Gwero: Counterpunch
Palibe "Kumanzere" kwandale komwe kungakhalepo kapena kuyenera kukhala:
+ sangayende kapena sangayende ndi kutafuna chingamu pa nthawi imodzi.
+ amalephera kutsutsa mwatsatanetsatane komanso mosabisa utsogoleri wa United States waposachedwa wa fascist, kusankhana mitundu, eco-cidal, komanso sexist komanso maziko ake oyipa a ku America.
+ moganizira komanso nthawi zonse amayankha kutsutsa kulikonse kwaufulu ndi Kumanzere kwa Trump ponena kuti "koma / bwanji za Hillary" (ndi / kapena "koma / bwanji za Obama," "koma / bwanji za Pelosi," ndi "koma / bwanji za Schiff, โ ndi zina.
+ Nthawi zonse amakambitsirana ndi anzawo komanso otsalira enieni za zomwe timadziwa kale bwino: ma demokalase ankhanza, odetsedwa ndi dola, a neoliberal-imperialist ndi gulu lolamulira mozama komanso chipani cha imperialist.
+ amangoganiza kuti kutsutsa Trump ndikuthandizira ma Democrats ndi corporate-imperial "deep state".
+ sangathe kapena sangasiyanitse gulu logwirizana la ogwira ntchito odana ndi kusankhana mitundu / anti-Nativism / anti-sexism ndi ndale zachidziwitso cha bourgeois.
+ sangathe kapena sangasinthe zidziwitso za chikhalidwe cha anthu zomwe zikuwonetsa kuti maziko a Trump amalumikizidwa ndi kuphatikizika kwa tsankho loyera ndi zikhalidwe zaulamuliro, osati madandaulo azachuma a anthu ogwira ntchito.
+ imagwera m'nkhani yodziwika bwino yoti Trump ndi chida cha "antchito oyera".
+ akuganiza kuti wina atha kukhala Kumanzere ndikuthandizira a Donald Trump
+ amalephera kusiyanitsa mokwanira pakati pa a Trump ndi apurezidenti am'mbuyomu aku Republican.
Magulu akulimbana mkati mwa gulu lolamulira la America. Omwe amatchedwa othandizira aboma (ndiko kuti, olamulira olamulira / ochita masewera olimbitsa thupi mkati ndi pansi pa nyumba yamalamulo ndi masankho andale ndi mfundo zaku US) akhala akutsutsa Trump pazifukwa zomwe zikuwonetsa zokonda za anthu osankhika (kudalirana kwamakampani, kukhazikika kwazachuma / kulosera, kukhulupilika kwa ufumu ndi dziko ndi kuyika chizindikiro pakati pa zinthu zina) zomwe (monga omenyera "kumanzere" a Trump akulozera moyenera) zilibe kanthu kotsutsana ndi mfundo, demokalase, komanso kutsutsa kotchuka.
Ganizirani kumvetsetsa izi ngati njira yoyambira yakumanzere akuyenda. Kodi kuyenda koyambirira kumeneku kumatanthawuza kuti munthu sangathe nthawi yomweyo kutafuna chingamu potsutsana ndi Trumpenstein ndikugwira ntchito kuti awonongeke mofulumira kwambiri potengera kumvetsetsa kwake kuti White House ndi neo-fascistic, wokonda tsankho, wokonda zachikhalidwe, komanso wokonda zachiwerewere ndipo motsogozedwa ndi munthu wokonda nkhanza komanso woipa kwambiri yemwe amasangalala kuzunza ana obwera kumayiko ena ndikunyalanyaza miyambo yachitukuko ndi malamulo - ndipo, mwa njira, akuchita chilichonse chomwe angathe kuti apititse patsogolo ntchitoyi. za kusandutsa dziko lonse lapansi kukhala Greenhouse Gas Chamber? Inde sichoncho.
Nthawi zoyamba za 300 zomwe ndidamva "koma Hillary" ndi "koma Obama" adangoyankha ngati mayankho akudzudzula a Trump, ndidapumira ndikupita nawo. Mmodzi atha kutchula zambiri ngati si mazana a zofalitsa zanga ndi nkhani za momwe chipani cha Inauthentic Opposition, a Democrats, ali ndi chidwi chapadera ndi a Obama ndi a Clintons ndi gawo lomwe iwo ndi chipani chawo cha neoliberal adachita poyambitsa utsogoleri wa Trumpenstein.
