Wanene zai iya lissafta ƙaryar zamaninmu? A zahiri, rukunin “ƙarya” da wuya ya rufe batun. Ɗauki misali mai sauƙi, a yanzu a shafuffuka na gaba a ko'ina: Shugaban ya gayyaci manema labarai don lokacin taron majalisar ministoci. Washegarin da ma'aikatan hukumar na 9/11 suka gabatar da wata kwakkwarar wahayi: watanni na bincike, tambayoyin masana da masu leken asiri, ba a maganar karatun tambayoyin manyan al-Qaeda da jami'an Iraki. duk sun bayyana - haƙiƙa - cewa babu "haɗin gwiwa," babu wata muhimmiyar alaƙa tsakanin Saddam Hussein da al-Qaeda, kamar yadda babu makaman lalata ko kuma dakunan gwaje-gwajen halittu na tafi-da-gidanka, kamar dai yadda babu yarjejeniyar Yellowcake na Nijar, kamar yadda. Jaridar Los Angeles Times ta ruwaito (6/17/04), leken asirin Amurka akai-akai ya “rikitar da” gidajen kajin Iraqi da wuraren makami mai linzami na Scud, kamar yadda…
Nan take shugaban ya mayar da martani ga labaran Hukumar ta 9/11 kamar haka:
“Dalilin da ya sa na ci gaba da nanata cewa akwai dangantaka tsakanin Iraki da Saddam da kuma al Qaeda, saboda akwai dangantaka tsakanin Iraki da Al Qaeda. Wannan gwamnatin ba ta taba cewa harin na 9 ga Satumba an shirya shi ne tsakanin Saddam da al Qaeda ba. Mun ce akwai alaka da yawa tsakanin Saddam Hussein da al Qaeda."
Jim Lobe na Inter Press Service sharhi:
“Wannan shi ne abin da masana kimiyya ke kira tautology, ko kuma ‘maimaitawa mara amfani,’ kamar yadda kamus ya fayyace shi, amma kuma alama ce ta yadda gwamnatin Bush ke kare kanta daga karuwar badakala da yaudara da ta samu kanta a ciki. . Maimaitawa da zargi kafofin watsa labarai, tsohon jiran aiki, wanda Mataimakin Shugaban kasa Dick Cheney da Shugaban Pentagon Donald Rumsfeld suka fi sha'awar tun daga aikinsu a karkashin Shugaba Richard Nixon da Gerald Ford shekaru 30 da suka gabata.
Yanzu, ba shakka, amfani da kalmar “dangantaka” da shugaban ƙasa ya yi yana tunawa da “ma’anar” fassarorin magabacinsa (ko da yake kan ƙananan al’amura na ƙasa). Wanene ya san, bayan haka, menene wannan Shugaban yake tunanin dangantaka? Tabbas, idan aka ɗauki misali ɗaya kawai, ta irin waɗannan ma'auni, dangantakar da ke tsakanin gwamnatin Bush da Taliban dole ne ta cancanci a matsayin abota mai zurfi kafin yaƙin Afganistan. Ko, a matsayin editan gidan yanar gizon War in Context Ya ce, "George Bush da John Kerry suna da wani dangantaka: Dukkansu ‘yan takara ne a zaben shugaban kasa mai zuwa. Ganin cewa sun shiga cikin muhawara ko biyu, wannan zai buƙaci wani matakin haɗin gwiwa. Shin hakan yana nufin Bush goyon bayan yakin Kerry?"
Amma fa sauran bangaren bayanin shugaban kasar? Shin "gwamnatin" ta taɓa cewa harin 9/11 "an shirya shi ne tsakanin Saddam da al Qaeda?"
To, kawai don faɗin “Shugaba ɗaya” ɗaya ne akan batun. Mimi Hall of USA today ya ce: “A cikin wata wasiƙa zuwa ga Majalisa a ranar 19 ga Maris, 2003—ranar da aka fara yaƙi a Iraki—Bush ya ce an ba da izinin yaƙin a ƙarƙashin dokar da ta ba da izini ga waɗanda suka ‘shirya, izini, suka aikata, ko kuma suka taimaka wa harin ta’addanci da ya faru. ranar 11 ga Satumba, 2001."
Kuma, ba shakka, ko da a zahiri bai faɗi haka ba - da kuma Fred Kaplan na Slate Ya nuna cewa Shugaban ya kasance daidai da fahimtar kalmominsa - yana danganta su biyun (kamar yadda sauran ma'aikatansa suka yi) har ma a wasu lokuta da ba a saba gani ba lokacin da ya yi kama da cewa Saddam ba shi da alaƙa da 9/11. . A cikin jawabin da ya yi a shekarar da ta gabata, alal misali, da yaƙi ya kunno kai, ya ce: "Ka yi tunanin waɗannan maharan 19 da wasu makamai da wasu tsare-tsare - wannan lokacin da Saddam ke ɗauke da makamai."
Mataimakin shugabansa wani lamari ne, duk da haka. Sai dai idan, ba shakka, ba kwa la'akari da Dick Cheney na ɓangaren "Gudanarwa," ƙila za ku yi mu'amala da shi. maganganu kamar haka (Washington Post, 6/17/04):
"A cikin Satumba, Cheney ya ce a NBC's 'Meet the Press': 'Idan mun yi nasara a Iraki . . . to, za mu yi wani babban rauni a tsakiyar sansanin, idan za ku so, yanki na ’yan ta’addan da suka kai mu farmaki tsawon shekaru da yawa, amma musamman a ranar 9 ga Satumba.
Af, ya zama shugaban kasa bai bayar da martanin sa na "kwatsam" ba a wancan zaman taron manema labarai na majalisar ministocin a cikin "kwatsam" gaba daya. Yana da takardar gadon gado, abin da ya faru ya kama shi a hoton AP, ya jujjuya kuma ya fashe saboda abubuwan al'ajabi na fasahar zamani kuma aka buga a wani hoton bidiyo. blog. Bisa lafazin Dan Froomkin na Takaitaccen Bayani na Fadar White House a Washington Post (6/21/04) ya ce:
"Saddam Ya kasance Barazana -
“Maƙiyin Amurka da aka rantse…
“Rundunar Rushewa…
"Yankin duniya mai canzawa…
"Yana da Makamai na Mass D. . .
“An ɗaure da ’yan ta’adda . . .”
Ho-hum. Daya tsoho, daya tsoho. Ya kasance kuma yana nan. Oh, kuma kawai idan har shugabanmu ya daskare a wannan lokacin na musanyawa na kai-tsaye yayin da yake mamakin ainihin wanda zai kira don ƙirƙirar irin wannan tsohuwar, tsohuwar tasiri, kawai ya faru yana da jerin sunayen 'yan jarida a kan wannan ɗakin. takardar, biyun farko ya kira su kafin ya karasa zaman. Idan kuna son sake duba lamarin al-Qaeda, je zuwa Gidan yanar gizon Cibiyar Ci gaban Amirka. Amma, ba shakka, akan waɗannan alaƙa, akan WMD, akan tasirin rage haraji, da kuma akan wasu batutuwa da yawa, zaku iya shiga cikin wannan aikin shaida da karyatawa har sai kun kasance shuɗi a fuska kuma yana iya zama ba kome ba. . Ko da wane irin gardama ne aka yi, wannan gwamnatin kawai - don amfani da kalmar Lobe - cikin ƙarfin hali ta sake tabbatar da abin da, a cikin kowane mahallin, zai zama alama a fili karairayi.
Kowanne mai ban mamaki na wani wanda yake wurin - David Kay akan WMD; Ta'addanci Tsar Richard Clarke kan asalin yakin Iraki, tsohon Sakataren Baitulmali Paul O'Neill akan rashin sha'awar gwamnatin kafin 9/11 ga al-Qaeda - kuma kuna tsammanin wata karya ta fado kuma ta kone. Duk da haka, kuma…
A cikin jerin kamanni na da aka yi yanzu-yanzu tsakanin zamanin Bush da Reagan, bari in lura cewa tsohon shugabanmu ya fara wannan hanyar tabbatar da gaskiyar da ya zaɓa sannan kuma ya nace ta sake tabbatar da ita ba tare da wata shaida ba. Shirinsa na Tsaron Dabarun, tsarin kariya na makami mai linzami da za a iya kaiwa ga harin nukiliya, watakila shine babban misali na wannan. Koyaushe ya kasance "babban kan iyaka" na kamfani boondoggle. Amma lokacin da masu sukar ta, waɗanda suka san sarai cewa ba za ta tashi ba, cikin izgili suka yi masa lakabi da "Star Wars," kawai Shugaban ƙasar ya ɗauki kalmar, yana ƙara da kyau, "Karfin yana tare da mu." Kamar yadda manyan masana kimiyyar makamai na kasar da masana a MIT da sauran wurare suka harbe shirin Star-Wars daya bayan daya, tsarin kawai ya zama sabon salo kuma Shugaban ya sake tabbatar da “hangen nesa.” Haka kuwa akayi. Yayin da Star Wars ba ta taɓa yin sararin sama ba, kuɗaɗen nau'ikansa suna gudana, kuma suna ci gaba da kwarara, cikin asusun tsaro na kamfanoni. Abin da Reagan ya nuna shi ne cewa irin wannan amsawar igiya-a-dope ta yi aiki kuma har yanzu ana amfani da ita.
A gaskiya ma, a cikin nau'i mai banƙyama, ya zama jigon wannan gwamnati kuma ya sami ƙwaƙƙwaran ƙa'idodin doka. Bayanan shari'a game da azabtarwa da ta dauki nauyin gaske suna tabbatar da cewa gaskiyar ita ce abin da shugaban kasa, a matsayin babban kwamandan, ya dage, kuma ba Majalisa, ko kotuna ba za su iya tsoma baki tare da sake fasalin gaskiyarsa muddin abin ya faru a "lokacin yaki" - ita kanta Majalisa ba ta bayyana shi ba amma shugaban ya bayyana haka. Kamar dai yadda ake ci gaba da tabbatar da alakar al-Qaeda/Saddam, wannan gwamnatin kawai ta dage cewa lallai ne a tabbatar da gaskiyar abin da take bukata kuma ba za ta yi magana da masu shiga tsakani a cikin wannan tsari ba.
Wannan a fili ya wuce maganar karya (inda da yawa masu adawa da wannan gwamnati suka makale). Yana da tabbaci game da yanayin gaskiya: Duniya ita ce abin da muka ce ita ce kuma harshe ba abu ba ne. Kamar yadda yake tare da duk ƙungiyoyin da ke mulki, koyaswar kai babu shakka tana taka rawar gani a nan. Waɗannan mayaka na cikin-da-Beltway sun tabbatar wa kansu gaskiyar da ke cikin zuciyar shelar da kansu “yaƙin da ta’addanci.” Wataƙila kaɗan daga cikinsu sun yarda cewa kansu suna yin ƙarya a kan muhimman al'amura (ko da yake suna iya fahimtar cewa sassan abin da suke faɗa suna wakiltar "wajibi" ko ƙaryar dabara).
Ƙara wani abu a nan, wanda rahoton 9/11 na Hukumar kwanan nan ya bayyana: Yayin da aka kai wa Cibiyar Kasuwanci ta Duniya hari, Shugaban froze (Washington post, 6 / 18 / 04) domin bakwai masu tsanani Mintunan kamara a cikin aji a makarantar firamare ta Emma T. Booker a Florida. Ya ci gaba da zama yana sauraron karatun yara yayin da abubuwan ke faruwa. (Dukkan mintuna bakwai za a duba su a cikin sabon fim ɗin Michael Moore, Fahrenheit 9 / 11, wanda za a bude mako mai zuwa.) Shugaban kasa da masu ba shi shawara sun firgita a cikin hargitsin, suka aika da jirginsa a cikin wani jerin gwanon daji zuwa yamma maimakon arewa.
Yanzu, gaskiyar ita ce ba ku taɓa sanin yadda za ku yi a cikin yanayi mai matsi ba. Kowa na iya daskare. Amma abin da Shugaban ya yi ya zama abin wulakanci da kansa. Na yi imani koyaushe cewa ya ba da kyauta ta musamman ga duk wasan kwaikwayo na macho da ya biyo baya ("Matattu ko a raye," "An cika manufa," "Ku kawo su!"). Mafi yawansa, ina zargin, diyya ne. Ina shirye in yi amfani da waɗannan mintuna bakwai - wanda a cikin dogon lokaci ba za a manta da shi ba - ci gaba da gnaw a George W. Bush kuma ya taimaka wajen fitar da shi da kansa a cikin "manufa" na yakinsa sannan kuma ya wuce duk iyakoki.
Shugabannin Hukumar 9/11 yanzu sun nemi daga mataimakin shugaban kasa musamman "duk wani rahoton sirri da zai goyi bayan dagewar Fadar White House cewa akwai dangantaka ta kut da kut tsakanin Saddam Hussein da Al Qaeda" (New York Times, 6/19/04); ko da yake Juan Cole comments, "Cheney kamar yadda ya yarda cewa yana samun labarinsa akan waɗannan abubuwa daga National Review, Mujallar dama ce wadda ba a san ta da samun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙwararrun ƙasashen Larabawa ba, waɗanda suka san Larabci kuma suka zauna a wurin, a cikin ma’aikata.”
Duk da haka gwamnati ta yi ƙoƙari ta yi watsi da wannan, abu ɗaya tabbatacce ne: Duk sokewar muƙaman gwamnati za a biyo bayan sake maimaita tsarin mulki iri ɗaya ko wani. Babu shakka gwamnatin Bush ta nuna kanta a shirye ta yi nisa da gaske don tabbatar da gaskiya ta dace da bukatunta kuma har a baya-bayan nan ta samu gagarumar nasara wajen yin hakan. Ko a yanzu, tare da bude kofofin watsa labarai a kalla, yawancin abin da ake ba da rahoto ba ya shiga. Za ku yi tunanin, alal misali, dangantaka ta kud da kud da shugaban wata kungiya da ta taba tayar da bama-bamai a cikin gari. Baghdad, mutumin da muka ba shi mukamin firaminista na Iraki, zai iya shafar martabar gwamnatin yaki da ta'addanci; amma wannan wahayin- a shafin farko na jaridar New York Times, ba kasa (6/9/04) - da alama bai yi wani tasiri ba.
A makon da ya gabata an bayyana cewa Donald Rumsfeld ya ba da umarnin a tsare wani fursuna na Iraqi na tsawon watanni a matsayin "wanda ake tsare da fatalwa," kuma hakan ya haifar da jita-jita a kafafen yada labarai. Wannan tsarewar, duk da haka, ɓarkewar dusar ƙanƙara ce a kan iyakar ƙanƙara da aka tsare mu. Maimakon fursunonin fatalwa guda ɗaya - Human Rights Watch ta gano aƙalla 13 daga cikin waɗannan - muna da cibiyoyin binciken fatalwa gabaɗaya. Kamar yadda Reuters ya ruwaito (6/17/04): "Amurka na tsare da wadanda ake zargi da ta'addanci a fiye da gidajen yari biyu a duniya kuma kusan rabin wadannan suna aiki ne cikin sirri, in ji wani rahoton kare hakkin dan Adam da aka fitar a ranar Alhamis." Wadannan cibiyoyin tsare-tsare sun fito ne daga Jordan zuwa Pakistan, tsibirin Diego Garcia zuwa masu jigilar jiragen sama. (Rahoto na farko na Human Rights, mafi girman asusu har yanzu na karamin guguwar mu na bakin teku, ana iya karantawa ta danna nan [gargadi: fayil ɗin pdf].)
Don haka ba zato ba tsammani bayanai suna ta fitowa kuma ga alama gwamnati tana kan hanyar yin ta'azzara, amma tambayar ita ce: Shin zai haifar da bambanci ko kuma ikirarin wata gaskiyar ta daban ce kawai?
Bari in kawo karshen wannan rashin fahimta da tatsuniya daga babban alkalami na James Thurber. Abin mamaki na, Thurber, ko da yake ya daɗe ya mutu, da alama ko ta yaya ya gabatar da lokacinmu. Ban ga wannan tatsuniya ba, wanda na tuna tun daga ƙuruciyata (wanda kuma ya bayyana a cikin littafinsa na 1940). Tatsuniya na Zamanin Mu), wanda aka ambata a baya a cikin wannan mahallin. Yana da hakki "Tsuntsaye da Foxes" kuma ya karanta gaba daya:
“A wani lokaci akwai wurin mafakar tsuntsaye wanda ɗaruruwan Baltimore orioles ke rayuwa tare cikin farin ciki. Mafarin ya ƙunshi wani daji gabaɗaya da katangar waya mai tsayi. Lokacin da aka girka shi, ɗimbin foxes da ke zaune a kusa sun nuna rashin amincewa da cewa iyaka ce ta sabani kuma ba ta dace ba. Duk da haka, ba su yi wani abu game da shi a lokacin domin suna sha'awar wayewa da geese da agwagwa a kan makwabta gonaki. Lokacin da dukan geese da agwagi sun kasance masu wayewa, kuma babu abin da za su ci, foxes sun sake mayar da hankalinsu zuwa wurin mafakar tsuntsaye. Shugabansu ya yi shelar cewa an taɓa samun ƙuƙumma a cikin harami amma an kore su. Ya yi shelar cewa Baltimore orioles na Baltimore ne. Ya ce, haka kuma, guraren da ke cikin harami na ci gaba da zama barazana ga zaman lafiya a duniya. Sauran dabbobin sun gargadi Foxes cewa kada su dame tsuntsayen a wurinsu.
“Saboda haka Foxes suka kai wa Wuri Mai Tsarki daddare, suka farfasa katangar da suka kewaye shi. Irioles sun fito da sauri suka kashe su suka cinye su.
“Washegari shugaban ’ya’yan dawa, wata ’yar ’ya’yan da Allah ke samun shiriya a kullum, ta hau kan dutsen, ya yi wa sauran varayin magana. Saƙonsa mai sauƙi ne kuma mai ɗaukaka. "Kana gani a gabanka," in ji shi, "wani Lincoln. Mun 'yantar da dukan waɗannan tsuntsaye!'
"Dabi'a: Gwamnatin dawakai, ta foxes, da foxes, dole ne su halaka daga ƙasa."
Yanzu, bari in juyo daga abin da ke lalata duniya da mahimmanci zuwa girman kugu da maras muhimmanci. tare da bayar da wata ‘yar tunatarwa cewa wannan gwamnati da magoya bayanta daban-daban suna karkatar da gaskiya a kowane mataki don biyan bukatunsu.
Fry na Faransanci
A cikin yakin da ake yi a Iraki, lokacin da Faransawa suka yi adawa da mu, ko kuma lokacin da gwamnatin Bush ta bar Faransanci ba tare da wata hanya ba don yin amfani da makamai masu linzami na tankuna da makamai masu linzami, ƙasƙanci amma ƙaunataccen Faransanci (wanda aka sani "a can") kamar a farar fata) kuma ya ɗauki bugun. Yayin da jaridar mu tabloid ta ayyana Faransanci a matsayin "weasels," ko wani ɓangare na "Axis of Weasels," da kuma New York Post rashin mutunci saman weasel shugabannin A kan hoton jami'an diflomasiyyar Majalisar Dinkin Duniya na Faransa da Jamus, wakilan mu na majalisar sun yi jarumtaka, suna baje kolin abin da ya wuce "kishin kasa" ta hanyar canza sunan soya Faransa, "soyayyar 'yanci," a cikin gidajen cin abinci daban-daban. “Wannan aikin a yau ƙaramin ƙoƙari ne, amma na alama don nuna rashin jin daɗin mutane da yawa a kan Capitol Hill tare da ayyukan waɗanda ake kira ƙawancinmu, Faransa,” ɗan majalisar Republican Bob Ney na Ohio ya sanar a lokacin. Ya kasance shugaban kwamitin kula da harkokin majalisar wakilai wanda ya rike amanar nauyi nauyi na sa ido kan soya majalisa. (Kada ku taɓa yin watsi da ƙarfin hali, Fadar White House ta ba da sanarwar yin lakabin toast na Faransa a kan jirgin shugaban kasa, Air Force One. CNN ta ba da rahoton cewa, "Tsarin 'yanci" ya kasance, "wani dabarar mariƙin Faransanci don taimakawa wajen rikitar da yunƙurin Amurka na ganin Kwamitin Tsaro na Majalisar Dinkin Duniya ya ba da izini ga sojojin soji a kan Iraki… ,' yayi murmushi ya ce, 'Muna alfahari da maza da mata na Sojan Sama'' "A cikin gidajen cin abinci na majalisa, fry mai tawali'u har wa yau ya cika da al'adunsa na Gallic. ana ci gaba da ba da hidima a karkashin ta nom de gure (Kirista Science Monitor, 6/9/04).
Kwanan nan, Shugabanmu, yana kallon manufofinsa na Iraki ya fado daga wani dutse, ya matsa don daidaita dangantakarsa da Faransa, yana gayyatar Jacques Chirac zuwa "ranch" a Crawford, Texas wata rana don ganin shanunsa na wasan yara sa'an nan kuma ya bantering tare da shi a Teku. Tsibirin yayin taron G-8 game da cheeseburgers. Da alama, duk da haka, Sashen Noma namu ya hango wannan lokacin. A shekara ta 2000, ba tare da sanin kowa ba, sai ɗakin fry-fry na Faransa (e, Virginia, akwai ɗakin cin abinci na Faransanci), ya fara haɓaka nau'in nau'in nau'in nau'in abincin mai tawali'u, mai daskarewa, daskararre. A wannan shekarar. kamar yadda Andrew Martin na Chicago Tribune ya bayyana (6 / 15 / 04):
"Cibiyar Kayayyakin Kayayyakin Dankali da aka daskare ta yi kira ga USDA… don canza ma'anarta na sabbin kayan abinci a ƙarƙashin PACA don haɗawa da batter, soyayyen daskararre na Faransa, suna jayayya cewa mirgine yankan dankalin turawa a cikin suturar sitaci, soya su da daskare su daidai yake da kakin zuma. kokwamba ko zaki da strawberry. USDA ta amince kuma, a ranar 2 ga Yuni, 2003, hukumar ta gyara dokokinta na PACA don haɗa abin da aka kwatanta a cikin takardun kotu a matsayin 'Dokar Batter-Coating'."
PACA, ta hanyar, wata doka ce da aka zartar a cikin 1930s ta Majalisa don kare 'ya'yan itace da kayan lambu masu cin ganyayyaki daga masu saye. Kwanan nan, wannan ba a lura da tsarin mulkin Bush ba-canjin ya kalubalanci a cikin wata kotu ta Texas ta wani kamfani mai daskarewa wanda ba ya so ya biya masu bashi cikakke (kamar yadda zai zama dole idan fry mai daskarewa ya kasance sabon kayan lambu) . Lauyoyin Ma'aikatar Aikin Gona ta Amurka sun yi yaƙi da hannu. "Yayin da mai gabatar da kara ya yi jayayya cewa fries na Faransa da aka yi da batter kayan aiki ne," in ji sun yi iƙirarin, "ba a sarrafa su ba har ya zuwa yanzu sun daina 'sabo'… . Yana riƙe ingancinta mai lalacewa.”
Kuma, wannan kasancewar Texas, alkali ya yarda, yana yanke hukuncin cewa soyayyen da aka rigaya ya mutu da daskarewa yakamata ya mutu azaman kayan lambu. “U.S. Alkalin gundumar Richard Schell ya ce kalmar 'sabobin kayan lambu' ba ta da tabbas." A cikin wannan, ko da yake mai yiwuwa bai sani ba, yana bin hanyar gudanarwa da aka rigaya ta yi nasara. Dangane da hukunce-hukuncen shigo da kayayyaki da yawa, lauyoyin gwamnati sun ba wa gwamnatin shawara a asirce cewa kalmomi kamar "mai tsanani" ko "mai zurfi" a cikin ma'anar azabtarwa suma ba su da tabbas kuma don haka suna buɗewa ga mai tsanani da sake ma'ana mai zurfi a cikin sabis na buƙatun yaƙi da ta'addanci. na manyan jami'an Bush.
A matsayin wani ɓangare na yunƙurin sake siffanta gaskiya a cikin jimla, ƙayyadaddun sake fasalin daskararre, soyayyen soya ba ta yi daidai da yunƙurin gwamnati ba. reclassify “aiki cikin sauri a matsayin aikin masana'antu, ”kamar yadda aka fara rahoto a cikin New York Times watanni da yawa da suka gabata. (Babu asarar ayyukan masana'antu a cikin teku a ƙarƙashin wannan gwamnatin, babu sirree; kawai yawancin masana'anta masu aiki tuƙuru suna jefar daskararre a baya, sabbin kayan lambu da aka yi musu zafi don ƙarancin albashi a masana'antar abinci mai sauri.)
Matukar dai mun hau turbar sake bayyanawa da sake suna, kuma kotuna sun yarda su goyi bayansa, ina da wata ‘yar karamar shawara don ci gaba da aiki da kuma taimaka wa masana’anta wanda tabbas yana da akalla asara kamar haka. daskararre-soya kasuwanci da yana da nisa da zurfi sosai a Ma'aikatar Aikin Gona ta gwamnatin Bush. Me game da sake rarraba naman sa? Bayan haka, yawancin shanu, waɗanda ake kiwon su a cikin manyan gidajen abinci, ba sa cin ciyawa. Yanzu sun kasance ainihin tasoshin masarar da Amurka ta girma (suna yin wannan shawarar musamman mai kishin ƙasa). Don haka, idan ka fara tunanin saniya a matsayin jirgin masara, to, naman sa kuma za a iya danganta shi da “sabo ne kayan lambu” (ko da yake wasu na iya cewa, dangane da matakin magungunan feedlot da ake ba da shanu, cewa a zahiri “sabo ne sinadarai”). ). Ka yi tunanin amfanin wannan ga masana'antar naman sa. Lokaci na gaba da aka gano cutar hauka- saniya, dole ne a mai da ita "cutar kayan lambu masu hauka," da kawar da matsananciyar matsin lamba daga kasuwancin da kuma kawar da buƙatar yin wani ƙarin ko ƙarin gwaji na shanu.
Duk wannan yana yiwuwa a fili tun da, kamar yadda mai shari'a Schell ya yanke hukunci, kalmar "sabo ne kayan lambu" wani abu ne mai wuyar gaske. I mana, ga shanun da ake nufi da kasuwa mai daraja waɗanda suke ci da ciyawa kuma an yarda su yi yawo, tabbas ba zai zama da yawa ba don ƙirƙirar sabon nau'in (wanda aboki ya ƙirƙira): kayan lambu masu kyauta.
Af, ga wani daga cikin waɗannan ƙananan kamance tsakanin zamanin Bush da Reagan. A cikin wa'adi na farko na Reagan, mutumin kirki ya yi ƙoƙari ya kai wani taimako na sake fasalin makarantu wanda, kamar yadda jaridar Washington Post ta ruwaito a watan Satumba 1981, "Samar da abincin rana kyauta ko rahusa ga ɗalibai masu karamin karfi yayin da suke ƙoƙarin magance raguwar dala biliyan 1 na tallafin tarayya na shekara ta kasafin kuɗi." Amsar mafi ƙanƙanta sannan ita ce, a wani ɓangare, don ƙirƙirar fakitin abincin rana mai rahusa ƙarƙashin jagororin abinci na tarayya ta hanyar sake rarraba ketchup da jin daɗi azaman kayan lambu. Kamar yadda mai taimaka wa Sakataren Aikin Noma John Block ya taƙaita shi a lokacin, “‘An yi rashin fahimta sosai a ƙasar game da yadda ake kallon waɗannan ƙa’idodin. Ina tsammanin zai zama kuskure idan aka ce ketchup per se an rarraba shi azaman kayan lambu . . . Ketchup tare da wasu abubuwa an rarraba shi azaman kayan lambu.’ Menene wasu abubuwa kuma? aka tambaye shi. "Fries na Faransa ko hamburgers," in ji shi.
Ƙarin canji. Bambancin kawai shi ne cewa gwamnatin Reagan, lokacin da ta fuskanci gaskiyar rashin amincewa, kamar yadda yake a cikin ketchup, wani lokacin yana goyan baya. Gwamnatin Bush kawai ta sake tabbatar da gaskiyar ta kuma ta yi kira ga lauyoyi don tabbatarwa.
[Wannan labarin ya fara bayyana Tomdispatch.com, wani gidan yanar gizo na Cibiyar Nation, wanda ke ba da ci gaba ta hanyoyi daban-daban, labarai, da ra'ayi daga Tom Engelhardt, editan dogon lokaci a cikin bugawa kuma marubucin Ƙarshen Nasara Al'adu da kuma Kwanakin Karshen Bugawa.]
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi