Mwina simunamvepo za sewero lachiyuda la David Baddiel kapena wosewera mpira wakale wakuda Jason Lee. Mwina simusamala za aliyense wa iwo. Koma msonkhano wawo woyamba - womwe wawonetsedwa m'mitundu iwiri yosiyana sabata ino - uyenera kusangalatsa aliyense wokhudzidwa ndi momwe nkhondo yolimbana ndi kusankhana mitundu ndi ndale ikuwonongera moyo wathu wandale m'njira zankhanza zomwe zikuchulukirachulukira.
Msonkhanowo udachitika kuti Baddiel apepese kwa Lee patatha zaka 25 atamuvutitsa mobwerezabwereza ndikumupezerera pa TV ya BBC TV yotchedwa Fantasy Football League - m'njira zomwe ngakhale panthawiyo zinali zatsankho. Baddiel adakhala wakuda ngati Lee, atavala chinanazi pamutu pake kuti anyoze mawonekedwe a Lee chifukwa amavala ma dreadlocks omangidwa pamutu pake pamasewera.
Mu imodzi mwamawonekedwe amenewo, Baddiel adawonekera pachiwonetsero cha Njira yatsopano ya podcast ya Lee, yomwe pakali pano yasonkhanitsa olembetsa oposa 700, ngakhale mothandizidwa ndi maonekedwe a Baddiel.
Lee adatenga mwayiwo kuti afotokoze chifukwa chomwe moyo wake ndi wa anthu ena ambiri akuda udavulazidwa ndi chipongwe cha Baddiel m'ma 1990. Lee adakhala chandamale cha kunyozedwa m'dziko lonselo, kunja ndi kumunda. Ana ake aang’ono anasokonezeka maganizo ndi kuchita mantha kuti nthaŵi iliyonse akayenda mumsewu ndi atate awo odutsa amafuula monyoza. Ndipo ana ena akuda amene analimbikitsidwa ndi chitsanzo cha Lee kunyadira choloŵa chawo chachikhalidwe mwadzidzidzi anakumana ndi chitonzo ndi kupezerera kusukulu chifukwa cha maonekedwe awo.
Mtundu wachiwiri unali wa Baddiel yemwe. Kuyambira Fantasy Football League, wosewera mpira - yemwe mbiri yake ya Twitter imangoti "Myuda" - wadziwonetsa ngati katswiri wa tsankho. Kudziyesa kumeneko kwavomerezedwa ndi kukana pang'ono kuchokera kwa akatswiri muzofalitsa zokhazikitsidwa, ngakhale ena ogwiritsa ntchito mafilimu akhala akukhululukidwa kale ndi tsankho lake.
Zaka zingapo zapitazo Baddiel adalemba buku lomwe likuwoneka kuti lili ndi mphamvu zotsutsana ndi anthu, ndipo sabata ino malingaliro ake adadziwika kwambiri muzolemba za Channel 4 za dzina lomweli: Ayuda Sawerengera. Mtsutso wa Baddiel ndi wakuti chidani cha Ayuda ndi mtundu wapadera komanso woopsa kwambiri wa tsankho, osati chifukwa chakuti anthu ambiri a ku Britain amalephera kuvomereza momwe amachitira mitundu ina ya tsankho, monga kusankhana mitundu kwa anthu akuda ndi aku Asia.
Baddiel adanenapo izi momveka bwino komanso mosabisa pawonetsero wa Frankie Boyle's New World Order mu 2018 kuti aombe m'manja, Poyerekeza kusankhana mitundu kwa Ayuda kupita ku khansa, komanso kusankhana mitundu kwa anthu ang'onoang'ono kupita ku shingles.
Kukoleza moto
Baddiel adagwira ntchito molimbika kuti awonekere bwino pa podcast ya Lee, ndikupepesa koopsa chifukwa cha mbiri yake yayitali yosankhana mitundu mosaganizira. Anavomereza kuti mantha ndi manyazi adachitapo kanthu pochedwetsa msonkhano wake ndi Lee kwa nthawi yayitali.
M'zolemba zake zomwe, Baddiel anali wocheperako pakulemba zomwezo. Adadzudzula mobwerezabwereza pawailesi yakanema za tsankho lake kwa Lee, ndi chinyengo chake, monga kuvutitsa anthu pa intaneti - ndipo adagwiritsa ntchito zitsanzozo kuti atsimikize zonena kuti zomwe adachita, monga Myuda, zinali zapadera komanso zosiyana.
Motetezedwa pamawayilesi omwe amawalamulira, zidamveka ngati Lee adapepesa mochedwa chifukwa Baddiel adachititsidwa manyazi kuti apange, kapena chifukwa Baddiel adaziwona ngati kulapa komwe kumafunikira asanayambe kukhala ndi makhalidwe apamwamba pa TV pamene. kufuna ufulu woweruzidwa mosiyana chifukwa cha tsankho lake.
Koma mmbuyo pa podcast ya Lee, Baddiel adavomeranso kuti zidatengera kusankhana mitundu kuti atsegule maso ake kuti anyozeke komanso manyazi Lee ayenera kuti adakumana nawo chifukwa amawunikidwa pafupipafupi pa BBC.
Baddiel adawona chochitika chimodzi pamasewera a mpira kumapeto kwa 2000s: wina adamuzindikira ndikufuula mobwerezabwereza mawu akuti "Yid". Mchimwene wakeyo adakangana kwakanthawi kochepa ndi munthu wokonda tsankho. Baddiel adawonetsa kuti panthawiyi adayamba kuzindikira momwe kuyatsa kwake moto kwa Lee kunali koopsa.
Izi zidakweza mfundo yakuti Baddiel sanalankhulepo pa podcast ya Lee kapena mwachindunji muzolemba zake. Kodi wosewerayu adakwanitsa bwanji kukhala ndi moyo nthawi yayitali asanakumane ndi mtundu wamtundu, wowopsa, wosankhana mitundu - wosiyana ndi zomwe makolo ake ndi Ayuda mbiri yakale adakumana nazo - zomwe zidamupatsa kulawa momwe zinalili kukhala Lee?
Anaphedwa ndi Klan
Ndikunena izi kuti zisakhale zokhumudwitsa, koma ngati nkhani yowunikira mfundo yovuta yomwe Lee adatulutsa. Adafunsa Baddiel yemwe woseketsayo anali ndi "ubwenzi" ndi: ndani amamuganizira ngati ogwirizana nawo polimbana ndi tsankho? Inali mphindi imodzi - mokulirapo kuposa pomwe adapepesa - pomwe Baddiel adawoneka wokhumudwa. Ndani kwenikweni anachita amaona ngati ogwirizana nawo polimbana ndi tsankho?
Baddiel adapalasa kumbuyo kuti azindikire kuti m'zaka za m'ma 1960 ndi 1970 madera achiyuda ndi akuda adakumana phewa limodzi pomenyera ufulu wachibadwidwe ku United States. Arabi adayenda ndi Martin Luther King ku Selma motsutsana ndi azungu, adatero. Mu Jewish Don't Count, iye ndi wochita sewero waku US David Schwimmer adanenanso kuti mu 1964 anyamata awiri achiyuda adaphedwa ndi Ku Klux Klan pomwe adapita ku Deep South kukathandiza womenyera ufulu wachibadwidwe wakuda - chochitika chomwe chidasinthidwa. mufilimu ya Hollywood, Missispipi Kuwotcha.
Baddiel adavomereza kuti mgwirizano wamtunduwu watayika kwambiri, ndikuwonjezera kuti samamvetsetsa chifukwa chake. M'gawo losamveka bwino la podcast, adakayikira ngati ndi chifukwa mtundu "wakhala wosiyana kwambiri ku America - ndipo ndipamene zinthu zonsezi zikuwoneka kuti zidayambira". Ananenanso kuti: "[Mgwirizanowu] ukhoza kubwereranso, koma nthawi zina zikuwoneka kuti ubale sunali momwe udaliri."
Pofunafuna yankho, anabwerera ku zoopsa zomwe banja la amayi ake linakumana nalo ku Germany ya Nazi. Zipsera zimenezo zinachoka m’madera a Ayuda, iye anatsutsa, makamaka poganizira tsankho limene anthu ena anali nalo: “M’zaka za m’ma 1960 ndi 1970, chifukwa cha zimene Ayuda ambiri anakumana nazo, kuona kuti anthu akuda akusalidwa mwankhanza. makamaka ku Amereka, iwo [Ayuda] anafuna kufikira ndi chokumana nacho chawo.”
Koma pafupifupi ngati munthu wamanjenje, Baddiel kenako adalunjika kwa Whoopi Goldberg, wochita masewero wakuda waku America adatembenuza gulu lazokambirana pa TV, kuti amudzudzule chifukwa cha mawu ake osokonekera okhudza kuphedwa kwa Nazi, komwe adanenanso kuti chiwonongeko chamakampani a Nazi sichinali pafupi. mtundu. Ndakhala ndikuchitapo kanthu motalikirapo ndi mkwiyo wokwiyitsidwa ndi ndemanga za Goldberg komanso kubweza kovutirako kwa mabungwe achiyuda ngati Anti-Defamation League, chifukwa chake sindidzayang'ananso gawoli pano. Mutha kuwerenga nkhani yoyambirira.
Mosiyana ndi podcast ya Lee, nkhani ya kusokonekera kwa mgwirizano pakati pa Ayuda ndi anthu akuda polimbana ndi tsankho silinatchulidwe muzolemba za Baddiel. Ndipo izi zitha kukhala chifukwa zikuwoneka ngati chinsinsi chotsegulira chisokonezo chachikulu chomwe Baddiel adawonetsa komanso ogwirizana nawo achiyuda omwe adawafunsa nawo pulogalamu yake yapa TV.
Kuzungulira kwa opondereza
Kumayambiriro kwa Ayuda Osawerengera, Baddiel amafika pachimake pa zomwe zikuwoneka kuti zimamuvutitsa za kudana ndi Ayuda ku Britain. Zimakhudza makamaka anthu omwe akupita patsogolo komanso odana ndi tsankho, osati anthu omwe amaukira masunagoge, ngakhale amatchulidwanso.
Zithunzi zochokera ku msonkhano wa chipani cha Labor wa 2019 zikuwonetsa zokamba za a Dawn Butler, MP wakuda yemwe panthawiyo anali mlembi wachithunzi wa Labor for Women and Equality. M'menemo, adalemba magulu ambiri omwe ali pachiwopsezo komanso ovutika omwe Labor akuyembekezeka kulandila ngati gawo lamgwirizano wazisankho kuti agonjetse chipani cholamula cha Tory. Anaphatikizanso omwe ali m'malo ochezera a anthu, ma gay, madera ogonana amuna kapena akazi okhaokha, ogwira ntchito, olumala, ochepera zaka 18, ndi akuda, azungu ndi Asiya. Koma kulibe, monga anatsindika Baddiel, panali kutchulidwa kulikonse kwa Ayuda.
Baddiel amayembekeza kuyika izi ngati chitsanzo chaching'ono koma chodziwika bwino chotsutsana ndi Ayuda. Mgwirizano wamasankho a Labour motsogozedwa ndi mtsogoleri wakale wa Labor Jeremy Corbyn adaphatikizira mwadala kupatula, akutero Baddiel, zikafika kwa Ayuda. Iye amafunsa mwachidwi chifukwa chake Ayuda samawerengera opita patsogolo.
Ndithudi ndikusiya kosangalatsa. Koma ndikukayikira kuti sizikuwonetsa zomwe Baddiel akuganiza kuti amachita - ndipo zitha kupereka chidziwitso cha chifukwa chomwe Ayuda ndi anthu akuda adataya mgwirizano womwe adakhala nawo m'ma 1960 ndi 1970s. Kapena tchulani njira ina, chifukwa chiyani kwa wina ngati Dawn Butler, Ayuda ngati Baddiel amalowetsedwa m'gulu la "oyera", monganso ma Sikh, Buddha ndi China ali m'gulu la "Asian".
Baddiel akutsutsa kuti “pali mayankho ochuluka” ku funso lakuti chifukwa chimene Ayuda akunyalanyazidwa ndi otsalira opita patsogolo, koma mwachiwonekere chofunika koposa chiri ichi: “Ayuda ndiwo okha amene ali ndi tsankho amene amalingaliridwa kukhala olemekezeka ndi apansi.” Amawonedwa ngati onse "odetsedwa, akuba, onunkha, oyipa", komanso "otengera, mwayi, wamphamvu komanso olamulira dziko mobisa".
Pachifukwa ichi, Baddiel akumaliza, opita patsogolo amakana Ayuda malo "m'gulu la oponderezedwa". Ndipotu, akupitiriza, nthawi zambiri amaonedwa kuti ali "m'gulu la opondereza". Progressives akuganiza kuti akukankha. Baddiel amatsutsa.
Kupaka kwa Teflon
Mwachilengedwe, wowunikira pa TV wa Guardian adakonda zolemba za Baddiel, adachita chidwi ndi zomwe adazitcha "nyenyezi zonse" za zikhalidwe zachiyuda zomwe zidagwirizana ndi mkangano wa Baddiel. Pepala la mutu adalongosola pulogalamuyo ngati "yodabwitsa kwambiri imamveka ngati siren".
Koma ndizodziwikiratu kuti Ayuda omasuka a Baddiel adatchulapo popereka mlandu wake - komanso anthu omasuka omwe si Ayuda omwe zolemba zake zimawalozera kwambiri - akuwoneka kuti alibe nkhawa ngati Baddiel mwiniwakeyo chifukwa chakuti zolinga zodziwika bwino za "Ayuda samachita nawo. count" ndizomwe zikupita patsogolo komanso mafuko ochepa, makamaka atsogoleri akuda.
Baddiel akuwoneka kuti ali ndi nkhawa kwambiri kuwadzudzula powauza kuti amadana ndi Ayuda mwadala kapena mopanda kuganiza kusiyana ndi kuthera nthawi yochuluka akudandaula za achiwembu osankhana mitundu pabwalo la mpira kapena munthu ngati Boris Johnson yemwe kuwuka kwake pandale sikunavulazidwe konse - mwina kupindula - polemba a buku lomwe chapakati, Johnsonesque khalidwe amakhulupirira kuti Ayuda nkhokwe mphuno ndi kulamulira TV.
Chochititsa chidwi n'chakuti, wowunikira Guardian wa bukhuli adakwanitsa kuphonya kutsutsa kwa Johnson ngakhale chakumapeto kwa chilimwe cha 2019, pamene kudana ndi Ayuda kunkachitika tsiku ndi tsiku pamene atolankhani adakantha Corbyn ndi chipani cha Labor.
Baddiel akanatha kutanthauzira kuphatikizika kwa mfundozo mosiyana ndi momwe amasankhira: kuti Ayuda samawerengera kokha ngati zili zokomera kukhazikitsidwa kwa Britain - kuchokera kwa Boris Johnson kupita kwa Guardian - kuti sawerengera. Amawerengera kwambiri pomwe bungwe lomwelo likufuna kuti awerenge, monga momwe adasiyidwira patsogolo pomwe Corbyn adasankhidwa kukhala mtsogoleri wa Labor.
Ndipo apa pali chinthu china. Chovala cha Johnson cha Teflon potsutsa zonena za tsankho chikufanana ndi kupambana kwa Baddiel popewa kulipira mtengo chifukwa cha mbiri yake yayitali ya tsankho.
Wothirira ndemanga pandale Ash Sarkar akunena bwino izi:
Mfundo yakuti [kusankhana mitundu kwa Baddiel] sikunamukhudze konse kumalepheretsa chiphunzitso chake chakuti Islamophobia, kudana ndi anthu akuda, mitundu ina ya kudana ndi anthu ochokera kumayiko ena imakhala ndi mwayi wapadera poyerekeza ndi kudana ndi Ayuda - chifukwa ntchito yake sinakhudzidwepo ndi chilichonse mwazinthu izi.
Ndipotu, panalibe zotsatira zochepa za mbiri yake ya tsankho kotero kuti adatha kukhala katswiri pa tsankho. ... Iye ndi woyenda, kupuma, kuyankhula kutsutsa lingaliro lakuti kudana ndi mdima kumatengedwa mozama kwambiri mumagulu opita patsogolo ndipo antisemitism sichiri.
Ganizirani za kumasuka komwe Johnson ndi Baddiel adazemba zowerengera zandale kapena zofalitsa nkhani chifukwa cha tsankho lodziwika bwino: pankhani ya Johnson chifukwa chodana ndi Ayuda, komanso Baddiel chifukwa cha tsankho lake lodana ndi anthu akuda.
Kenako siyanitsani izi ndi ziwanda za Corbyn, yemwe adatsitsidwa ndi zaka zambiri zopanda umboni zotsutsa kuti chipani cha Labor chidakhala chodana ndi semite panthawi yake.
Zonenerazi zidapatsidwa moyo ndi zonyansa zochokera ku gulu la Tory, media media, the ulamuliro wamanja wa chipani cha Corbyn cha Labor, ndi Ayuda ololera ngati Baddiel. Onse ankawopsezedwa ndi Corbyn odana ndi imperialism, makamaka, pankhani ya zigawo zazikulu za utsogoleri wokonzekera wa Ayuda, zotsutsa zake za Israeli ndi ndondomeko zake za tsankho kwa Apalestina. Ndipo ambiri amawopa pulogalamu yake yochepetsetsa ya sosholisti yomwe ingathetse kusagwirizana kofala.
"Israel, Schmisrael"
Sizikuwoneka kuti zikuchitika kwa Baddiel kapena Ayuda ena omasuka omwe amawafunsa kuti sangawoneke ngati ogwirizana ndi gulu lopita patsogolo, lodana ndi tsankho, kapena kwa anthu akuda, chifukwa chophweka. Chifukwa mabungwe a utsogoleri achiyuda omwe amadzinenera kuti akuimira unyinji wa Ayuda aku Britain - monga Board of Deputies, Community Security Trust, Campaign Against Antisemitism, Jewish Labor Movement, mndandanda ukupitilira - onse amangokhalira kunena kuti Ayuda sali ogwirizana nawo. opita patsogolo.
Utsogoleri wa gulu lachiyuda, komanso olemba ndemanga otchuka monga Jonathan Freedland mu Guardian, amanena mobwerezabwereza kuti zisankho zimasonyeza. 10 mwa Ayuda XNUMX aku Britain thandizani Israeli - ngakhale ambiri akuwoneka kuti sakonda boma lake lomwe lilipo, lomwe lidalipo kale ndi lomwe likubwera pambuyo pake.
Iwo amathandizira Israeli, zikuwoneka, ngati mtundu wina wodzipatula, monga momwe amapondereza poyera komanso nthawi zonse mowonekera komanso kulanda anthu aku Palestine, kuzinga ndi kupha anthu wamba ku Gaza, ndipo akulengezedwa kuti ndi boma la tsankho potsogolera magulu a ufulu wa anthu. Zimamveka ngati ndidathandizira tsankho ku South Africa zaka 40 zapitazo koma ndikulimbikira kuti sindine watsankho chifukwa ndimatsutsa boma la P W Botha.
Osati zokhazo, koma Freedland ndi Ayuda ena owolowa manja amatsutsa mwamphamvu kuti Israeli ali pankhondo maziko a umunthu wawo ndipo kuti kutsutsa Israeli ndiko kuwadzudzula. Iwo amanena kuti kutsutsa kwa kupita patsogolo kwa kumanzere kwa maganizo a ndale a Zionism - lingaliro lomwe lakhudza kulanda dziko la Palestine ndi kulandidwa kwa anthu ake - kuli kofanana ndi kudana ndi Ayuda.
Ngati lingaliro ili silinafalikire pakati pa gulu lachiyuda, ndiye kuti mwina atolankhani kapena gulu lachiyuda palokha achita ntchito yabwino kwambiri kutisokeretsa. Ayuda omwe amatsutsana nawo, monga omwe adathandizira Corbyn, nthawi zonse amadzipeza akutsutsidwa ndi Ayuda ena, momveka bwino kapena momveka bwino, monga odzida kapena "Myuda wolakwika".
"Ayuda olakwika", monga Al Jazeera posachedwapa zolembedwa mwatsatanetsatane, akuchotsedwa mwadongosolo kuchokera ku chipani cha Sir Keir Starmer's Labor - ndipo palibe chidziwitso cha izi kuchokera kwa Baddiel kapena abwenzi ake omasuka achiyuda.
Powonjezera kulimbikitsa chisokonezochi, Israeli mwiniwake amafuna kuzindikirika ngati dziko la Ayuda onse padziko lonse lapansi. Malamulo a Israeli amalengeza kuti Ayuda onse ndi a dziko lotchedwa "Chiyuda". Israeli amadzinenera kuti amalankhula m'malo mwa Ayuda onse. Ili ndi gawo lake lonse - ngakhale gawo la Palestine - kudalira Ayuda kulikonse. Pamene Israeli akuchita kuyeretsa kwa mafuko a Palestina, monga momwe amachitira tsiku ndi tsiku, amatero m'dzina la David Baddiel - kaya Baddiel amakonda kapena ayi.
Izi ndi zomwe Baddiel atha kudzutsa ndi wolemba Howard Jacobson panthawi yofunsa mafunso pomwe Jacobson adati Israeli idzadedwa chilichonse chomwe angachite, ngakhale atakhala Switzerland. Iye ananena kuti “chidzadedwa m’chinenero chimene anthu ankalankhula zaka pafupifupi 2000 zapitazo.”
M'malo mwake, Baddiel adalumpha ubale wa Ayuda aku Britain ndi Israeli ndikukana - komanso kosavuta - "Israel, Shmisrael".
Phindu la nkhondo
Baddiel akulondola kunena kuti ndi zotsutsana ndi Ayuda kuti azigwira Ayuda omwe ali ndi udindo pazochitika za Israeli, kapena kuyembekezera kuti azitsutsa Israeli. Koma omwe adafunsidwa ngati Jacobson ndi wochita sewero waku US Sarah Silverman amasokoneza mfundo zake posankha kuwonetsa thandizo la kamera ku Israeli, ponena kuti ndi dziko lawo komanso "malo otetezeka" kwa Ayuda pomwe amafunanso kuti asakhale ndi udindo pazochita zake. kupanga gawo lomwelo kukhala lopanda chitetezo kwa anthu aku Palestine.
Ndiye ndi chiyani? Kodi Israeli ndi dziko loyimira Ayuda onse, monga Israeli amanenera?
Kapena kodi ndi dziko lomwe likuyimira Ayuda okhawo monga Freedland, Jacobson ndi Silverman - ndi mabungwe onse akuluakulu achiyuda aku Britain omwe amati amalankhula m'malo mwa Ayuda - omwe amati Israeli ali pakatikati pa kudziwika kwawo?
Kapena kodi Israeli akulakwitsa ndipo akuyimira Ayuda okha omwe ali nzika za Israeli - osati iwo, monga atolankhani achiyuda a New York Times ku Yerusalemu, omwe asankha zaka zambiri kutumiza ana awo kumenya nkhondo m’gulu lankhondo la Israyeli?
Baddiel angakonde kupewa kuyankha funsoli, koma opita patsogolo sakhala ndi mwayi womwewo akasankha omwe angawerenge ngati ogwirizana nawo ndale. Kumanzere kumavutikira kudziwa kuti ndi ndani yemwe ali ndi mgwirizano ndi mabungwe omwe amadzinenera kuti akuyimira gulu lachiyuda la Britain, kuphatikiza Ayuda omasuka, akupitilizabe kupereka mawu okhululukira Israeli chifukwa amapha ana ku Gaza kapena amatcha anthu opita patsogolo ngati antisemites pochita kampeni yoletsa mgwirizano waku Western. kupha uko.
Baddiel sali ndi udindo pazochita za Israeli, koma ali ndi udindo ngati Myuda wokhala ndi nsanja yodziwika bwino yokhala chete pamene Bungwe limamulembera iye ndi Ayuda ena ambiri ku Israeli popondereza anthu aku Palestine kapena pamene akugwiritsa ntchito antisemitism motsutsana ndi omwe amatsatira, otsutsa- zoyambitsa imperialist.
Israeli yadzaza ndi zida za azungu, thandizo, malonda amalonda ndi chithandizo chaukazembe pamene ikuchita zolakwa zake kwa anthu aku Palestine m'dzina la Myuda aliyense padziko lapansi. Asitikali ankhondo aku Israeli, omwe amalipidwa kwambiri ndi US, amangoyendayenda ku Middle East akudzinenera kuti ndi gawo lachigawochi. Ikusunga Nkhondo Yozizira ndi Iran yomwe imatha kuphulika nthawi iliyonse. Imayesa zida zake kwa anthu aku Palestine ndi oyandikana nawo achiarabu kuti apindule ndi asitikali aku Western ndi ogulitsa zida. Imatumiza zida zake za cyber kwa olamulira ankhanza omwe amawagwiritsa ntchito kuyang'anira otsutsa. Ndipo mochulukira zimathandizira kulimbikitsa maulamuliro achisilamu oyipa mofanana ndi Saudi Arabia okhala ndi luntha lofunikira.
Chifukwa chake funso la omwe akupita patsogolo pomwe akusankha ogwirizana nawo ndi ndani yemwe ali nawo polimbana ndi West yomwe imapindula ndi nkhondo zopanda malire, zomwe zimapangitsa kuti kupitiliza utsamunda, komwe kumachita dziko lonse lapansi ngati mbali yolakwika ya omwe akuganiza kugawikana kwachitukuko, ndipo izi zimayika Israeli mozama mu intaneti iyi ya zokonda?
Utsogoleri wa tsankho
Mwinamwake kusamvana kwa gulu lamanzere ndi lakuda ponena za mgwirizano ndi gulu lachiyuda - mosiyana ndi Ayuda pawokha - zikuwonetsa chithunzi chosokoneza ichi, chisokonezo atsogoleri achiyuda ndi Israeli adalimbikitsa.
Mwina mfundo yoti opita patsogolo amawona gulu lachiyuda ngati losatetezeka komanso lamphamvu nthawi imodzi ndikungoyambitsanso kudana ndi Ayuda kwanthawi yayitali kusiyana ndi chisokonezo chobwera ndi ogwirizana nawo omwe amati ndi oyimira magulu a utsogoleri wachiyuda ngati Board of Deputies. Agwirizana ndi wozunza wankhondo wa zida za nyukiliya, Israeli, pomwe amagwirizananso ndi bungwe la Britain lofunitsitsa kugwiritsa ntchito antisemitism ngati smear kuti asowetse kumanzere kwa ndale zaku Britain - zomwe Starmer akuchita pompano.
Baddiel akufotokoza m'zolemba zake zofooka zomwe Ayuda amamva, makamaka omwe akukumana ndi mliri wotsutsana ndi utsogoleri wa Labor motsogozedwa ndi Corbyn. Koma opita patsogolo omwe atsala ku Britain akuyenera kuwona zochitika izi kudzera m'mawonekedwe osiyana kwambiri.
Mwachitsanzo, iwo ankangoyang'ana mopanda mphamvu pamene phungu Wachiyuda wa Labor, Ruth Smeeth, ankatsogolera zomwe zinkawoneka ngati zosokoneza. lynch mob mwa ena 50 aphungu a Labor - Ayuda ndi osakhala Ayuda chimodzimodzi - motsutsana ndi munthu yemwe ali yekhayekha, yemwe ali pachiwopsezo, yemwe anali msilikali wakuda wotsutsa tsankho, a Marc Wadsworth, akufuna kuti chipanicho chimuthamangitse ngati wodana ndi Ayuda.
Mlandu wa Wadsworth unali amatsutsa Smeeth pochita ndendende zomwe zimawoneka kuti akuchita: kufotokoza mwachidule nyuzipepala ya telegraph yomwe ili ndi mabiliyoni ambiri - chosangalatsa kwambiri pakukhazikitsidwa - motsutsana ndi Corbyn, mtsogoleri wosankhidwa wachipani chake, kuti amugwetse.
Ndi chiyani chomwe chinatsalira chomwe chiyenera kuganiziridwa ponena za "kuyanjana" panthawiyi?
Baddiel moyenerera akuwona kuti mantha ochuluka - mantha a Holocaust yatsopano, kuthamangitsidwanso kwatsopano - akupitirizabe kugwira Ayuda a ku Britain. Koma amanyalanyaza mantha omwe akugwira kumanzere komwe kwakhala kulibe kulembetsa mu ndale zaku Britain kwazaka zopitilira theka, kupatula kukwera kwake mwangozi komanso kwakanthawi kochepa ndi Corbyn, ndipo pakadali pano. kuzimitsidwa kwa m'badwo wina wolemba Starmer.
Opita patsogolo omwe atsala, monga Ayuda, amapangidwanso - ndi kukhazikitsidwa komweko - kukhala ofooka ndi amphamvu nthawi imodzi. Starmer akudziwa kuti atha kuthetsa kumanzere kwa Labor popanda mtengo wandale, chifukwa atolankhani amabisa msana wake akamatero. Koma nthawi yomweyo, kumanzere kumawonetsedwa ngati kwamphamvu kwambiri kotero kuti kumawoneka ngati "chiopsezo chopezeka” kwa Ayuda ku Britain. Ngati Corbyn adapambana mphamvu, mwachiwonekere akanasintha Britain kukhala Third Reich.
Baddiel amagwiritsa ntchito zolemba zake, kachiwiri, kulimbikitsa utsogoleri wa tsankho, kuchonderera chidani cha Ayuda ngati gulu losiyana. Kuchonderera kwake kwapadera pa kudana ndi Ayuda ndi umboni wa mwayi womwe amauyembekezera komanso mgwirizano womwe amaukana.
Chowonadi ndichakuti madera ofooka, omwe ali pachiwopsezo ayenera kukhala limodzi, komanso akamazunzidwa - kaya wosewera mpira wakuda ngati Jason Lee, wotsutsa tsankho ngati Marc Wadsworth, 'Myuda wolakwika' ngati Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi, kapena Mwana waku Palestina ngati ana a Masafer Yatta - amafunikira mgwirizano wathu, osati kunyozedwa kwathu. Amafunikira mgwirizano, wokhazikika pa kufanana. Ndipo ndizo ndendende zomwe Corbyn anali kupereka.
Jason Lee adafunsa Baddiel omwe anali othandizana nawo. Baddiel sanadziwe momwe angayankhire. Ndipo nthawi yomweyo, Lee adapeza yankho lake.
ZNetwork imalandira ndalama kudzera mu kuwolowa manja kwa owerenga ake.
Ndalama