Nthawi zachiwiri za 300 zomwe ndidamva "bwanji Hillary," "bwanji za Obama," komanso "bwanji a Democrats" poyankha zotsutsa zotsalira za utsogoleri wa Trump, ndidati "chabwino, koma mwina mwawonapo pano. kuti dzina la purezidenti ndi a Donald Trump, osati a Barack Obama kapena a Hillary Clinton ndipo GOP yoyera ya dziko lino ili ndi nthambi zonse zitatu zaboma [ngakhale a Democrat adapeza theka la Congress mu Januware 2019] Chonde lingalirani kuti wamkulu waposachedwa waku America. Empire nthawi zonse ndi mdani wapagulu #1 komanso kuti Trump ndi yoyipa kwambiri m'njira zomwe anthu ambiri oganiza mozama amaziwona kuti ndizosangalatsa. Mukumveka ngati mbiri yosweka kwambiri. Kukonda kwanu kwayamba kumveka ngati kuipitsidwa kochepa. โ
Pambuyo pa nthawi zachitatu za 300 ndinamva kuyankha kwa Trump pa "kumanzere," ndinayamba kuchotsa anthu m'bokosi langa ndikuwawombera m'mindandanda yanga ya "social media". Otsalira enieni safuna ma harangu osatha pazovuta za demokalase. Tamvetsetsa kuopsa kwa chipani china cha capitalist-imperialist kuyambira pomwe Upton Sinclair adatcha a Democrats ndi Republican "mapiko awiri a mbalame yodya nyama imodzi" (mu 1904). Kulephera kuzindikira kuti munthu akhoza kutsutsa onse Donito Assolini ndi makampani-Wall-Street CIA Democrats nthawi imodzi ndi mawonekedwe osatha kuyenda ndi kutafuna chingamu nthawi imodzi. Sikuwala kwambiri.
Otsatira mfundo komanso enieni akumanzere akufuna kuti boma la Trump-Pence ligonjetsedwe chifukwa cha zigawenga zodziwika bwino zomwe sizikumana ndi a Trump okha ndi Trumpism koma ma capitalist, ma imperialist, kusankhana mitundu, kugonana, komanso chikhalidwe cha anthu, kuphatikiza ma Democrats, omwe adayambitsa Trump. Otsalira kwambiri / enieni otsalira (ndinaphatikizaponso) akhala akulimbikitsa izi kuyambira tsiku lomwe Trump adamaliza maphunziro awo ku Electoral College.
Kumanzere kwenikweni kumamvetsetsa bwino nthawi zonse kuti kuyenera kutsutsa tsankho, Nativism, ethno-centrism, ndi sexism pomanga mgwirizano wodziwika komanso wogwira ntchito polimbana ndi kusintha ndi kusintha. Inde, ma Democrat osankhika amatsutsa Trump ndi ma Republican kuchokera ku a "Progressive-neoliberal," malingaliro a bourgeois-identitarian. Ife tikudziwa zimenezo. Koma maganizo amenewo ali nawo palibe chochita ndi zenizeni ndi mfundo za ndale za kumanzere ndipo ndizosautsa kuphatikizira ndale zotere ndi ndale zandale zamakampani a Democrats ndi media. Kuyitana Lipenga ngati wosankhana mitundu komanso wokonda kugonana ngati gawo limodzi la gulu lachisinthiko cha anthu ogwira ntchito sikufanana ndi mlangizi wakale wa Obama National Security Advisor Susan Rice kutcha Trump kukhala wosankhana mitundu komanso wokonda zachiwerewere monga gawo limodzi la zolimbikitsa zamphamvu kwambiri zaku US. Kudana ndi kusankhana mitundu/-sexism/-nativism/-homophobia/- nationalism/-chauvinism ndi gawo limodzi la kulimbana kwa ogwira ntchito ndi otsika ambiri motsutsana ndi olemera onyansa komanso amphamvu kwambiri Ochepa.
Trump ndi maziko ake ndi atsankho kwambiri. Izi mwachiwonekere zili choncho mwachisawawa komanso mwachiwerengero. Pafupifupi modabwitsa ngati lingaliro la Trumpenleft la Trump ngati "purezidenti wamtendere" (uzani anthu aku Yemen, a Kurds aku Syria omwe angotsala pang'ono kumenyedwa, ma Palestine, ndi anthu masauzande ambiri omwe ataya achibale ndi abwenzi awo. Trump ndi chinsinsi kukhazikitsa mbiri yankhondo ya drone) ndi zonena kuti adasankhidwa kukhala paudindo ndi (oyera) ogwira ntchito chifukwa cha zonena zake zokomera chuma. Malo ovotera a Trump anali olemera kwambiri komanso osasunthika makamaka osati pa "populist" madandaulo azachuma otsutsana ndi neoliberalism koma m'malo molumikizana ndi neo-fascistic conjunism yaulamuliro wandale komanso chizindikiritso chamtundu / tsankho.[1]. Chiwerengero cha ovota ogwira ntchito oyera omwe adasiya kuvota kwa Obama mu 2012 kupita ku Trump mu 2016 - gawo lalikulu lankhani yopusa ya Trumpenproletarian - "ndi ochepera theka la anthu aku America ambiri," malinga ndi wasayansi wandale wakumanzere Anthony DiMaggio, yemwe buku lake likubwera Kupanduka ku America: Zipolowe za nzika, News Media, ndi Politics of Plutocracy (Routledge, 2020) aphwanya nkhani yopusa ya Trumpenproletarian ("Trump's white work-class base"). DiMaggio akunena kuti "ovota m'madera omwe anavulazidwa ndi kuwonongeka kwa mafakitale anali ndi mwayi wosankha Hillary Clinton kuposa Trump." "Nkhani yeniyeni ya 2016," DiMaggio adandilembera posachedwa, inali "kuthamangitsidwa kwa demokalase kwa ovota ogwira ntchito, osati kulima kwa Trumps."
"Ogwira ntchito enieni amapandukira neoliberalism mu 2016 ndi 2020." Zotsatsa za DiMaggio, "adapita / amadutsa kampeni ya Sanders, yomwe imakokera kumanzere, kuphatikiza Occupy, Madison, ndi Fight for 15. 'Ofufuza' omwe amati Trump adavoteredwa ndi gulu la ogwira ntchito amasokoneza Trump ndi Sanders ponena kuti. kuti zonse ziลตiri ndi zisonyezero zatanthauzo za kupandukira ulamuliro waulamuliro wa anthu ogwira ntchito.โ Zoneneratu ndi zopanda pake: โSanders,โ akutero DiMaggio, โamatsutsa ulamuliro wa plutocracy. Trump ndiye chitsanzo choipitsitsa kwambiri m'mbiri yamakono ya US. "
Ponena za kupusa, lingaliro la โzina kumanzere ... zomwe zimathandizira Trumpโ ndizodziletsa zokha komanso nthabwala za Orwellian. "Kumanzere" komwe kumathandizira wokonda zokwawa, kusankhana mitundu, kugonana, woyera-dziko, wotsutsa kusintha kwa nyengo ngati Trump si "kumanzere" koyenera kulembedwa. Awiri kuphatikiza awiri ndi anayi. Sichifanana naini.
Trump ayi pulezidenti wina woyipa wa Republican. Kupatulapo Gerald Ford komanso kupatulapo George HW wowopsa "Zomwe Tikunena Zikupita" Bush, ndizowona, Purezidenti aliyense waku Republican kuyambira pomwe Dwight Eisenhower wayamba kutsutsa, kusankhana mitundu, kutsagana ndi dziko, kuthandizidwa ndi evangelically, komanso mokonda. Komabe, kuchuluka kwake kunasintha kukhala mtundu ndi monstrosity ya lalanje. Anzeru akumanzere akumanzere omwe akuthamangitsa Fascism okhala m'mphepete mwa nyanja Kum'mawa kapena Kumadzulo ayenera kupita kumadera owuluka ndikuwona zomwe zikuchitika mu "malo owuluka" omwe akuimiridwa mopanda nzeru. Ayeneranso kupita ku msonkhano wa Trump. Trump wathyola nkhungu, kudumphira zonse pa herrenvolkish woyera nationalism. Iye watenga palinegenetic nationalism, tsankho lankhanza poyera, nativism, sexism, nkhondo yolimbana ndi chowonadi, komanso kudalirana kwachilengedwe kumagulu atsopano owopsa limodzi ndi ulamuliro wankhanza womwe umagwirizanitsa poyera utsogoleri wachifumu waku US ndi katangale waumwini, kulimbikitsa ndi kulimbikitsa ziwawa zandale zamapiko amanja, komanso nkhanza. kuchotsedwa kwa lamulo la bourgeois. Trump ndi purezidenti woyamba waku US m'mbiri yamakono yemwe angayembekezeredwe osalemekeza zotsatira za chisankho izo sizipita njira yake. (Nanga bwanji za neo-fascistic, arch-authoritarian Trump kusiyana ndi za kudzipereka kwamalingaliro komanso kuchuluka kwake komwe kumakhudzana ndi vennal and malignant narcissism-gangsterism ndi funso lotseguka koma sitiyenera kukayikira kuti Trump45 ikuyimira kunyamuka kwa mbiri yakale yokhala ndi malingaliro amphamvu a fascistic.)
Trumpified GOP maziko si osankhidwa akale ankhanza aku Republican. Zambiri mwa izi mwachidziwikire gulu losakhala la proletarian ladutsa poyambira pa proto-fascistic.
"Otsalira" omwe sangatsutse mosabisa komanso mosabisa nkhumba yoyera yokonda kusankhana mitundu, a Donald Trump ndi omutsatira ankhanza ayenera kusiya kudzizindikiritsa okha, komanso otsalira. Trumpenleftism ndi chikhalidwe cha oxymoronic cha Orwellian kudziletsa. Otsatira ake achilendo ayenera kukana kukopa kwake kapena kukonzekera kulowa mu Red-Brown Hall of Shame pamodzi ndi anthu otchuka kwambiri a mbiri yakale monga "nthawi yachitatu" utsogoleri wa German Communist Party ("After Hitler, Us") kumayambiriro kwa zaka za m'ma 1930.
Postscript: motsutsana ndi Zofanana Zabodza
Oyang'anira ma portider akuluakulu sayenera kutengera zolakwika zokhudzana ndi vuto la momwe angayankhire zochita "zakuya". Wankhanza wankhanza a Trump tsopano akukumana ndi zovuta zandale kuphatikiza kutsutsidwa komanso mwina kuchotsedwa chifukwa oyang'anira akuluakulu a CIA ndi ena "chitetezo cha dziko" adagwira Trump akunyalanyaza miyambo yomwe idakhazikitsidwa kwanthawi yayitali pogwiritsa ntchito mfundo zachifumu za ofesi yake kuti alandire thandizo kuchokera kwa atolankhani. dziko lakunja muzoyesayesa zake zakusankhanso. Mlanduwu umachepa ndi zolakwa zambiri zomwe opita patsogolo amadziwa kuti ndi mndandanda wautali wamilandu ndi kuzunza kwa Trump. Mndandandawu umaphatikizapo: kuthamangitsa Ecocide; kumanga misasa yachibalo mโmalire; kuphwanya ufulu wa chikhululukiro cha mayiko; Kuphwanya malamulo oyendetsera dziko lino pazandalama zapakhomo; Kuphwanya malamulo oyendetsera dziko lino pazandalama zakunja; kuyambitsa ziwawa; kusokoneza ufulu wovota; tsankho chifukwa cha chipembedzo; nkhondo yovomerezeka; Chiwopsezo chosaloledwa cha nkhondo ya nyukiliya; kugwiritsa ntchito mphamvu za chikhululukiro cha pulezidenti; kulepheretsa chilungamo; kulowerera ndale za milandu; kulephera kukonzekera bwino ndikuyankha mphepo yamkuntho Harvey ndi Maria; kulekanitsa ana ndi makanda ku mabanja; chinyengo chamisonkho ndi kunamizira anthu; kuwononga ufulu wa atolankhani; kuthandizira kulanda boma ku Venezuela; kulengeza zadzidzidzi mosagwirizana ndi malamulo; kulangiza Border Patrol kuti aphwanye lamulo; kukana kutsatira ma subpoena; Declaration of Emergency popanda chifukwa chophwanya chifuniro cha Congress; kuchuluka kosaloledwa kwaukadaulo wa zida za nyukiliya; zosaloledwa kuchotsedwa kwa US ku Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty.
Kuwonedwa motsutsana ndi mbiri yayikuluyi yolakwira, Chipata cha Ukraine chikuwoneka ngati cholakwika chaching'ono komanso nkhani yosankhika. Komabe, palibe munthu wodzilemekeza yekha yemwe angayitanitse kapena kutsogolera ziwonetsero zoteteza utsogoleri wa Trump motsutsana ndi kuyesayesa kwa "boma lakuya" kuti achotse ku UkraineGate ndikulepheretsa chilungamo. Imeneyo si nkhondo yathu yolimbana ndi โdeep stateโ. Ingoganizirani zochitika zina, komabe: "dziko lakuya" likutsatira purezidenti wa demokalase kapena womasuka (mwachitsanzo, Purezidenti Bernie Sanders kapena Purezidenti Liz Warren) - kapena pankhaniyo pulezidenti wakumanzere (ndikhoza kulota) - poyesera kukhazikitsa pulogalamu yayikulu yademokalase monga inshuwaransi yaumoyo ya Single Payer komanso/kapena pulogalamu ya Green Jobs ndi chilungamo chanyengo. Munthawi imeneyi, ikhala ntchito ya aliyense wodzilemekeza Kumanzere kuchita ziwonetsero zazikulu m'malo mwa zomwe Purezidenti wachita. Chifukwa chake, ayi, kukhala "chabwino" ndi (kapena osakaniza) kuchotsedwa kwa olamulira amphamvu a Trump pa chinthu ngati UkraineGate (chomwe chimaphatikizapo kugwiritsa ntchito molakwika mphamvu mopanda manyazi ndi Malignant Freak ku White House) SIkutanthauza ( monga ambiri a Trumpenlefties ayesera kundiuza pa intaneti) kuti wina angakhalenso "chabwino" ndi kuchotsa kwa olamulira amphamvu kapena pulezidenti wamanzere chifukwa choyesa kuchita zinthu zabwino komanso zopita patsogolo. Zakale sizitiyika m'misewu. Womaliza amatero.
Mawu omaliza
1) Pankhani yeniyeni ndi deta pa maziko a Trump, onani Konstatin Kilibard ndi Daria Roithmayr, "Nthano ya Rust Belt Revolt: Donald Trump Sanasinthe Ovota Oyera Ogwira Ntchito. Hillary Clinton Anawataya, " Slate, December 1, 2016; Kim Moody, "Ndani Anaika Trump mu White House?" Jacobin, January 11, 2017; Anthony DiMaggio, "Election Con 2016: Umboni Watsopano Ukuthetsa Nthano ya Trump's 'Blue-Collar' Populism, ' Kuwongolera, June 16, 2017; Eric Draitser, "Donald Trump ndi Kupambana kwa White Identity Politics, " Kuwongolera, March 24, 2017; David Norman Smith ndi Eric Hanley, "Masewera a Anger: Ndani Adavotera Donald Trump mu Chisankho cha 2016, Ndipo Chifukwa Chiyani?" Critical Sociology, February 9, 2018, Pakuwunika kwapamwamba kwambiri komanso mwanzeru kwa osankhidwa a Trump a 2016 omwe adapangidwa mpaka pano, Smith ndi Hanley adapeza kuti maziko a Trump oyera amasiyanitsidwa ndi ovotera oyera omwe si a Trump osati ndi kalasi kapena zinthu zina "zambiri" (kuphatikiza ndalama, zaka, jenda ndi amene amati amawazindikiritsa maphunziro) koma ndi malingaliro ndi zikhalidwe zisanu ndi zitatu zazikulu: kuzindikirika ngati "wosunga"; kuthandizira "atsogoleri opondereza"; Chitsimikizo chachikhristu; tsankho kwa alendo; tsankho kwa anthu akuda; tsankho kwa Asilamu; tsankho kwa amayi, komanso malingaliro opanda chiyembekezo pazachuma. Otsatira amphamvu a Trump adachita bwino kwambiri pothandizira atsogoleri opondereza, okhazikika, otsutsa olowa m'mayiko ena komanso kukayikira zachuma. Iwo anali okonda kwambiri kuthandizira atsogoleri opondereza omwe adalonjeza kuti ayankha molanga kwa anthu ochepa omwe amawoneka ngati "odula mizere" - "osayenera" ena omwe akuti amatsogola azungu aku America pakugula ntchito ndi zopindulitsa zaboma - komanso kwa omwe amayenera kukhala omasuka. "maapulo owola" omwe akuti amalola "odula mizere" awa kupita patsogolo pa amuna achizungu achi America. Thandizo kwa atsogoleri aulamuliro pandale komanso kusalolera kusiyana pakati pa mitundu, mafuko ndi jenda ndi mbali ziwiri za ndalama imodzi ya Trumpian. Chikhumbo chachikulu chomwe chinapangitsa maziko a Trump chinali "chikhumbo chotsutsa cha mtsogoleri wopondereza komanso wopanda ndale" cholumikizidwa ndi "chikhumbo chofuna kusintha zomwe maziko ake akuwona kuti ndi chikhalidwe komanso tsankho."
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama