choncho, zikanafunika chiyani? Ngati sichoncho, bwanji osatero?”
Monga tanena kale, kupanga anzawo kumangogwira ntchito yopanga zinthu zopanda thupi, koma kumatha kulumikizidwa ndi kupanga thupi. Momwemonso, magulu a anzawo ali olimba mokwanira kuti agwire ntchito ndi mabizinesi omwe ali pafupi kwambiri pamakhalidwe ndi machitidwe. Izi zikuchitika kale muzochita zosakanizidwa zomwe zilipo kale. Athanso kupanga zawo, monga ma coops, kapena mabizinesi olimbikitsidwa ndi parecon.
Pazinthu zina zolumikizidwa ndi p2p, onani:
- http://p2pfoundation.net/Holoptism
- http://p2pfoundation.net/Communal_Validation
6.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
Mumati "njira za anzawo zikuyamba kuchitika m'moyo wonse wa anthu," koma pokhapokha ngati ndikusowa chinachake ndikuwoneka kuti akhala nafe kwa zaka mazana ambiri - pokhapokha mutapangitsa kuti zinthu zikhale zovuta kwambiri. Ndikumvetsa kuti matekinoloje atsopano azambiri atsegula domeni yatsopano kuti igwirizane ndi anzawo - kupanga ndi kufalitsa zidziwitso - koma ukadaulo ndizomwe zikuwoneka zatsopano, osati zochita za anzawo - kudzipereka, kudzipereka, ndi zina zotero. Kodi ndikulakwitsa za izo?”
Ayi, mukulondola. P2P, kapena mwaukadaulo (onani http://p2pfoundation.net/Relational_Model_Typology_-_Fiske), kugawidwa kwamagulu, kwakhala kulipo, koma kunali kochepa mu nthawi ndi malo kumagulu ang'onoang'ono. Pokhapokha m'mene magulu ang'onoang'onowa angakhoze kusuntha kufika pamlingo wapadziko lonse lapansi kupyolera mu mgwirizano wapadziko lonse. Pazinthu zinayi zophatikizana za anthu ndi njira zopangira phindu (zina zitatuzo kukhala Kufanana Kufananiza = chuma champhatso; Kufananiza ndi Ulamuliro = Kugawika Kwamagawo; ndi Mitengo Yamsika = capitalism), ndi mtundu wokhawo womwe sunakhalepo wolamulira. Ndi kuthekera kwa intaneti, matekinoloje a anzawo, ndi zida zina zogawidwa, zosintha bwanji ndikuti sizingangopanga zinthu zovuta kwambiri zamagulu, koma zimatha kukhala njira yopangira zinthu zonse zomwe zimafanana, ndipo zitha kukhala lingaliro lalikulu la ndale zatsopano zachuma/chitukuko.
7.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"Pambuyo pa mawu oyamba a anzanu ndi anzanu, mumamveka bwino ndi zinthu zitatu. Kwa ine, komabe, mikhalidwe imatanthawuza kuti kuyanjana ndi anzawo ndi kupanga chinthu wamba, kokha. Ndichoncho chifukwa chiyani? Chifukwa chiyani mukufuna kuchepetsa chidwi chanu pakupanga zinthu zapagulu? Kodi ndizowona kuti kupanga zinthu zapagulu kokha kungaphatikizepo zabwino zonse - zilizonse zomwe zidalembedwapo - za anzawo? Bwanji osapanga mitundu yonse?”
Kuti tigwirizane ndi anzathu kuti tiwonjezeke kumitundu yonse yopanga, tifunika kuthana ndi vuto la kubweza mtengo pakupanga kwakuthupi. Izi mwina sizingakwaniritsidwe kwathunthu, kapena zingafune nthawi yayitali yosinthira. Choncho, njira yabwino ndiyo kuganizira za anzawo kuti ayang'ane pazachuma chochuluka. Tangoganizani kuti zatsopano ndi kulenga kumakhala nkhani yamagulu otseguka padziko lonse lapansi, ichi ndicho maziko a chilengedwe chamtengo wapatali; Pakatikati apa, muli ndi magulu, magulu a parecon, chuma champhatso, malonda achilungamo ndi misika yosakhala ya capitalist, ndi zina zotero… Kufikira momwe tingapangire zochulukira (misika yama capitalist ikupangidwa kuti ipangitse kusowa kochulukira), malingaliro ogwirizana ndi anzawo. za zopereka zaufulu ndi kupezeka kwa anthu onse kungathe kufalikira kumadera ambiri a anthu.
8.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"Kodi zowona kuti ogwira ntchito akuvomera kutenga nawo gawo mwakufuna kwawo (ngakhale atakhala movutikira) komanso kuti kampaniyo imatulutsa zidziwitso zomwe imaperekanso kwaulere - tinene kudzera patsamba lalikulu, kapena china - ngakhale amagulitsanso zotsatsa kuti azipereka ndalama zonse, kuti ayenerere kupanga anzawo?
Ngati ndalamazo zili zovomerezeka pakupanga, sizingafanane ndi anzanu, ngakhale zotsatira zake zimapezeka mwaulere. Mutha kukhala ndi ma commons ngati kutuluka, popanda p2p monga kulowetsa ndi kukonza. Ndipo mutha kukhala ndi zolowetsa za p2p, koma zotsatira zake zimakhala zongogulitsidwa. Choncho zikhalidwe 3 ziyenera kukwaniritsidwa. M'maphunziro a capitalist, ogwira ntchito sakhala omasuka kwenikweni malinga ndi makontrakitala antchito, chifukwa sangakhale ndi moyo popanda imodzi. Ndikofunikira kusiyanitsa njira ya commons yopanga anzawo, pomwe pali cholinga chimodzi, kuchokera kumasamba ogawana omwe ali ndi nsanja zamakampani. Pamenepa, muli ndi malingaliro apawiri: anthu omwe amapanga zinthu kuti zipezeke padziko lonse lapansi m'njira yokhudzana ndi p2p, pomwe makampani akugulitsa chidwi chambiri pamsika wotsatsa. Ndi mtundu wosakanizidwa, wothandizidwa ndi likulu. Izi zimapanga mtundu watsopano wa mikangano ya anthu, pakati pa chidwi cha anthu ammudzi, ndi chidwi cha nsanja. Koma chochititsa chidwi ndi mwayi waukulu wogawana nawo, ndikuti gawo lazachuma likusiya kudalira kwake pa Intellectual Protection. M'mbiri yakale, njira zopangira zangosintha, pamene panali kusintha kofanana kuchokera kumagulu opangira mtengo komanso makalasi ochotsera mtengo. Kuwonekera kwa netarchical capitalism, monga gawo la ndalama lomwe limathandizira ndikupatsa mphamvu 'kugawana' kuti lichitike' litha kuwoneka ngati chitukuko chabwino pang'ono.
9.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"Bwanji ngati gulu la opanga mapulogalamu apanga pulojekiti yoti apange pulogalamu yatsopano, yomwe idzapezeke kwaulere, ndi zina zotero. Amafuna maofesi, magetsi, mapulogalamu, makompyuta, ndipo amafunika kudya ndi kugona, ndi zina zotero. kuyeretsa malo awo antchito, kuwaphikira chakudya, kuwagulira. Amalipira makompyuta ndi kusamalira kwawo, magetsi, ndi zina zotero. Amapeza ndalama za zonsezi polemba antchito ena kuti apereke chithandizo chaukadaulo chomwe anthu amalipira. Kenako amagawana phindu lomwe limabwera pakati pawo, ndikulipira antchito anzawo. Kodi mnzawoyo ndi mnzake chifukwa akupanga zomwe akunena kuti zithandize anthu ndipo opanga mapulogalamuwo, akuchita izi modzilamulira okha (ngakhale akugwiritsanso ntchito akapolo olipidwa)?"
Chochitika chosangalatsa, ndipo chitha kuchitika. Ndizochitika zodziwika bwino ndi ma coops, omwe amalemba ganyu ogwira ntchito mgulu lachiwiri kuti apitilize kulumikizana ndi gulu loyamba lamwayi (Mondragon amabwera m'maganizo).
10.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"Zimakhala ngati anzawo akukhulupirira kuti pali cholakwika ndi kulipidwa kapena kupanga kuti anthu odzisankhira azigwiritsidwa ntchito ndi anthu ochepa, kapena ngati kuti zinthuzo zikachitika, sitingathe kukhala ndi ubale wabwino."
Monga tafotokozera pamwambapa, tikuyenera kuvutika kuti tipangitse anzathu kuti aziwoneka ngati gawo lodziwika bwino la moyo wa anthu, ndikuphatikiza madera otseguka ndi apadziko lonse lapansi / mapulogalamu / mapangidwe okhala ndi mitundu yazachuma yopanga zinthu zakuthupi, zomwe zimagwirizana kwambiri ndi zikhalidwe zake (zotseguka komanso zotseguka). zopereka zaulere, ndondomeko yogawana nawo, zotulukapo zomwe zimapezeka kawirikawiri). Kupanga zida zogawira zomwe zitha kuloleza kudziphatikiza kunja kwa ndalama ndi njira ina yowonjezera. Kulimbana ndi anthu pakupeza ndalama zoyambira, kapena njira zomwe zimalola anthu ambiri kuchoka pamsika, ndi zina.
11.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"Pafupifupi chilichonse chomwe chimapangidwa ndikugwiritsidwa ntchito popanga ndi chosowa m'lingaliro lenileni kuti chikadapanda kugwiritsidwa ntchito pazifukwa zomwe adasankha, bwenzi china chake chikadapangidwa nacho. Pali mtengo wa mwayi wogwira ntchito, chuma, zipangizo, nthawi, ndi zina zotero. Ichi ndi chowonadi chosatha m'moyo. Palibe kupeŵa gawo lomalizali koma kugawa chuma kuzinthu zina m'malo mwa zina kutha kuchitidwa molingana ndi mfundo zoyenera ndikuwunika zonse zokhudzana ndi chikhalidwe cha anthu komanso zachilengedwe, kapena zitha kuchitika kudzera munjira zomwe zimapondereza mfundo zoyenera ndikugwiritsa ntchito kuwerengera kolakwika ... kukhala ndi makhalidwe abwino amenewa padziko lonse, pa zachuma ndi m’madera onse, m’malo mongodzipereka popanga zinthu za boma.”
Ndikuvomerezana ndi inu kuti tiyenera kuwonjezera ubwino wa kumasuka, ufulu, kutenga nawo mbali, ubwino wamba, kufanana ndi zina. Monga mukunenera, kusowa kuli paliponse. Koma kusowa - kuchulukirachulukira kumapitilirabe, ndipo dongosolo lapano lili ndi mbuyo: likuwona kuti zinthu zomwe zimasoweka mwachilengedwe kukhala zopanda malire, ndipo zimafuna kuti zochuluka zikhale zosowa mwachilengedwe. Choncho tiyenera kubweza. Kuchuluka kochuluka kumapezeka m'dziko lopanga zinthu zopanda thupi, komwe p2p tsopano imachitika mwachilengedwe, chifukwa tili ndi malo ochezera. Tizisunga ndikuwonjezera. Kenaka, timachita zomwe tingathe kuti anthu athe kusonkhanitsa momasuka momwe angathere pazochitika zakuthupi, popanga zida zogawidwa. Ngati tili ndi mapangidwe otseguka, ndi mwayi wosavuta wopeza zinthu zazikulu, titha kupanga chuma chamgwirizano. Koma ili si funso laukadaulo chabe kapena lazachuma, koma funso landale. Chiyembekezo changa ndichakuti magulu a anzawo asintha kuchokera ku machitidwe ophwanya malamulo (mwachitsanzo, kugawana mafayilo), kupita kumayendedwe olimbikitsa (kunena za General Public License), kupita ku machitidwe omwe amatsutsa kukhazikitsidwa kwa mabungwe omwe alipo komanso chuma chandale.
12.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"Kupitilira apo," njira zopangira nawo zosagwirizana nazo" zimamveka bwino, koma sindikudziwa zomwe zikutanthauza. Ngati tili ndi chipatala kapena gulu lazaumoyo, kapenanso gulu lopanga mapulogalamu, ndiye kuti sizosapatula chifukwa munthu ayenera kukwaniritsa miyezo ina kuti atenge nawo mbali, ayi?
Ngati mumalipidwa molingana ndi zomwe mumapanga, tilibe zopereka modzifunira zomwe simukubweza chifukwa chake palibe mnzako wina aliyense. Ngati wina wakulembani ntchito, palibe mnzake wofanana naye.
13.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"Chomwe ndikudabwa ndichifukwa chiyani mumamva kuti anzanu ndi anzanu amalimbikitsa mgwirizano womwe mukufuna kwa onse."
Sindikuganiza kuti kuchita nawo unzanga kumapangitsa kuti anthu azikhala ndi chidwi chogwirizana ndi anthu onse, koma ndikuganiza kuti chifukwa p2p imaphatikizapo makhalidwe apamwamba kwambiri, choncho imatha kukopa anthu kumbali imeneyo. Chifukwa chake ndikuganiza kuti ndizosangalatsa zandale kuchita nawo opanga anzawo m'njira yotere, kuti agwiritse ntchito chikhumbo chawo chachilengedwe chakuchita nawo p2p, ndi chikhumbo chokulirapo cha anthu omwe angawonjezere kuthekera kwawo ndikupanga mgwirizano pakati pa anthu onse.
14.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"Mukanena kuti kusintha kwa chikhalidwe cha anthu kumafuna "gawo lokulirapo la dongosolo lolamulira lomwe likupita kunjira yatsopano" ndimaganiza kuti ndizopanda tanthauzo, komabe zimandikhudzanso. Olamulira onse akale amakhalapo m'dongosolo latsopano, motero ayenera kufotokozera momveka bwino kuti azitha kugwira ntchito molingana ndi zikhalidwe za dongosolo latsopanoli. Izi ndi zoona, sichoncho? Koma mukamanena kuti zikuchitika ndi anzanga tsopano, ndili ndi nkhawa ndi izi - chifukwa zolinga za osankhidwa akale zimakhalabe za capitalist ndikuwongolera kufunitsitsa kwawo kugwiritsa ntchito anzawo anzawo. ”
Ndikumvetsa nkhawa, koma ndicho chenicheni cha gulu la anthu, kuti magulu osiyanasiyana amateteza chidwi chawo choyamba. Chifukwa chake, pamene magulu omwe amapanga anzawo akufuna kukulitsa kukhazikika kwawo ndi kuthekera kwawo, momwemonso ndalama zimafuna kupindula nazo. Zochitika zakale zimatiwonetsa kuti dongosolo lakale likuyamba kufunafuna kugwiritsa ntchito njira yatsopano kulimbikitsa malingaliro ake, zomangamanga ndi mabungwe, pomwe pamapeto pake zikugonjetsedwa. Umu ndi momwe kusinthako kudachitikira kuchoka ku ukapolo kupita ku serfdom, komanso kuchoka ku feudalism kupita ku capitalism, ndipo chifukwa chake ndikuyembekeza kuti njira yomweyo igwire ntchito pakusintha kwa anzawo kupita kugulu la anzawo. Mwachiwonekere, komwe ndimachokera, ndipo ntchito ya P2P Foundation idaperekedwa kwa izo, ndikupititsa patsogolo njira yopita ku chitsanzo chimodzi. Komabe, zilinso choncho kuti netarchical capital imachita zinthu zingapo zomwe zili ndi chidwi chathu, kotero kuti onse akhoza kukhala ogwirizana nawo komanso adani ena. Google ndi chitsanzo chabwino. Ikamenyera nkhondo yowonekera ku Congress, imagwirizana, ikamagwiritsa ntchito molakwika zidziwitso zathu, ndi mdani. Kutsamira kwa anzawo olimbikitsa anzawo kudzakhala pamaudindo ambiri. Anthu ngati Lawrence Lessig amasangalala ndi chuma chaufulu mwachitsanzo, ndipo anthu monga Yochai Benkler, amawona kupanga anzawo monga chothandizira pamsika. Ndikuwona ngati njira ina, 'yosapeŵeka' yomwe iyenera kumenyedwa.
15.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"Kufooka kwa zomwe zimatchedwa sosholizimu, kapena sosholizimu yazaka za zana la 20, kapena zomwe ndimakonda kuzitcha kuti coordinatorism, sizinali mphamvu zake zopanda phindu - ndipo kuyambira liti kukulitsa zotulukapo zathu pakuweruza magulu, mulimonse momwe zingakhalire. otsika pa mbali imeneyo - koma, m'malo mwake, bungwe lake la chikhalidwe cha anthu, utsogoleri wa magulu, ulamuliro wa authoritarianism, ndi zina zotero. Ndikuganiza kuti timavomereza zimenezo."
Kupanga anzawo kumakhala kopindulitsa kwambiri osati kungopanga, koma ndale potengera nawo gawo ndi demokalase, komanso kupezeka kwapadziko lonse lapansi. Socialism ‘yokhalapodi’ inali yaulamuliro ndipo inali ndi kagawidwe kosiyana. Monga m’malo mwa kupanga, sichinatsimikizike kukhala chaphindu m’kupita kwa nthaŵi, pamene ukapitalist unatsimikizira kukhala wogwirizana ndi mitundu ina yoŵerengeka ya demokalase. Koma P2P imasungabe zokolola zambiri, imayambitsa demokalase pakupanga ndi mbali zonse za moyo wa anthu, ndikulola aliyense kuti apindule ndi zomwe akwaniritsa.
16.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"N'chifukwa chiyani kulimbikitsa zomwe zimati ndi njira yaumunthu yosiyana ndi capitalism monga njira yotsitsimutsa dongosolo la capitalist loyipa kwambiri? Koma zochulukira, ndikuyesera kuwona momwe anzanga amalozera ku "mgwirizano" watsopano m'maso mwanu, kapena m'maso mwa omwe amawulimbikitsa, ndipo ndili ndi vuto ndi izi. Kwa ine, ndikuganiza kuti zingatheke - mwachitsanzo powonetsa ngati gawo la chikhalidwe chake ndikuyang'ana kukhudzika kwa kudziwongolera komanso kusakhala m'gulu, komanso kukambirana mothandizana pakugawa, malipiro ofanana, ndi zina zotero. "
Ndiye kachiwiri, ndikudabwa kuti ndi chiyani?"
Inu ndi ine titha kupeza kuti capitalism ndi 'yoyipa kwambiri' (ndiyenera kuti ndiyenerere mawuwo, koma tiyeni tidutse mpaka pano), koma anthu ambiri padziko lapansi sagwirizana, ndipo zaka mazana awiri zolankhula komanso zolimbana ndi anthu sizinakhalepo " t ndinathetsa izo. (Sindimakhulupiriranso kuti kusowa m'kalasi ndizotheka kwenikweni muzochitika za zolinga kapena kusowa komwe kumaganiziridwa.) Kotero maganizo anga ndi awa: pamene tikuwona njira za post-capitalist zikukwera, timazikulitsa bwanji momwe tingathere. Ine sindiri ndi chidwi ngakhale pang'ono pa mawu odana ndi capitallist, kokha pa zochita zomwe zimatilola kupyola kupanga katundu. Pachifukwa ichi, timalimbitsa madera omwe akupanga anzawo, timamanga mabungwe athu, timachita zomwe tingathe kulimbikitsa zida zogawidwa m'dera lililonse lomwe tingathe, ndikupanga gulu lachitukuko lomwe lingateteze bwino zomwe timachita, ndipo mwachiyembekezo tsiku lina, tidzachotsa mabungwe oletsa.
17.
Michael Albert analemba kuti:
"Ndikuopa kuti ngakhale mukunyalanyaza mbali zazikulu za moyo wachuma - malipiro, kupanga zisankho, kugawa kwa ogwira ntchito, ndi kugawa - palibe amene angayang'ane nawo maadiresi omwe alipo - pamene mukunena kuti amapereka chitsanzo cha tsogolo labwino. ”
sindikuwanyalanyaza konse. M'gawo lake lachipambano, kupanga anzawo kwathetsa bwino njira zopangira zisankho (ulamuliro wa anzawo), m'malo mwa magawo a anthu ogwira ntchito, pogawa anthu ogwira ntchito, komanso kugawa kwamagulu / msika podziphatikiza zokha zopangira zopindulitsa. Komabe, tilibe njira yothetsera malipiro opanda malire. Pakupanga kwakuthupi, ndiwo omwe amadetsa nkhawa kwambiri ndipo ndimakhala nthawi zonse, pamodzi ndi gulu la akatswiri / ofufuza / omenyera ufulu wa P2P Foundation, ndikuwona momwe magulu opanga anzawo akupangira mayankho okhazikika m'gawoli.
18.
Michel Albert analemba kuti:
"Mukanena kuti "kupanga anzawo ndi mwayi waukulu kwa ogwira ntchito, kupanga mgwirizano wamphamvu, ndikukakamiza mabizinesi awo kusintha zinthu, pomwe palibe chomwe chimawalepheretsa kupanga zopanga zawo, monga ma cooperatives a parecon" zili choncho molingana ndi zomwe tazitchula pamwambapa, koma kodi sizingakhale zokakamiza kwambiri ngati anzawo onse ogwira nawo ntchito komanso olimbikitsa anzawo amavomereza izi, motero amayesa mosalekeza kulemeretsa zolankhula za anzawo ndikuchita mozindikira kuchokera kumalingaliro amtundu wa anthu? Kodi iwo?”
Ayi, satero, ndikanakonda akanatero. Ndipo ndikugwira ntchito. Kodi mungatani?
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama