Idan kuna son sabon fim ɗin Michael Moore, "Capitalism: a Love Story" (Na yi) kuma kun daɗe da gamsuwa da biyayyar Barack Obama mai zurfi da hidima ga masu biyan kuɗin kamfani (Ni ne), to wannan maƙalar na iya zama a gare ku. Na fara da wasu tunani mai dadi
"ARZIKI YAZAMA ZUWA"
Aikin fim na Moore ya fara ne da ƙwaƙƙwaran satirical, shirin neo-Dickensian (mai suna "Roger and
A karshen gwamnatin Bush-Cheney, ita kanta tana kan gaba
"Na yi wannan aikin tsawon shekaru 20. Na fara ne da gargadin mutane game da General Motors, kuma duk aikina yana ƙoƙari na ce sarki ba shi da tufafi a nan, kuma gara mu yi wani abu a kai. irin buga kaina da bangon nan tsawon shekaru 20 ina fadin wadannan abubuwa."
"Shekaru biyu da suka wuce, na yi ƙoƙari in sami muhawara game da kiwon lafiya, kuma daga ƙarshe ya faru, kuma yanzu ina muke? Wataƙila ma ba mu da shi. Me ya kamata in yi a wani lokaci?"
"Na fara wannan fim ne kafin hadarin. Hadarin ya faru, ina tunani, oh, wani zai fara magana game da abin da nake magana a cikin wannan fim din… Har yanzu ban ga nunin magana ko karanta wani op. ed inda wani ya sanya masa suna, kawai ya fito ya ce, ' Jama'a, abin da zai faru a nan shi ne tsarin jari-hujja ya tafi. Domin ba za mu iya samun tsarin da kaso 1 na masu hannu da shuni suka mallaki abin da ya kai kashi 95 cikin XNUMX na kasa ba. Wannan dai ba dimokuradiyya ba ce, ba haka ba ne.
"Na gaji da jin kamar ni kadai nake yin haka, duk tsawon shekaru takwas na Bush, ku Google 'Bush' da 'nemesis' kuma ni ne sunan farko. Kuma babu cikakken yawa. sauran sunaye,"
Kusa da ƙarshen sabon fim ɗin sa dole ne ya gani,
Na juya ga wanda ke zaune kusa da ni na ce, "Damn. Dama".
Moore ya yanke shawarar cewa tsarin ribar ba ya aiki ga kowa ga 'yan kaɗan - hukuncin da Hagu na tarihi ya yi (tare da kyawawan dalilai) yana komawa baya ko da yake Marx kuma ya dawo aƙalla har zuwa babban karni na 17 na Burtaniya. "Digger" Gerrard Winstanley. Moore yana ba da sanarwar wani abu na canji na tsakiyar rayuwa daga Charles Dickens (wanda muhimmin al'amari ya kasance mara kyau daga ɓangaren ɗan jari-hujja na Victoria da sauran hukumomi) [2] zuwa Karl Marx [3] (wanda babban batun shine tushen tsarin jari-hujja na zalunci na aji), daidai da ƙarshen Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., wanda ya yanke shawarar aƙalla tsakiyar shekarun 1960 cewa: "Ta hanyar sauye-sauyen tsari ne kawai za a iya kawar da muguntar yanzu, saboda tushen yana cikin tsarin. maimakon a cikin maza ko ayyukan da ba daidai ba; [4] "Sake gina al'umma kanta ita ce ainihin batun da za a fuskanta;" da "wani abu ba daidai ba ne ... tare da tsarin jari-hujja. Dole ne a sami ingantaccen rarraba dukiya kuma watakila
Barka da shiga, Michael Moore. Ni ma mai adawa da jari hujja ne.
Anti-Jari Jari-hujja AS SRUGGGGNATIONS
Akwai muhimman cancanta guda biyu zuwa
A cikin sabon fim ɗin nasa, Moore ya yi murabus saboda fushinsa na ban dariya a ƙoƙarinsa na ƙarshe na yin magana kai tsaye tare da Shugaba na General Motors kuma yayin da yake yin aikin kaɗaici da rashin amfani na yawo tef ɗin "Crime Scene" mai launin rawaya a kusa da hedkwatar wani kamfani. Babban Kamfanin Wall Street. "Ba zan iya ci gaba da yin wannan ba,"
"A gaskiya Mike," na yi tunani a kaina, "za ku so ku yi tunanin yadda kuka fara kan sabuwar hanyar maraba a fili na sukar mulkin kama karya na babban jari. Wannan sabon abu ne mai ban sha'awa don gani, ko ba haka ba? Ina so in yi tunanin kun fara sabon."
MICHAEL MOORE DA BARACK OBAMA: LABARI NA SOYAYYA, KASHI NA 1: "WANNAN MUTUM MAI TSARKI"
Na biyu, daidai da rikicewar da ya bayyana (a ƙarshen bayanin Toronto da aka ambata a sama) tsakanin kasancewa mai adawa da jari-hujja da kuma kasancewa (tare da Sean Penn da marigayi Ted Kennedy), anti-Bush, Moore ya bayyana "Jari-hujja: Labarin Soyayya "Ya kasance mai ban mamaki tare da kalamai na alaka da tsohon shugaban kasar Barack Obama, wanda watanni tara na farko a kan karagar mulki ya nuna cewa 'yan bindiga sun mika wuya ga Wall Street da kuma, da kyau, ummm……
Kamar yadda jaridar New York Times ta ruwaito a shafi na farko na sashin "Arts & Leisure" na Lahadi a ranar 20 ga Satumban da ya gabatath, "Bayan da aka nuna a Toronto, Mr. Moore ya ɗauki tambayoyi daga masu sauraro masu sha'awar sanin ainihin abin da ya kamata su yi. Ya ba da shawarwari masu yawa, yana jaddada cewa ya damu da cewa 'yan Democrat a cikin
Wannan asusun ya yi daidai da
"Akwai masu cewa Obama bai shirya ba, ko kuma ya zabe shi ba daidai ba a kan wannan ko wancan. Amma wannan yana kallon bishiyoyi ne ba gandun daji ba. Abin da muke gani ba wai kawai dan takara ba ne, amma mai zurfi, gagarumin yunkurin jama'a na neman sauyi. Amincewa na ya fi na Obama The Movement fiye da na Obama dan takarar."
"Hakan ba wai a kwace wani abu daga wannan mutumin na kwarai ba, amma abin da ke faruwa ya fi shi girma a wannan lokaci, kuma hakan abu ne mai kyau ga kasar. Domin idan ya yi nasara a watan Nuwamba, wannan yunkuri na Obama ya kamata ya yi. zauna a faɗake da aiki.Kamfani
BARACK OBAMA DA JINJIN JINJININ KAI: LABARIN SOYAYYA
"Babban Kadararmu:" Jari-Hujja
Wataƙila Moore mai adawa da jari-hujja a yanzu zai so ya waiwaya duka akan tsarin manufofin Pro-Wall Street na gwamnatin Obama da kuma maganganun yakin neman zabe na Obama akai-akai na "ƙauna" ga abin da ake kira "kasuwar kyauta" (harshen lambar ga tsarin riba) kuma a wani sashi mai ban sha'awa daga littafin ɗan takarar 2006 The Audacity of Hope. Wata mahimmin tambaya da aka yi magana a cikin Audacity ta fito kai tsaye daga ra'ayin duniya neoconservative: menene ya sa
"Calvin Coolidge ya taɓa cewa "babban kasuwancin jama'ar Amirka shine kasuwanci," kuma lalle ne, zai yi wuya a sami wata ƙasa a duniya wadda ta kasance mai karimci ga basirar kasuwa. Tsarin Mulkinmu ya ba da izinin mallakar masu zaman kansu. Al'adunmu na addini suna nuna darajar yin aiki tuƙuru kuma suna bayyana ra'ayin cewa rayuwa mai kyau za ta haifar da lada, maimakon zagin mawadata, muna ɗaukar su a matsayin abin koyi… Kamar yadda Ted Turner ya shahara ya ce, in
"Sakamakon wannan al'adar kasuwanci ta kasance wadata ce wacce ba ta da misaltuwa a tarihin ɗan adam. Yana ɗaukar balaguron balaguro zuwa ƙasashen waje don jin daɗin yadda Amurkawa ke da shi sosai; har ma talakawanmu suna ɗaukar kaya da ayyuka na yau da kullun - wutar lantarki, ruwa mai tsabta, aikin famfo na cikin gida. wayoyi, talabijin, da kayan aikin gida - waɗanda har yanzu ba a iya samun su ga galibin duniya.
The Audacity of Hope ya bar shi zuwa ga masu son ci gaba na hagu - wanda Obama da yawancin magoya bayansa suka nuna a matsayin "masu gaskiya" da wuce gona da iri "masu kishin dabi'a", "cranks," "masu kishi," da "gadflies" ( zagin Obama kwatankwacin fitaccen dan majalisar dattijai na Amurka Paul Wellstone [9]) - don lura da wasu daga cikin sakamakon da ba a so da kasa da "nasara" na "tsarin kasuwa na 'yanci" da "al'adun kasuwanci." Waɗannan sakamakon sun haɗa da gudunmawar dumamar yanayi na wata ƙasa wadda ta ƙunshi kashi 5 cikin ɗari na al'ummar duniya amma tana ba da gudummawar fiye da kashi ɗaya cikin huɗu na iskar carbon da duniya ke fitarwa. Sauran fitattun illolin sun haɗa da samar da talauci ga dubun-dubatar mutane
An bar shi zuwa ga rashin wadatar "masu aiki" Masu tunani da masu fafutuka don lura da tsarin Amurka wanda za'a iya cewa ya zama almubazzaranci da lalata kasafi na sama da kashi uku na dukiyar al'ummar zuwa sama da kashi 1 cikin dari na
"Masu hankali" "masu tsattsauran ra'ayi" an bar su don lura da cewa wuraren aiki da ke mulkin kasuwanci da kasuwannin kwadago suna satar "yunƙurin mutum ɗaya" daga miliyoyin ma'aikatan Amurkawa da aka yi ta maimaita maimaitawar sau da yawa marasa ƙarfi da ruɗar rai da aka gudanar don irin waɗannan lokutan da ba za a iya jurewa ba - a matakan lada na kayan aiki da tsaro - cewa mutane masu aiki ba su da ikon shiga cikin ma'ana a cikin babban "dimokiradiyya" Obama a matsayin babban gadon Kafa.[11] An bar su kuma don "koka" game da gaskiyar cewa yawan motsin jama'a na Amurka yana da ƙasa sosai idan aka kwatanta da sauran manyan ƙasashe masu masana'antu, yana nuna ƙayyadaddun tsarin aji a cikin "sihiri" (bayanin Obama) Amurka.[12]
"Menene Darajar Dala na mai Ido mai Ido?"
Mai yiwuwa mai yin fim ɗin ya yi nazari mai zurfi game da ɗan takararsa na musamman a fitowar New Yorker na Mayu 7, 2007. A cikin hoton Obama da aka yi bincike a hankali bisa manyan tambayoyi, MacFarquhar ya gano cewa Obama ya yi nisa da kasancewa mai tsattsauran ra'ayi kamar yadda mutum zai iya tunani. "A ra'ayinsa game da tarihi, game da mutunta al'ada, a cikin shakkunsa cewa za a iya canza duniya ta kowace hanya, amma a hankali sosai, Obama," MacFarquhar ya ƙaddara, "yana da ra'ayin mazan jiya ... Ba wai kawai yana tunanin juyin juya hali ba zai yiwu ba. : yana daraja ci gaba da kwanciyar hankali don son kansu, wani lokacin ma fiye da yadda yake kimar canji ga mai kyau. Dauki kula da lafiya, alal misali, "MacFarquhar ya lura, yana ambaton Obama kan yadda kamfanonin inshorar kiwon lafiya na Amurka ke da zurfi sosai. daure don mu kore su daga yadda Mafia suke kula da lafiyar mu nan gaba. Mawallafin MacFarquhar mai taken "Mai sulhu: Daga ina Barack Obama yake zuwa?" [14]
"Babu Wanda Ya Nemanka Ka Gina Mafi Adalci
Idan har ya taba yin bincike mai tsanani kan Obama,
Waɗannan baƙon imani ne don (da'awar) riƙe ta cikin hasken ainihin tsarin tarihin kasuwanci wanda a zahiri yana haifar da manufa da tsarin tsarin riba mai zaman kansa. Sojojin da ba su da iyaka na ƙungiyoyin agaji da masu ba da sabis na zamantakewa, ƴan ƙasa, masu fafutukar kare muhalli da al'umma, masu sasantawa na ƙungiyar kwadago, da masu tsara manufofi sun shafe shekaru da yawa suna tambayar (sau da yawa isa bara) kamfanoni na "Amurka" da jari-hujja don ba da gudummawa ga cikin gida. kyautata zamantakewa - don kadan ko babu amfani.
Kamar yadda wanda ya kafa Cibiyar Siyasar Tattalin Arziki ta Washington Jeff Faux ya lura a cikin littafinsa na 2006 Yaƙin Duniya na Duniya: Yadda Amurkawa Bipartisan Elite Ya Rasa Makomar Mu da Abin da Zai ɗauka don cin nasara a Komawa, yawancin tushen kasuwanci da yanki na Amurka. "Ba shi da alaƙa ta musamman ga mutane, al'ummomi, kiwon lafiya, ko ma gasa na Amurka a kowane lokaci. "A farkon shekarun 1950," Faux ya lura, "Wani jami'in Ford Motor ya gyara wani dan majalisar dattijai na Amurka wanda ya kira kamfanin a matsayin 'kamfanin Amurka. Mu kamfani ne na Amurka lokacin da muke ciki.
"Ina son kasuwa"
A lokacin yakin neman zaben shugaban kasa, abin da ake tsammani (don haka na'urar hayaniya ta dama ta Republican ta al'ada da da'awar addini) "Obama mai ra'ayin hagu"[19] ya maimaita kansa a matsayin mai kishin jari-hujja, yana cewa abubuwa kamar, "Duba, ni mai goyon bayan ci gaba ne. , mutumin kasuwa kyauta, ina son kasuwa." [20] Jawabinsa na farko ya yi shelar cewa "tambaya" na "ko kasuwa ce mai karfi ko rashin lafiya" ba a yi muhawara ba. "Ikonsa na samar da dukiya da fadada 'yanci," in ji shi, "ba shi da irinsa."[21].
Ni da wasu da yawa a kan ainihin, Hagu marar ganuwa bisa hukuma sun yarda da Laurence Shoup, wanda ya lura a lokacin rani na 2008 cewa yakin neman zaben Obama na "ƙaunar" ga kasuwa "sun kasa lura da cewa kasuwa yana ƙauna kuma yana ba da kyauta ga waɗanda suka riga sun sami kuɗi. da kuma iko, ba wadanda ba su da wannan fa'ida ba. A ce kuna son kasuwa, daidai ne," in ji Shoup, "a cewar kuna son masu mulki (kashi 1 cikin 20 na al'ummar kasar da ke sarrafa kashi 40 cikin dari na kudaden shiga na kasar). da kusan kashi 60 cikin 25 na dukiyar kasar) kuma ba su damu da mafi rinjaye ba (kashi 5 na al'ummar kasar da ke da iko da kashi 22 cikin XNUMX na kudin shiga da kashi XNUMX cikin XNUMX na dukiyar) Don a ce 'Ina son kasuwa' - at lokacin da tsarin hada-hadar kudi ke tabarbarewa saboda shekaru da dama na karya game da yadda manyan kasuwannin da ba a daidaita su ba, wadanda suka haifar da cece-ku-ce, da kima, da tabbaci na yaudara - shi ne ya zama kurame ga gaskiyar yadda gwamnati ke kare muradu mai karfi yayin da kowa ke samun. lacca kan alhakin kai. 'Canjin da za mu iya yi imani da shi,' zai haɗa da fuskantar karkatar da jari-hujja da ke haifar da kasuwa..." [XNUMX]
Ra'ayin Girma
Ta hanyar haɗa "ƙaunar" ga "kasuwa" zuwa "ƙaddamar da ci gaba," Obama ya goyi bayan ra'ayi mai daɗaɗɗen ra'ayi na muhalli da na zamantakewar jama'a cewa mafita ga matsalolin zamani shine faɗaɗa kayan abu ba babban rabo na dukiya da mulki ba. Wani "tashi mai tasowa yana ɗaga dukkan kwale-kwale," daidaitaccen ma'aunin Yammacin Turai ya kiyaye, yana yin kwatancen "fushi" tsakanin 'yan ƙalilan da jiragen ruwa na Manya waɗanda ba su daina aiki ba. "Faɗaɗa kek," hikimar kamfani mai mulki, ta kawar da tambayar da ake zaton ba ta da mahimmanci na sake rarraba tattalin arzikin zamantakewa - na yadda ake raba kek. "Don guje wa duk wani sake dubawa," in ji marubucin nazarin halittu na Faransa Herve Kempf, "oligarchy yana ci gaba da maimaita akidar rinjaye bisa ga abin da mafita ga rikicin zamantakewa shine haɓaka samar da kayayyaki. Wannan ita ce kawai hanyar yaki da talauci da rashin aikin yi."
Bayanai masu yawa a cikin shekaru uku da rabi da suka gabata sun nuna cewa ci gaban tattalin arziki a haƙiƙanin gaskiya ba ya warware waɗancan da sauran munanan halaye na zamantakewa. Amma ra'ayin cewa ci gaban abin duniya shine amsar da ke ci gaba da wanzuwa saboda yana haifar da al'ummomin da ke fama da talauci da rashin zaman lafiya "su yarda da rashin daidaito ba tare da tambayar su ba."
Bayan kasancewar ƙarya a kan nasa sharuɗɗan, haka ma, koyarwar da ke mulki ta yi watsi da ƙaton girman girma
ZNetwork ana samun kuɗi ta hanyar karimcin masu karatun sa.
Bada Tallafi