"Chofunika kwambiri paufulu wotetezedwa ndi dongosolo lathu la Anglo-Saxon la maulamuliro olekanitsidwa kwakhala kumasuka kundende yosatha malinga ndi chifuniro cha Executive." Woweruza Antonin Scalia
Zotsatira za mlandu wa Padilla zimabweretsa "chiwopsezo chapadera komanso chomwe sichinachitikepo ku ufulu wa nzika iliyonse ya ku America… Pachiwopsezo sichinthu chocheperako kuposa chikhalidwe chaufulu… sichiyenera kugwiritsa ntchito zida za olamulira ankhanza ngakhale kukana kuukiridwa ndi mphamvu zankhanza.” Woweruza John Paul Stevens
Pokana kumvetsera mlandu wa Padilla Khoti Lalikulu Kwambiri linadzudzula munthu wosalakwa kuti apitirize kutsekeredwa m’ndende popanda mpata uliwonse wotsutsa zimene akanakhala m’ndende. Kukana kwawo kumakhala ngati chigamulo chotsimikizirika ndipo kumathetsa mfundo ya nthawi yaitali ya "wosalakwa kufikira atatsimikiziridwa kuti ndi wolakwa."
Kuonjezera apo, chigamulo chawo chikulimbitsa udindo wosokoneza wa Bush Administration kuti akaidi omwe ali mu nkhondo ya apocryphal on terrater atha kutumizidwa ngati "ankhondo osaloledwa"; zolankhula zabodza zomwe zilibe tanthauzo lililonse lalamulo.
Miyezi yambiri m'mbuyomo, Khoti Lachiwiri la Apilo linachotsa gulu lopanda pake lomwe linapangidwa ndi Bush Administration ndipo linagamula kuti Padilla amasulidwe nthawi yomweyo. Chigamulo chimenecho sichinanyalanyazidwe ndi akuluakulu a boma, ndipo mlanduwo unafika ku Khoti Lalikulu.
Tsopano "asanu ophwanya malamulo" atsimikizira udindo wa Purezidenti pokana kuweruza mlanduwu pazabwino zake. M’malo mwake, abweza mlanduwu kukhoti laling’ono kuti likaunikenso popanda kunena kuti Padilla wakhala akulandidwa ufulu wonse woti achitepo kanthu kwa zaka zoposa ziwiri.
Yankho lawo likhoza kutanthauzidwa ngati chigonjetso chathunthu kwa olamulira omwe (ngakhale sakanatha kupeza khoti kuti liwononge poyera Constitution) adapeza zotsatira zomwezo; "kutsekeredwa m'ndende kosatha" popanda njira iliyonse yotsutsa kutsekeredwa kwake.
Sizingatheke kufotokozera tanthauzo la mlandu wa Padilla. Ndi cholinga chilichonse, ndiye nkhani yofunika kwambiri m'mbiri ya khothi.
Chomwe chimapangitsa kukhala chodabwitsa kwambiri nchakuti, m’chenicheni chake, sichimangonena za “ufulu umene nzika zili nawo” kapena “komwe malamulowo ali” koma, “ngati nzika zili ndi ufulu nkomwe.”
Kumbukirani, Padilla sanalandidwe ufulu wapadera …Walandidwa maufulu ONSE. Mpaka pano, sanaimbidwe mlandu wopalamula; zongonena za nthawi ndi nthawi komanso tsankho zochokera ku Dipatimenti Yachilungamo yomwe yagwira ntchito molimbika kuti iwononge mlanduwo.
Bush akunena zosavomerezeka kuti atha kutaya zonse zotetezedwa ndi malamulo oyendetsera dziko komanso kumanga anthu omwe akuwakayikira mpaka kalekale mwakufuna kwake.
Ngati zili choncho, ndiye kuti “ufulu wosakanizidwa” ndi mphatso zanthawi yochepa chabe za boma zomwe zingathe kuchotsedwa mwachisangalalo cha Pulezidenti.
Awa ndiye malingaliro a Purezidenti pankhaniyi.
Ndi malingaliro omwe amagawidwa poyera ndi ambiri a khoti omwe avomereza izi mwa kusakhulupirika.
Uthenga wawo ndi womveka; sangateteze ngakhale mfundo zofunika kwambiri za malamulo oyendetsera dziko lino, koma adzasankha akuluakulu a boma kuti ndiye okhawo amene atha kuweruza chilungamo.
Sitirinso mtundu wa malamulo; mlandu wa Padilla ukutsimikizira zimenezo mokhutiritsa.
Panali machenjezo a izi kale m'mbiri ya Khotilo. Khothi lomweli linakana kulangiza Wachiwiri kwa Purezidenti Cheney kuti amasule mapepala a Energy Task Force kwa anthu. Zolemba izi zikanati ziwonetsere zakusintha kwamisika yamagetsi ku California, komanso kuwulula makampani amafuta a 60 omwe adagwirizana ndi Cheney pakugawa minda yamafuta ku Iraq, ndipo pamapeto pake, kutsogolera dzikolo kunkhondo.
Zomwe zili m'mapepalawa ndi zokomera anthu ndipo kukana kwa Khothi kukakamiza kuwulutsa kwawo kukuwonetsa kuzama kwa mlandu wawo.
Momwemonso, koma chochititsa chidwi kwambiri, ili ndi khoti lomwelo lomwe lidasokoneza ndondomeko ya demokalase pogwiritsa ntchito mawu onyoza a 14th Amendment kuti athetse chisankho cha 2000. Pogwiritsa ntchito chiganizo cha "chitetezo chofanana" kuti ayimitse kuwerengera mavoti ku Florida, khotilo linakhazikitsa mfundo zake zogawanika ndipo linasokoneza mfundo yoyambira boma la demokalase. (ufulu woti munthu awerengetse mavoti)
Pachifukwa ichi, mlandu wa Padilla umangomaliza ntchito yomwe inayamba kalekale; kugwetsa mabungwe odzilamulira okha. Pochotsa chitetezo chomwe chimateteza nzika ku zisankho za boma, khotilo limangowonjezera zipambano zake zokayikitsa.
"Kumangidwa popanda chifukwa" kumakhalabe chizindikiro chosatha cha nkhanza. (Pepani kwa Alexander Hamilton)
Kutsekeredwa kosalekeza kwa a Jose Padilla kumatsimikizira kuti Khothi Lalikulu lomwe lilipo tsopano likugwirizana ndi zolinga za ndale za Executive ndipo silingayembekezerenso kuteteza Constitution kapena kusunga malamulo.
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama